4 ms·
Before I couldn't imagine how anyone could make this mistake, but now I see it. The pilots were familiar with SFO and knew that there were two runways, but didn
by modeless 9y ago
Before I couldn't imagine how anyone could make this mistake, but now I see it. The pilots were familiar with SFO and knew that there were two runways, but didn't realize the left hand runway lights were turned off, so they had an off-by-one error when choosing the runway.
- mirimir 9y agoThat is quite plausible. They somehow didn't register the "X" on 28R. Edit: Sorry, I meant 28L. Just dyslexic, I guess.
- inferiorhuman 9y agoThere wasn't any.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- CaliforniaKarl 9y ago> Runway 28L was closed to accommodate construction; its approach and runway lights were turned off, and a 20.5-ft-wide lighted flashing X (runway closure marker) was placed at the threshold.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- mosheroperandi 9y agoYou wouldn't be the first person to confuse R for L.
- newman8r 9y agorecently harrison ford screwed up and landed on the taxiway at KSNA in southern california. he didn't even do a go around, just landed on the taxiway - and he gets to keep his certificate apparently http://www.ocregister.com/2017/04/04/harrison-ford-will-keep-pilots-license-after-john-wayne-airport-taxiway-landing/ http://www.ocregister.com/2017/04/04/harrison-ford-will-keep...
- mirimir 9y agoWell, he didn't hit anything ;) But apparently he didn't file the requisite NASA report.[0] The last time this story was on HN, I vaguely recall links to several such landings. 0) https://generalaviationnews.com/2017/03/22/taxiway-landings/ https://generalaviationnews.com/2017/03/22/taxiway-landings/
- notatoad 9y agoi'm not a pilot and have no idea what it looks like when landing a plane at night, so i really shouldn't be commenting here, but: the report says the one operational runway had 2400 ft of approach lighting that was functional. The disabled runway had no approach lighting, and presumably the taxiway didn't have any approach lighting because nobody should be approaching a taxiway. So yes, they were just "off by one", but they were off by one on a dataset of one.
- mosheroperandi 9y agoYeah, but once you decide that the leftmost runway you see (with the dark void on its left) is the left runway, then obviously the parallel strip of lights to the right of it is the right runway. Sure, the lights look odd, and your gut's giving off this feeling, but you see, that's the left runway, and I don't see the right runway anywhere else, so this must be the... They probably got stuck in several cycles of that before the contrary evidence was overwhelming enough to break them out of their off-by-one mental model.
- tajen 9y agoCan you see the X at the beginning of the runway while sitting in the pilot seat? I was told the pilots' eyes are expected to be at mid-windshield height, but pilots prefer their seats in slightly reclined position and no position is compulsory.
- dmurray 9y agoIt's meant to be seen when approaching the disabled runway, not as a generic landmark to help the pilots orient themselves. So it's not prominently visible when approaching the taxiway.
- phkahler 9y ago>> Can you see the X at the beginning of the runway while sitting in the pilot seat? On approach you should be looking at the threshold and the numbers. That's right around where the X was, so it would be clearly visible to anyone trying to land on the closed runway. They were not trying to land on that one, and since they were over the taxiway the X was actually two "lanes" away from where they were. I don't think the X is terribly relevant to what happened here.
- akavel 9y agoYeah, that's the key new info for me too, something I missed during the previous discussion - I think it wasn't mentioned at all then. The key quotes from the OP article: "Runway 28L was closed to accommodate construction; its approach and runway lights were turned off, and a 20.5-ft-wide lighted flashing X (runway closure marker) was placed at the threshold. Runway and approach lighting for runway 28R were on and set to default settings, which included a 2,400-foot approach lighting system [...] Both pilots said, in post-incident interviews, they believed the lighted runway on their left was 28L and that they were lined up for 28R. They also stated that they did not recall seeing aircraft on taxiway C but that something did not look right to them."
- jve 9y agoUm, where were they supposed to land if 28L had lights off and an 'X' marker indicating runway closure? And where did they land afterwards?
- tvaughan 9y agoExcept this is something the pilots should have known about in advance. You always check the NOTAM's (Notice To Airmen) before plan your flight. This site doesn't let me link to the search results. But search for SFO and you'll see plenty of notices about the runway closure. https://notams.aim.faa.gov/notamSearch/nsapp.html#/ https://notams.aim.faa.gov/notamSearch/nsapp.html#/