3 ms·
Well, It's true that self-driving cars will/would change a huge amount. But the article seems to make a lot of assumptions that may or may not be warranted. Wi
by joe_the_user 9y ago
Well,
It's true that self-driving cars will/would change a huge amount. But the article seems to make a lot of assumptions that may or may not be warranted. Will this facilitate population spread or population density? I think there are a lot of paradoxical factors which may come up.
One change someone pointed out here a while back is self-driving-ability increases the willingness of people to idle their cars in traffic. It stands to reason that an owner would have little disincentive to send their car out to idle in traffic and pick them up a few hours later, if it was convenient. It seems the final result would be gridlock.
Roads today are a free or low priced good whose use is limited by the ability by each person's ability and willingness to drive. Driverless cars could consume this good with fewer limits creating a "tragedy of the commons" type situation.
So it seems like either you will have regulation or you will have an unregulated situation where traffic grinds to even more of a halt than it is at today in major metropolitan areas.
If you have regulation, you may find eventually everyone forced into an Uber/Lyfte situation (self-driving cars become smart-buses) since that would optimize the use of street space. This would facilitate density imo.
If you have no regulation, you might find some folks going further out despite the time and because of the not having to do their driving. But that seems hard to know.
And generally, the change would be big enough that indeed predicting all the results seems hard. What level of autonomy is achieved when is a big factor, etc.
- solatic 9y ago> self-driving-ability increases the willingness of people to idle their cars in traffic I disagree with this premise. There is a cost to idling in traffic: electricity/gas expended while idling, and the opportunity cost of recharging/refilling before going home, if your car idled too much. Reducto ad absurdum: there will always be a need for airport parking lots. If there is income to be made, Uber-style, from idling your autonomous car, effectively decreasing the costs of idling, then it's easy enough for the municipality to tax income from services like Uber untill some equilibrium is reached, whereby most people are incentivized, like today, to take high-throughput public transit. Everything old is new again: particularly, taxi medallions.
- Tiktaalik 9y agoThe availability of self driving cars will significantly remove some of the biggest disincentives to car use, such as licensing and parking costs. The immediate impact of this would be a stronger incentive to drive a car over other alternatives and more cars on the road. This change in balance between transportation options will have significant negative impacts on cities, many of which are already actively engaged in encouraging people to choose other transportation options than the car. A collision between self driving car share companies and city governments seems likely. As self driving cars become more prevalent, we may see cities enact more anti-congestion regulations as a result.
- justinjlynn 9y agoIf self-driving vehicles become common, there is no real reason to own a vehicle besides extremely heavy utilisation or aesthetics. A public grid of transport is a natural outcome of removing the transport driver bottleneck. Heavily travelled routes will see buses and mass options dynamically (why bother with routes and schedules?) and requests not efficiently served could be handled by unit transport. One might pay extra for direct per-unit transport or pay less for hub-spoke transfer routing. The options are quite intriguing.
- Tiktaalik 9y agoThere are already examples of routeless public transport, which is in third world countries with private, relatively poor quality mini bus based public transport. As transit systems become more developed they graduate toward fixed routes with larger capacity buses because it is the most efficient way of transporting people. This is why we've seen Lyft move toward this as well (reinventing the bus). It will be interesting to see how autonomous vehicles change public transit as the technology develops, but I would not be surprised if the utopian vision of public transit that delivers the user to their exact destination never becomes a reality.
- justinjlynn 9y agoIt's sadly likely to be true that, unless someone finds some way to implement corruption features in such a system, that it is unlikely to replace taxi, private and mass transport. However, one can dream.