4 ms·
> Years from now, we will be reading amazing business school research Serious question: Is there a decent future for business schools? Has anyone done a decen
by paganel 9y ago
> Years from now, we will be reading amazing business school research
Serious question: Is there a decent future for business schools? Has anyone done a decent ROI calculation on them based on the financial and business results of the past 15/20 years? Are they currently on an upward trend? Downward? Stagnant?
The reason I'm asking is that from half a globe away (Eastern Europe) the MBA and business school hype seems to have died a little compared to 10 years ago, as in I don't get to see "this guy/lady graduated from Wharton School" all that often when reading business/financial profiles.
- Overtonwindow 9y agoThat's a fair question and I don't know the answer to it. I study and work in public policy. Ergo I imagine that the study and analysis of business would come from b-schools. However, to try and answer your question, I've seen it mentioned here and in the news that the primary value of going to a business school is not the education, but the contacts you make.
- greenburger 9y agoThe Economist has done this a few times in recent years: https://www.economist.com/news/business/21601884-payback-time https://www.economist.com/news/business/21601884-payback-tim... http://www.economist.com/whichmba/think-twice http://www.economist.com/whichmba/think-twice
- sjg007 9y agoAn MBA from a top school is worth the money and what you make of it.
- markdavis33 9y agoThe Financial Times did an interesting story about this recently: https://www.ft.com/content/36942668-8ca0-11e6-8cb7-e7ada1d123b1 https://www.ft.com/content/36942668-8ca0-11e6-8cb7-e7ada1d12...
- chongli 9y agoIs there a decent future for business schools? Yes, as long as you understand their purpose. They exist as a form of class signalling. [0] Many of the older forms of nepotism/cronyism have been made illegal. Racial and IQ discrimination are also illegal. Therefore, business schools and law schools fill the gap. They exist to tell an employer that the applicant is either a member of their class or an ally. [0] http://lesswrong.com/lw/did/what_is_signaling_really/ http://lesswrong.com/lw/did/what_is_signaling_really/
- sliverstorm 9y agoI'm not a fan of floods of MBAs, but surely the degree serves some purpose other than class signalling. It seems like an exercise in typical engineer hubris to think <other field> is a trivial pursuit <engineer> could learn in a week. Suppose you take a veteran engineer heading into management, and send him/her to get an MBA. Will they come back no better for it?
- chongli 9y agoIt's not that these degrees are required, it's that candidates are expected to have degrees from specific schools such as Harvard. That's what makes it class signalling. You could be a business genius but if you went to a low-tier state school you're not getting hired at the big Manhattan bank.
- lordnacho 9y ago> I'm not a fan of floods of MBAs, but surely the degree serves some purpose other than class signalling. It seems like an exercise in typical engineer hubris to think <other field> is a trivial pursuit <engineer> could learn in a week. You won't find engineers saying that medical degrees are just BS. Fact is, business degrees are thin on content. I know this because I studied engineering and went to a business school. Now of course any degree has some kind of content, but business content just has very little that would pass for being academic content. The core stuff like Porter's Five Forces and Taylorism is no different than what you'd "know" if you read some of those airport magazines now and again. Imagine an engineering class where you just watched a Discovery show about how the Channel Tunnel was made. Yes, it's content, but nobody should be hired to build tunnels based on having seen that video of the French guy shaking hands with the British guy. But that is how we hire executives. A guy who knows some things about the history of some industry, and can talk about it confidently. > Suppose you take a veteran engineer heading into management, and send him/her to get an MBA. Will they come back no better for it? They'll know something about the culture of management, which will be useful for duping someone into promoting him. Well actually I rather like the idea of having technically trained managers, so I'd cheer that on. But not because you'll know how to manage from studying management.