9 ms·
Not even wrong: Why does nobody like pilot-wave theory? [pdf]
- Koshkin 9y agoI am sure that laymen like it - because it seems to offer an "intuitive" picture of the wave-particle dualism. Problem is, neither QFT nor modern deeper theories such as strings gain anything from this kind of metaphysical image.
- gipp 9y agoIsn't that true of any of the major "interpretations" of QM? Copenhagen etc.
- meri_dian 9y agoEquivalently we can say that neither QFT nor string theory gains anything from the empty hand-waviness of the copehagen interpretation, Everett's many-world's, etc.
- Barrin92 9y agoThose also don't really play a role in the professional life of a physicist, nowadays you really do stare at computer screens a lot and try to find things in data, it's not like physicists sit around and discuss many-world theory as part of their day job. These are just the popular things that make it out into public discourse
- madhadron 9y agoDepends on the physicist. Those working on foundations of quantum mechanics do. There just aren't many of them.
- svarnypetr 9y agoFor example the whole group around beyondspacetime.net does that.
- colordrops 9y agoI'm layman but am biased against it being true as it is not as fun and exotic as many worlds, regardless of merit.
- guscost 9y agoTL;DR: Postmodernists don't like it because it abandons locality in favor of determinism. Modernists like it for the exact same reason.
- CPAhem 9y agoAlso Bohm was unpopular with the US government in the early 1950's - he had to leave for Brazil because of McCarthyism and anti-communist feeling.
- olegkikin 9y agoI have an unrelated question to the physics nerds. Is it even possible to determine whether the universe is deterministic or not from inside the universe? Let's imagine a simplified example. I give you two sets of numbers (let's pretend they are atom coordinates). One set is purely random, another one is generated with a very simple formula (example: f(n) = SHA256(N + salt)). I will give you as many of the numbers as you want. Can you determine which set is which (if you don't know the formula ahead of time)?
- Govindae 9y agoAny randomness could in principle be predetermined. God could have rolled the dice ahead of time.
- justinpombrio 9y agoAmazingly, we have an experiment that shows that this is not the case, if you make some pretty reasonable assumptions. It's based on Bell's theorem. Your statement is very intuitive, and the fact that it may be wrong is very surprising. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bell%27s_theorem#Bell_inequalities_are_violated_by_quantum_mechanical_predictions https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bell%27s_theorem#Bell_inequa... EDIT: tone.
- guskel 9y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Superdeterminism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Superdeterminism
- Xcelerate 9y ago> if you make some reasonable assumptions Not everyone agrees on what is "reasonable". I have no problem giving up locality, but "true" randomness (i.e., information generated without an algorithm) seems like a philosophical cop out. Note that something can also be globally deterministic but indeterministic from the perspective of a subsystem. In this sense, the universe would appear random as far as we're concerned, but not random to whoever is simulating the universe (this is often called superdeterminism, but I think that's a silly word—the universe is either deterministic or it isn't).
- AgentME 9y agoMy understanding of QM is only surface-level, so there may be subtleties I'm missing, but this presentation's arguments against the many-worlds interpretation seem pretty weak. Page 28 grudgingly alludes to the idea that MWI could be simpler than other theories ("Objection based on surprisingly common misconception that standard QM defined solely by Schrödinger's equation ... It is only within a many-worlds framework that this view could begin to make sense"), but later introduces MWI as a contender beginning with a nonsense news headline and then characterizes it as intuitively bizarre for proposing a large multiverse, as if the size for its proposed multiverse was an obvious point against it. It seems to me there's an implied misuse of Occam's razor: "Entities are not to be multiplied without necessity" is most properly applied to the number of rules in a theory, not the amount of matter a theory predicts. (If you apply it based on the amount of matter a theory predicts, then Occam's razor surely should rule out theories that dim clusters of light in the sky correspond to trillions of galaxies like our own, and should prefer theories that predict that they're illusions, reflections, or something otherwise insignificant that fits the observations.) Page 39 and 40 both quote paragraphs from books that seem more convincing to me than the presentation's seemingly hand-waving refutations. Page 40's refutation appears to do nothing but insist upon PWT's "epiphenomenal 'pointer'", naming our branch as real and explaining away the many deep interactions of other branches as only being "mathematical significant" rather than having "ontological significance". ... Maybe this is a bad time to mention my preference for the Mathematical universe hypothesis ("which posits that all computable mathematical structures (in Gödel's sense) exist"), which seems to make the idea of something having mathematical significance but not ontological significance meaningless.
- colordrops 9y agoOccam's razor is so commonly misused and abused. It seems to be more often used to support whatever pet theory someone has rather than as an impartial tool.
- millstone 9y agoThe "nonsense news headline" and followup discussion are less critiquing MWI than poking fun at David Deutsch. This is because Deutsch is a prominent critic of PWT. The arguments against MWI from Occam's Razor are indeed weak. The stronger critiques are the difficulty of deriving the Born rule, or indeed quantum randomness at all, from the deterministic MWI. This is presumably what the authors hint at in their "doubtful it [pure Hamiltonian evolution] makes sense even there (in MWI)".
- EGreg 9y agoI love PWT. I think it is the right explanation for what we observe. Other theories don't rule out nonlocality anyway. And I'd rather have nonlocality than their non realism!!
- thisrod 9y agoPilot waves are not a theory. No experiment can exclude them, unless it falsifies the entire quantum theory of mechanics. One reason to dislike pilot waves is that people, speaking as scientists, take them too seriously. This is not to say that scientists shouldn't talk about them, just that we shouldn't pretend we're doing science when we do. In particular, don't pretend that anyone can be scientifically right or wrong about the human interface to quantum mechanics. Some interfaces cause fewer errors than others do, and the rest is Vi and Emacs. Speaking subjectively, there are two reasons that I prefer Everett's relative state interpretation. (It's the serious version of the approach that these slides send up as many worlds.) Relative states make it blatantly obvious why I can't put a contract on my great-great-grandfather. In other approaches, you have to think about this. In the pilot wave "theory", there are superpositions, a.k.a. "pilot waves", and a bunch of other things. In the Everett worldview, by contrast, there are superpositions, full stop. Everett does leave some grey areas, roughly speaking the quantum version of, "Is 7 a random number?" I doubt that any interpretation of quantum mechanics can clarify that, and Everett at least acknowledged the problem and made it fairly explicit.
- vbuwivbiu 9y agohttp://puredhamma.net/wp-content/uploads/Observing-the-Average-Trajectories-of-Single-Photons-in-a-Two-Slit-Interferometer.pdf http://puredhamma.net/wp-content/uploads/Observing-the-Avera... Using weak measurements, average photon trajectories predicted by Bohmian mechanics observed.
- amai 9y agoHas anybody successfully incorporated relativity into pilot wave theory? For example, how does the Dirac equation emerge from pilot-wave theory?