7 ms·
That's pretty neat. The thing that stands out to me like a sore thumb though is the 'load' numbers. You only get 1 hour of battery life. I know modern chips c
by MBCook 9y ago
That's pretty neat.
The thing that stands out to me like a sore thumb though is the 'load' numbers. You only get 1 hour of battery life.
I know modern chips can be a hog but that terrible, especially compared to the 11 hours of light surfing on wifi.
This is the problem with optimizing power sipping all over the place. As soon as you push things none of that matters and your battery time PLUMMETS.
I don't know what they could do though outside of doubling the battery capacity.
- toomuchtodo 9y agoStop optimizing for pretty and add more battery. My laptop is a tool, not a piece of art.
- JohnTHaller 9y agoYou'll have to buy something other than Apple if you want that.
- toomuchtodo 9y agoI just buy only older refurb Apple gear.
- jethro_tell 9y agoAt some point, the hardware is no longer supported by the OS though.
- pgm8705 9y agoMy 2010 15 inch MBP is still getting OS updates. Installed 8GB of memory and an SSD a few years back. Other than the fact that 1.5 hours is about all I can get from the battery, I haven't been compelled to upgrade.
- jethro_tell 9y agoSure, a 2 year old macbook isn't that old. I think they support them for 4 or 5 years so you're about half your life time there. Good for now but not really sustainable long term.
- zitterbewegung 9y agoIt seems like the issue with manufacturers doing this is that optimizing for battery has diminishing returns (going from 11 hours from light load to heavy load) and most importantly people buy pretty.
- bartread 9y agoThis. Four years +/- ago the Macbook Pro was my go to laptop for serious work. Note the "Pro" in the title (and, yes, I bang on about this a lot when provoked). Apple, please: I work on batteries a lot. Start putting in BIGGER batteries, along with better connectivity (yes, I would like standard USB 2 and 3 connectivity without requiring dongles for, like, most things I want to plug in; yes, I would like an HDMI port or two built in so I don't need to carry dongles; yes, I would like a wired ethernet port because it's still a lot better than WiFi and, again, doesn't need yet another dongle; yes, I do require line in audio built in to the damn box, not just line out, and don't be forcing me to use a dongle to plug in a pair of headphones or I will become militantly angry). Also, whilst I'm at it, more cores, please: 8, minimum. More memory as well. 32GB minimum, ideally 64GB. And 2 - 4TB storage. I know, it'll weigh more: I don't care, I'm not puny. Even still, you used to be able to build decently powerful machines with good battery life without building the kind of ridiculous lumps that Dell, et al., shovel out the door as "desktop replacements". Please, remember how to do this, and stop building toy computers for undernourished hipsters with chronic muscle atrophy.
- zimpenfish 9y agoThe thing is - they could do all this and ... about 250 people would buy it. Maybe 1000. To break even at that level of production, they'd probably have to charge 5 times what people would want to pay. Meanwhile they have tens of millions buying their "toy computers". Where would you focus your efforts?
- mschuster91 9y ago> about 250 people would buy it. Maybe 1000 Lolwut, companies would INSTANTLY go back to the older MBPs if they could. Do you know how much replacing lost/misplaced/stolen/broken adapters cost?! The only thing where companies can save with the new USB-C MBP is on power bricks because once the cable inevitably fails you only have to get a new cable instead of a whole new brick.
- dkonofalski 9y ago
- rz2k 9y agoHow many users want their laptop to be less portable? Every quarter pound does make a difference in real world convenience. You're already giving up performance if you choose a laptop over a desktop computer as your "tool", and probably using some form of cluster if you're doing any heavy computation. Sometimes reading pros talking about how they need to do pro computing on their pro computer, you wonder whether they would get even more satisfaction from a bag of external batteries and lots of serious-looking accessories. If they're running complex models somewhere off the grid, a large solar array and some car batteries would look even cooler!
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- jethro_tell 9y agoAside from the tone, I think the thought that the 'pro' series should follow the older body type and optimize for battery and performance. That's not the craziest thing. If you want a console to hit your cluster or work machines, get the not pro line. There are worlds where people need self-contained mobile compute.
- not_kurt_godel 9y agoHow portable is your laptop if you can't use it for more than 30 minutes without an electrical socket? A quarter pound is an insignificant amount of weight. Most people would probably quickly get used to having to carry around 5 extra pounds of weight in their daily bag/backpack/whatever. Also, there is a massive range of computing power between "I can barely use gmail because my browser is laggy" and needing a compute cluster; and a massive difference between being able to perform your daily computing tasks smoothly vs. with noticeable lag that adds friction to everything you try to do. Your dichotomies are false and hyperbolic. I think a significant proportion of people who are even moderate computer users would prefer increased battery life and snappy performance at the expense of a slightly bulkier laptop.
- skybrian 9y agoThere are FAA limits on how big a battery can be if you want to take it on a plane. Your best bet is probably an external battery.
- masklinn 9y agoThe limit on li-ion 100W.h standard and 2x160W.h in carry-on with airline approval. The 2017 15" MBP has a 76W.h battery.
- kalleboo 9y agoApple used to stick 99 Wh batteries in the 15" Pros, but with the last 2 generations they downgraded that to 76Wh batteries (presumably since their battery life targets are based on Safari browsing and QuickTime playback - or at least that's all they advertise)
- skybrian 9y agoYes, I'd be curious to know why they don't push the limit anymore. But in any case, we're talking a maximum of 30% improved battery life that you can get by going bigger. Better efficiency when consuming power is likely to make a larger difference.
- LeifCarrotson 9y agoThe FAA limits allow up to 160 Wh within a device. A Thinkpad T430 with the 9-cell with a Slice battery pushes that to 188 Wh, and no one seems to question it. You can also bring spare batteries (not the same as an external battery) to plug into it. The MacBook Pro is not pushing these limits. They have a glued-in, non-replaceable 49.2 Wh battery. Your best bet at this point may be an external, but users would be better off if manufacturers offered machines with large, replaceable batteries.
- captainmuon 9y agoYeah, but not everyone flies, not everyone flies into/from the US, the current MacBook is with 76 Wh (IIRC) below the rumored 99 Wh and the actual 160 Wh limit. And for the love of god I don't understand why a pro notebook does not have swappable batteries [1]. It would add a millimeter and a few dozen grams, but allow you to choose between slim and fat batteries, and replace them when they lose capacity. You can get rid of ports and tell people it is for their best, and they will buy it. Surely you can make it a bit thicker and use the same explanation. And here is an idea for a business. You know how companies like Westfalia and Karman take VW buses and modify them? Take a new MacBook, saw open the case at the bottom, and add an aftermarket battery, and if you're at it more RAM. Impossible for an individual, but maybe not impossible if you have a factory with all the necessary equipment. It's going to be expensive, but just sell those modded MacBooks to people who buy business class tickets and who have enough money. [1] OK, I know why - so people have to buy a new one when the batteries go bad.
- j_s 9y agoKeep this battery trickle-charging in your car? $699 412Wh / 116,000mAh / 11 pounds https://amzn.com/dp/B071FG4G13 https://amzn.com/dp/B071FG4G13