4 ms·
> He said that those differences make attempts to achieve numerical parity misguided, discriminatory, and harmful. No, he said quite clearly that Google was hi
by ajross 9y ago
> He said that those differences make attempts to achieve numerical parity misguided, discriminatory, and harmful.
No, he said quite clearly that Google was hiring too many women and minorities (and also that said women and minorities suck at tech jobs, though not in so many words). It's the specifics of the argument that got him in trouble. Bland abstract stuff like you paraphrase above wouldn't get anyone fired.
- blusterXY 9y agoPerhaps you can post exactly where he said that, because as far as I'm aware he said nothing of the sort.
- tptacek 9y agoHe said Google has '[h]iring practices which can effectively lower the bar for “diversity” candidates by decreasing the false negative rate', created in part because "humans are generally biased towards protecting females".
- notgood 9y ago...which is true and even google admits they do so to increase female count?
- tptacek 9y agoI'm pretty sure Google does not in fact "admit they do [anything] to increase female count".
- notgood 9y agoOh they do, a lot: https://www.blog.google/topics/diversity/focusing-on-diversity30/ https://www.blog.google/topics/diversity/focusing-on-diversi... https://www.wsj.com/articles/tech-firms-borrow-football-play-to-increase-hiring-of-women-1474963562 https://www.wsj.com/articles/tech-firms-borrow-football-play... https://www.google.com/diversity/ https://www.google.com/diversity/ https://qz.com/604723/when-google-increased-paid-maternity-leave-the-rate-at-which-new-mothers-quit-dropped-50/ https://qz.com/604723/when-google-increased-paid-maternity-l... http://money.cnn.com/2017/06/29/technology/google-diversity-report/index.html http://money.cnn.com/2017/06/29/technology/google-diversity-...
- ubernostrum 9y agoThe claim made is that they "decreased the false negative rate". Google has long prided itself on rejecting large numbers of qualified candidates. Since decreasing the false-negative rate inherently means "hire a greater quantity of qualified candidates", I fail to see how the bar was lowered.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- ctlby 9y agoThe most direct reading of his claim is that they're hiring unqualified women. He would presumably be happy with a larger mix of female colleagues if he felt standards weren't being lowered.
- ajross 9y agoExactly. To wit: he thinks Google is hiring too many women. Yikes. Yeah, that'll get you fired, folks.
- agentdrtran 9y ago>Note that contrary to what a social constructionist would argue, research suggests that “greater nation-level gender equality leads to psychological dissimilarity in men’s and women’s personality traits.” Because as “society becomes more prosperous and more egalitarian, innate dispositional differences between men and women have more space to develop and the gap that exists between men and women in their personality becomes wider.” We need to stop assuming that gender gaps imply sexism. "the lack of women in tech is fine becuase that's just what happens when women, who are biologically worse at programming, don't go into tech"
- orangecat 9y agoresearch suggests that “greater nation-level gender equality leads to psychological dissimilarity in men’s and women’s personality traits.” That's a quote from this study: https://scholar.google.com/citations?view_op=view_citation&hl=en&user=ZY8ZWRAAAAAJ&citation_for_view=ZY8ZWRAAAAAJ:UeHWp8X0CEIC https://scholar.google.com/citations?view_op=view_citation&h.... You can argue that even in more egalitarian countries the differences are entirely due to social pressures; you can't say they don't exist. "the lack of women in tech is fine becuase that's just what happens when women, who are biologically worse at programming, don't go into tech" "biologically worse at programming" is a total fabrication. The accurate claim is "less interested", although I suppose that's not as effective for your Two Minutes Hate.
- glorkk 9y agoYou can take any statement and rephrase so that it sounds horrible. This is just sophistry. That whole paragraph is saying that men and women, __as populations__ , have biological differences in psychology, temperament and interests. In prosperous societies, men and women naturally assume complementary, rather than overlapping, roles. > We need to stop assuming that gender gaps imply sexism. Do you disagree with this? And if so, why? "Facts don't care about your feelings".
- eej71 9y agoI don't see any text in there that warrants that claim. Is there a specific sentence or two that you could highlight that leads you to your conclusion?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- geofft 9y ago> I strongly believe in gender and racial diversity, and I think we should strive for more. However, to achieve a more equal gender and race representation, Google has created several discriminatory practices: > - Programs, mentoring, and classes only for people with a certain gender or race [5] > - A high priority queue and special treatment for “diversity” candidates > - Hiring practices which can effectively lower the bar for “diversity” candidates by decreasing the false negative rate > - Reconsidering any set of people if it’s not “diverse” enough, but not showing that same scrutiny in the reverse direction (clear confirmation bias) > - Setting org level OKRs for increased representation which can incentivize illegal discrimination [6] He is saying quite a bit more than that Google is hiring too many women and minorities: he's claiming, in straightforward terms, that Google is illegally discriminating when doing so. Yes, in theory there's a world in which he's right (I'm pretty sure that's not this world) but he is definitely making the claim either way.
- ViktorV 9y agoHe's saying that Google hires people for the wrong reason. He does not say that he has a problem with hiring any group.
- eej71 9y agoI do not read his words as "google is illegally discriminating". He has listed several discriminatory practices. And I see and use the word "discriminatory" in a non-pejorative/non-judgemental sense. The programs are "set asides" for specific groups of people unrelated to "merit". Is that not a fair way to describe that? That's _not_ to say that those who go are meritless, but that the programs differentiate on factors unrelated to merit for the purposes of admission to said program. Is that a factually incorrect description of those programs? Do they not differentiate "applicants" on characteristics unrelated to merit?