18 ms·
Hacking Voting Machines at Defcon
- Canada 9y agoAfter more than a decade of security researchers raising the alarm over critical electronic voting machine vulnerability, I hope this finally causes some real demand for verifiable ballots.
- ThomPete 9y agoNo one really claims that the voting machines were secure because it was technically advanced. The voting system is secure because it is irregular and physically distributed and not connected. In other words. Hacking the election is up there with the us planned 9/11 it would require social engineering of unheard proportions.
- yflu 9y agoThere are far far too many links in that massive chain to trust on obscurity as security.
- ThomPete 9y agoUnless you can point to how someone get access to a lot of machines at one time then yes obscurity is actually a really strong method. Furthermore it's not just obscurity it's also the other things I mentioned non-connectedness being one of the biggest.
- deif 9y agoYou don't need to get access to a lot of machines. Because the chain is long and obscure, there's no way to be verifiable, and even if there was that chain would require specialist infallible programmers to ensure nothing has been tampered with. I'm not sure how you can argue that obscurity is a strong method of security when one machine in the country could be compromised, or the counting method code could be compromised, or the programmer verifying the code could be compromised, or the distribution system of voting machines could be compromised, or any part inside the voting machines could be compromised (e.g. the touch interface), or the voting machine remains secure during the voting period (i.e. voters are tampering with it on poll day).
- ThomPete 9y agoIf the machines aren't connected of course you need access to a lot of machines to have any effect on an election. All machines are hackable all systems are hackable. But focusing on the box showing you can hack that changes absolutely nothing about the overall threat of the US election being hacked. No one with serious technical understanding would claim that it was impossible to hack the boxes. And so you are back to a much harder task which is the social engineering part of convincing thousands of people to betray their country and no one finding out.
- foepys 9y ago> All machines are hackable all systems are hackable. Then why use machines at all? As mentioned in this thread multiple times, Germany can count all votes within a few hours without any voting machines.
- rurban 9y agoTo alter the results in a cheaper way than with traditional vote stuffing methods, as recently observed in the Turkish national referendum. https://arxiv.org/abs/1706.09839 https://arxiv.org/abs/1706.09839
- ThomPete 9y agoSince when has any of this been rational? People want digital because they think it's better or more accurate.
- learc83 9y agoIn a close election it's potentially feasible to flip an election by hacking the machines in a few hundred precincts across 2 or 3 states. Still unlikey but potentially feasible given a determined, well funded adversary. And you wouldn't have to actually flip the election to undermine it's legitimacy. >In other words. Hacking the election is up there with the us planned 9/11 9/11 happened, so someone planned it. Very few people are worried about the US government hacking voting precincts. They're worried about a foreign government doing it.
- ThomPete 9y agoHacking the machines in a few hundred precincts is impossible and not more possible today than it was 10 or 20 years ago. 9/11 happened because someone outside the government planned it and it didn't need that many to work. If the US government was behind it the way the conspiracy theories are told, it would have had to involve tens of thousands of people. Hacking the election to be anything meaningful would require exactly the same thing.
- CydeWeys 9y agoI don't understand what makes you think some massive conspiracy would be required. With a remote exploit you wouldn't need many conspirators at all. And plenty of elections are stolen each year the old-fashioned way with a massive number of conspirators, and ... it works.
- ThomPete 9y agoRemote how? They aren't connected to the net.
- CydeWeys 9y agoYou sure about that? Most of them have WiFi cards in them; they're connected to something, that is likely reachable from the net. You can also imagine a single person compromising the firmware to be used in the next election to randomly flip enough votes over to a specific side to cause a win. This could be done by either an insider, or an outsider that has managed to hack the voting machine company's network.
- 5trokerac3 9y agoDepending on how conspiratorially minded you are, being able to exfiltrate/alter voter rolls could be seen as more of a feature than a bug.
- cyborgx7 9y agoThe Chaos Computer Club did some extensive educational work a couple years back to make sure we keep our paper ballots here in Germany. And this work keeps going to this day. I'm very greateful, seeing all the issues we are avoiding because of this, but the fight against misinformed or malicious politicians is still going on. A very important factor in their work was making sure people called them "voting computers" instead of "voting machines". Most people have a sense by now that computers are hackable and insecure, if only through movies where hackers can hack every system. Calling them machines gives people the sense they are a unhackable mechanical appliances.
- dx034 9y agoVoting in Germany is very efficient anyway as votes are usually counted within 1-3 hours and a final result overnight. It's hard to see the advantage of computers, buying the machines will likely outweigh paper costs. That's a bit different in other countries where counting paper ballots can take days. Doesn't make voting machines safer, though.
- cyborgx7 9y ago>That's a bit different in other countries where counting paper ballots can take days. Seems to me the solution is to figure out what makes german voting and vote counting so efficient and replicate that, rather than switching to voting computers.
- greenshackle2 9y agoIt's that ineffable German efficiency.
- jvandonsel 9y agoA voting machine with frickin' open USB and Ethernet ports?
- kuschku 9y agoAlmost all of them have open USB and Ethernet ports, or just connect to the alphabetically first WiFi they can find.
- lngnmn 9y agoOne word: Microsoft.
- thrillgore 9y agoPut us back on paper ballots. Christ, some systems should be as simple as possible.
- maxerickson 9y agoMuch of the US does use optical scan paper ballots: https://ballotpedia.org/Voting_methods_and_equipment_by_state https://ballotpedia.org/Voting_methods_and_equipment_by_stat... Hopefully the message that paper ballots are simpler and provide a strong audit trail will continue to beat back the new and shiny.
- CWuestefeld 9y agoAre optical scan ballots really "paper ballots"? It seems to me that in all the relevant criteria, this is just electronic voting with a different input method.
- maxerickson 9y agoYes, they are paper ballots. The "machine" is a pen and the ballot and the official record of the vote is the paper ballots, the electronic tally is just for convenience. So for example, if the machine in a precinct catches fire and explodes, the vote proceeds, except the ballots are placed in a box. If the numbers reported by the machine are nonsensical, the machine is set aside and the ballots are counted manually. If there is a recount, the ballots are counted manually.
- kennydude 9y agoSo, just make the machines nationwide present "sensible" but false results?
- maxerickson 9y agoWell, in addition to (just) hacking all the machines, you'd have to tamper with a sufficient number of exit polls to limit recounts (and the waves of subsequent recounts that would follow widespread evidence of tampering).
- dec0dedab0de 9y agoEvery time this comes up, it seems to me that the obvious answer is that we should get rid of the secret ballot. If everyone's vote is public then everyone can check that their own vote was counted correctly. I know the argument is that people may face pressure at home and be afraid to vote, but is there anyone left who doesn't tell everyone how they voted? Maybe I'm living in a bubble, but I know exactly who all of my friends, and family voted for, none of them ever tried to keep it a secret.
- netcraft 9y agoI think the argument is more that someone can then sell their vote, because they can prove how they voted.
- vowelless 9y ago> but is there anyone left who doesn't tell everyone how they voted? 2016 was full of such examples in at least 2 countries ...
- herrkanin 9y agoNot only is secret voting an integral part of a democratic voting system, it is also entirely possible to implement a system where everyone can check their own vote while keeping their vote secret. Each registrant can simply be given a unique string that is connected with their vote.
- bluejekyll 9y agoWe have these "receipts" with a code that matches the one on the ballot on the paper ballots in SF, though I've never actually tried to check it anywhere. Has anyone else tried this?
- medmunds 9y agoThe SF elections website allows you to confirm that your ballot was counted. But not how you voted.
- Klathmon 9y agoElectronic voting is dangerous and is a very bad idea. Voting should be done on paper, using pencils, put into ballot boxes, and counted by people. Paper works, and it works well. It's a system that has worked well enough for thousands of years, and we have figured out most of the issues with it during that time. Anyone that can count can validate a single precinct. You can have one person, or 100 people all standing there watching a ballot box all day for tampering. You can have a whole group of people count the results, or just a few. In a traditional paper system, swaying a single precinct with "blackhat" methods takes a lot of physical resources, a lot of time, and in most cases a lot of people. Then multiply that by every precinct in the country, and it quickly becomes pretty much impossible to do and get away with. Plus it leaves a physical "paper trail" (in the form of payment for people, communications, and physical materials or the receipts for those materials). Electronic voting gives us very few benefits, and a significant amount of downsides. And it doesn't matter if it's FOSS, it doesn't matter if it's vetted, it doesn't matter what safeguards are put in place, all it takes is one mistake. One fuckup, and someone can now choose the leader of a nation, and in some cases that leader can change the rules of the next election, meaning it only takes one single mistake to ruin it for many many generations in the future. And replacing a system where literally everyone can validate a system on voting day if they want to with a system where only a fraction of a fraction of people can even read and understand the code, let alone validate the code (and can't actually validate the hardware, or make sure what is running on the hardware is actually that code, or make sure that the hardware is even what it says it is), and it takes a magnitude more time to do so, just isn't a good idea.
- TeMPOraL 9y agoI know it's tangential to the point you're making, but I have to ask: > using pencils Why pencils? Aren't pens more secure (more difficult to erase / alter without leaving a visible mark on paper)?
- Klathmon 9y agoNo reason why it needs to be pencils specifically, just that they are the simplest, and simple is better. I was more trying to speak to the idea that a person is making the mark themselves without any other "machinery" or anything. I've seen complicated mechanical hole punching machines that can break down, or machines that generate a cast ballot that is placed in a box that you can't be sure cast the vote correctly. That's the kind of stuff I'm talking about avoiding when I say "using pencils". Plus once your vote is put in the box, it doesn't matter if the ballot itself can be tampered with, as there should be multiple people watching that box until counted. So pen or pencil makes no difference. Erasable or otherwise doesn't matter. It can even just be a hole you poke in a box using the pencil. The important part is that nobody can touch it till it's counted in front of a bunch of people who all don't trust one another.
- vowelless 9y agoI used to think electronic voting was the logical next step. But now, I think voting is too important to be left to electronics. It should be done on paper. We trust billions of dollars every day to electronic banking, so why not a vote? Electronic banking comes with many types of federal guarantees to protect against fraud. The government can step in to investigate and prosecute the fraud as well. But there is no such guarantee for the voting to select the government itself! But it takes so long to aggregate the votes if done with paper ballots. Precisely the point. Electronic voting allows scalable attacks where the number of weak points is dramatically reduced. It is very hard to scale attacks on paper ballots. You would need a coordinated effort in many voting stations to make it work as opposed to hacking a more central electronic system. That is why I moved from thinking that electronic voting is the logical next step to thinking that we probably need to revert back to paper ballots.
- baby 9y agoTotally agree with you, I do not understand this need to go digital. Voting has worked and works really well with paper, it's a process anyone can audit, even non-technical people. Sure it might take a day, and a bunch of money, but so what? Our democracy heavily relies on this process.
- KGIII 9y agoIn theory, I don't mind digital voting. I do mind network connectivity and closed source machines.
- simias 9y agoEven if the machines were open source you'd have to personally inspect it to make sure it's actually running what it's supposed to be running. Unless you're reading to bring an electron microscope to the polling booth it doesn't seem particularly practical. It would make more sense to check whether your vote was counted post-facto but it's hard to especially if you still want to make it difficult to figure out who voted for whom. There are a few mathematical possibilities but they don't seem particularly practical to me: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BYRTvoZ3Rho https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BYRTvoZ3Rho So for the time being paper ballots are probably the way to go.
- miheermunjal 9y agothis just re-stresses the point to COMPETITION in the electronic voting space. If you had a monopoly over the systems, what encouragement would you have to upgrade them? There are all sorts of ways to innovate "e-voting", and all of them are objectively improved over the current US methods
- cr1895 9y ago>There are all sorts of ways to innovate "e-voting", and all of them are objectively improved over the current US methods Can you expand on the objective improvements?
- Klathmon 9y agoWhat are some of the benefits of e-voting that make up for the possible shortcomings? From my perspective, e-voting is more difficult for the blind/disabled, more difficult to audit and check (you'd need to be a programmer that is well versed in cryptography to even begin to audit a codebase), much harder to verify/validate your own vote was even cast, much less reliable, and overall is confusing and harder to use. The only benefit I can see is making it easier to vote for those working or who aren't able to get to a precinct. But that's a problem I'd much rather have solved by making it a mandatory holiday and providing state-paid-for transportation on election days.
- cyborgx7 9y agoYap, let's introduce the "invisible hand of the free market" into the voting system. As we have all experienced, that always leads to the safest and most ethical outcome.
- lurker456 9y agoespecially when the customer differs from the users
- elbac 9y agoThere is an excellent podcast series on the subject of electronic voting, where several experts give their opinions. https://www.predictingourfuture.com/online-voting/ https://www.predictingourfuture.com/online-voting/ After listening, I became convinced that electronic/internet voting is a terrible idea.
- cobookman 9y agoI'm for both. Aka you submit your ballot on paper. Have a machine and people both count the vote. If the machine count has a different outcome vs people then you know you've got an issue. By outcome I mean something like machine had person A winning, people count has person B.
- JorgeGT 9y agoWe do something similar in Spain. We vote with paper ballots. Then, when polls close, the volunteers at each table count the ballots and input the data into an electronic system, which makes the aggregates. In a few hours (4-5) we have the results of the election. However, paper ballots are returned to the voting urns and sealed. The sealed urns are then sent to a few centralized counting locations where they are manually counted again by civil servants during the corse of a few weeks. (Party representatives can witness both countings). Usually there are some very very small differences between the first and the second counting, but I don't recall even a seat changing because of them. This has the advantage of being both fast and safe.
- corpMaverick 9y agoIn my country a losing presidential candidate has been able to convince part of his base that there was electronic fraud using an 'algorithm' even though the whole process was done manually. Imagine if it was really done electronically. That is why I am convinced voting should be done with paper and pencils.
- itodd 9y agoIn my country, it was the winning presidential candidate complaining about fraud.
- bdz 9y agoI'm more surprised that you can buy voting machines from eBay
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- tcbawo 9y agoI am not a fan of electronic voting as it exists today. But, I expected to see someone advocate a blockchain-like trail to ensure election integrity. Also, why don't we have automatic voter registration? Let's pay this cost once and move on.
- Larrikin 9y agoIt's not to the advantage of all parties to ensure everyone can vote
- alistproducer2 9y agoI'm old enough to remember the when e-voting was brought about by the Bush administration. At the time those of us on the far left were convinced that Bush was the American incarnation of Hitler (seems quaint now, doesn't it) and Diebold e-voting machines were going to precipitate the end of democracy.
- vuln 9y agoThat seems like the typically attitude of the left. "If you're not with the left, you're hitler."
- cr0sh 9y agoWhat if we've gotten into some kind of weird feedback loop where every swing of the pendulum between the two parties has been leading to more and more "extreme" candidates on each side? Or what if the extremism is only on one side, because they perceive the other side as being too extreme, when that side is just trying to be for the people? I'll leave you to decided which side is which, of course...and where all this might lead (it ain't pretty, should this actually be what is playing out).
- UltimateFloofy 9y agoVery nice. Voter McVoteyFace deserves an upvote.
- iainmerrick 9y agoI think the key problem with electronic voting is the possibility of a "class break", as explained here by Bruce Schneier: https://www.schneier.com/blog/archives/2017/01/class_breaks.html https://www.schneier.com/blog/archives/2017/01/class_breaks.... If there's a flaw in the system -- and there will be flaws, the only question is how soon they're found -- there's a risk that the whole thing can be compromised in one fell swoop. Whereas pen and paper voting, counted by hand, is slower and less accurate and has plenty of its own flaws, but there's no simple way to compromise the entire vote at once. You'd have to fool a whole bunch of different people in different ways, and/or recruit them into a huge conspiracy. Other countries use pen and paper and it works fine. Electronic voting machines should be banned.
- tribby 9y agoI like paper voting but there should be a holiday and the vote should be mandatory even if only to check off "none of the above." The reason I like electronic despite its flaws is someone can do it while on the toilet, and here in the US where there is low turnout and voter suppression, that's about where I want the bar to be.
- em3rgent0rdr 9y agoWhere is the memory card physically stored? Is that something that a hacker could easily gain access to without being noticed?
- tjhorner 9y agoTop of the device, secured with a simple philips head screw during use, easily accessible.
- em3rgent0rdr 9y agoVoting needs something called "homomorphic encryption", which allows simple arithmetic to be performed on encrypted data without decrypting it.