8 ms·
I can't think of a single popular site redesign that actually made the site better. They're almost inevitably worse, usually much worse. A common failing is t
by pmoriarty 9y ago
I can't think of a single popular site redesign that actually made the site better. They're almost inevitably worse, usually much worse.
A common failing is trying to make the design more shiny and pretty while decreasing functionality, dumbing the site down, adding bloat, and slowing the site down to a crawl.
I really hope Reddit does not go down this road, because they really have a good thing going now. It would be a real shame to ruin it.
- sirtastic 9y agoI can think of one. Google's material design. I love it and feel it tied their apps together while making them easier to use.
- iamatworknow 9y agoIt's all subjective, of course, but if a Material app starts getting more complex the bare bones nature of the UI actually starts making it more confusing to use in my opinion. Maybe I just haven't used it enough, but every time I look at a Google Cloud Platform console or something it takes me longer than I think it should to find what I'm looking for.
- wl 9y agoMaterial design ruined Google News on the desktop.
- shawnee_ 9y agoYes, a thousand times, yes. To me, this is the worst and most offensive redesign of something so pivotal to research, investigative reporting, everything beyond the surface. Being able to dig and dig and find out who is reporting what pieces of the story. I don't CARE if there are 12 articles about the same thing if there are truly 12 different legitimate reports about the event of interest. I want to see all 12 sources in their original place, date stamp, author, etc. The original links are where the real stories hide... not in this curated crap. Thomas Jefferson said: "Advertisements contain the only truths to be relied on in a newspaper." Google already has all the news indexed; why it is choosing to provide less surface area over which to sell its ads is something that makes absolutely no sense. Company press releases are a gold mine of information. These used to be so prominent in news.google.com; they are completely gone. Multiple pages of results. Gone. All so the already-digested news can belch all over cell phones. I see it as an attack on our democracy. Basically, censorship. But apparently they don't care.
- jacquesm 9y agoI stopped using it for what I used it before. But I haven't found a replacement yet.
- shawnee_ 9y agoI found myself laughing the other day when I went to Bing for what I used to use Google news for... because of all the alternatives tested, it seemed to provide the best breadth of what I was looking for. Redesigns like this make me wish more designers thought in terms of a toggle option for users who don't want the slick and shiny. Seems like such an obvious, idiot-proof solution to pissing off your users en masse.
- glenstein 9y agoMaterial design just doesn't work on desktops. Speed and information density are the way to go, and I'd argue they played no small role in reddit's ascendance.
- khedoros1 9y agoIt tied their apps together, but I don't think it made them easier to use. I feel like I get around in the apps that I use most frequently just by rote. In an unfamiliar app, it's often unclear if something's a touchable option or just a text label. In previous versions, buttons stood out more from the background. I liked that, and I think it was clearer and easier to use.
- pluma 9y agoI'd disagree. I like some of the Material related changes to Google Maps, for example, others seem like they were only done for consistency's sake with no benefit to Google Maps UX. Also IMO they managed to make YouTube even worse with the recent attempts to shoehorn it into their Material design. The problem with a unified design language is you end up with the lowest common denominator for vastly different products. Material works great for Google Now, somewhat okay for Google Maps, pretty meh for GMail and terribly for YouTube. But that's just, like, my opinion, man.
- astrodust 9y agoThere's few things in the world I hate more than Google's design. Maybe GoDaddy's control panels. Possibly Ubuntu's installer. It's absurdly wasteful in terms of space on desktop applications. So many uselessly gigantic buttons with no effort to describe what they do other than an icon.
- mobilethrow 9y agoSo many comments here and not a single mention of "Slashdot Beta". It was a huge disaster, every single article had complaints about it while it was in effect. They changed owners shortly after and it's still a running joke years later.
- SomeStupidPoint 9y agoI was going to quip that reddit has gone full-Digg.
- endymi0n 9y agohttps://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_Coke https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_Coke 'nuff said. Every brand that has a large enough following will run into pitchforks for large redesigns - a lot of people are fans for something. If you want to do this successfully, take a slice from Facebooks playbook. Their site looks nothing like 10 years ago, yet they somehow did all those radical UI changes gradually over years, always one step at a time, (mostly) listening to their user base inbetween.
- khedoros1 9y ago> Their site looks nothing like 10 years ago, yet they somehow did all those radical UI changes gradually over years, always one step at a time, (mostly) listening to their user base in between. I remember being really annoyed at one of the changes in about 2008. Looking at the timeline of Facebook[0], it was probably the rearrangement of the site into tabs (and then into something like the current layout 2 years later). I think that it's telling that I remember being annoyed at the time (and a bunch of other times, after other changes) than I remember what those changes were. Sometimes it's hard to remember exactly what it was like in the early days. So, I went looking and also found a Cnet slideshow illustrating the different looks of the site over the years [1] [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Timeline_of_Facebook https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Timeline_of_Facebook [1] https://www.cnet.com/pictures/facebook-then-and-now-pictures/ https://www.cnet.com/pictures/facebook-then-and-now-pictures...
- 9y ago
- shawnz 9y ago> A common failing is trying to make the design more shiny and pretty while decreasing functionality, dumbing the site down, adding bloat, and slowing the site down to a crawl. If you look at the new reddit profiles beta, you will see that it checks all these boxes.
- ShinTakuya 9y agoYeah I regret agreeing to the irreversible change on my main account. So much harder to get to the information I care about.
- apercu 9y agoI have no idea why I care about the NFL, but I have been going to profootballtalk.com daily for years. NBC partnered with a bunch of independent sports blogs like PFT a few years ago. They then rolled 'em all out on a new redesign. I stopped visiting after the first couple tries, then PFT backed out of the redesign and went back to their previous (crappy, old) layout. The other blogs I used to go to (pro hockeytalk and pro basketball talk) didn't and I've never returned. What I like about reddit and HN (more so) is the minimal, fast, low overhead experience. It's like the original slashdot. I hate the new animated, ad heavy slow web.
- ryanmerket 9y agoWhy not have both?
- crazypyro 9y agoPFT looks like one of those blogs that is just made up stuff, but it is a pretty good source. I feel like their layout actually harms their credibility though.
- heartbreak 9y agoTheir reputation among hardcore NFL fans is strong enough that they don't need a slick layout.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- hyperpallium 9y ago"The slow web" is a much better buzzword than web 2.0.
- cyxxon 9y agoI also never get why these sites don't change gradually. I mean, Slashdot tried - their code was a mess, and it looked really old. But it took them ages to rewrite this, and they did it all in one go. Bam! Community was pissed. Why not move the broken old HTML to standard compliant one section at a time, and clean up things here and there, and maybe introduce a new font, or section images, ... instead of this huge explosion_ Sure it might be more work and might also not be completely doable, but if you do it all at once, you are almost guaranteed to alienate your users. And if you are Reddit or Slashdot, that's what makes you. (I somehow triggered a wrong keyboard layout while typing. I tried to find all typos, but probably didn't get them all)
- danso 9y agoI'd say Facebook has done a decent job with redesigns, given the new features they roll out to such a huge user base. The advent of the timeline in 2011, and then the single-column simplification a couple years later, seemed to me to be pretty successful https://www.dailydot.com/debug/old-facebook-profiles-news-feeds/ https://www.dailydot.com/debug/old-facebook-profiles-news-fe...
- narrator 9y agoWell's there's always the smoking hole in the ground known as Digg. They royally screwed that site up and crashed and burned hard with their redesign. That's how Reddit rose to prominence in the first place.
- dageshi 9y agoNah it was growing pretty hard even before Digg fucked up, that sure helped but Reddit was going places whether Digg screwed up or not.
- mbesto 9y ago> I can't think of a single popular site redesign that actually made the site better. Depends on your definition of "better". Facebook has done several redesigns that the audience has groaned about and here we are 1 billion users later. TechCrunch did a large redesign several years, and here we are, still reading TC articles. The list goes on and on...
- Mahn 9y ago> still reading TC articles That's debatable (albeit for reasons other than design)
- mbesto 9y agoHeh, I knew I'd get dinged for that. As much as I loathe TC myself, it does still get linked here often and the design, while funky at first, hasn't appeared to have had a significant negative impact on them.
- provost 9y agoI recall Digg did a complete redesign for version 4, even the backend systems and database. And the users abandoned it shortly after launch.
- eridius 9y agoAnd that fueled Reddit's rise, because the Digg users flocked there.
- HelloMcFly 9y agoI believe Reddit had already surpassed Digg by then. Digg's redesign may have been in part an attempt to respond to reddit's rise, rather than creating it.
- eridius 9y agoReddit was growing, but the Digg exodus gave it a significant boost. I don't know if Reddit was larger than Digg at that time, but even if it was, a near-doubling in users is a pretty big jump.
- Angostura 9y agoWhat killed Digg though, wasn't any change in look at feel, as much as a fundamental change in content policy. It went from 'users submit stuff and upvote it' to 'content publishers can automate a firehose of their stories into the system for a price' people didn't like that.
- wldcordeiro 9y agoI'm seeing a similar parallel to Reddit's new profiles though. Not exactly the same but it's a move to appease the content publishers that has been angering their core userbase.
- Angostura 9y agoAgreed. I think the profile initiative does feel quite Digg v4
- CM30 9y ago> trying to make the design more shiny and pretty while decreasing functionality, dumbing the site down, adding bloat, and slowing the site down to a crawl. Another good example of this is a car forum called AudiWorld after Internet Brands took it over. Initially, it ran on a super minimalistic forum script that loaded incredibly quickly and worked well for the community. It was certainly ugly yes, but it's what the members liked and had gotten used to. Then IB came in, converted the whole site to vBulletin on a whim and pretty much killed the community there and then. The members revolted, people left the community in droves and a successor with the old software sprung up immediately to get the refugees from the site. [1] One poorly thought out move to 'redesign' the site nearly killed a large forum and ended up creating one of its more popular competitors in the process. It's like a mini version of what happened with Digg, except possibly even worse. [1] http://8bit.minimal.net/post/87727243/how-to-destroy-a-community-with-software http://8bit.minimal.net/post/87727243/how-to-destroy-a-commu...
- skinnymuch 9y agoIt can't be worse than Digg, can it? Just as bad seems like the worst you can realistically get. Digg lost what, 95% or more of its users within months?
- ipsum2 9y agoYoutube has undergone multiple redesigns, each better than the last, in my opinion.
- CamperBob2 9y agoYouTube is a pretty trivial piece of work compared to Reddit. Nobody would lose a moment's sleep if YouTube's comment system were radically revised, and few would complain if it went away entirely. On Reddit, the comment system is everything.
- heartbreak 9y agoYouTube's comment system was revised a few years ago when Google+ launched, and people definitely "lost sleep" over it.
- CamperBob2 9y agoNot because of the design, though. The way they introduced unified IDs was viewed as problematic (to put it mildly).
- rrdharan 9y agoCan't tell if you are joking, but just in case you aren't: http://www.forbes.com/sites/insertcoin/2013/11/09/google-plus-creates-uproar-over-forced-youtube-integration/ http://www.forbes.com/sites/insertcoin/2013/11/09/google-plu... https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/the-switch/wp/2013/11/14/youtube-commenters-bring-in-text-art-tanks-to-fight-google-integration/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/the-switch/wp/2013/11/14...
- CamperBob2 9y agoThe integration complaints had absolutely nothing to do with design aesthetics. There were some serious privacy concerns that arose when Google unified YouTube accounts with accounts used for other Google services.
- 9y ago
- hyperpallium 9y agoFrom a market, not engineering pov: It's easy and effective to iteratively improve a website, to suit its present users. But once you've got most of that type of user, you're approaching a local maxima, and your growth slows. When you want to grow beyond that, you have to appeal to a larger, broader, different segment - though hopefully a superset, not (too) disjoint. For me, reddit is much less interesting than it used to be (HN also). Perhaps, if they alter it to become more like it was? e.g. subreddits partially achieved this.
- unclebucknasty 9y ago>A common failing is trying to make the design more shiny and pretty... That, and trying to make it behave like more successful (read, profitable) sites, even if the purpose/audience is totally different. That is, "well if it works for FB it should work for us".
- virgilp 9y ago> I can't think of a single popular site redesign that actually made the site better. Seriously? How about Google.com? Google Maps? Gmail? Apple.com? CNN? Uber? Surely you must believe at least some of those made the site better...
- vasili111 9y agoIt is controversial. For example, Gmail old design was much better for me than current white design which makes much harder to read for me.
- pluma 9y agoApple.com is a marketing site. It's essentially a brochure that is expected to change completely for every new release of the product. The only major Google Maps redesign was from the original boxy low-fi design to the modern pan & zoom gestural design with overlays. The redesigns after that were mostly incremental and rarely affected the general look and feel of the site. There have been a number of design changes recently to unify it with the mobile app and some would argue those weren't always for the better (much like YouTube where it sometimes feels like the UX is getting worse every time). Google.com always was fairly minimalist to begin with and that never changed much except for additions like the cards added to the mobile site to bring it in line with Chrome for Android. Again, whether these additions are good or not is heavily disputed. GMail is yet another case of a site that never underwent a significant redesign but merely iterations on the same look and feel. I can't say anything on CNN or Uber because I don't frequent them sufficiently to have observed any redesign other than Uber's confused rebranding earlier last year. The way the new design for Reddit is being described reminds me of the Digg redesign. If you don't remember Digg: Digg was essentially pretty much like Reddit, the biggest differentiator was the community. Digg completely redesigned the site because it was failing hard. Digg today is irrelevant and what little community there was has left before the redesign largely been displaced by the redesign (and refocussing). Changing aspects of a design that are so strongly part of its look and feel (or it's "DNA" if you insist on being poetical) is extremely risky and extremely easy to do badly. It's especially dangerous if you apparently only do it because you want something new/prettier. HN and Craigslist don't look ancient because of a lack of effort, they look that way because the designs work and there's not much to be gained from changing it.
- i_cant_speel 9y agoIMO, the problem is that the kind of people that generally browse this site generally value functionality over looks. Unfortunately, we are a relatively small subset of the population and Reddit is looking to broaden their reach as far as possible. So they are going to make their site more like other social media sites where a big portion of the user base will like it, another portion won't care one way or the other, and a small portion will hate it. I think they know some people will hate the redesign and potentially stop using the site, it's just a small enough portion of the user base that they don't really care. Luckily for me, I spend > 75% of my time on Reddit on my phone, so it won't really affect me for the most part.
- JakeTheAndroid 9y agoGo ask the SoylentNews people how the Slashdot redesign worked out for them. Disclaimer, I have the UID 10 on SoylentNews.
- magic_beans 9y agoThe New York Times had a major redesign earlier this year or last year, and it's as incredible. MUCH improved, way better comments, lovely UI, and loads quickly on many devices.