4 ms·
How much flexibility do they have? It's a real question, can they easily challenge some requests and maintain their safe harbor status?
by maxerickson 9y ago
How much flexibility do they have?
It's a real question, can they easily challenge some requests and maintain their safe harbor status?
- shmageggy 9y agoI mean, they could probably challenge requests that are obviously invalid like the Admiral one. http://lmgtfy.com/?q=can+you+copyright+a+domain+name http://lmgtfy.com/?q=can+you+copyright+a+domain+name (No, you can't)
- maxerickson 9y agoI'm asking a specific question about the workings of the DMCA. Does your link address that question? Is your opinion on the DMCA well informed?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- shmageggy 9y agoThe lmgtfy was meant towards github's lawyers, not you. My point was that this is so obviously invalid that they should absolutely have flexibility to challenge it.
- pbhjpbhj 9y agoIf you think this is about copyright in a domain name you're missing the point. The DMCA is being used because uBlock is blocking a technology [script download] that is used to prevent access. uBlock is working like a DRM remover (the argument goes) and so is committing contributory copyright infringement. Modifying uBlock mitigates the argument but doesn't entirely remove it. For example if the people who control uBlock control a third-party source that allows the same preventions to be implemented then technological changes have been made but the situation is legally homologous (AIUI, IANAL). IMO uBlock need to provide facility for a domain to be blocked but say "search online to find blocklists" and have no legal associations with the blocklist maintainers; akin to how emulator sites manage ROMs, they stay as legal separated from them as possible. Putting Google in the middle makes getting sued harder, in theory Google is linking the people to the tech/info that enables the alleged infringement. Remember DMCA is strongly weighted towards the accuser in the initial instance and that a service provider has to take down content in order to maintain their safe-harbour protections, leaving it to the alleged infringer to counter the accusation (guilt until claim of innocence).
- jlgaddis 9y agoIt's not up to Github to challenge them. It's up to the person(s) responsible for the "violation". In this case, Github is just the messenger (AIUI).
- maxerickson 9y agoMy question is whether there is even a provision in the law that enables Github to challenge the notice.
- notyourday 9y agoNot if the notice follows the requirements of DMCA.