5 ms·
Hiring engineers based on data structure trivia is like hiring a marketing department based on spelling bee scores.
by pavlov 9y ago
Hiring engineers based on data structure trivia is like hiring a marketing department based on spelling bee scores.
- savanaly 9y agoIn that one wouldn't want to hire someone as a marketer who couldn't spell "cat"? Not because it's necessary to be able to spell "cat", even, but because the inability to do so might indicate in a bayesian sense that the person is not likely equipped to do the job.
- thaumasiotes 9y agoNot really apt as to spelling bees. High-level spelling bees try to use words that are as obscure as possible, because people will happily go forever on words they know. SAT vocabulary questions are chosen to be informative about the test taker's IQ; spelling bee words are chosen to be unfamiliar to everyone. You get a list of words that you're supposed to memorize; they could just as easily be random strings.
- Terr_ 9y agoExactly, it's analogous to how companies seek obscure interview question variants, sometimes explicitly stating that their goal is to to see "how you think" rather than to get the right solution.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- drewrv 9y agoI think these types of questions are a good filter for the big tech companies, just in a different way than most suspect. What these types of interviews filter for is... - People fresh out of college and therefore relatively young. It would be illegal to make this an explicit policy. - People who really really really want the job. All employers want to filter by this criteria. - People who will accept the status quo and tolerate absurd bureaucracy.
- zerr 9y ago> - People who really really really want the job. All employers want to filter by this criteria. But then you miss out a lot of brilliant people who "just want" (instead of "really really...") the job, but think that it is not worth to allocate month(s) for preparation.
- seanwilson 9y agoYou'd really be fine hiring a senior developer that had no idea how a linked list, a hash table or a binary tree worked? Understanding which data structures are good for speed and memory usage is at a minimum required for memory constrained apps and dealing with large scale data.
- virtualized 9y agoMost "senior developers" I know don't know much about data structures. Standards are pretty low in the industry. One reason might be that optimizing for memory consumption or handling "large scale data" almost never happens in practice.
- baruch 9y agoI never had a software development job where optimizing memory consumption and handling large scale data (for whatever definition of large was for that particular system) wasn't a necessity. It was also useful to know when these measures were and weren't needed depending on the context in the system. I do mostly what's called "systems programming" and did embedded previously but also did some work on "normal" software but in all cases it was useful to care memory, data structures and performance at some levels of the system.
- ubernostrum 9y agoI do mostly what's called "systems programming" and did embedded Sure. And what's most crucial to do in those fields is not necessarily what's most crucial to do in other fields. 99% of interview horror stories are basically someone saying "I decided this is an important thing based on my narrow perspective, and anyone who doesn't know it as well as I do will be dismissed as completely incapable".
- seanwilson 9y agoIf you're already good at programming and didn't learn computer science foundations along the way it should literally take you a few hours to understand the majority of the core data structures. I don't understand why people complain about common interview questions when you can readily learn the answers in advance.