24 ms·
The bubble part is endlessly debatable, as it's strictly a subjective concept. The rather dramatic multiple expansion the last few years is not debatable howev
by adventured 9y ago
The bubble part is endlessly debatable, as it's strictly a subjective concept.
The rather dramatic multiple expansion the last few years is not debatable however, it's at historically high levels.
Microsoft's net income has not increased since 2011/2012 or so. The stock went up nearly 200% bottom to top over five years regardless of that. It's up roughly 67% over just two years, for absolutely no good reason that relates to actual growth in their sales or earnings. Plus, they've loaded up massively with debt in that time as well, their balance sheet keeps getting worse by the year.
So who are the suicidal investors paying ~30 times earnings for zero net income growth for half a decade and an epic pile of debt?
How about for Amazon's ~300 times 2017 earnings? It'll take them a minimum of ten years of 20% annual growth, to justify their present valuation, assuming they can ever manage to produce ~$20 billion in net income even with that amount of continued sales growth.
There are far more mundane examples of the extreme valuation expansion that is going on (thanks Federal Reserve for another asset party!).
ADP has hardly expanded its net income since 2011. The stock is up over 100% in that time, for absolutely no good reason. They have no growth of consequence, and there isn't likely to be any inbound. Quite the opposite if anything, they're probably on the chopping block of having their business seriously threatened by cloud competitors over the coming decade.
Priceline.com has a tremendous business, with modest 10-15% annual sales growth... trading at ~45 times earnings, meanwhile their net income hasn't increased in years. The stock is up ~67% in 14 months or so, for absolutely no good reason, their growth didn't just suddenly shoot through the roof and it isn't about to.
Why is PayPal's modest 14-15% net income growth worth 50 times earnings? A little over a year ago it was worth barely over half that. Dramatically increased future growth expectations? Yeah right.
The examples don't stop, it's practically every publicly traded stock.
Who's paying 30 times earnings for Coke (KO)?!? Its business is collapsing:
2014: $46b sales | 2015: $44.2b sales | 2016: $41.8b sales
Net income for KO has gone from $9 billion in 2012, to $6.5 billion today, with a persistent annual erosion. Why is the stock at an all-time high? McDonald's is similar, their business has contracted by 10%+ since 2012, with net income down 13% over that time - the stock is up 50% in two years for absolutely no good reason.
The damage on the way down will be immense, again.
- ecesena 9y agoYour data speaks about the companies but not about dollars invested in the stock market. If more people invest more (compared to the growth of companies/stocks) the value increases.
- adventured 9y ago> If more people invest more (compared to the growth of companies/stocks) the value increases I'm not sure why you pointed that out. Of course my data speaks about the companies, the future potential earnings of said companies is mostly what is being (over) paid for.
- ecesena 9y agoMaybe I said something imprecise, but my line of thoughts is that the number of people putting money in the stock market in increasing, as well as the total amount of money. If you assume the number of companies and shares is constant, then the value increases. Why some companies and not others? Maybe their ability to attract these money. (The amount of companies/stocks isn't constant, I agree, that's why I was comparing relative growth.)
- adventured 9y ago> Why some companies and not others? Maybe their ability to attract these money. It isn't some companies, it's most of the public companies containing substantial invested capital. The S&P 500 earnings multiple has gone up ~60% since 2011. Currently near 25 times, it's at roughly the second highest non-recessionary level in US history.
- ecesena 9y agoGot it - I misinterpreted your original point and I thought you were specifically pointing to some companies. I think the rest of my argument still holds, more availability of cash = increase value. (I actually just noticed that the top comment says basically the same.)