6 ms·
If you can't keep up, that's not other people's fault for being better than you.
by jstanley 9y ago
If you can't keep up, that's not other people's fault for being better than you.
- Sholmesy 9y agoThis is such an ignorant statement, it makes my blood boil. People shouldn't be left to die, because they weren't naturally blessed with an adaptability that allows them to be retrained into software engineers. There are a huge number of reasons why someone might not be able to "keep up" in todays world. To write that off as 'being better' is disgusting.
- oblio 9y agoOk, let's say you're right. 1. Are you willing to leave behind, say, 40-50% of the population? Especially since that group could include people such as your parents or your partner or your kids. 2. If you're willing to leave them behind, what are you going to do with them?
- jstanley 9y agoIf it's your parent, partner, or kids, (or even if it's not -- it could be anyone) you're welcome to provide for them yourself. You're also welcome to donate to (or even work for!) charities that provide for them. But it's not OK to force everyone else to provide for them.
- chongli 9y agoYou ought to familiarize yourself with the social contract. Rich people do not create their wealth in a vacuum. Everybody contributes to the creation of an environment whereby wealth creation is possible. This includes everything from basic utilities, infrastructure (roads & rail), health and safety, education, food security, military etc. If you want to try your hand at creating wealth without "forcing" others to provide for you, there are plenty of lawless regions in places like Somalia, Syria, and Afghanistan for you to test your mettle. Sound unappealing? There you go.
- mamon 9y agoAre you suggesting that rich people use those utilities like education or infrastructure for free? Because I'm pretty sure that they already pay for them, in taxes or otherwise. And of course their companies also PROVIDE some of the services you mentioned.
- chongli 9y agoAre you suggesting that rich people use those utilities like education or infrastructure for free? They don't start out rich. So, maybe some rich people inherit their wealth, but go back enough generations and everybody had to start non-rich. It's not just that, though. Rich people don't live in a vacuum with their wealth. They interact with the economy. They employ people, they contract for services, they trade with people. All of the people they interact with need to be fed, clothed, educated, etc. However, thanks to the power of economic growth, they still get more out of society than they pay in taxes.
- pdkl95 9y agoMark Blyth (prof. of political economy at Brown) has advice for anyone with this attitude: "The Hamptons is not a defensible position"[1]. What are you going to do when a large fraction of the population starts getting hungry and they decide taking what they need from you (and everyone else with wealth/resources)? Do you really think that the police will simply arrest them? What about when someone starts shooting and the protests turn into a mob burning down the city and the streets becoming a war zone? Contrary to what other comments have suggested, welfare isn't about being a nice civilized society that doesn't leave people behind. Welfare is a bribe. It's a tribute ("danegeld"[2]) we pay to the poor so they don't burn down the city or murder anyone between them and food/shelter. Arresting that class of people would be more expensive as it still pays for their food and shelter. Do you really want to give up the cheapest and safest option for defending yourself against the bottom ~quarter of the population? Recent events at Ferguson and Baltimor are warning. Ignoring them is not recommended if you value maintaining your current standard of living. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Zzl4B3mrKQE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Zzl4B3mrKQE [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Danegeld https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Danegeld [3] Exact amount and the scope of what is mean by "national defense" is off topic.
- oblio 9y agoIt's both, actually. At the base level it is about protection, but at a higher level, if you've ever been in a society with a welfare state, things are so much nicer. People are calmer, more relaxed and even more polite (they might be colder or more distant due to cultural characteristics, though). For me, personally, a random town in Germany is more pleasant from the social aspect than San Francisco with all its riches and its hobos.
- yters 9y agoIn the long term isn't it economically better to get people out of this welfare culture so they can provide for themselves? Gangs aren't formed to feed starving people, they form because the culture is broken. In the long term, placating gangs with welfare money will backfire. Arguably it's the welfare money that significantly led to the culture breakdown in the first place by destroying economic and social structure.
- sgift 9y agoAnd here's my monthly reminder that places exist out there where you aren't 'forced' to help others (by some evil government): Somalia welcomes you any day now. For some reason people are always reluctant to follow that advice.
- jstanley 9y agoSomalia's government situation is a mess because the country has no economically productive activity. Not the other way around.
- coldtea 9y ago>If you can't keep up, that's not other people's fault for being better than you. Who said they were "better than [me]"? You seem to presuppose what in fact needs proving: that if someone ended richer than someone else, they were better to begin with. Except if you mean "better at getting rich" which is a tautology. Between inheritance and class status of parents, and between connections and lucky chances (including geography and color), there are so many ways to undeservingly be more wealthy than someone else and so many ways the "starting conditions" are not the same that this is not even wrong. Now, two types of people usually have difficulty seeing this: those that played life in 'easy mode' (well off parents, good education, etc) and can't see how it's not as easy for everybody, and people who managed to overcome bad chances and who, due to confirmation bias, can't see that the chances for what they did were slim for others in the same boat but attribute it all to their hard work and smarts (and the lack of those in others). http://thewireless.co.nz/articles/the-pencilsword-on-a-plate http://thewireless.co.nz/articles/the-pencilsword-on-a-plate
- snuxoll 9y ago> Now, two types of people usually have difficulty seeing this: those that played life in 'easy mode' (well off parents, good education, etc) and can't see how it's not as easy for everybody, and people who managed to overcome bad chances and who, due to confirmation bias, can't see that the chances for what they did were slim for others in the same boat but attribute it all to their hard work and smarts (and the lack of those in others). * I dropped out of high school, got my GED * Worked for a call center doing Verizon Wireless tech support, got customer service experience for my resume * Worked for Support.com, got desktop support experience for my resume * Worked on Taos' service desk, was there at the right time for a Salesforce.com Developer opening and was lucky enough that the people interviewing me decided to take a chance on me * While working at Taos there was a co-worker in the NOC working on a little C# WinForms app that I helped out on occasion, he thought highly enough of me that he gave my information to a friend of his * Said friend of my former co-worker decided to interview me, I've now been working at my current employer for three years and have been promoted twice My abilities were a key component of my journey from a low-paying call center worker to a "Sr. DevOps Engineer" making twice the median household income in my area, but they wouldn't have mattered at all without a tremendous amount of luck. If I hadn't decided to quit working at the call center to try and go to college I wouldn't have ended up working for Support.com, since I applied there over winter break as required by the state unemployment office. If I hadn't started working at Support.com my resume may have been tossed in the bin when I applied at Taos due to having no documented desktop support experience. If I hadn't started working at Taos when I did I wouldn't have networked with the people that led to my current employer, they got a government contract when I was leaving that required help desk personnel to get security clearance and I would have never applied in the first place. Not to mention they gave me an opportunity to prove myself as a high-school dropout with no degree, one which I probably only got because I was already an employee with positive references from others I interacted with. I think it's easy for many people to underestimate where pure chance plays a part in their lives and careers, but I know I could have easily wound up doing menial low-paying customer service work forever without it. I merely had the means to take advantage of opportunities when they came up, but nobody gets anywhere without the opportunity to do so in the first place.
- apatters 9y agoThe assumption which seems to underly this statement (that failing to keep up signifies some kind of personal inferiority) is fallacious. The fact of the matter is that around 40% of Americans end up in the same income quintile as their parents. Extreme moves in either direction are rare; 4% in the bottom quintile will move to the top and 8% in the top will fall to the bottom. So in fact a large part of someone's ability to "keep up" (e.g., not be poor) depends on whether they were born into wealth in the first place. No matter what level they're born at, most people don't move very far. Source: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Socioeconomic_mobility_in_the_United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Socioeconomic_mobility_in_the_...
- igravious 9y agoThe severely disabled, we should provide zero social supports for them and their families so? It's nobody's fault that they're garbage people. Luck of the lottery.
- logicchains 9y ago>The severely disabled, we should provide zero social supports for them and their families so? If "we" want to provide support to any group, it can be done through charity. I'd argue this way is more moral: it's more of a good deed to be generous with one's own money than with other peoples', and it's not much of a good deed to give money if one's only doing so due to threat of imprisonment for failing to comply. There's also research suggesting that charitable behaviour makes the givers happier too: http://www.hbs.edu/faculty/Publication%20Files/10-012.pdf http://www.hbs.edu/faculty/Publication%20Files/10-012.pdf.
- coldtea 9y ago>If "we" want to provide support to any group, it can be done through charity. Charity implies voluntarily providing support, leaving it to the benevolence (or lack thereof) of each individual. In the end, it teaches people that being uncharitable is OK and an acceptable trait, just like being charitable. I want a society that mandates that support -- and even more so, one where everybody is OK with that. In other words, instead of pushing out the disabled, in my society I'd rather push out (as useless scum) those that don't wont want society to help the disabled. >I'd argue this way is more moral: it's more of a good deed to be generous with one's own money than with other peoples' Then, since everybody will be using their own money to pay the "help the disabled" tax, it's a good deed to mandate by law that everybody has to fork out. >it's not much of a good deed to give money if one's only doing so due to threat of imprisonment for failing to comply. That would be irrelevant if the desired outcome is to effectively help the disabled, rather than to test honesty of people's charity.
- igravious 9y ago> In other words, instead of pushing out the disabled, in my society I'd rather push out (as useless scum) those that don't wont want society to help the disabled. Amen to that. I was merely taking the original comment to one of its logical conclusion. Seems like there are those who would like to bring back charitable almshouses and asylums to replace state institutions, how quaint but also how despicable. After all: If you can't keep up (even if you're disabled), that's not other people's fault for being better than you.
- amelius 9y agoThat statement should apply perhaps to companies, not people.
- youdontknowtho 9y agoI disagree with you, but people shouldn't downvote you just because they don't like what you said. In fact, it's important to remember that people do actually think what you wrote. They just don't say it aloud.