3 ms·
Pretty much everything that has derivatives tied to it is manipulated. Option expiries, FX fixes as well. Or it was when I was looking at it. The thing is ther
by lordnacho 9y ago
Pretty much everything that has derivatives tied to it is manipulated. Option expiries, FX fixes as well. Or it was when I was looking at it.
The thing is there are derivatives that are sometimes non-linear, things with triggers and barriers. When some large enough fish has one of these (eg by taking the other side vs a customer) they have an incentive to move the rate in whatever way they can. Whether it's getting someone to submit a bad rate or sitting on an FX cross, it can be worth it.
Before I went full quant I was often looking at the screens manually. You'd often see at around the WM/Reuters fix that the price would move strangely. An unusually large move would happen with no apparent news. You'd get a rumour from a broker, but who knew how they knew? And quite often the move would fade after the window closed.
This would happen even in exchange traded options. If you knew the specifics of the settlement window, you would know when the price would go wonky. You wouldn't know who, but you knew that is wasn't a normal time in the market.
The LIBOR was a bit less obvious, only really clear to me in hindsight. Swaps don't have a common schedule like listed options, so there's a fixing every day that could be in someone's interest to influence. Same goes for FX, but since LIBOR is a bunch of opinions (as opposed to trades) it's not as obvious.
- JumpCrisscross 9y ago> This would happen even in exchange traded options. If you knew the specifics of the settlement window, you would know when the price would go wonky. Exchange-traded options settle on a predictable window; there's no "if you knew" to it [1]. Also, the price goes wonky near expiries because that's when delta approaches one. Market makers switch from hedging with derivatives to hedging with spot; that means jitters. Not saying there's no fraud. But pricing going wonky around a settlement event makes sense as everyone prepares for it. [1] http://www.dtcc.com/~/media/Files/Downloads/legal/service-guides/Settlement.pdf http://www.dtcc.com/~/media/Files/Downloads/legal/service-gu...
- lordnacho 9y agoYes, I used to work in this. "If you knew" should say "Because you knew"... Might actually be a reason for the exchange to fuzz the expiry (eg random time) but that has its own problems. People do have to look at the options as they expire for legitimate hedging reasons.
- coliveira 9y agoYour understanding of the market doesn't consider that there are big players who overshadow everyone else. Yes, everybody prepares for the expiration of an option, but very few players can do anything to influence prices. Only a handful of institutions can successfully trade around these expiries, which is what the commenter above is mentioning.
- wahern 9y agoRetail and transactional banking have built-in incentives for honesty, at least with other banks. Banks are repeat players in a millennia old game. The banks primarily profit by charging their clients for their services. There's little upside and tremendous downside for being dishonest. But when investment and retail banking merged, the stable system of incentives disintegrated. Before the merger, retail banking was more expensive, but it was incredibly stable; that premium was more than worth the cost. I don't see why investment banking needs to merge with retailing banking anymore than VC firms need to merge with retail banking. It just results in a chaotic system. In an increasingly electronic age where the technical transactional costs are quickly eroding to nothing, you don't gain much efficiency by merging these roles. The remaining transactional costs are functional and specifically serve to ensure that incentives are well-aligned internally and externally. Removing those barriers merely permits people to extract all that value, diminishing the overall value of the systems and the economy in general. Likewise, the global value of assets is so tremendous that investment firms don't need direct access to the capital within the retail banking sector. We're quickly approaching something like $100 trillion in highly liquid investments globally.
- justincormack 9y agoEven the retail banking behaviours broke down, eg look at RBS being sued now for bankrupting its own customers for gain https://www.theguardian.com/business/2016/apr/25/rbs-royal-bank-scotland-legal-claims-damages-small-businesses-bankruptcy https://www.theguardian.com/business/2016/apr/25/rbs-royal-b...
- ThrustVectoring 9y agoDoesn't this work as an argument against cash-settling options and futures? Owning a giant pile of call options and driving the price up during the settlement window doesn't help you any if you have to unload a massive quantity of the underlying stock.
- lordnacho 9y agoForgot to mention it was mainly indexes I was talking about, and they are cash settled. Single stock options tend to be settled with actual stock, and at least in Europe tend to be a lot less liquid. And there's other problems with trading them, like other people knowing a lot more than the market maker about what's happening. You also have pin risk which seems to be like a magnet.
- ThrustVectoring 9y agoYeah, sorry if that wasn't clear - I was thinking that the manipulation you saw with the options on index was because they were cash settled. If they were physically settled (somehow), then it doesn't help you to be the buyer at an arbitrarily high price of the underlying. You have to sell the underlying to profit off of the call options, you can't just support the price against all comers at the time of exercise.
- formerjpl 9y agoI'm really not understanding how someone could manipulate index futures (or options on futures, which, in the US, are subject to stock-type settlement). The "Final Settlement" on an index future is determined by the settled value of the underlying index. Any discrepency between the index future and the underlying index near expiration would result in an easy arbitrage opportunity. Are you implying that, close to expiration, a large player would move the index, in order to move their option position in the money? In the case of ES, that would imply buying an impossibly large of amount of SP500 assets---which they would have to liquidate at some point after the ES settlement or liquidation... Also not understanding your point on pin risk, pinning is the result of maintaining a delta neutral hedge, which is a well known strategy...
- cm2187 9y agoThere were two kinds of libor manipulations. Those instructed by the management of the banks to reduce the perception of the bank struggling to fund during the crisis, and the manipulations requested by the swap traders before the crisis. I suspect the swap traders were mostly targeting future delivery dates (4 fixings a year). That's the only way the fraction of basis points they were asking the submitters to move the fixing by would have any material P&L impact. So it's kind of like other markets with strandardised contracts. The former manipulation would have affected every days fixings.
- rbcgerard 9y agoyeah - imagine what physical commodities traders can do in the physical market that can have huge financial derivative impacts for them...
- totalZero 9y agoHow were option expiries manipulated when you were looking at them? Or do you just mean that stocks tend to trade differently when a large position is expiring? Sometimes it's just innocuous things like a market maker trading out of his delta from gamma.