6 ms·
Progress relies strongly on people working together toward a common goal. If being "unreasonable" works for Linux, that's fine. But before others go trying to b
by kibwen 9y ago
Progress relies strongly on people working together toward a common goal. If being "unreasonable" works for Linux, that's fine. But before others go trying to blindly emulate Linus, I'd suggest attempting to be reasonable first.
- emidln 9y agoNobody cares how reasonable you are if you don't actually produce anything.
- kibwen 9y agoAnd nobody cares how much you produce if you're too unreasonable to sell them on your creation. Creating strawmen out of maximally-extreme arguments is silly. Unless you think that being reasonable is mutually exclusive with being productive?
- laumars 9y agoI think it's fair to say Linus has already proven his worth. But even the Linux kernel and git aside, the fact that people listen to him despite his frankness speaks volumes for how respected he is.
- kibwen 9y agoAgreed, just as it would be a fallacy to presume that one can't be both productive and polite, it would also be a fallacy to believe that being impolite immediately invalidates all productive endeavors. I'm not using this thread to try to tear Linus down, just trying to keep people from promulgating the myth that Linus' governance style is the only effective one. :P
- lomnakkus 9y agoTrue, but irrelevant for Linus. It's not a good way to get ahead[1], but if you're already far enough ahead... Personally, I think I'm on "your" side -- as it were -- on the side of civility, but sometimes you've just got to get shit done. Properly, which sometimes means shouting the right things at the right people[2]. I do think it's unreasonable of you to say that Linus is not "being reasonable", as you've clearly implied in your comment. To my mind he's being entirely reasonable, just not very "polite" or "civil" or whatever you want to call it. [1] As in: Rise up the corporate ladder. [2] Sorkin's "Too Big To Fail" was a big eye-opener in this regard, FWIW.
- kibwen 9y ago> I do think it's unreasonable of you to say that Linus is not "being reasonable", as you've clearly implied in your comment. I'm literally using the terminology of the person that I'm trying to refute! :P If you want to argue phrasing, take that to jacquesm.
- lomnakkus 9y agoI'm sorry. I was too carried away to notice! :) (Which reminds me: There should probably be some sort of mandatory-quoting mechanism on HN. It seems weird that you can snipe comments by editing at just the right time. That's not what happened in this case, I'm just saying that it would probably be a good thing to have measures against it. Sorry, that's my META-rant done.)
- Daishiman 9y ago> And nobody cares how much you produce if you're too unreasonable to sell them on your creation. But Linus already has.
- jacquesm 9y agoWhat people really don't seem to get is that Linus' cultural background is Finnish, and that Finns tend to be extremely outspoken and that they couldn't lie or polish their words if their life depended on it. http://www.karelia.fi/welcomingguide/the-finnish-way-of-life http://www.karelia.fi/welcomingguide/the-finnish-way-of-life What to American sensibilities are grave insults to Linus is most likely just him speaking his mind without any filter in place, the way he was brought up.
- kibwen 9y agoI'm aware of this, and I can respect differences attributable to different cultural norms. But firstly, I have spoken to a Finnish developer who has said that he also considers Linus more frustrating than average; secondly, acknowledging cultural differences creates a foundation for effective communication, but does not infallibly forgive any and all transgressions (context still matters); and thirdly, most other developers will not have the excuse of being Finnish, and so my suggestion to other developers to consider alternative approaches stands (i.e. blindly emulating Linus as an attempt to lead a software project makes as much sense as blindly emulating Steve Jobs in an attempt to lead a company).
- jacquesm 9y agoWell, personally I prefer the 'Linus' approach rather than the politically correct avoid-the-language-of-conflict and make sure you dress up every insult as a compliment approach, but I can see why if you're not used to it it can be tough. Sure, Linus is an outlier, even by Finnish standards, but I'm willing to cut the guy some slack because of his contributions, I'd be less willing to cut someone slack who does not have the required merit badges and who just goes around insulting people for effect. Linus simply has a hard time feeling passionate about stuff he really cares about and expressing himself in a way that would not be frowned on at the boardroom level. It's a problem, but it's mostly his problem and I've yet to see others emulating him so if that's a huge problem I'm not presently aware of it (and I meet lots of developers).
- geofft 9y ago
- aerovistae 9y agoNo, progress often relies on both those things-- people working reasonably together on ideas brought forward by people who might be deemed "unreasonable."
- Shorel 9y agoProgress also requires a common standard. Linux is not unreasonable, it just has its own standards. Things that don't conform to that standard are 'garbage' or are simply in other words 'non compliant'. Linus could express all the same ideas without profanity, if people cared about quality as much as he does. Strictly enforcing some compliance to their developing process doesn't make Linux development 'unreasonable', because trying to change their developing process just because of some external web tool doesn't constitute 'reasoning'. Trying to change their development process is just fire and motion ( https://www.joelonsoftware.com/2002/01/06/fire-and-motion/ https://www.joelonsoftware.com/2002/01/06/fire-and-motion/ ) from a third party.