5 ms·
He's implicitly claiming some of them shouldn't be there, or he believes that miraculously every single women at Google clears the bar for desirable traits in a
by refulgentis 9y ago
He's implicitly claiming some of them shouldn't be there, or he believes that miraculously every single women at Google clears the bar for desirable traits in a programming without affirmative action.
Come on now, which one do you think he believes? He made it pretty clear, clear enough that pretty much no one would want to work with the dude.
- davemp 9y agoI'm sorry, you can't just say the man is "implicitly claiming" anything. Espectially when his career was so negatively effected. Support your claims with direct quotes or keep your slander to yourself.
- halostatue 9y agoThe man in question claimed that some large portion of folks are hired under diversity programs which supposedly “lower the bar”. That is, those people don’t deserve to be at Google, and he doesn’t believe that they are qualified. That’s in his own words, and I would have fired him a hell of a lot faster than Google did, because I will not have my team disrupted by a prima donna.
- manfredo 9y agoThis is not what the document stated. Here is the quote about "lowering the bar" in its original form: > Hiring practices which can effectively lower the bar for “diversity” candidates by decreasing the false negative rate The author deliberately narrows the scope of this sentence stating that the hiring practices decrease the false negative rate, not increasing the false positive rate. Stating that the false negative rate is lowered for diverse candidates is to say that qualified, non-diverse, candidates are rejected at a greater rate than qualified and diverse candidates. It is not stating that unqualified, diverse, candidates are accepted at a greater rate.
- celtain 9y agoHe literally says that those hiring practices can effectively lower the bar. Sure, maybe he's saying that the bar for white/Asian men is higher than intended rather than that the bar for women and minorities is lower than intended, but you can't honestly argue that he isn't saying that women and minorities could be clearing a lower bar than white/Asian men.
- manfredo 9y ago> Sure, maybe he's saying that the bar for white/Asian men is higher than intended rather than that the bar for women and minorities is lower than intended, but you can't honestly argue that he isn't saying that women and minorities could be clearing a lower bar than white/Asian men. This is not necessarily the case. This is a vast oversimplification of a tech company's hiring process, but for the sake of simplicity let's say that phone interviews have a 50% rate of generating a false negative and on-sites have a 0% error rate. Say a company does one phone-interview, and if passed, moves on to on-sites. But for diverse candidates they do two phone interviews and if either passes they move on to on-sites. * Unqualified candidates always fail, since neither phone interviews or on-sites have a false-positive rate. * Qualified non-diverse candidates have a 50% chance of getting the job. * Qualified diverse candidates have a 75% of getting the job. At no point do any unqualified candidates receive offers. But at the same time, qualified non-diverse candidates are still rejected at twice the rate as diverse candidates. The "bar" so to speak isn't always something that people have a higher chance of passing the better their skills are. A working knowledge of data structures and concurrency is all that's necessary to pass all of my company's coding interviews. Practice and luck is probably a greater asset than skill in many interviews. But getting into the efficacy of technical interviews is opening a whole 'nother bag of worms.
- Malice 9y agoI had to read this a few times, but I think I get it now. The original manifesto author means that the "bar is lowered" for diverse candidates because they're scrutinized more carefully and fewer qualified candidates are eliminated? If you're good enough and diverse, you're more likely to be hired than if you're good enough and ... whatever the word for not-diverse is? The original author is not claiming that more unqualified diverse candidates are hired, just that it's easier to get hired if you're qualified and diverse? If I've understood that correctly I really appreciate your effort in explaining it. Your comment should be higher so more people could see it :) Also, if I understand you correctly, the phrase "lower the bar" might have gotten him fired for something he wasn't intending to say.
- curun1r 9y ago> That is, those people don’t deserve to be at Google, and he doesn’t believe that they are qualified. You should read what he wrote more closely. He said that Google was creating hiring practices that "lowered the bar by decreasing false negative rate." That last bit is important because it fundamentally changes what he's asserting and means you've entirely misrepresented what he was saying. Anyone familiar with the Google hiring practices knows that, unless you're famous to some extent, there's an element of luck to getting hired. A lot of qualified candidates get rejected because Google just gets a lot of applicants and they can't hire everyone that's qualified. Those candidates are the false negatives...people they could have hired without making a mistake but didn't. What he's saying is that while a white male needs to be qualified, pass his interview and not be one of these false negatives, the minority candidate just needs to be qualified and pass his/her interview. That is a lower bar for entry, but it isn't what everyone is accusing him of having said...that his minority colleagues aren't qualified or are less qualified. They still passed all the merit parts of the process, they just never had to undergo the arbitrary part of the process that non-minorities are subjected to.
- agentdrtran 9y agoyeah, the entire screen against women in tech is not claiming anything about any women he works with, no siree
- refulgentis 9y agoThis is by far my highest upvoted post in this thread, even higher than ones that exhibit much stronger "virtue-signaling" Given that, I'm guessing the justification for the statements is a little more self-evident than you're letting on. In it effort to save myself some time (seriously, you're asking me for about 20 minutes worth of work), just checking first, have you read the leaked document? It's at Gizmodo: http://gizmodo.com/leaked-document-details-apple-employee-injuries-hints-1794482497 http://gizmodo.com/leaked-document-details-apple-employee-in.... EDIT: Also, do the other replies to you make things a little clearer? Please keep in mind I'm not trying to be passive-aggressive, I come from similiar intellectual stock to you. That's why I'm in disbelief that you need pullquotes and an explanation to tie them together, I'm sure it'll click for you without that.
- davemp 9y ago> This is by far my highest upvoted post in this thread, even higher than ones that exhibit much stronger "virtue-signaling" argumentum ad populum [1] > In it effort to save myself some time (seriously, you're asking me for about 20 minutes worth of work) Making a worthwhile, intellectual contribution to a public forum should take more than 20min of work/preparation. Being familiar enough with the contents of the paper to make an informed arguement should mean that you could easily pull quotes (maybe with ctrl+f to save time) in less than a minute. Especially when your comments have the potential to destroy someone's reputation/career. > Also, do the other replies to you make things a little clearer? Please keep in mind I'm not trying to be passive-aggressive Congratulations, you can make fallacy ridden, condecending, and harmful comments without even trying! > I come from similiar intellectual stock to you. Irrelavant and you most likely do not. > That's why I'm in disbelief that you need pullquotes and an explanation to tie them together, I'm sure it'll click for you without that. argumentum ad hominem [2] I know it's easy to write off when someone pulls up latin fallacy names, but please do read those wiki articles. Formal arguementation is important. Your reply to me was disrespectful and added absolutely no value to this thread. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Argumentum_ad_populum https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Argumentum_ad_populum [2]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ad_hominem https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ad_hominem
- weberc2 9y ago
- brighteyes 9y agoAffirmative action policies by definition change hiring in order to increase the number of minority candidates. That's why we progressives support them! Are you saying he's wrong for pointing out that Google has affirmative action policies? Or that the policies themselves are bad? I don't understand.
- manfredo 9y ago> He's implicitly claiming some of them shouldn't be there, or he believes that miraculously every single women at Google clears the bar for desirable traits in a programming without affirmative action. Come on now, which one do you think he believes? He believes neither. We don't need to speculate, because the author writes quite deliberately to communicate his point. Here's the quote you're likely referring to, the one that mentions "lowering the bar": > Hiring practices which can effectively lower the bar for “diversity” candidates by decreasing the false negative rate. (emphasis mine) The author is not stating that Google's hiring practices result in unqualified diverse candidates receiving offers at a higher rate than non-diverse candidates. The author is stating that a greater portion of qualified, non-diverse, are being rejected. In other words, the author is not stating that diverse employees at Google shouldn't be there. Rather he's claiming that there are a substantial number of non-diverse candidates who should have received offers, but didn't.
- evolve2017 9y agoJust for people who might come along later: It looks like the author is talking about setting a threshold, as in the context of creating a test. Please have a look at [1]. In this setting, it is not possible to decrease the false-negative rate without increasing the false-positive rate. I think the author is phrasing things this way simply as a matter of rhetoric, not to express the point you are suggesting. 1. http://www.prolekare.cz/dbpic/jp_5403_f_21-x1000_1600 http://www.prolekare.cz/dbpic/jp_5403_f_21-x1000_1600
- manfredo 9y agoThis same reply was posted to several of my comments, this is my response: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14954138 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14954138
- novembermike 9y agoI'm not sure I understand you. He's trying to make a statement about Google's hiring practices. The obvious discussion would be about whether he's right or wrong, and I don't know if that's the case. You seem to care that he's making the claim at all. It really feels like you're ashamed that he's telling the emperor that he has no clothes.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]