13 ms·
Safari Should Display Favicons in Its Tabs
- mi100hael 9y agoWith Firefox, you get the best of both worlds. You get favicons, but you also get a minimum tab width so you can always read the first word or two of the page title. Rather than squishing down infinitely like Chrome, they just quickly scroll side-to-side more like Safari.
- bangonkeyboard 9y agoSide-scrolling tabs are one of the worst UI innovations I've suffered in recent years. They wreak havoc on spatial tab organization, make it impossible to see how many tabs are open, and slide out from under the mouse cursor unpredictably when clicking. The original Safari behavior of a vertical overflow list of tabs, favicons included, keyboard searchable and navigable, was much more usable. https://i.stack.imgur.com/eyXum.png https://i.stack.imgur.com/eyXum.png
- mi100hael 9y agoStrongly disagree. That list menu made it hard to reorganize tabs, required a mouse click, and arbitrarily split your tabs into those visible and those relegated to some obnoxious menu.
- bangonkeyboard 9y agoEvery one of those downsides was addressable without flushing the baby. Sessions (https://sessions-extension.github.io/Sessions/ https://sessions-extension.github.io/Sessions/) provides a keyboard-controllable vertical tab popover with draggable tabs from all open windows.
- eridius 9y agoSpatial tab organization is already lost any time you open or close a tab.
- detaro 9y agoIt really isn't, human brains are clever enough to deal with that quite well.
- eridius 9y agoAnd they're not clever enough to deal with Safari's tab bar? Just as humans can adapt to the tab bar shifting when tabs are opened and closed, humans can also adapt to the concept the tab bar focusing on the left or the right and collapsing the opposite side. The point of my previous comment is you've lost literal spatial organization already, as the exact same position isn't guaranteed to be the same tab after other tabs have opened/closed, so we're already talking about dealing with relative positioning of tabs instead of absolute positioning. And Safari's tab bar does not screw with relative positioning.
- detaro 9y agoIt gives you less clear landmarks though. Spatial navigation through 20 items with no differentiation isn't easy. Even if you know "9 items from the right", you can't do easily do that subconsciously. "The tab next to the Stack Overflow one" or "The third Stack Overflow tab" is a lot easier in comparison. At least for me, navigating a lot of sites without favicons or large amounts with the same one decreases efficiency a lot, for exactly this reason.
- chrismorgan 9y agoIf your tabs scroll in Firefox, there’s a dropdown at the right which lists all tabs. I find this decidedly superior to the overflow behaviour you describe.
- bangonkeyboard 9y agoI'm not seeing any differences between the two.
- malnourish 9y agoI wonder when, if ever, vertical tabs will become the norm, or even a well-supported option. They seem to resolve most tab issues while also being a better use of space in many use cases.
- esMazer 9y agoswitched on firefox and can't look back!
- kakarot 9y agoJust another reason why Firefox is king. Another killer feature for me is that you can basically middle click anything and open it in a new tab, whether a bookmark, back button, etc. Makes some tasks very intuitive and trying to maintain the same workflow on Chrome is extremely frustrating. I cannot understand for the life of me why this isn't a native feature in Chrome.
- blcArmadillo 9y agoMiddle click works the same way in Chrome
- doubleunplussed 9y agoYou can even middle-click-and-hold the back button, bringing up the tab history so you can go back to a page several steps back in a new tab!
- kakarot 9y agoDoesn't work for me on GNU/Linux. I checked a Windows VM and it works from there. My browsing mainly occurs in Linux so this is still an issue.
- blcArmadillo 9y agoHumm, it worked for me in a VM running Ubuntu.
- wvenable 9y agoWith Firefox you can go one better and install the TabMixPlus extension and get multi-row tabs. I don't know how anyone functions with Chrome or Safari -- any reasonable number of tabs is unusable to me.
- chrismorgan 9y agoEnjoy it while it lasts—as of Firefox 57 (November) such functionality will be dead in the water. The sidebar panel is able to be used for things like vertical tabs, but there’s nothing which would allow the browser tab bar to wrap onto multiple lines (and I don’t expect it to ever happen). (I run Nightly and have successfully migrated all my extensions to WebExtensions alternatives with only very minor loss or change of functionality.)
- wvenable 9y agoYeah that will probably end my use of Firefox or I'll just "never" upgrade.
- chrismorgan 9y agoI’ve been a Firefox user since 0.93, with a year or so in the middle when I was forced to use Chrome as my primary browser because I was needing to run it from a USB drive and Firefox was just too slow from a USB drive. (I could switch back with Firefox 4.) There are really good reasons for the move to WebExtensions, technical, for security and for performance. I was intensely sceptical of the timeline initially announced, but as a Nightly user I can report that November is actually sounding very reasonable now. Not upgrading your browser leaves you insecure, and within a year or two websites will start breaking on you. In little things of design, mostly, but steadily more and more. Oh, and you’ll miss out on the continuing performance improvements of the Quantum project. (Also, what would you migrate to? Even without XUL addons, Firefox is still going to be better for what you want than all the mainstream alternatives.)
- wvenable 9y ago
- ash_gti 9y agoI think you only see fav icons in safari mobile in the bookmarks menu as well.
- TazeTSchnitzel 9y agoI wonder if it's because Apple didn't like the mush that 16x16 favicons become on Retina screens with their preferred linear upscaling. Of course, other sizes of favicons are possible for use by site owners (.ICO supports multiple resolutions in a single file!), and there's no particularly good reason to use linear upscaling for what's often pixel art.
- yborg 9y agoThis predates Retina by like a decade.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- robin_reala 9y agoIE used to use 32×32 for saving a bookmark to the desktop, 16×16 for the address bar favicon.
- visarga 9y agoAll favicons appear normal on retina display. Source - writing this on a retina macbook.
- abrookins 9y agoTotally valid. If they were going to change one thing about Safari, though, for me it would be to drop the required $99/year payment for a developer program membership just to distribute a signed Safari plugin. You can't really distribute plugins without a developer certificate, as Safari uninstalls them automatically when the browser restarts. Probably the worst Safari-related decision Apple has made recently, much worse than favicons, though I completely agree that they should return.
- rubatuga 9y agoYou can always distribute unsigned ones. You lose the ability to auto update however, as well as the extension store
- abrookins 9y agoSo far, I haven't found a way to stop Safari from uninstalling an unsigned extension when it restarts. Have you? Because that would be great! More conversation about this issue: https://forums.developer.apple.com/thread/3675 https://forums.developer.apple.com/thread/3675
- rubatuga 9y agoI've just installed the following extension, and it persists when I restart the browser: https://github.com/JoeKuhns/PiedPiPer.safariextension https://github.com/JoeKuhns/PiedPiPer.safariextension
- bangonkeyboard 9y agoThat extension is signed. You cannot build a .safariextz archive without paying for a signing certificate.
- abrookins 9y agoIndeed. If you add an unsigned plugin (that is, one lacking a .safariextz file) to Extension Builder and try to install it from there, and you do not already have a developer certificate, you will see the message, "Without a Safari Extensions Certificate, this extension will only be available until you quit Safari." And it will be so.
- amir 9y agoSafari should also stop restoring private windows upon reopening.
- sp332 9y agoWhoa, that's not cool. It stores all your private tabs on disk somewhere?
- rubatuga 9y agoThey’re copying iOS behaviour
- 0xCMP 9y agoAgreed, but it should change. On iOS the OS can kill the browser for you so you may still want that page you didn't kill. On the OS quitting the browser should reset it back to a normal state that doesn't include the private tabs you had.
- glhaynes 9y agoI don't really see why a distinction would be made there. iOS's and macOS's process models are being made more similar as time goes on. And as a heavy user of both platforms I'd find it surprising if it didn't behave this way. An option to change it would be welcome, though.
- staplung 9y agoIt's worth noting that Safari _can_ display favicons. If you pin a tab, it uses the favicon. It's even displayed in monochrome until you hover over the tab so they've definitely worked out a way to display them.
- bouke 9y agoThat’s not the favicon that’s being shown there. It is either a b/w mask as defined by the site, or defaulting to the first letter of the site’s name.
- andrethegiant 9y agoCorrect — defined by <link rel="mask-icon" />
- yoodenvranx 9y agoUnfortunately there is a general trend towards removing colorful icons and I hate that trend with a passion. Take for example the setting menu from stock Android: Yes, there are still icon but they all have the same color and it is really difficult to tell them apart. Every time I go to settings I have to search around until I find the settings I was looking for. If it had colorful icons then navigation would be easier because my brain would learn "blue icon = keyboard settings" Or take Chrome on Android: Open Chrome, press the three dots on the bottom right for the menu and try to find the 'search in page' entry. Every time i wanna search something I have to read half of the menu items to find the search function... If it would have a distinct icon it would be much easier to find.
- kakarot 9y agoMy bookmarks bar is a row of unlabeled favicons arranged by color. Beautiful and extremely efficient. I only need to store the color of an icon in my head, not the icon itself or the url. If this ever gets taken away from me I will become extremely cross.
- jasonkostempski 9y agoI don't use bookmark bars anymore, but when I did I remember noticing that most things I bookmarked were blue for some reason. Maybe that's the reason I stopped finding it useful.
- rbritton 9y agoIt's a couple years old now, but there's a similar trend towards certain colors in the iOS universe too: http://hboon.com/ios-app-icon-colors-in-the-year-2015/ http://hboon.com/ios-app-icon-colors-in-the-year-2015/
- icelancer 9y agoThis is exactly what I do. I am floored to hear that people are considering moving away from favicons. It's a tremendous space saver. The all-out war on bookmarks and the original ways we organized information back in the 90s on the web is getting to be absurd.
- drcongo 9y agoI much prefer to have no favicons. They're a really poor indicator of the content of the tab, especially when 20 of them are Stack Overflow and Read the Docs. Safari has a really good way of visually distinguishing between tabs, a two fingered pinch on the trackpad and I can see the actual content of every tab that I have open. Can't remember the last time I even looked at the text in the tabs.
- abrookins 9y agoIndeed, it is good. And for non-trackpad-users, Shift-Command-\ is the keyboard shortcut for "Show All Tabs," which also makes the tabs searchable.
- ProfessorLayton 9y agoTab Exposé is one of my favorite features in Safari (Right behind Reader view) that I wish other browsers copied.
- pswenson 9y agoit's cool, but can't scroll them w/o mouse/trackpad. cursor keys don't work :(
- dbbk 9y agoThe user experience once you have many tabs open in Chrome just completely falls apart. The tabs shrink so tiny you can hardly see them, and there's no way to reorganize them other than to one-by-one pull them out into a new window. Safari, on the other hand, has Tab Exposé and also horizontally scrolls the tab bar once there are too many. It's such a simple thing that makes a huge difference.
- ecoffey 9y agoYou can shift click a range, or command click a disjoint set, of tabs in chrome. And then with one mouse drag move all of them to an existing window or create a new one. It's a feature that I wish safari had (although I have tried tab expose)
- kin 9y agoI agree for sure. At the very least have it as a preference. My bookmark bar consists of icons w/ no label. I treat Favicons more or less like I do iOS app icons.
- coverband 9y agoIt should first start displaying the whole URL on my phone.
- eridius 9y agoIf you tap on the URL bar, it does. What's the argument for showing it all the time? There's not enough space to show the entirety of even relatively short URLs without scrolling (and scrolling means tapping on it anyway).
- Crontab 9y agoPersonally, I am not a fan of Favicons; it feels like yet another form of advertising - which the web has more than enough of.
- phailhaus 9y agoThat doesn't seem to make sense. Favicons tend to be the website logo, making it easy to pick out the tab when you have multiple open. The favicon tells you the site, the tab title tells you the page.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- matrixagent 9y agoBy far my biggest gripe with Safari is the behaviour of the URL bar: https://www.reddit.com/r/Safari/comments/2uikrg/any_way_to_disable_the_centeralignment_of_the_url/ https://www.reddit.com/r/Safari/comments/2uikrg/any_way_to_d...
- mistersquid 9y agoI agree a centered URL is a bit of aesthetic ridiculousness when exposing the entire URL. Aesthetic opinions aside, the linked complaint relies on a workflow that could be considered a UI anti-pattern. 1. Move hand to mouse. 2. Position cursor. 3. Click URL bar. (activate caret) 4. Move hand(s) to keyboard. 5. Type replacement. The following workflow lends itself more easily to UI automation (and muscle memory) 1. Type Command-L. ("Open Location…" which selects all in location bar.) 2. Type left/right-arrow. (Move caret to left/right side of location bar.) 3. Option left/right-arrow. (move caret left/right one "word".) 4. Type replacement. The distinct advantage of the second workflow is that it is susceptible to the automated editing of URLs of many tabs using Keyboard Maestro [0] and a simple AppleScript. Combined with keyboard tab-switching (Command-shift-[ and Command-shift-] for next left and right tab, respectively, you can fast web-page switch to spot small differences similar to the way in which a Hinman Collator works to highlight differences between bound books. [1] Admittedly (and a bit off-topic), the link I provide for the Hinman Collator doesn't exactly illuminate what such a device does. A better demonstration of how collation can be used to highlight subtle visual differences between two artifacts can be derived in the service of solving a puzzle from one of my favorite web sites, Kindertrauma. [2] The puzzle, which asks you to spot the differences between a series of two photos, is mildly challenging. That mild challenge is reduced to laughably simple when the images are collated. [3] EDIT: Move parenthetical into footnote. Add adverbial phrase to footnote parenthetical. Rewrite Kindertrauma example. General readability. [0] https://www.keyboardmaestro.com/main/ https://www.keyboardmaestro.com/main/ (I'd be embarrassed to name drop Keyboard Maestro yet again here on HN if it just weren't so darned useful. A truly amazing piece of software Keyboard Maestro is. No relationship except as a satisfied user.) [1] http://library.unc.edu/2016/11/video-hinman-collator-compare-contrast-create/ http://library.unc.edu/2016/11/video-hinman-collator-compare... [2] https://www.kindertrauma.com/the-thing-2011-funhouse/ https://www.kindertrauma.com/the-thing-2011-funhouse/ [3] https://secure.fluffycloud.net/shimmering/kindertrauma/20111014.The-Thing-2011-Funhouse/ https://secure.fluffycloud.net/shimmering/kindertrauma/20111...
- Sujan 9y agoiTunes Connect and other Apple properties that developers tend to bookmark should have favicons. Then you could just edit out the title/name and identify by icon.
- logand 9y agoI made a Safari extension that simulates favicons by prefixing tab titles with emoji. It's not a perfect substitute, but it's made it a lot easier for me to distinguish between tabs. https://github.com/logandaniels/emoji-tab-icons https://github.com/logandaniels/emoji-tab-icons
- throwaway2016a 9y agoOut of curiosity, how does it know which Emoji to use?
- petrosh 9y agoso you don't even read 15 lines of readme?
- heavymark 9y agoThat type of response probably won't get too many people rushing to your GitHub that you are suggesting here people should try out. To answer his question, it appears it allows you to manually add/choose a emoji on a site by site basis. As of December it looks like you can now set differently for different subdomains or other variations. Also appears to offer some suggested options to choose from for popular sites.
- oDot 9y agoFirefox shines here. Not only does it have the favicons but typing a site in AwesomeBar will prompt to "jump to tab".
- StronglyTyped 9y agoIs Apple even still working on Safari?
- ash_gti 9y agoThey release every other week updates to Safari Technology Preview as well as daily builds of Webkit. Both include new features. They have blog posts about feature development as well here: https://webkit.org/blog/ https://webkit.org/blog/
- runnr_az 9y agoForget favicons... it supports emoji domains!
- omn1 9y agoI never understood why people wanted their tabs on the top instead of on the side. I'm using [Tree Style Tab][1] on Firefox and whenever I need to use any browser I feel limited by screen real estate. With modern widescreen displays I can have my tabs on the side and the titles are still readable while the website content is readable, too. What's not to like? [1]: https://addons.mozilla.org/de/firefox/addon/tree-style-tab/ https://addons.mozilla.org/de/firefox/addon/tree-style-tab/
- bhnmmhmd 9y agoThanks for introducing this extension. Turns out, it's available for Chrome as well: https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/sidewise-tree-style-tabs/biiammgklaefagjclmnlialkmaemifgo?hl=en https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/sidewise-tree-styl...
- konart 9y agoIt's not. Chrome counterpart is just a weak attempt to make something similar. At the very best.
- lowboy 9y agoI use a 4k monitor and my browser window is usually 1280x2160.
- StavrosK 9y agoSame here, portrait orientation is amazing for everything that's not watching video. The latest Gitlab redesign really irks me because the left sidebar takes up 30% of my tall and narrow screen.
- type0 9y agoPortrait i.e vertical orientation screen gives you so much more overview for source files. For portrait orientation even smaller screens benefit from 4k
- 9y ago
- mthoms 9y agoFor anyone willing to get a little experimental (it requires mySIMBL), Github user anakinsk's fork of SafariStand can enable tab favicons. It's a total hack though.... every time a new version of Safari is released it tends to break. But kudos to him for trying. https://github.com/anakinsk/SafariStand https://github.com/anakinsk/SafariStand Here's a (long) thread with some of the backstory about why this is so difficult: https://github.com/anakinsk/SafariStand/issues/38 https://github.com/anakinsk/SafariStand/issues/38
- dwighttk 9y agoI wouldn't mind favicons in the url bar when the cursor isn't in it too if we are adding things to safari.
- ams6110 9y agoDaring Fireball should use a larger font and better contrast. Thank goodness for Reader mode.
- packeted 9y agoI completely agree, one of the things that keeps me coming back to Chrome is favicons in tabs which is particularly useful when you have a bunch of tabs open. I also have a favorites bar with purely favicons so I can fit as many of my regular sites/resources in there as possible while still looking visually appealing.
- vermooten 9y agoThis is the single reason I don't use Safari.
- khana 9y agoyyyea.... NO. KISS
- chmaynard 9y agoSheesh, Daring Fireball whips up another tempest in a teapot. If he isn't more careful, Gruber could lose his "most favored blogger" status at Apple.
- 0xCMP 9y agoI concur. I don't use safari because it feels worse. I felt the reason was I couldn't easily identify where my tab was supposed to be easily without reading. Many websites these days do not provide super great titles. Although I do kind of wish some of these browsers supported the ability to switch tabs similar to emacs and give me a full view to select and search between tabs. It would also show the favicon.
- MBCook 9y agoI'm quite surprised to find myself disagreeing with Gruber on this one. I like the way safari works currently, I don't want a bunch of loud little icons crowding up my screen. I don't have any problem identifying the tabs I have, and as others I have mentioned I can just use tab expose to find them quickly. I've seen a few mockups on Twitter that he's re-tweeted recently and they just look more cluttered to me. That may come from using Safari as my main browser for 13+ years, but I'm certainly quite happy with things the way they are.
- kevindong 9y agoI tried out Safari for a week but I just couldn't stay there because extension support was terrible. Technically, the two critical extensions I use (LastPass and uBlock Origin) support Safari in some form, however they were strictly worse than the Chrome version. I can tolerate to some degree worse extensions. However, the UX was just _too_ bad to stand. To be perfectly honest, I didn't even realize Safari lacked favicons until I read this article. I generally close tabs are soon as I finish using them. Consequently, I never have more than ~5 tabs open at any given moment.
- MBCook 9y ago> However, the UX was just _too_ bad to stand. How so?
- kevindong 9y agoFor me at least, the auto fill feature in LastPass didn't work half the time. Simultaneously, LastPass doesn't let me copy and paste my password without opening up the 'Edit' page for that particular username/password entry. In Chrome, the autofill feature didn't always work either (but it did work >90% of the time). However, I could just click the little 'LastPass' logo that popped up in the username/password field and click the 'Copy' button on my password. For uBlock Origin (or rather, the fork of it since the actual developer abandoned the official version due to the difficulty of developing for Safari), I _hated_ how the icon in the toolbar displays the number of elements blocked in a big red badge that you couldn't turn off. I couldn't just remove it from the toolbar either because uBlock Origin frequently blocks what it thinks is an ad but is actually a critical part of a webpage. The only way to show the webpage correctly is to disable uBlock Origin for that webpage. And the only way to do that was to click on the button in the toolbar. One of my favorite extensions for Chrome is 'Disable HTML5 Autoplay' which just blocks HTML5 videos from auto playing. Safari has no such extension. I also hated how when you type in a web address in the omnibar in Safari and hit enter, half the time there would be no response (i.e. no loading bar, no change in the tab's contents, etc.). I don't actually know what's happening behind the scenes, but a refresh usually fixed it.
- m3kw9 9y agoFavicons rainbowing up my top tab just acts as even more distractions. It only helps marginally because if you open 10 stackoverflow tabs, you would still need to open each one to see what’s what. That’s why Safari has the tabs overview view that shows you what’s inside. You can’t tell exactly, but you can most of the time.
- omnifischer 9y ago>The Mac attracts visual thinkers and its design encourages visual thinking. Any proof?
- konart 9y agoOne of the reasons why I don't use Safari (aside from almost no extensions, dev tools, tabs below navigation). Even though I usually use Vimium's T to navigate through tabs I still feel disoriented with no favicons on tabs. What I don't really get - why is this not optional setting?
- hungerstrike 9y agoFavicons in Safari for Mac? That's the least problem. They need to fix Safari on iOS so that it doesn't open the same site over and over again in a different tab each time. They also need to catch up to the rest of the world and give the user a choice of which browser to open up by default on iOS. Oh, this is Apple though - they give you the absolute least amount of functionality that they can get away with while charging the highest prices. I can't wait for the time of Apple to come to an end.
- fredsir 9y ago> They need to fix Safari on iOS so that it doesn't open the same site over and over again in a different tab each time. Seems to work perfectly fine for me. > They also need to catch up to the rest of the world and give the user a choice of which browser to open up by default on iOS. It's not as simple as that. If you want an OS that everyone can use, options are your enemy. Would I like to be able to decide the standard browser on my OS? To be honest, I don't care in this instance since I like Safari better than the alternatives, but sure, the choice would be great to have should that change.
- hungerstrike 9y ago> Seems to work perfectly fine for me. Thanks. It still doesn't work fine for me. > It's not as simple as that. Yes, it is. > If you want an OS that everyone can use, options are your enemy. That's a ridiculously absurd notion and it couldn't be further from the truth. I'm not even going to ask you because you've got no evidence for this whatsoever. It equates exactly to "Choices are bad". Perhaps that is true for marketing purposes but not for solving actual real-life problems. I guess we have our answer now though because "more marketing and less functionality" fits precisely within Apple's modus-operandi.
- fredsir 9y ago> Thanks. It still doesn't work fine for me. Sucks for you, you should probably talk to apple about it since it's probably a bug. > Yes, it is. No it isn't, and it has been shown numerous times. You have probably experienced it yourself with a parent or someone else needing your help because they were trying to do change their wallpaper on their windows pc and now their internet is not working anymore. More options equals more complexity which isn't good if you need your phone to work for as many people as possible. iOS even has had its fair share of problems with this for example with its third-party keyboards with people installing them from the App Store and coming back later and having no idea how they did turn them on, or that they even did so, they just did what the app told them to do while they thought they were installing some game and now they can't hit the keys any more because it's all different, and they don't remember what happened nor how to get things back to normal. > That's a ridiculously absurd notion and it couldn't be further from the truth. I'm not even going to ask you because you've got no evidence for this whatsoever. No it isn't, and a very famous and popular book was even written about it by Barry Schwartz called The Paradox of Choice: Why More is Less which spiked a lot of research on the topic. You should read it. > It equates exactly to "Choices are bad". Perhaps that is true for marketing purposes but not for solving actual real-life problems. I guess we have our answer now though because "more marketing and less functionality" fits precisely within Apple's modus-operandi. Yes it is. It might not be optimal for you specifically, but if they made a phone that worked perfectly for you, it possibly wouldn't work perfectly for me, and surely not for my grandmother. Why? Because we need very different things from our phones. If you introduce all the features all 700+ million of active iPhone users need/want, the phone would be a complete cluster fuck. Even if you took the features of a few 100 select but very different people, that would be the case. I would say that Android phones is a perfect example of why more (choices) is less (good). I can't remember when I last had to help someone with a problem with their iOS devices, but every time I am with a family member that uses android, they have a bunch of problems piled up for me they need help with. Of course, it's not only android but just as much the terrible apps that is on the android platform, but low quality apps is something the android platform enables, so it's kinda it's fault too. The solution is not to put every single option into iOS. It's to have a wider range of operating systems that are tailored for different groups of people, like hacker types, the "I only call, text and facebook" type, and so on, but that costs a lot more money and takes a lot more time than making a single device that everybody buys.