10 ms·
The document is the definition of sexism and a perfect example of why we still need diversity laws and programs. Despite the attempts to provide disclaimers, m
by ilaksh 9y ago
The document is the definition of sexism and a perfect example of why we still need diversity laws and programs.
Despite the attempts to provide disclaimers, many of the comments he wrote were explicitly sexist. For example the sections "Personality differences" and "Men's higher drive for status".
Sexism means prejudice related to gender. Prejudice means pre-judging a group. For example the belief that women do not have as high as drive for status can (and previously has been) used as an excuse for promoting men instead of women or a particular man instead of a particular woman.
https://assets.documentcloud.org/documents/3914586/Googles-Ideological-Echo-Chamber.pdf https://assets.documentcloud.org/documents/3914586/Googles-I...
And other comments. In the context of discussion of things like hiring, promotion and pay, acting on the beliefs he stated has been outlawed (even though unfortunately these biases are still very prevalent). If they do not fire him, the document will be used as evidence in discriminatory lawsuits.
These sexist beliefs are still just as popular as ageist and racist beliefs. Many may be able to find scientific studies that back up their prejudice. There are usually studies backing up just about any view, just due to the nature of science. Regardless of how well accepted or not these studies are, the laws have already been made years before. So if you want these types of prejudicial beliefs to be openly consulted in hiring, promotion, etc. decisions in companies, those laws will need to be changed.
- visarga 9y ago> Prejudice means pre-judging a group. Would it be a prejudice to say women on average are less tall than men? Where do you draw the line between "pre-judgement" and "statistics" (can we call it post-judgement?). Height is OK but work drive is not OK to post-judge?
- ilaksh 9y agoIn this context it's clearly a prejudicial belief that he is promoting that can have negative consequences for women. Go ahead and bury my comments. Judges will eventually explain the laws to you people.
- baumy 9y agoThe author took great pain to distinguish between traits having a tendency to exist at higher rates within a group, and traits being exhibited by an individual. You don't seem to have comprehended his point. Barring diversity programs allowing members of select groups to pass a lower hiring/performance bar, a person sitting at the desk next to me at work is just as likely to be a competent engineer as anyone else, regardless of their gender. But if you were to take 1,000 women and 1,000 men from a young age and treat them precisely equally, there are strong scientific arguments that we should expect to see a larger number of the men go into tech than women. To reiterate, this says precisely nothing about the qualifications and competency of individuals who actually enter tech, it only speaks to the relative number of men and women we ought to expect our workforce to be composed of. It could be that the natural result of equal opportunity for all men and women to enter tech is for there to be more than 50% men, possibly quite a bit more. Again, there is a lot of research that indicates this (for citations, see the "manifesto").
- aaomidi 9y agoHow does this apply to other countries where women are higher in STEM and tech than men? For example, in Iran more than 60% of STEM students are female.
- baumy 9y agoI am not particularly knowledgeable about that, so I don't have much to offer here. I'll take a stab, but I don't have anything to cite, and my opinions aren't well informed - For various reasons I don't want to go into on this thread, Iran is not a society that I think should be looked up to and emulated. It frequently gets cited as an example of highly misogynistic culture, and as far as I know has plenty of laws / official practices that codify inequality of women in a way that many other developed countries (e.g., the United States, countries in the EU, etc) don't. I'm happy to be corrected on this as I really don't know all that much about Iran, but I strongly suspect the people decrying the google essay as being sexist would agree that Iran is not a good role model for egalitarian society. Regardless, from what little I do know, if the structure of Iranian society/culture is what it takes to get high representation of women in STEM, is that really worth it? I have one more thing to add - I found this video to be thought provoking: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=p5LRdW8xw70&t=300 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=p5LRdW8xw70&t=300 (I've linked to a specific time where the material is particularly relevant, but the whole thing is worth a watch) To summarize, that video makes the observation that less wealthy, less egalitarian countries have higher rates of women in typically male professions. Conversely, very rich and egalitarian countries have a lower amount of women in them. The explanation for this phenomenon that is proposed in the video (if I remember right, I watched this years ago) is that when factors like wages, status, family expectations, etc are given less and less importance, and people are therefore relatively more free to choose professions based on desire rather than need, women tend to avoid jobs within STEM fields. To be clear, that's merely one interpretation of the data (although it sounds plausible to me), there are likely other valid ones.
- davidreiss 9y ago> The document is the definition of sexism I would love some examples of your accusation. You say it's the "definition of sexism". So you must have plenty of examples from his writing. > and a perfect example of why we still need diversity laws and programs. Yes. The fact the guy got fired for having his own opinions proves that we are in a dire need for diversity of thought and ideas. > For example the belief that women do not have as high as drive for status can (and previously has been) used as an excuse for promoting men instead of women or a particular man instead of a particular woman. But that's societal/evolutionary theory proposed by some scientists/thinkers? Also, the belief that women can't compete with men physically is used as an excuse to created women's tennis assocation, WNBA, women's hockey, women's soccer, etc? Is that sexist? There is sexism and there is biological facts/inquiry/etc. He was just offering a possible explanation for why more men are in leadership roles. "The greater tendency for men to be interested in having a higher status fits with a long line of biological research dating back to Darwin. It seems men believe that higher status brings the mating opportunities that come with being top dog." https://phys.org/news/2012-12-women-money-men-status.html https://phys.org/news/2012-12-women-money-men-status.html http://rspb.royalsocietypublishing.org/content/early/2010/12/04/rspb.2010.2145 http://rspb.royalsocietypublishing.org/content/early/2010/12... http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/science/evolution/9005552/Men-twice-as-likely-to-take-risks.html http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/science/evolution/9005552/Me... It's almost as if humans were evolutionarily driven to be this way. Is science and discussing scientific topics now bigotry? If that's why people are upset and if that's why he got fired, then google is going to lose and he's going to be wealthy.