12 ms·
Amid layoffs, Microsofties reveal further turmoil in Redmond
- ryanjmo 16y agoIt looks like pg was right 3 years ago: http://www.paulgraham.com/microsoft.html http://www.paulgraham.com/microsoft.html
- watmough 16y agoYeah, Microsoft was relevant to me when the launched Access in about '96 or so. Then there was a brief spell of relevance with .NET and all the cool stuff attached to that. Since then, Linux or OS X have become the OS' of choice for many techies, and open software has eaten the lunch of MS when it comes to internet development. MS are on life support (though in a quite comfortable state!) kept alive by a HUGE installed and locked-in base. There are flickers of life in Office and Windows 7, but they may be fighting a losing battle in future markets, likely to be more cost sensitive than the high productivity and high-priced US.
- arethuza 16y agoAbout the comment on Microsoft being evil like Commodus - I've been listening to the excellent "History of Rome" podcast and it points out that the real Commodus was quite a bit nastier/madder than the character in Gladiator. http://thehistoryofrome.typepad.com/the_history_of_rome/2010/06/97-the-fall-of-hercules.html http://thehistoryofrome.typepad.com/the_history_of_rome/2010...
- Anechoic 16y agoBefore succumbing to schadenfreude just remember that this will eventually happen to your favorite tech company in the future, be it HP, Dell, Apple, Google, Yahoo, Fog Creek, Amazon, Y Combinator, etc. Companies have ups and down. Hopefully MS will see this as a learning experience, become a better competitor and then we as consumers will benefit.
- lanstein 16y ago/ did happen in the past (Apple)
- Anechoic 16y agoSure, and it's arguably happening right now to some of the companies I mentioned (Dell, Yahoo) but if/when they recover it will likely happen again. Apple will likely face bad times at some point in the future.
- timr 16y agoDon't tell anyone, but I think it's happening to Google right now. It's just early stages (like MS in 1995), and Google still has more good products than bad, so it isn't exceptionally noticeable. But the recent, high-profile launch disasters, the clutter that's slowly creeping into the result pages, and stuff like the search page background goofiness...they sure feel like early MS-style mistakes.....
- nostrademons 16y agoMS in 1995 still had many, many years of good work ahead of it. Remember that they won the browser wars, after everyone had written them off as being too big and clumsy to adapt to change. That was also when we got Win2k and WinXP (arguably the best versions of Windows ever) and their Office product matured into its familiar form. I'd say Microsoft started going downhill after 2002, when they disbanded the IE team and embarked on the disaster that was Vista. But I remember that when I started college in 2001, I hated Microsoft and yet virtually all the software on my computer was by them. It's a sign of market dominance when your customers hate you and yet use your products anyway. ;-)
- tmsh 16y agoCan you think of a project, a product or a company that succeeded with a somewhat negative-sounding name (even if meant somewhat ironically or as sort of a renegade mentality)? I'm drawing a blank.... It's odd that I can't think of a single one though. Even among game studios, etc.
- shasta 16y agoGarage games?
- kaisdavisOR 16y agoUpvoted since I live in Eugene and know some of their employees. :)
- mhansen 16y agoGit
- astrange 16y agoWhat do you mean "a somewhat negative-sounding name"? Products succeed with embarrassing names like "Wii" all the time.
- robryan 16y agoYou'd have to think they would be better off giving up on owning the mobile platform, given that they are up against Android and iOS/iPhone I don't think they could possibly come up with something compelling enough to get mobile companies to pay for a license over the free Android OS which iterate much faster. Possibly they could form a partnership with the aim of bringing other products to a platform. They could support Android, build it into there development tools and release mobile versions of their software there, integrate with xbox ect. Would probably be a bigger opportunity than the dead end that is windows mobile. I think there would be a lot of businesses at Microsoft that could be cut in order to regain some focus. Although the same could be said about Google and they seem to be doing pretty well at the moment.
- rbanffy 16y ago> they would be better off giving up on owning the mobile platform They can't afford that. Their strength comes from the lack of viable options - each of their product lines reinforces the dependency on other product lines. If you use Exchange, you probably won't be able to use anything other than Outlook, which runs on Windows and is part of Office, which makes using Sharepoint more or less painless, which runs only on top of Windows servers and requires Microsoft's database... Their value proposition is based on dependency loops. Break the loops and the value disappears (or becomes negative).
- kenjackson 16y agoOr the other more sensible response that mobile devices are one of the major growth segment in the industry. Why would you give up on that? But conspiracy theories work too.
- evilduck 16y agoWhat conspiracy theory? The vendor lock-in behavior of MS is practically advertised as a platform feature. To up and reverse their product lock-in policy would cast doubt on many (most?) of their other claims.
- Tichy 16y agoIt's all a symptom of too much money and too many resources, I think. Focus get's completely lost. Isn't there a way to run a big company? Is anything known on how Apple does it? How big are their development teams, even? Would it make sense to manage internal teams a bit like startups, that is they would have to succeed on their own and pitch for investments?
- rbanffy 16y ago> It's all a symptom of too much money and too many resources Not only that. Wrong people in the wrong places.
- city41 16y agoAccording to Wikipedia, Apple has 34k employees. Microsoft has over 100k. Maybe at that scale, 34k and 100k aren't very different, or maybe that's like night and day.
- Tichy 16y ago34K still seems a lot, but how many are really involved in developing the core products? A lot of them would probably be sales people etc? Maybe MS would do better with 34K than 100K people...
- jorgeortiz85 16y agoYeah, Apple probably has a lot of retail employees for their Apple Stores.
- city41 16y agoA lot of people have that opinion. Such as the Mini-Microsoft blog: http://minimsft.blogspot.com/ http://minimsft.blogspot.com/, which is supposedly ran by an MS employee.
- kalid 16y agoYes, and how many work in their retail stores (not sure if that's included). Every Apple store I've been to seems to have a 1:1 customer to employee ratio.
- mikecane 16y agoThe problem with Microsoft isn't a lack of bright talent. It's "Who's Next?" People are jockeying for political positions, not concentrating on products. Ballmer won't be there forever and everyone wants to be the next Ballmer. If Steve Jobs passed away tomorrow, there could be similar jockeying at Apple -- we've already seen how product introductions lacking Jobs have been split up among several people. We don't know how many of those people got the idea from that experience that they could be "the next Jobs." Jobs also once criticized company leadership in general (someone else can go find this), stating that what happens after a founder leaves is that a marketing person ascends to the top -- and he pointed to Ballmer as an example. It's interesting to note that Palm began to sink also when a marketing person was leading it -- Ed Colligan.
- gfodor 16y agoEh, Ives is almost certainly heir to the throne.
- wmeredith 16y agoAs a shareholder, I certainly hope so.
- dieterrams 16y agoI don't know anything about Ives' business skills, but I'd worry that making him CEO would be promoting him to his level of incompetence. He's a fantastic designer, and I'd rather not see him distracted from that role. But it might be wise for him to have final approval over product designs, the way Jobs presumably does now.
- philwelch 16y agoI think the most probable succession plan is to put Tim Cook in charge of the company with Ive in charge of design and aesthetics. Who has what job title is hard to predict.
- dieterrams 16y ago
- InclinedPlane 16y agoMany of these complaints are the same reasons I left Microsoft about a year ago. It's becoming less and less a place where good work is rewarded; where engineering reality trumps corporate BS; where you feel empowered to make the best products; where you look forward to spending time at work. As more and more talented people are pushed out or leave, as the compensation continues to stagnate, as the corporate culture continues to rot all of this will snow-ball. People will find that they no longer enjoy work because all of the good people on their team have left. They'll no longer be bound by MS's golden handcuffs because their compensation won't be any better than a dozen competing companies in the same city. Etc, etc, etc. Increasingly I get the feeling that the exodus is just beginning from MS.
- todayiamme 16y agoI don't think that even if Microsoft layed off 60% of its staff it would become competitive as Apple or Google. The more I read into their problems the more I think that this is not a management issue. No they have rigid management controls to ensure that stuff doesn't go wrong like the other giants, but due to the lack of a vision. If you ask an Apple, Google, old HP, or any employee of an innovative company they will be able to tell you what their company is about. They will be able to define what they are contributing towards at in work. They know what their company's mission is and what that company stands for in respect to their product line and their positioning in the market. This has stopped happening in Microsoft. An interesting question is whether all failing companies have similar blind spots of vision. As someone once put it; management is knowing how to cut down trees efficiently, vision is about knowing if you're in the right jungle in the first place.
- nostrademons 16y agoI think a lot of Microsoft's problem is that they succeeded in their mission statement. "A computer on every desk, all running Microsoft software" was incredible hubris in 1974. It's reality now. What can Microsoft do to top that? It makes me wonder about what the world will look like in 15 years. Google's mission statement is "Organize the world's information, and make it universally accessible and useful." Right now, I'd tend to think that Google is safe from many of Microsoft's woes, because I couldn't imagine how they could possibly finish their mission statement. But I would've thought the same thing about Microsoft in the 1970s.
- todayiamme 16y agoI agree with what you say, but a part of having a vision also means looking beyond your own accomplishments. I have noticed something in how I think/do things everything feeds to the next thing. Unrelated things become connected somehow and just continue some undefinable chain. 'What's next?' is really the question they can't seem to answer. Maybe, the problem over here is that the dreamers have stopped dreaming and they're now concentrating on spreadsheets? Look at Elon Musk after he exited PayPal he could have coasted in that paradigm. Done incrementally better things, or just continued looking after it. He didn't do that. Instead, he asked himself what's next for me, and put his money where his mind was. In a lot of ways to me that defines a vision. Or, we could take the perennial example, Steve Jobs, Apple could have coasted after the iPod, or the iPhone but they somehow keep on pushing on and they've started creating an ecosystem where all the other products feed into one another. It is true that his dictatorial style helps him, but someone had to see this possibility to work towards it, and that's where the challenge lies in my opinion.
- aresant 16y agoYes, MSFT lacks focus but they are virtually forced to compete across dozens of fronts hoping that someday all the nodes add up to the former glorious whole.
- known 16y agoSplitting Microsoft into 3 companies would have helped. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thomas_Penfield_Jackson http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thomas_Penfield_Jackson
- rbanffy 16y agoIn retrospect, not splitting it will prove to make it fail faster.