4 ms·
I read this article last weekend and after reading it, I put batteries in my shortwave radio to see what was out there. Turns out, there's pretty much nothing.
by criddell 9y ago
I read this article last weekend and after reading it, I put batteries in my shortwave radio to see what was out there. Turns out, there's pretty much nothing.
I couldn't hear anything on 4625 kHz. I let my receiver scan and when it was done I checked out what it detected and found absolutely nothing interesting. The most powerful signals were Christian broadcasts that had a kind of doomsday feeling about them.
It seems like there's a lot of underutilized spectrum.
- tuxxy 9y agoWere you in a good spot? I can hear a lot of stuff with my shortwave receiver and I'm in SLC, Utah. Occasionally, I get to hear pirate transmissions and whatnot.
- criddell 9y agoI'm in central Texas (Austin). No idea if that's a good spot or not. I pick up a lot on the FM and AM bands. The shortwave bands feel comparatively empty.
- PappaPatat 9y ago"pirate transmissions" I am surprised. Only a month ago I met a guy who (as an "art project") has actually started to transmit on the shortwave. Bought an old army radio and was now jumping all over the country with the installation and transmitting... well, arty stuff. He claimed he got responses every now and then, now I think he might be right. Is that a thing? I bailed out of the radio waves 30 years ago when I got access to data links...
- wedowhatwedo 9y agoAs the article says, just because you couldn't hear it the one time you tried, doesn't mean it isn't transmitting. You hearing it depends on the condition of the ionosphere. The time of day, the number of sunspots along with other things will effect your reception of the signal.
- squarefoot 9y agoNight hours are best for shortwave reception. You could also need an external antenna depending on how far you are listening from. Another problem, probably the biggest one today, which affects reception on these frequencies (and generally on the HF bands) is the radio noise generated by many bad designed switching power supplies and appliances. Switching regulators (power supplies, converters, chargers etc.) for efficiency and size reasons have moved from the tens of KHz through the hundreds of KHz and recently they started working above 1 MHz which means having into our homes one or more transmitters with antennas (mains or output cable) that if not properly designed, filtered and shielded will render reception on HF bands next to impossible.
- criddell 9y agoThanks for the information. The shortwave frequencies still feel very underutilized. When I scan the FM (88 - 108 MHz) and AM (540-1600 kHz) radio frequencies, I pick up a lot of stuff. The shortwave band is relatively vast and feels very sparse. Considering how valuable spectrum is these days, it's hard to believe that we couldn't find a better use for it. Is it because it is so prone to noise that it's less valuable?
- eeZah7Ux 9y agoBandwidth is key. Transmitting digital signals at high rate would eat up most of the spectrum.
- hourislate 9y agoFrom what I understand it isn't on all the time. There are actually long periods of time where it doesn't transmit anything. Last week when I was digging a little deeper I ran into an older discussion on another board where they were saying it was off for years and came back on when Russia invaded Ukraine. It could be off again, don't know.
- crispyambulance 9y ago> The most powerful signals were Christian broadcasts that had a kind of doomsday feeling about them. Perhaps WMLK? Weird stuff coming from Berks County PA! Here's the antenna: https://www.google.com/maps/@40.4793923,-76.279183,3a,44y,282.49h,101.16t/data=!3m6!1e1!3m4!1sH4_xv__VjD34GAZpLV5ycg!2e0!7i13312!8i6656 https://www.google.com/maps/@40.4793923,-76.279183,3a,44y,28...
- criddell 9y agoThat sounds familiar. I think I was also getting something from somewhere near Scottsdale, AZ.
- jacquesm 9y agoIt might be single sideband, try USB or LSB.
- simmons 9y agoAs others have mentioned, the time of day may have effected reception of the 4625 kHz station. However, in general, I've noticed that there seems to be far fewer stations received on the shortwave band these days, compared to the 1980's when I listened to shortwave a lot as a kid. I think this is because I'm using a low-end receiver with its built-in telescopic antenna instead of a more sophisticated SWL setup with a proper antenna. Broadcasters such as the BBC World Service target specific geographies with their transmissions so they can be received on a low-end radio, and they no longer bother targeting developed regions such as North America with these transmissions. I'm guessing if I used the same radio somewhere like Africa, I'd be able to pick up a lot more stations.
- Neliquat 9y agoMore noise to signal also.
- soneil 9y ago> It seems like there's a lot of underutilized spectrum. There's some good reasons for this. HF is pretty challenging to fully utilize. You have propagation that varies between "worldwide" (so it's difficult to assign new bands without ITU involvement), and "sunspot" (so you better have a plan B). And these variations aren't just over the duration of a sunspot cycle, but also over the day/night cycle. eg, for maritime use, we have channel clusters at 2, 4, 6, 8, 12 and 16MHz. Which to use depends on the time of day the distance to the other station, and how much the sunspot cycle is messing with your first choice. Fun! Then the physical challenges that arise from the ideal antenna length being proportional to the length of the wave. At 2.4GHz the challenge is precisely cutting your quarter-wave antenna to a fraction of a mm (31.25mm). At 2.4MHz same challenge becomes finding space for a 31.25m (~100feet) antenna. Another big consideration is that these frequencies aren't particularly friendly to high-speed digital use. I suspect this is related to Nyquist theorem - the fewer waves you're receiving per second, the fewer symbols per second can be encoded into them. And finally, some rather difficult legacy users. Aviation and Marine users who consider their usage life-or-death, radio amateurs that likely do too (heh), radio-navigation (I was reading about Loran making a comeback recently, to provide some backup when GPS is manipulated), over-the-horizon radar (which can be a lot like sharing a telephone call with a foghorn), etc. All this taking up about as much bandwidth as one wifi channel ..