14 ms·
Can a Living Creature Be as Big as a Galaxy?
- bitL 9y agoWe still don't know if the Universe itself isn't a living organism with us playing the role of tiny viruses that require intelligence/consciousness to fulfill certain tasks, like what gut bacteria does for us.
- banachtarski 9y agoWe do. If you bothered to read the article, it makes a point that the communication speed between the components would be slow enough (even at light speed signaling) that the age of the universe would not have permitted sufficient time for such an organism to evolve and do anything.
- paradite 9y agoWell, maybe the age of universe is indeed "too short" for it to do anything useful yet? Your argument seems to be supporting the idea that the universe is like a baby who is still too young to do anything.
- dwaltrip 9y agoOr that it might not be useful to conceptualize the entire universe as a single biological organism.
- banachtarski 9y agoI mean, before humans, there were eukaryotes, and prokaryotes before them. My argument is not supporting that the universe is a baby. It is saying that the being does not exist because it could not have evolved on this timescale, in the same way that single celled organisms are not human babies.
- Taek 9y agoIf we assume that the big bang was actually the conception event of some other cosmic entity, the universe could very easily be a living organism that's the equivalent of a few microsecond old fertilized zygote. So yes, a universe sized lifeform could not have evolved randomly since the big bang, but you can only be confident about that if you assume that nothing exists outside the spacetime bubble we call the universe.
- jfoutz 9y agoor it could be the big bang is the relaxing of a muscle cell is some cosmic monster. Or perhaps the big bang was kinda like enzymes, breaking something hard to eat into a nice easily digestible heat bath. or it could be an edge transition of one wire of some cosmic computer. It's fun to kick around crazy ideas on Saturday afternoon. It could be anything. Sadly, there's no way i'll ever know. But the idle speculation is still amusing.
- meric 9y agoOr, you can write a science fiction short story and make it true in a fictional world you invent.
- simonh 9y agoSuppose an organism is born and lives for 100 years. The organism is 10 metres across. However the rate of propagation of chemicals, blood, nerve signals, etc across its body is only 1mm per year. So over the 100 years if someone touched one of its extremities, the signal for that event would only have propagated across 10% of the diameter of the organism in its lifetime. Does it really make sense to talk about it as being a single organism? How could it do anything in a coordinated way? Or how about an organism that grows at say 10m in diameter per year, but signals across its body only propagate at 1cm per year? Again, how can it be considered to be functioning as a discrete organism? Surely if such a being evolved, its parts would perforce do so independently of each other? There could be no cross-organism coordination. It would have to disintegrate or devolve into local functional or operational units if it were to do anything effective at all.
- wellboy 9y agoThough most stars will have burnt out in a couple of billion years and heat death will come, where no cellular life can exist, so not sure if this is more useduo than now.
- bitL 9y agoUniverse is full of particles with quantum entanglement; those can be your "immediate" messengers of information. But anyway, there are way too many assumptions in your objections about the character of such life and its requirements, as well as in the article itself. We still don't know the fabrics of the Universe, just some rough approximations in certain areas with known confidence; there likely are many surprises awaiting us in the future (like discovery of radioactivity etc. in the past).
- dwaltrip 9y agoAs I understand it, quantum entanglement doesn't allow for affecting causality faster than the speed of light. So that doesn't solve the problem. Your comment doesn't really give accurate credit to the current state of knowledge.
- bitL 9y agoYeah, it was kinda stupid in this context; I meant to show that some actions are happening "immediately" even across huge distances and not that we need to wait for e.g. gravitational waves to move at the speed of light. Not that we can actually utilize this for conveying information immediately.
- carapace 9y agoI think you're onto something. Yes, quantum entanglement doesn't seem to allow for transmission of information in the conventional sense. However... Take a universe full of particles, many of which are entangled with each other. If you consider the entanglement as primary you can think of the entangled particles as single entities that have "extensions" into space-time that can be widely separated. I don't think it's at all clear that "living" processes cannot be carried out on this "substratum" of interspersed non-local entities. But I'm waaaay over my head here, so I'll stop waving my hands. :-)
- samstave 9y agoWhat if quantum entanglement is simple an indicator that there is another way to send information - but we haven't discovered that function of that mechanism to do so yet?
- benaadams 9y ago> Given that our brains are composed of neurons, which are themselves, in essence, specialized cooperative single-cell organisms Don't humans to a degree fulfill this role; the mass behavior of the species (recently) acting as form of brain with emerging self-awareness of the galaxy/universe; since we study it, and are also part of it?
- tomrod 9y agoI argue against this idea. Part of our sapience is that our neurons can coherently aggregate into specific thoughts leading to choices (and actions performed on those choices). What would the nature of supersapience be? Just sapience, so a single human brain is a holon. Behavior can be influenced by others, but will isn't superceded by a crowd.
- benaadams 9y ago> Behavior can be influenced by others, but will isn't superceded by a crowd. It often is by governments though. Also judging by polling on small sample sets, which often match whole population elections they do coherently aggregate; and then those governments make laws which incarcerate or penalize going against them. Also isn't that the nature of science to provide coherent aggregation of knowledge that is agreed upon (though testable hypothesizes). Which is generally different from government policy, which usually doesn't use evidence based decision making in the scientific sense.
- olegkikin 9y agoYou're presuming the speed of light is the hard limit. Whereas we know for a fact faster movement is possible - the space-time itself was expanding faster.
- Cozumel 9y ago^This. The universe expanded faster than light, that's why we still can't see everything, so saying things like 'the communication speed is too slow to permit evolution' is just wrong, it also doesn't take into account things like time doesn't actually exist, it's just a biological construct. The whole article is predicated upon a bunch of faulty assumptions, it's like it was written by a simple minded child.
- andars 9y agoYou have some misunderstandings about the expansion of the universe. I would recommend reading http://www.preposterousuniverse.com/blog/2015/10/13/the-universe-never-expands-faster-than-the-speed-of-light/ http://www.preposterousuniverse.com/blog/2015/10/13/the-univ...
- jerf 9y agoIn addition to that, positing a 'life form' that exists in the presence of space continuously and literally pulling it apart doesn't seem likely to be a net positive for our galaxy-sized life form.
- olegkikin 9y agoNo, it's you who gets incorrect information from some random blogs. The size of the observable universe: ~93 billion light-years Time since the big bang: ~13.7 billion years. http://curious.astro.cornell.edu/about-us/104-the-universe/cosmology-and-the-big-bang/expansion-of-the-universe/616-is-the-universe-expanding-faster-than-the-speed-of-light-intermediate http://curious.astro.cornell.edu/about-us/104-the-universe/c... https://phys.org/news/2015-02-fast-universe.html https://phys.org/news/2015-02-fast-universe.html
- 9y ago
- philovivero 9y agoI bothered to read the article, and I don't buy that premise at all. It seems to indicate that for a thought to happen, a signal must traverse the entire length (width?) of your brain. That isn't how it works at all. Many thoughts are localised in the brain. Further, some signals don't need to get to the brain at all. And some functions of life don't even need signals to ever leave the localised region at all. If you are cut, your blood cells spill out, clot, and prevent further bleeding from happening, all without anything outside of the immediate vicinity of the cut to be notified (although it's good to let other parts of the body nearby, say another finger, from exacerbating the wound). If the organism were larger than say a planet, then why would not the brain become distributed, with the parts needed to deal with one quadrant of the planet located at that part of it? Basically, this article is lazy. It makes a couple of very dubious assumptions, then runs full-forward on those assumptions, never stopping to think if those assumptions even make sense. Yes, if we are to try to imagine a life form that looks exactly like a human (or other life-form that we find on Earth), but is the size of the galaxy, we start to laugh, because that couldn't work. But that thought experiment is pretty silly.
- ZenoArrow 9y agoWe don't. How do we know that the big bang wasn't part of the internal activity of another organism? There are just some things we will never know.
- dang 9y ago> If you bothered to read the article This particular nasty swipe is not only not ok on HN, there's a specific rule against it. Please (re)-read https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html.
- zipwitch 9y agoI'm no expert on xenobiology, but it seems like in our search for life we're always looking for life like Earth's. Are we even looking for life at much different scales of size or time?
- kanzure 9y ago> Are we even looking for life at much different scales of size or time? Yes, see: http://www.xenology.info/Xeno.htm http://www.xenology.info/Xeno.htm
- jerrylives 9y agoThis book is amazing. Thank you for this
- DonaldPShimoda 9y agoNo, because we have no idea what the bounds are. We don't know what dissimilar life could possibly look like. If I send you to a junk yard and say "Find my old microwave" can you do it? You'll probably start by looking for things that look like what you think a microwave looks like, right? But what if mine looks different? We know life is probably somewhat rare in the universe, at least compared to the raw number of planets. But we know that Earth ticks all the right boxes to generate life, despite that adversity. So we look for things like Earth because it's more likely to be productive than a blind search with no bounds.
- CuriouslyC 9y agoThat comes out of the fact that life is an arbitrary label we apply to certain chemical systems. It lacks a rigorous physical definition.
- jerf 9y agoLife on smaller, faster scales has been posited, but not in anywhere we can currently see. See, for instance, Dragon's Egg [1], which is a science fiction novel that very seriously tries to discuss life on the surface of a neutron star. I know it's fiction, but it's probably still one of the best treatments of the idea out there. Even if such a civilization would have zero interest in our resources we still certainly see no evidence of a star-faring galactic civilization of that type. Life on larger, slower scales rapidly hits the problem that 15 billion years turns out not to be all that long when you start dividing it by thousands or millions at a time. The problem is that if you're spread out that far, you're probably mostly running at the ambient temperature, which is very cold and much slower, so not only do you need to take 3-6ish orders of magnitude of speed off for dispersion in space, you need to take 3ish orders of magnitude off for being very cold and thus chemistry being very slow. And you may need to take another 3-6+ orders of magnitude off for waiting for your very dispersed, very cold molecules to encounter each other at all, in order to do whatever reactions are supposed to be supporting you. The problem you have there is that on that time scale, the galaxy is a very active and violent place, with supernovae popping off and galactic collisions and passages through the arms and all these stars flying about far faster than you can react to them (rather than the stately procession we think we see) and all kinds of things that tends to make a sensible person thinking about this problem starting thinking that even were some magical force to create such a life form, it wouldn't subjectively live very long before being violently destroyed from its point of view. (And there are really quite a few more factors missing from the story of how one could have such an enormous life form, like how one forms from what are, to a first approximation, hydrogen atoms with trace contaminants. The biggest "contaminant" also happens to be helium, which you're not going to be doing much chemistry on. Seems difficult to imagine what "chemistry" would be going on here. (And if you want to say "energy being", be concrete about what sort of energy it is you are talking about, and how it manages to accomplish any sort of reaction or computation. It turns out that at least in our universe, "energy being" is probably just a nonsense phrase with no possible physical referent.)) I wouldn't write the idea off perhaps as entirely as some people here have, but if such large organisms or civilizations are going to ever exist, they're going to have to exist in a later epoch of the Universe, i.e., they're still many, many billions of years in the future. Right now the universe is too young and vibrant and explosive for anything like that to exist for very long. If these sorts of things intrigue you, and you'd like a semi-realistic treatment of some of the similar ideas, you might consider https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Pld8wTa16Jk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Pld8wTa16Jk . The boundary between "science fiction" and "the optimal possible engineering" is fuzzy but that video does a decent job of riding the line. One of the things I don't think he mentions is that some of the "slow" civilizations he mentions, where a thousand years literally pass like a single thought, is that they might be geographically dispersed, for at least some of their components, on this scale. As you hypothesize beings or civilizations (and honestly, from where we sit, there isn't necessarily that great a difference between the two things) that exist orders of magnitude more slowly than we do, the speed of light stops being such a bummer and "virtually" speeds up. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dragon%27s_Egg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dragon%27s_Egg
- trophycase 9y agoThis is my belief. I've always wondered how the reproductive mechanism will work. It's a little anthropocentric and pseudoscientific, but I like to imagine it's our destiny as humans to reproduce the universe.
- bitL 9y agoI would rather hack and reprogram it ;-)
- rightnow 9y agoAsk your mom
- devoply 9y agoThis article does not take into account quantum phenomenon. It's possible that instead of being limited by the speed of light transmissions, such a system uses quantum phenomenon for communication. Which then would make the whole argument that this article makes invalid. It's based on the premise that life would be based on the same sort of physics as life on Earth... which does not make sense as such life if it exists would evolve using a different set of rules which would include things such as limits on speed of light transmission in such large systems... so it would've learned to exploit quantum phenomenon for transmission. edit: Superluminal, or faster than light, communication is said not to work because it allows information to be sent into the past. There is however non-locality which is not the same thing. Sorry not an expert on this, but this seems to apply to the exact discussion. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bell%27s_theorem#Importance_of_the_theorem https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bell%27s_theorem#Importance_of...
- balfirevic 9y agoIt is not possible to use quantum phenomena for faster-than-light communication. It's fine to speculate about completely new physics allowing for such communication, but it really doesn't have to do much with what we call quantum physics.
- danharaj 9y agoThere are no quantum effects that allow superluminal communication of information.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- Cozumel 9y agoSure there is. You've just not seen it on HN yet.
- banachtarski 9y ago
- baron816 9y agoChallenge accepted
- dwaltrip 9y agoA bit of tangent -- the article talks about powers of ten, and hints at how powerful a tool it is for analyzing everything around us. This resonates very strongly with me. The entire known universe, from the smallest particle to the width of the cosmos itself, fits within several dozen points on this scale. It's incredible. Personally, the last few years, I have felt that working to understand how all phenomena can be sketched out on the log scale has helped me gain a deeper understanding of the world. Of course, this goes hand in hand with related ideas, such as having a generally skeptical mindset, seeking first principles, etc. These ideas has been very powerful for me, and I thought it might be worth sharing. P.S. the book "The Black Cloud", mentioned in the article, is a really fun and quick read. I recommend it for any sci-fi fans.
- kindadumb 9y agoThis theory was once proven in a famous documentary http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AJOVUF-HaDw&t=0m37s http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AJOVUF-HaDw&t=0m37s
- tsunamifury 9y agoIt's answer of "No" is predicated on two assumptions: that the lifeform is not colonial in nature and that time is not a localized phenomenon. While on the surface that later assumption might sound absurd, our universe could very well be a Local Bubble of time. Time could even be a biological function of a higher dimensional being that is the size of the universe. There is also no way to disprove that without observing beyond the universe, which may get a bit dicey.
- Swizec 9y ago> There is also no way to disprove that without observing beyond the universe, which may get a bit dicey. My high school physics prof had the best answer to "What is beyond the universe?" --> "Surely if we ever find something outside of the universe, we will be smart enough to call that the universe too" He was referencing the idea that universe contains everything by definition.
- jfaucett 9y agoThats a clever but not very mathematical answer. The general problem here is the conflation of universe i.e. "all of spacetime and everything we will ever discover" with the idea of a universal set, which doesn't have to include all elements and is rather arbitrary/relative.
- olegkikin 9y agoIn terms of definitions, generally cosmos contains everything. Universe is our local observable space-time with the earliest event we can detect being the big bang.
- Swizec 9y ago> Universe is our local observable space-time So if we observe something beyond what is currently observable, would that not become observable and thus part of the universe?
- 9y ago
- jeffdavis 9y agoRelated: On Being the Right Size https://irl.cs.ucla.edu/papers/right-size.html https://irl.cs.ucla.edu/papers/right-size.html
- Poc 9y agoIt make me think of Von neuman probe. If we can consider that a robot or something with connections similar to our neurons can be a living creature. Then maybe if something like Von Neuman probes existed it could have colonized the whole galaxy (actually it could be done in a few hundred millions years) then those probes, while each one have is own brain, could communicate with the other probes and even if two probes at two opposite sides of the galaxy couldn't communicate, they would still be connected. Then maybe this network could be consider as a living creature.
- 11thEarlOfMar 9y agoIt's a different topic, but related. I was marveling at the diversity of life on Earth, which led me wonder: to what extent does sustained life on Earth depend on that diversity? I.e., what would be required or different for a planet to host and sustain a single species of life? Given the nature of evolution, and that one subscribes to it, life on Earth started with a single organism that replicated. From that point until a replication modified the organism into a different species, there would have been one species. But was it necessary to have multiple species in order to sustain life?
- heckerhut 9y agoYes. Evolution is actually its own evidence. Biological evolution evolved out of necessity. Without constantly changing evolutionary pressures exerted by an organism's external environment there would be no need for evolution and it therefore wouldn't have evolved.
- idlewords 9y agoThat's the opposite of an evolutionary argument. Evolution is not teleological, it doesn't arise to meet a need. It's a kind of feedback loop in low-entropy systems that given enough time can produce interesting phenomena, including this message board.
- oblib 9y ago"life on Earth started with a single organism that replicated." I would tend to ponder that life in it's simplest form is not singular and never has been and this is the cause of evolution.
- dredmorbius 9y agoAvailable evidence suggests that life on Earth has a common ancestor. This doesn't mean it was the only origin of life on Earth, but it is the only surviving line. It also took a few days for complexity to arise. About a trillion of them.
- alexpetralia 9y agoDoes a group of people have an emergent consciousness in its own right that no one person can individually experience? Perhaps certain parts of the brain too "think" they are conscious but can't individually experience the same consciousness we as people experience.
- Koshkin 9y agoSince proteins cannot exist in space, then, using the currently accepted definition of "life" at the basic level as the complex of processes that allow protein molecules to exist, then the answer must be 'no'. On the other hand, it is an interesting mental exercise to also consider other reasons why such creature might be impossible. One reason could be because the time needed for such creature to grow from something much, much smaller (as it usually happens in biology) would be longer than the age of the universe. Another one is that nerve impulses travel slower than the speed of light, and so, again, it would take forever for a signal to reach the central nervous system. One could argue that the creature can be "decentralized", i.e. look more like a large colony of smaller organisms, but then the question arises as to what makes it a single creature in the first place. Yet another issue concerns what drives the evolution of this particular species, and, again, the time it takes. So far, all these considerations unavoidably lead to the answer 'no'.
- 21 9y agoMaybe you should expand your definition of life to not require proteins. From Wikipedia: > From a physics perspective, living beings are thermodynamic systems with an organized molecular structure that can reproduce itself and evolve as survival dictates. ... A major strength of this definition is that it distinguishes life by the evolutionary process rather than its chemical composition.
- alextheparrot 9y agoIs a sterile human not alive by this definition? I find that life needing to reproduce is a questionable condition. If we say reproduction is not requisite, then neither is evolution as evolution requires generations. "Evolve as survival dictates" is a bit pointless, as if you don't change to survive (Assuming the change is requisite) you do not survive. Survival is defined as still being alive, so if you don't survive you are no longer alive and thus not living. We've then defined a state where a living being must continue living to be living, well sure - I agree.
- 21 9y ago
- SCHiM 9y agoI love topics like this :) If yes, the next question might be: > Imagine a creature that is as big as the galaxy, imagine its organ that is analogous to our brain is as efficient and big as is possible, what is the most complex concept that that brain can fully comprehend?
- axplusb 9y agoI'm surprised to find no mention of Solaris by Stanislaw Lem among the fiction references. In this novel, a whole planet is somehow a living organism, truly alien to human conception of life.
- mrdrozdov 9y agoAn excellent read! I had the same thought. It's almost negligence not to mention it.
- mcappleton 9y agoLook, the vast majority of a galaxy is empty space. A living creature is obviously not empty space, so all that space would have to be filled with the creature's matter. Well, if you put that much matter so close together, it will all collapse on itself and create a black hole. So no, you could not have a living creature as big as a galaxy.
- philovivero 9y agoUh. The vast majority of what constitutes YOU is empty space. Sometime go look up the amount of space between the protons, neutrons, and electron cloud in an atom.
- mcappleton 9y agoThe center of every galaxy is a black hole. Lol so the center of this creature would be a black hole?? Some weird creature
- stareatgoats 9y agoThe question is not correctly formed: what we really want to know is if there are life-like beings that could operate on a totally different scale than ours (both time and size wise, including viruses and whales here). Self centered thinking, i.e. restricting our inquiry to only include protein-based lifeforms or other qualities required on our scale obviously prevents us from having the required open minded mindset.
- diminish 9y agostates, companies, religious communities, planets as whole ecosystems can all be construed as "single being"s.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- dawnerd 9y agoSimilarly fire ant colonies could be considered the same. https://youtu.be/NpiDADw5Omw https://youtu.be/NpiDADw5Omw
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- Consultant32452 9y agoThere are more bacterial cells in your body than there are human cells. Where exactly do you draw the line between what constitutes "you."
- delecti 9y agoA zoo is still a zoo if there aren't any animals in it, but it wouldn't stay in business very long. No matter how important the animals are to the long-term viability of the zoo, they are not the zoo. My gut bacteria may be vital to my survival, but they are not me. I don't find placing that line to be difficult at all.
- asah 9y agore heat dissipation - the author assumes a mostly-convex form, but if the life form as concave spaces (e.g. tentrils) then the surface-area-to-volume ratio can be arbitrary.
- mbrookes 9y agoNo.
- danaan1003 9y agoYeah, your mom
- jfoutz 9y agoSo this requires a few things, First off, single organisms can have pretty advanced local processing of control. An octopus has a nerve cluster for each tentacle that can operate independently of the main brain [1]. So in at least one case, biological brains delegate work out to another region of the body. An argonaut octopus actually detaches part of it body, which as far as i can tell, keeps living for a while. it's kind of creepy. The only thing i can't find an example of, is remote control. A detachable body part, with a nerve cluster, that responds to light or sound seems like what would be needed for the base creature. Evolution hasn't stumbled on that trifecta here on earth. But it sure seems like something that could have come about. The latency argument isn't compelling. If i can send one message, i can send another hundred billion messages along with it. So, sure only a few thousand round trips, but a fabulous amount of information transferred. There's no actual biological equivalent to a semi autonomous drone, so i'm not sure what that would look like before the creature took to the stars. There's also no real obvious way for this lone detatched tentacle to consume the resources of a planet. But whatever. I think one entity with those three features might have a chance. Also, is the creature smart? Does it get to genetically engineer itself? do cyborgs count? That greatly simplifies things as well. The detachable parts could have detachable parts, and recurse down to whatever arbitrary degree is useful. Alternatively if you admit superorganisms, then everything is much easier. So anyway, you don't really need to send many messages when the message is "here are the latest designs for industrial architecture to dismantle a solar system and send the resources back" It's up to the billions of lone tenticles and their machines to execute the will of the super brain. On the other hand, yeah, there's not going to be a galaxy sized amoeba or panther or anything like that. maybe an incredibly fine mist of fungus or mold, but i think it'd be too hard to keep a system like that from collapsing in on itself from too much mass. a galaxy sized ring of spider silk orbiting a black hole sounds like great science fiction. but i can't imagine that working. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Octopus#Nervous_system_and_senses https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Octopus#Nervous_system_and_sen... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Argonaut_(animal)#Sexual_dimorphism_and_reproduction https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Argonaut_(animal)#Sexual_dimor... [3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Superorganism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Superorganism
- sriku 9y ago"Exhalation" by Ted Chiang is, I think, a great literary exploration of this topic and brings the essence of what is required for life, though it doesn't get into what life is as opposed to other phenomena. For those who've not read it, I may be giving off too much if I said anything more. It is certainly more insightful (again imho) than this article. http://www.nightshadebooks.com/Downloads/Exhalation%20-%20Ted%20Chiang.html http://www.nightshadebooks.com/Downloads/Exhalation%20-%20Te...
- FrozenVoid 9y agoThe comparison about surface areas is wrong. A creature could drastically increase its surface area by having many tendril-like appendages (i.e. hairy surface) and limiting the core body to consist of thin shapes. A fractal web of tendrils would dissipate energy far more effectively.
- DonHopkins 9y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elder_Thing https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elder_Thing
- visarga 9y agoWhen thinking about such things, you've got to ask yourself: under what circumstances would such a creature appear and under what circumstances could it die? What does it need? What constitutes a good or bad thing for it. How does it learn? How does it perceive? How does it act out its intentions? Does it have a self preserving instinct? It doesn't make much sense for a creature the size of the galaxy. If it did, it would be extremely slow and alien to us. A more plausible way would be if a human-scale civilization would create self replicating probes that would spread in the galaxy and bootstrap some sort of large biological or AI civilization.
- andy_ppp 9y agoSort of tangentially related is the physicist Geoffrey West, who decided to try to apply the thinking of a theoretical physicist to biological systems. His book Scale is excellent, and this is one of the most interesting podcasts I've ever heard: https://www.samharris.org/podcast/item/from-cells-to-cities https://www.samharris.org/podcast/item/from-cells-to-cities
- mirimir 9y agoIt's a thoughtful article, and I love the reference to Burroughs' Soft Machine. But it doesn't distinguish clearly enough between self-conscious organisms and the rest. It's true that consciousness and evolution thereof likely crap out when latency goes over a few hundred milliseconds. However, I see no limit to the size of zero-gravity organisms like the honey fungus. Fungi are filamentous, so there's no unsurmountable problem with heat dissipation. And even for self-conscious organisms, I can imagine hierarchical organization, such as Rajaniemi's "metaself" or Watts' Bicameral Order.
- cardigan 9y agoHmm, but what if the living creature had a density of neural circuitry similar to ours, and mainly interacted with things inside itself, and had slow propagation of knowledge? Not sure I understand this except under the hidden assumption of having a similar number of neural circuit elements
- rcthompson 9y agoIf anyone is interested in a sci-fi novel series that explores these kinds of themes for intelligent life, I highly recommend Ancillary Justice by Ann Leckie. (I've left the statement above intentionally vague to avoid excessive spoilers.)
- nils-m-holm 9y agoWhy only as big as a galaxy? Why not the entire universe? http://www.geoffreylandis.com/infinite.htp http://www.geoffreylandis.com/infinite.htp (Geoffrey Landis, the Melancholy of Infinite Space)
- brunomarx1 9y agoWhat if the galaxxy itself were a living being, but we are so small to grasp this form of life
- brunomarx1 9y agoWhat if the galaxxy itself were a living being, but we are so small to grasp this form of life
- hypertexthero 9y ago> Stars are best regarded as living organisms, but organisms which are physiologically and psychologically of a very peculiar kind. The outer and middle layers of a mature star apparently consist of “tissues” woven of currents of incandescent gases. These gaseous tissues live and maintain the stellar consciousness by intercepting part of the immense flood of energy that wells from the congested and furiously active interior of the star. The innermost of the vital layers must be a kind of digestive apparatus which transmutes the crude radiation into forms required for the maintenance of the star’s life. Outside this digestive area lies some sort of coordinating layer, which may be thought of as the star’s brain. The outermost layers, including the corona, respond to the excessively faint stimuli of the star’s cosmical environment, to light from neighboring stars, to cosmic rays, to the impact of meteors, to tidal stresses caused by the gravitational influence of planets or of other stars. These influences could not, of course, produce any clear impression but for a strange tissue of gaseous sense organs, which discriminate between them in respect of quality and direction, and transmit information to the correlating “brain” layer. From Star Maker by Olaf Stapledon, Chapter 11, Stars and Vermin https://ebooks.adelaide.edu.au/s/stapledon/olaf/star/chapter11.html https://ebooks.adelaide.edu.au/s/stapledon/olaf/star/chapter...
- Balgair 9y agoQuick reminder: We don't know what the majority of the mass/energy of the universe is. Dark matter is ~20% of the universe and pretty much all we know about it is that 'it falls down'. Dark Energy is ~75% of the universe and all we know about it is that it makes galaxies accelerate away from each other. So, defining life or intelligence as we do is maybe not the best idea for long term thinking.
- bhldr 9y agoThe ocean is mostly water, so hypothesizing the size of a whale is not the best idea for long term thinking.
- sebastianconcpt 9y agoAren't creature body sizes a function of some combination of food size and quantity? If so, what this hypothetical creature would eat?
- 22TrilAsecond 9y agoHere are the ten core beliefs that most scientists take for granted. Everything is essentially mechanical. Dogs, for example, are complex mechanisms, rather than living organisms with goals of their own. Even people are machines, ‘lumbering robots’, in Richard Dawkins’s vivid phrase, with brains that are like genetically programmed computers. All matter is unconscious. It has no inner life or subjectivity or point of view. Even human consciousness is an illusion produced by the material activities of brains. The total amount of matter and energy is always the same (with the exception of the Big Bang, when all the matter and energy of the universe suddenly appeared). The laws of nature are fixed. They are the same today as they were at the beginning, and they will stay the same for ever. Nature is purposeless, and evolution has no goal or direction. All biological inheritance is material, carried in the genetic material, DNA, and in other material structures. Minds are inside heads and are nothing but the activities of brains. When you look at a tree, the image of the tree you are seeing is not ‘out there’, where it seems to be, but inside your brain. Memories are stored as material traces in brains and are wiped out at death. Unexplained phenomena like telepathy are illusory. Mechanistic medicine is the only kind that really works.
- swarup182 9y agomay be galaxy on itself is a living creature, and we are just like neurons in it. or cells.