7 ms·
The Kafkaesque Process of Cancer Diagnosis
- maxxxxx 9y agoThis is a real problem with any kind of serious disease. I am watching this with my girlfriend now. The patient is thrown into this inscrutable, faceless and expensive machine without knowing what's going on. I wonder how much the health outcome could be improved by treating patients more humanely.
- kartan 9y ago> I wonder how much the health outcome could be improved by treating patients more humanely. Treating patients more humanely costs money, while health care is just another business, human care is just for the people that can afford it. She is lucky to have you by her side. For you, she is not just a business, she is a beloved human being.
- grok2 9y agoWhat exactly would you consider as a "humane" approach -- it is possible that the doctor and her/his team don't really want to be the bearer of bad news and take refuge in the system to allow you to come to the conclusion yourself?
- maxxxxx 9y agoJust act like real people. Admit that you are not sure about something, have doctors talk to each other and not make the patient run back and forth, don't "protect" the patient from bad news (they have no problems giving the news that you owe 10000 dollars). For example, if one doctor is not sure about something another doctor said, they don't seem to be able to pick up the phone and ask the other doctor to clarify. Instead they often assume something and work with that assumption or they make the patient go back to the other doctor which costs days or weeks to set up and hours of appointments.
- icantdrive55 9y agoIf you're lucky you have someone to drive you to one specialist after another, and all they seem to care about is their fee. People don't need hand holding, but they don't need to put up with doctors who are deep in professional deniability. I don't have a solution. I watched my father go through hell with his cancer diagnosis. They had residents comming into his hospital room Palpating his liver tumor. The last straw was when this very young person came in, and started to lift his gown. I had a feeling what was going on, but asked anyways, "What are you doing?" White smock, "Oh, I need to palpate the patient!" Me, "You are the third person pushing into his right upper quadrant, for no apparant reason? Are you a resident, and just learning on my father?" The person abruptly left the room. All the doctors said we can't help you father, but we had to drag him into their fancy offices. And they loved his insurance plan. It was a good one. Paid 90% of whatever they charged, and they charged. Specialist, "Well after reviewing your chart, I can't help." Rinse repeat, after another doctor's office call. "I would like to see you!" Done. I thought Pallitive Care would be efficient. Then a call from a Doctor. "I can help you." He also gave a speech on drinking. I knew at the time, this little stocky dude was enticed by the good insurance, but what do I know? Well, after a week, my dad gets the call. "I'm sorry. I can't help you." He did seem sincerely dissapointed. Weeks later my father slowly wither away in pain. The hospice doctors never quite gave enough medication. (It got to the point, if I knew a drug dealer, I would have gone out to buy heroin for my father. Great system?")
- hycaria 9y agoSo you're able to jerkily refuse students to come and learn on patients, but you can't refuse specialists appointments (and these unbearable doctors keep doing their job, trying to do prevention by discouraging people from drinking and smoking !), even when you knew that this case was helpless ? I understand it is painful to lose a parent and see them in such distress, but I really don't get patients/families who turn into salt mines when the unevitable happens. Some patients are very willing to sollicitate many specialists in hope for good news, no matter how unlikely they are, and hold praticians responsible for what is often more of a patient/family's own unability to deal with [diagnosis]. Good luck with your grief.
- bastijn 9y agoIn my line of work we say: "It ain't cancer until the pathologist says so." Basically it is a joke amongst the pathologists that no matter what MD does the diagnosis, s/he will always send a biopt to the pathologist and ask if it is cancer. Well, in simple terms of course. I guess the correct moment to say you have been diagnosed with cancer is when the pathologist tells the physician it's cancer. Beautiful thing is neural networks / deep learning can really outperform the pathologist now that we have introduced digital pathology. Sure they will for some time give the final verdict but before too long AI will do the actual diagnose with better accuracy than a human possibly could in a fraction of the time. Reports started coming in the last year. E.g. [0][1][2]. Last one is directly mentioning years. 0) https://www.extremetech.com/extreme/233746-ai-beats-doctors-at-visual-diagnosis-observes-many-times-more-lung-cancer-signals https://www.extremetech.com/extreme/233746-ai-beats-doctors-... 1) https://news.developer.nvidia.com/diagnose-heart-disease-with-ai/ https://news.developer.nvidia.com/diagnose-heart-disease-wit... 2) http://bigthink.com/paul-ratner/heres-when-machines-will-take-your-job-predict-ai-gurus http://bigthink.com/paul-ratner/heres-when-machines-will-tak...
- opportune 9y agoGood luck ever convincing doctors (or the general public, legislators, etc.) to let themselves be replaced by machines. Working in healthcare, everything ML/AI related has to be worded very carefully as something that helps doctors spend time doing other things, rather than replacing what they do. People aren't super comfortable with the idea of AI in medicine yet, and physicians have a history of being extremely protectionist when it comes to their jobs. What's going to happen when this starts becoming a reality is that doctors will start bringing up Dr. House level medical sleuthing tales as proof that machines can never replace physicians in medicine. Obviously this will just be confirmation/survivorship bias, but few people even know what those terms mean. I bet it will take decades for AI to be integrated with medicine after it's ready to do so.
- bastijn 9y agoWe are doing it today. We of course sell it as assisting the doctor. Partly because of things like FDA and legislation, partly because doctors and reluctant to change. In due time they will value the algorithms decision over their own and the balance will shift. It is like the chess computer. They claimed it could never beat them, they tried, and they lost. Our algorithms run against millions of other cases in milliseconds. A number a human brain cannot possibly contain no matter how experienced. And each new case adds to its power. Not only the cases one doctor sees, but that every doctor in the world sees. It's numbers really. Healthcare becomes the next industrial revolution. Of course nothing is ready yet. Not only doctors but also law needs to change. When an algorithm makes a false negative, who will we sue? Note I do not say doctors will no longer be needed. They very much will be. But their work shifts towards the social part of the job. Guide the patient, help him/her understand. Assure. Etc.
- mevile 9y agoHeh, I started a bad cough last week and an xray found pulmonary nodules and my doctor ordered ct scans on Friday. Waiting on the results now. My cough seems to be getting better, but not a fun process. I don't know how it could be made better, they're getting data, what are doctors supposed to do while they're getting data? Lie to you? Hold your hand?
- bastijn 9y agoNot something a doctor can do, but Healthcare can. By making the process faster shorten the period of uncertainty. Partly by optimizing the way data is and can be shared, you would be surprised how hard that is even within a single hospital, much worse with multiple or country/state boundaries. Next, digitize and automate using NN and deep learning reducing the burden on doctors allowing them to run more cases a day. We can further reduce the time period case by optimizing reporting, especially for a regular 2 minute case they spend most time on filling the report. Much of which can be automatically filled. If we cut all these times you could get a diagnose much faster than 2 weeks. Of course next step is to monitor every day so we detect before cancer actually manifests. Start treatment so early it never gets a chance. Using all sorts of monitoring. Wristbands are the proof of concept, but in say 10 years that will mature and maybe we get a constant monitoring realtime watched by a digital MD watchdog. Who knows.
- nradov 9y agoBe careful what you ask for. More monitoring and testing leads to more false positives, more expenses, and more invasive treatments for conditions that might never have caused any serious symptoms if just left alone.
- bastijn 9y agoI agree with the first sentence but not with the latter. Right now The top 5% of al patients accounts for 50% of the spending [0]. The public reference does not go into depth but it closely resembles our internal studies. We also predict that remote monitoring and early detection can severely reduce the costs for that top 5 percent. In addition, a large group will never become the top 5 percent. Finally, I think we can get the number of false positives under control or well guarded at a first line of checkups. When I read your first line I was thinking you would say "who wants to be monitored all day". I think the ethics aspects requires attention. Do we even want to go that route from a human perspective? 0) https://www.linguamatics.com/blog/mining-unstructured-patient-data-successful-population-health-management https://www.linguamatics.com/blog/mining-unstructured-patien...
- pinaceae 9y agoExactly the same as explaining to a paying, non-technical customer why you haven't found the bug at the core of his issue yet and thereby given a fixdate is not possible right now. It's clearly broken, so why the hell is it not simple to know whats wrong and how to fix it? And this is for software you've written and you have the full source code for. Don't envy doctors at all.
- jessriedel 9y agoYea. It wouldn't surprise me if there'd be value to having a medical concierge who would help you integrate info from different doctors. But, on my reading, the main thing being complained about in the article is uncertainty and doctors being unable to quickly issue definitive diagnoses. Trouble is, that's the nature of science. Insofar as the process approximates an ideal sequence of Bayesian updates, it has to look like an unpredictable (unbalanced) random walk.
- aYsY4dDQ2NrcNzA 9y agoThe medical concierge job you're talking about sounds like a private patient advocate.
- taforthis 9y agoI actually had a decent experience with this. Ended up being esophageal adenocarcinoma, stage III, which isn't the worst type of cancer, but doesn't have a great prognosis either. The idea that it's not official until the patholigist says so did hold, however... From the moment cancer was a possibility, my primary care doctor let me know. Let me know which types were possible, a short overview of each, and also what else it could have been...less concerning things like maybe a hiatal hernia, for example. The GP sent me to another doctor for the endoscope, to look inside my esophagus, and that doctor gave me a similar overview. Then, right after that procedure, was very frank, something like "You know I can't say for sure, but it does look like cancer to me. The next step is pathology and a cat scan, and we'll know for sure within 4-6 days or so". He even fast-tracked me for these next steps by admitting me to the hospital so that the tests would be done quickly, versus the slower outpatient route. Just a few hours after the tests came back positive, they had an oncologist assigned, who again, was as polite and frank as he could have been. So, while it may remain a crappy process in general, there are doctors out there that seem aware of the tension and anxiety and do their best to help. PS: I'm a year past it all (chemo/radiation/surgery) now, and while it can still re-occur, I'm looking clean thus far. Also, this type of cancer is driven by long-term chronic acid reflux, so if that's something you have, and you're 40+, get yourself checked. Most people find out too late to do anything about it.
- matthewrudy 9y agoThanks for sharing, and glad things are going well. I would say, though, regardless of age you should get it checked out. (not just if you're 40+) I was diagnosed with stomach cancer aged 33, which is highly abnormal, but... it happened. (finish up my chemo/surgery/chemo+radio this friday... whoop!)
- taforthis 9y ago>regardless of age you should get it checked out. (not just if you're 40+) Ah, yes. Guess I should have expanded on that a bit. If you've got chronic acid reflux, the ongoing symptoms of that aren't much different from the initial symptoms of esophageal cancer...even if you're being treated. So, suggesting that you ask about it specifically if you're 40+. Anything unusual or new, though, yes, don't wait on that. >(finish up my chemo/surgery/chemo+radio this friday... whoop!) Congrats!
- mmagin 9y agoGiven that we will all get cancer if we live long enough (unless some significant new technology emerges), possibly it's more useful to learn to think philosophically of the state of healthy as being a sort of Schroedinger's box in which we do not really know the internal state of the system without inspecting it, since cell mutations are happening all the time (albeit usually being resolved harmlessly) -- that you're not in some Garden-of-Eden pure, noncancerous state ever.
- nradov 9y agoIf you do a detailed autopsy of most older people who die of other causes you'll find a few small, slow growing cancerous tumors.
- dora_700 9y agoit is das wana famous blog da inqatano fus tonan games free-downloadgames globaf fis nor itna free all das recomendedsoftware norming folishd da mastunsab da an getintopcuk kis fortune getintopcus da fdan . Love is games da blogs da.
- dora_1999 9y agoit is das wana famous blog da inqatano fus tonan games free-downloadgames globaf fis nor itna free all das recomendedsoftware norming folishd da mastunsab da an getintopcuk kis fortune getintopcus da fdan . Love is games da blogs da.
- loudandskittish 9y agoI love the term "Kafkaesque," but had never thought of applying to the process of a cancer diagnosis. As soon as I read the headline alone, I got it, though. I went through this while looking after my mother during her treatment...from the lead up to the diagnosis, to the diagnosis to the actual treatment. It started with the doctor at the local medical clinic being concerned about a growth in my mother's mouth and referring her to an ENT. That appointment would be in several weeks, then a biopsy scheduled several weeks after that...then an appointment with the ENT to discuss the biopsy three weeks later...meanwhile, all these doctors are talking to each other. My mother goes to the local health clinic for something unrelated and mentions some symptoms to the receptionist, who replies, "Yeah, those are common side effects to chemo..." To which my mother says, "Oh? I'm getting chemo am I?" ...the receptionist could only give an "oops" facial expression. Then the meeting with the ENT to discuss the biopsy never happens, anyway. Instead, my mother gets an automated phone call from the big city hospital saying "You have an appointment with Dr. Ugonnadie at the Cancer Centre on Tuesday." ...so, for all the secrecy and, "you need to come in and talk about this in person in three weeks..." it gets let out of the bag by an automated phone call. In retrospect, yeah, felt pretty Kafkaesque.
- joe5150 9y agoI didn't have this experience when I was diagnosed with Hodgkin's disease in February; I got a talk about the possibility of having cancer and was given some documents on lymphoma by the ER physician before I got a biopsy, CT, or even saw an oncologist. I think it went a long way toward softening the blow of getting an "official" diagnosis after pathology. My post-diagnosis experience with my oncologists has been anything but distant, but I spent four weeks in the hospital seeing them daily before I started chemotherapy, so that could be a factor.