10 ms·
It's weird seeing this. In Australia prostitution is completely legal. There was actually a publicly listed brothel for a while. Strange to think other socie
by andrewstuart 9y ago
It's weird seeing this. In Australia prostitution is completely legal. There was actually a publicly listed brothel for a while. Strange to think other societies criminalise it.
I think being legal is best for the health and wellbeing of the sex workers and minimises the criminal involvement.
There are brothels all over the place but mostly they are pretty low key, often hidden in backstreets or warehouse areas with only a red light and a sign to indicate they exist.
I wish we had such an enlightened position on drugs, which remain almost completely criminalized, whilst other parts of the world move towards legalization of various aspects of drug law.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- pitaj 9y agoThere are several public brothels in Nevada. Prostitution is on a state-by-state basis.
- duncan_bayne 9y agoI hear it's most common in Washington D.C.
- pc86 9y agoI think the key word there was "public."
- alistairSH 9y agoNope, brothels are illegal in DC. There used to be loads of street walkers, but not so many as the city has gentrified, cleaned-up, and crime rates in general have gone down.
- duncan_bayne 9y agoI was referring to the practice of political lobbying and revolving doors, not literal prostitution. For example: https://www.opensecrets.org/revolving/rev_summary.php?id=78755 https://www.opensecrets.org/revolving/rev_summary.php?id=787...
- notjesse 9y agoThe thing with Australia is it's very difficult for the US to learn from Australian social experiments and determine if they will be effective. Australia has extremely tight border control and far more police powers. So while legalized prostitution has been a huge success in Australia, it may open avenues for human trafficking to thrive in the US. While I generally agree with the notion that legalized prostitution reduces human trafficking, this wouldn't be a certainty from looking at the effects on Australia/NZ.
- iamflimflam1 9y agoI suspect that legalising prostitution would actually make it much easier to prevent human trafficking for sex work.
- Noos 9y agoI think that it would increase it, because contrary to what people seem to think here, prostitution is very low on people's ideal career choices. Increasing demand is going to increase the need labor, and I don't think anyone here is advising their sons or daughters to have sex with strangers for money. SO trafficking would increase.
- iamflimflam1 9y agoIf something is legal then workers have protection, can form unions and have rights. It's more difficult in a legal environment to have people who are coerced or forced to work. If prostitution is illegal then it will be run by people who do not obey the law and will happily traffic people and have people people working illegally or forcibly. http://humantraffickingsgp.weebly.com/amsterdams-red-light-district.html http://humantraffickingsgp.weebly.com/amsterdams-red-light-d...
- lighthazard 9y agoCurrent laws seem to penalize the sex worker and the buyer, not the traffickers. Legalizing this would let both parties involved feel safer, no repercussions from calling the police if something goes awry.
- ClassyJacket 9y agoYeah. A bunch of my friends are sex workers. They make literally ten times as much money as me per hour and love their jobs.
- throwaway29292 9y agoHow much money do you make per hour?
- Cthulhu_ 9y agoBut do they work as many hours as you do? (the answer is probably "they don't need to")
- ivrrimum 9y agoHuh..?
- quickthrower2 9y agoSays more about how little tech workers are paid in Australia, than anything else. Work for Google in US and earn more than a hooker!
- andreasklinger 9y ago> Work for Google in US and earn more than a hooker! What a marketing claim
- TeMPOraL 9y ago...and then spend 90% of it on rent ;). Costs of life matter.
- pault 9y agoAustralia ain't cheap.
- joesb 9y agoHave to account for stability of the job as well. How many people can work in sex markets in their 40s.
- wsc981 9y agoSomehow The Netherlands, once a front-runner on legalisation of drugs and prostitution, seems to become more strict lately. For example the local government of Amsterdam is trying to close the window brothels [0] in the cities' Red Light District and many cities now have a policy where they don't grant licences for new coffeeshops and wait for the current licenses to expire [1]. The cited reasons for wanting to close the coffeeshops (too close to schools, within 250 meters) are stupid since every Dutch student rides a bicycle and for my friends it was no big problem during a free hour to bike for a few kilometers to buy and smoke hash or weed. My friends did this many times (none became a worse person for it, either). --- [0]: http://www.scmp.com/news/world/article/1763216/amsterdam-prostitutes-protest-planned-shutdown-brothel-windows-red-light http://www.scmp.com/news/world/article/1763216/amsterdam-pro... [1]: http://www.dutchamsterdam.nl/3485-amsterdam-coffeeshops-phased-out http://www.dutchamsterdam.nl/3485-amsterdam-coffeeshops-phas...
- Cthulhu_ 9y agoThe problem with prostitution in NL is that it's not tightly regulated, it's still a bit of a private organization of sorts. There's problems with things like loverboys (pimps seducing / coercing young girls into prostitution) and human trafficking. Eastern-European women getting lured to NL with the promise of jobs and such. Regulation is failing, so it's being banned instead. Which will only push things further underground.
- timwaagh 9y agoI hope they dont ban it. although i dont like the concept it needs somewhere to go. i dont think a ban is on the cards. utrecht is still building brand new brothels. unfortunately in my neighbourhood. would be better if they used areas outside of city limits for this though. you dont want kids growing up near brothels.
- Iv 9y agoThe reasonable reason often cited is that it attracts drug tourists and prostitution tourists which all attract their own problems. They wanted to restrict access to coffeeshop (not sure about brothel) to only Netherlands citizens but this raises constitutional problems. They initially thought they would be at the forefront of a wave of legalization across Europe, but as it failed to materialize, their uniqueness brought their own issues. I do have hopes for France though. Macron has the same political sense as Hollande, who just made a show of gay marriage legalization to prevent talking about other issues. I think they are keeping weed legalization as the next smokescreen. On prostitution, the French liberals are a bit more divided. A lot of people actually associate human trafficking and prostitution and feel that criminalizing clients could be a way to make it go away. I tend to think that legalization would actually make the fight against sex-slavery much easier but I understand why people are more cautious about this issue. Also the far-left shared some fake stories (but not totally implausible scenario) under which legalization of prostitution could mean that unemployed women could be forced by unemployment office to accept prostitution jobs or lose their unemployment benefits. They used the outcry to justify that prostitution is not a job like every other one. It is a complicated issue, muddied by emotional bias and over-simplified solutions.
- disordinary 9y agoYep, the same in NZ. The other thing is that legalisation means that both the prostitute and the customer are protected by law. There was a case recently where a customer took a prostitute to the small claims court for not providing the services agreed to and of course prostitutes can call the police without fear of repercussions if a client is getting too rowdy. They pay tax and get the government work related accident insurance and retirement saving schemes, they get health checks and are regulated to prevent unsafe behavior, they also are presumably subject to inspections to ensure that no drugs, human trafficking, or underage prostitution occurs.
- keerthiko 9y agoThat sounds nice, but as far as I can tell, in America even most above-board jobs aren't required by government to provide those kinds of protections. Prostitution needs it more than simple things like plumber or electrician, especially things like health checks and accident insurance, but legalizing without those around is kind of a half-baked scheme which could be more harmful than the present state of being illegal.
- disordinary 9y agoYeah, consumer protection and general employment law in the US is a whole other conversation.
- nojvek 9y agoAustralia and NZ both have prostitution legalized with a bunch of European countries. When I came to US I was amazed that guns and weed were legalized but not prostitution. Even in Vegas. I'm sure there is plenty of underground prostitution in US where the workers have little rights and are probably abused. I have no hopes that this will ever happen in trump administration but hopefully in 2020+ this could be a possibility.
- Teknoman117 9y agoweed is not legalized in most of the country, and even where it is "legal", it's a complete gray area. It's illegal federally, which completely overrules the states' ability to legalize it. Basically all the legalization you see is that the local state/county police will not come after you for it, but the DEA is still perfectly within their right to come after you if they wanted to - which has happened to some dispensaries.
- thewhitetulip 9y agoUsually when conservative governments come to power they try to enforce their way of thinking onto the general populous and they do it in a smart way. Propaganda everywhere, tv adverts etc
- BearGoesChirp 9y agoJust conservative? Isn't a defining feature of any government passing laws that enforce its way of thinking on others?
- hackinthebochs 9y agoNot in any robust sense, no.
- thewhitetulip 9y agoYes, but when you have conservative governments, they try to enforce such notions. Then have an abysmally narrow minded point of view of the world and they try to make regressive changes to the country. and no, the defining feature of any govt is not to enfore its way of thinking on others, it is to govern others in a proper way. but at least in India, politics has become a business.
- sjy 9y agoProstitution is not 'completely legal' in Australia. Brothels are still illegal in some states and even those states which have decriminalised prostitution have brothels operating illegally. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prostitution_in_Australia https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prostitution_in_Australia
- TheSpiceIsLife 9y agoIn Australia prostitution is completely legal ... There are brothels all over the place It can vary from state to state. Under Tasmanian law it has never been illegal to be a sex worker, however Current Tasmanian Legislation – Sex Industry Offences Act 2005 Provides that it is illegal for a person to employ or otherwise control or profit from the work of individual sex workers (brothels are illegal) Allows two sex workers (but not more) to work together in a partnership arrangement, provided neither controls or manages the other; Makes it an offence to offer or procure sexual services in a public place – making street prostitution illegal for both worker and client 1. https://www.justice.tas.gov.au/__data/assets/pdf_file/0008/188738/Regulation_of_the_Sex_Industry_Discussion_Paper.pdf https://www.justice.tas.gov.au/__data/assets/pdf_file/0008/1... 2. http://www.scarletalliance.org.au/laws/tas/ http://www.scarletalliance.org.au/laws/tas/
- timwaagh 9y agosome sensible rules right there. pimping is not what you want. good for tasmania.
- shams93 9y agoIts a mistake to re-criminalize, just look at Germany when they legalized prostitution they were able to focus efforts on slavery and human trafficking, by separating the issues of human trafficking and slavery from prostitution they saw a 75% increase in prosecution of human traffickers.