7 ms·
I wonder if anything from today will still be around in 2000 years, it is such a long time by today's standards. The humankind progressed very slowly from the
by Koshkin 9y ago
I wonder if anything from today will still be around in 2000 years, it is such a long time by today's standards.
The humankind progressed very slowly from the early time of Babylon (some five thousand years ago) through the time of Rome - both civilizations seem equally ancient to us. But today, even one hundred years seems an incredibly long time.
On the other hand - and somehow it is hard to believe -
hundreds or thousands of years ago people were the same as now, with the individual and cultural differences from us probably being smaller than the differences that exist between us right now.
- netule 9y agoI think it's incredibly optimistic to think that there will be people around in 2,000 years to analyze our remains. The way things are going, I can't help but to lose faith in our species.
- simias 9y agoIt seems hard to imagine that humanity could be completely wiped out. Billions dying in a huge catastrophe? Maybe. Terrible survival conditions for the survivors? Possibly. Complete annihilation? Improbable. We're quite tough at a species and now we have the technology to make even the most terrible environments survivable. That's why I find plans to colonize Mars as a "backup" in case something terrible happens on Earth rather ridiculous. It would be incredibly difficult to make Earth more inhospitable than Mars is right now. Nuclear winter Earth would probably be paradise compared to normal Mars. If you're worried about humanity's survival build underwater cities and bunkers in the arctic, Mars isn't worth it.
- 300bps 9y agoIf you're worried about humanity's survival build underwater cities and bunkers in the arctic, Mars isn't worth it. We could do both. In fact, the technology for both likely has overlap.
- simias 9y agoOh yeah, it's not an argument against space exploration. I'm just pointing out that if your only objective is survival of the species then building autonomous bunkers on earth is probably massively more cost effective than building autonomous stations on Mars. And once the danger clears out you can start to recolonize right-away.
- PhasmaFelis 9y agoI think the "eggs in one basket" argument is also concerned about asteroid impacts. A large enough rock wouldn't be survivable anywhere on or beneath the Earth.
- jacobush 9y agoTrue. I wonder though, what the cultural and psychological impact on the Earth survivors would be... if... if the struggling survivors knew there was a population on Mars, living on unscathed by the disasters on Earth.
- jamesrcole 9y ago> It seems hard to imagine that humanity could be completely wiped out. Billions dying in a huge catastrophe? Maybe. Terrible survival conditions for the survivors? Possibly. Complete annihilation? Improbable. "Maybe" and "Possibly" are pretty vague. You seem to imply the odds are quite low. You list the last case as "Improbable". Do you really have any solid ground for making these judgements? You say it seems hard to imagine. One thing that history clearly shows is that the future is always hard to imagine, and that you always have to expect the unexpected.
- thinkfurther 9y agoEven just "terrible survival conditions" contains such a vast range of possibilities, including humans I might not consider people, and itself is dwarved by terrible political and social conditions. The question isn't so much will there still be some form of two-legged entitites. Technology doesn't help here at all, to the contrary, it can be used to enforce the wiping out of all people as I understand them, and not at all to protect that. That does have to come from people; and it's not. So, the trends remaining as they are, it's curtains.
- Houshalter 9y agoIf our civilization falls, it will be difficult to rebuild. We've exhausted many of the easy to get to minerals. The conditions that let us bootstrap the industrial revolution won't exist again. But more than that, technology improves every day. The only reason we aren't extinct now is because nuclear weapons happen to be very difficult to build. Imagine if the materials required to build them were common, and any idiot could do it with some parts from the hardware store. How long do you think the world would last? Well who is to say the next world destroying technology will be the same? Maybe there's a reason the sky is empty.
- njharman 9y agoExhausted all the minerals? Pfft, who cares about minerals when refined alloys and other recyclable materials are all over. The parking lots of one USA town has more metal than the (few) survivors of any civilazation collapsing level event could even use. Also, civilization existed before the industrial revolution. In fact that would be a good point to mark the start of the fall. Giving the rate of increase in pollution, overconsumption, climate and environment destruction since and before then.
- jfoutz 9y agoEhh, try welding aluminum. I agree with you, but it ain't no walk in the park. Oil and coal seem like the real keys to industrialization. We took most of the easy stuff.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- Houshalter 9y agoWe've taken concentrated deposits of minerals and scattered them widely. And exposed them to the air where they quickly corrode away into nothing useful. Sure, digging up landfills for a handful of aluminum cans might meet the needs of a small primitive post apocalyptic town. But that's not enough to sustain an industrial revolution. Preindustrial civilizations are nothing to aspire to. By all measurements the quality of life was abysmal and almost not worth living for the majority of the population. I'd rather our species just go extinct than endure that forever.
- njharman 9y agoMore than 99% of all species are extinct. And we are currently at an extinction rate 100-1000x the "normal" rate. I.e. we are in a mass extinction event. But, 2000 years is nothing. Humans will be off the planet in that time and it would be really, really hard to wipe us all out in that tiny timescale. Btw, we are not tough as a species. Trilobites are tough. Those fuckers survived 3 mass extinctions. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Aji2VnQFUCs&index=11&list=LLB_kTi3xelaBehM_Pc8evsw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Aji2VnQFUCs&index=11&list=LL...
- cm2187 9y agoIf we keep building everything in glass, there won't be much ruins to look at in 2000 years. All that will survive from our civilization is probably going to be a few motorway interchanges and perhaps some soviet-area, all-concrete monuments.
- trentnix 9y agoAlarmists have been warning us of impending catastrophe for thousands of years. People have feared overpopulation since Hannibal was marching the elephants over the Alps. Ministers have said for generations "this is as bad as it can get, we are doomed". You'll have to pardon my skepticism.
- jamesrcole 9y agoWhatever people's opinions are of the dangers is independent of whatever the actual dangers are/aren't. Two things are worth keeping in mind. One, in real terms the human race has existed for a tiny amount of time. What we've experienced so far doesn't tell us anything definitive about what can happen. Two, a catastrophe that wipes out humanity only needs to happen once. You don't get a second chance, and history won't be any guide if it did happen.
- icebraining 9y agoOne, in real terms the human race has existed for a tiny amount of time. Right, but we're talking about 2000 years in the future, so the argument is reversed: we've existed for quite a long time compared to a couple of millennia.
- jamesrcole 9y agoIt's not clear to me what you're saying. 2000 more years is nothing in broad terms.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- aaronblohowiak 9y agoHumans almost went extinct 72,000 years ago.. look it up, kind of neat
- mikeash 9y agoEverything is great until it isn't. I find this "people have said that before and it wasn't true" argument to be lacking. For one thing, having massive arsenals of nuclear weapons ready to go at a moment's notice is qualitatively different from anything in history. Global thermonuclear war wouldn't wipe out humanity, but it would wreck civilization badly enough to qualify as "doom" as I see it.
- will_brown 9y agoThat same kind of doom and gloom end of the world thinking existing 2,000 years ago, it obviously exists today and guaranteed if we are around in 2,000 years it will exist then. A quote I like that just about sums up human nature from the time of the Romans to today: "When Jesus comes back, these crazy, greedy, capitalistic men are gonna kill him again." - Mike Tyson
- thinkfurther 9y agoThat's not "human nature", that's the nature of sick people who were mistreated in some form (most of them considered benign by too many) as children or later (which is at least a better simplification than most rationalizations I hear most of the time). That that now engulfs the planet so much it is considered "human nature" kind of proves the point that we're fucked. Look at a baby who is acknowledged and treated well, and doesn't happen to have a problem to cry about atm. That's "human nature" to me. Now skip forward to kids, that's human potential. Now skip forward to youths, and you see people with all sorts of sticks up their butts; skip to adults, you see and smell death. Yes, I'm generalizing, but I also see what I see. Something usually goes wrong very quickly, but it still goes wrong, and people call all sorts of things personalities or cultures (or even "human nature") because they're not able or willing to ask what is really going on.
- randyrand 9y agoI agree, they most definitely wont be human. Some AI/bio-hack hybrid.
- VectorLock 9y agoShoot we just cracked how to make Roman Concrete that can last 2000 years being beaten by seawater. https://www.nature.com/news/seawater-is-the-secret-to-long-lasting-roman-concrete-1.22231 https://www.nature.com/news/seawater-is-the-secret-to-long-l...
- vslira 9y agoA thought just crossed my mind: can you patent rediscovered ancient technology? I mean, prior art and all... (not joking)
- pbhjpbhj 9y agoIf there's no extant disclosure of the means to work the invention then I don't see why not. For example we could find that you got the method wrong, and thus that no prior art existed. If there's a document, stele, or something you can examine to learn how to work the invention then that would be prior art. Recall, USA have harmonised with the other systems now on using "first to file". However you'd have to be the inventor, so you'd need to be able to argue you'd reinvented it. In practice you could just not reveal your source and probably get away with saying you invented it.
- kpil 9y agoYou can certainly patent the process.
- philh 9y agoI recall an article saying that a) We use rebar in concrete for tensile and shear strength, which massively decreases the amount of concrete you need but shortens lifespan. b) Our concrete sets a lot faster. c) The specific mineral that the nature article is about, was already known. (I'm not sure if it was widely known.) (These are the main things I remember, anyway.)
- jotjotzzz 9y agoI think it is nearsighted to say that "humankind progressed very slowly" when we can't even figure out all of the wonders accomplished by our ancestors and to the precision of the way they built so many of structures that still exist today without our "modern tools" and knowledge. There were no books that survived to tell us of all the lost knowledge uncovered before us. The reason why I think our society is laying the foundation for future progress is the Internet. All knowledge aggregated and never lost in one central place. We have to still discover what was lost thousands of years before us. What could be "new" to us may have been already known common knowledge in the past? And who knows the many lost civilizations that could have been just as technically knowledgeable before us.
- cjjuice 9y agoAlso the collective goals of humankind have changed. We can't measure past civilization "progress" on our metrics of progress today. They weren't trying to "progress" in the ways we are progressing today.
- abritinthebay 9y ago> when we can't even figure out all of the wonders accomplished by our ancestors and to the precision of the way they built so many of structures that still exist today Err, source? There are a few surprising examples of advanced stuff (Damascus Steel for example) but almost always they are due to taking advantage of luck/sources (like Damascus Steel) rather than inherent skill or design that was "lost". Have any examples in mind?
- thaumasiotes 9y agoSocietal loss of skill is well attested; Mycenaean fortresses were so impressive to the post-dark-age Greeks that they assumed the fortresses had been built by cyclopes rather than men. (Also, the Mycenaeans kept written records; their writing system was lost and the classical Greeks had to develop a new one.) And the Australians who colonised Tasmania soon lost most of the technology they'd brought with them. Whether we today can understand how to build massive stone fortresses or make bows and arrows is a somewhat different question.
- eesmith 9y agoMany things will be left in 2,000 years. The Killarney Copper Mines were in use starting over 4,000 years ago, and we've found remains from that era. Think of all the tunnels and mines we've built, many with things inside. The faces of the four presidents carved on the illegally confiscated Six Grandfathers aren't going to erode away in 2,000 years. Watch the long-running BBC series "Time Team" to see just how much is in the ground still from the Middle Ages, Roman era, and even back to the neolithic. Our trash heaps are the middens of the future.
- dageshi 9y agoTime Team wasn't a BBC series, it was made by Channel 4 (one of the other main UK TV Channels) It is however an exceptionally good show https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LLcxwPeeohk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LLcxwPeeohk One of my favourite episodes
- eesmith 9y agoOops! Thanks for the correction. I watched the series on YouTube.
- paulddraper 9y ago> illegally confiscated Six Grandfathers Odd description. Illegal according to US law, or Lakota law? (Legality has interesting implications in war between two nations.)
- jerrylives 9y agoIt was a war started to invade a nation with whom we made a treaty (Treaty of Fort Laramie) to respect their sovereignty. So, we broke the treaty which is illegal and then we proceeded to plunder their sacred lands in the name of God and gold.
- clock_tower 9y agoSpeaking as a Catholic, I have no idea how people can break a treaty and think they're fighting for God. Isn't He traditionally called to witness that treaties will be kept sacrosanct?
- hwillis 9y agoThe things we have today aren't as new as we like to think. The Antikythera mechanism is a clockwork calculator for astronomical phenomena from 2150 years ago. It wasn't surpassed until Babbage.
- pbhjpbhj 9y agoVikings supposedly used polarity of sunlight to determine the suns position through cloud cover. Eg https://www.newscientist.com/article/dn20052-vikings-crystal-clear-method-of-navigation/ https://www.newscientist.com/article/dn20052-vikings-crystal....
- jboggan 9y agoProbably Javascript.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- johansch 9y agoI'm just now holding a 1996 Intel Pentium 150 MHz CPU (A80502150) with a ceramic encasement and gold-plated pins. I think it will survive for a very long time. http://www.cpu-world.com/CPUs/Pentium/Intel-Pentium%20150%20-%20A80502150.html http://www.cpu-world.com/CPUs/Pentium/Intel-Pentium%20150%20...