7 ms·
This is what I never understood about bitcoins's reputation, especially earlier on, about its supposed anonymity. I suppose that's much less the case now. But i
by ineedasername 9y ago
This is what I never understood about bitcoins's reputation, especially earlier on, about its supposed anonymity. I suppose that's much less the case now. But it always seemed odd that people considered it at all anonymous when the blockchain kept a record of everything. Sure it might not be immediately identifiable with a specific individual, but unless it was a wholly closed system, entry & exit points would always be clear, along with all the hops from wallet to wallet along the way.
And the longer the system exists, the more information will accumulate that would allow anyone with an interest in doing so to correlate blockchain transactions to "real-world" people & systems.
I'm sure I'm missing something though, since I'm by no means a cryptologist, or more than an interested spectator on crypto-coins. (I mined about 0.1 bc back when it was still possible to do that in a week or so on a mid-range AMD GPU. and, shocked at the rise in value, cashed it in for about $200 a few years ago.)
- TylerE 9y agoAnonymous != Untraceable. Anonymous means, well, anonymous.
- ineedasername 9y agoNice, succinct, seems the essence of the misconception. Thanks :D
- Dylan16807 9y agoNot really. The transactions are very far from anonymous. You don't have to attach your real name, which makes it pseudonymous. Cash is actually anonymous (assuming no serial number tracking).
- stale2002 9y agoThe technology is getting better and better. These days there are things like mixers that make it extremely difficult to track. There are even crytocurrencies where mixing is built in and every transaction effectively goes through a mixer.
- ethbro 9y agoRandomly swapping coins is an attempt to address anonymity. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cryptocurrency_tumbler https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cryptocurrency_tumbler
- rkowalick 9y agoThis is basically money laundering, right?
- wcummings 9y agoIt's only money laundering if the source of coins is illicit. You can legally tumble clean coins all day long.
- ryanlol 9y agoCertainly.
- MichaelGG 9y agoIt's privacy. Money laundering is a fake crime and propaganda by governments with prosecutors unable to find real crime. It's as bad as calling copyright infringement "theft" or even "piracy", though the later term has been pretty watered down. Or how banks push the idea of "Identity theft" as if someone stole your identity versus the bank failing to verify your identity. We don't call encryption "information laundering" and niether should simple financial privacy have any negative term.
- home_boi 9y agoFrom the utilitarian perspective, what is the point of financial privacy (from the government)? It looks like money laundering and purchases of illegal substances seem to be the biggest "benefits". Those are benefits that aren't beneficial to the government or the people that are governed.
- smichel17 9y agoSpending habits can reveal a ton of information about a person. At that point, financial privacy has the same justification as encrypted communication or any other kind of privacy: protecting people from Government overreach. Knowledge is power.
- abetusk 9y agoIt's the difference between pseudonymity and anonymity. Saying that I've transferred B bitcoin to identity A doesn't tie that identity to a "real" person, it just says whoever holds A's identity (secret keys) can do other transactions with the bitcoins A holds. In practice this gets complicated as some exchanges require a valid government ID (drivers license say) and that's why these so-called "tumbling" services sprung up. The idea is that, for a small fee, you put X bitcoin into a pool with other people, and get (X - eps) back out and put into another identity of your choosing (eps being transaction fees). As long as the tumbling service doesn't get compromised so that the destination address can't be tied to the source address, this allows for a level of real world identity protection. Presumably even sending bitcoin from an identity that's tied to your meat space identity directly to another identity that you create provides a layer of protection.
- vkou 9y ago> Presumably even sending bitcoin from an identity that's tied to your meat space identity directly to another identity that you create provides a layer of protection. But then any transaction from your second, secret identity that compromises you will retroactively compromise all other transactions made from that identity. Your opsec has to consistently be perfect.
- cinquemb 9y agoThis is true, which is why it makes sense that one would throw away one's secret identity (and creating another) after each and every transaction to mitigate agaisnt this. Not to say one is in the clear even if they do such, because as some say, metadata kills…
- basketbasket 9y agoThis is a problem with the internet in general. In the future, we will have an archive of everything everyone did on the internet and can use stylometry, Facebook likes and clicks, and temporal association to uncover individuals. The only way to opt-out is to just stop participating. All newer cryptography based systems for preserving privacy, like ZCash and Monero, are based around elliptic curve math that will one day be broken. As with 4chan or reddit, the belief that one is anonymous can lead one to engage in riskier or more controversial activity. This is at risk of being uncovered in the future, with potential for damage to the individual.
- rothbardrand 9y agoHow soon is that day when elliptic curve cryptography will be broken? AFAIK RSA is still mostly unbroken and it has been decades. EC could last 50 years or 500 years, right? And if one were to, say, take some transparent ZEC, send it to an invisible location, then take it out to a transparent location and do the same again to a third transparent location (to then convert to bitcoin or whatever)... EC would have to be totally completely broken to figure out the private keys of all three transparent addresses (not just weak in the sense of $1B of GPUs can reverse find one key in 6 months). And still you don't know who those addresses belong to (and haven't broken the invisible part to know where the coins that went to the second and third address came from), right?
- louithethrid 9y agoActually, i think the walled garden internet will collapse spectacularly, as any mono-culture has done before- beeing prone to viruses and attacks. Linux and Open Source might be the users last choice, but might be the last man standing one day- if for example sb would write a maschine learning virus able to detect and exploit new weaknesses in a dormant form.
- basketbasket 9y ago10 years, at most. Google is seeing to production-ready QC within the next 3 years for specific applications. Factoring elliptic curve point multiplications is log(n) with QC, so once the cat is out of the bag decrypting a large dataset should be trivial.
- swinglock 9y agoBitcoin was not designed to be anonymous but this seems to be really difficult to grasp. You don't even have to scratch the surface of Bitcoin to learn that at its core Bitcoin is a distributed ledger, powered by the "blockchain" which is open book for anyone to follow every transaction ever made. This is not a separate tracking system, it's the very fundamentals of how Bitcoin is able to function and it makes no effort to attempt to keep its users anonymous. I can only conclude that claims Bitcoin is anonymous when compared to cash is either propaganda or ignorance.
- t0mbstone 9y agoBitcoin can be anonymous. All you have to do is mine the coins while you are on an anonymous internet connection (such as tor and a public wifi hotspot). Another way for bitcoins to be anonymous is to use a "mixer". If you send your coins to a very large wallet (that contains a lot of money owned by a lot of other people), and then whoever controls that wallet then distributes those coins to a bunch of other newly created addresses (which you control the keys for), then there would be no way to tell whose money was sent to those wallets. It might be your money. It might be a thousand other people's money. This is called bitcoin laundering. Transactions are always traceable, though. People might think their bitcoins are safe and anonymous, but then they use their own personal computer on their own personal internet connection to actually spend the bitcoins on something illegal. Guess what? News flash! The NSA and who knows how many other government agencies have been monitoring internet traffic since the 90s! Ever heard of Carnivore? How about NarusInsight? Do you honestly think they can't track P2P traffic? Do you honestly think that your P2P bitcoin spending transaction can't be traced back to your IP and to your address? They can probably track a lot of Tor traffic, too. The only way bitcoin is anonymous is if someone keeps every single step of the entire process anonymous. Mining/purchasing has to be anonymous. Storage has to be anonymous (no third party wallets). Using an exchange has to be anonymous (good luck with that). Selling the coin (or purchasing something with it) has to be anonymous. The chain is only as strong as its weakest link, and each link has many potential attack vectors. For example, you might think you are using a perfectly safe bitcoin "mixer" service, but for all you know, the feds are actually the ones operating the mixer service, and are tracing every single transaction from start to end. So yeah. The long and short of it is that Bitcoin is heavily monitored and traced, which is why the government allows it to exist.
- celticninja 9y ago0.1btc was only worth approx $200 in the last 12 months so I am not sure how you sold 1/10th of a bitcoin for $200 a few years ago because 1 bitcoin would have cost approximately that.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- brndnmtthws 9y agoMonero[1] was created, among other reasons, to solve the privacy problem. It uses something called a ring signature[2], which is composed of a group 'decoy' public keys, plus yours, as part of every transaction which makes it impossible for an outsider to trace. Monero is fungible, whereas Bitcoin is not. [1]: https://getmonero.org/ https://getmonero.org/ [2]: https://getmonero.org/resources/moneropedia/ringsignatures.html https://getmonero.org/resources/moneropedia/ringsignatures.h...
- X86BSD 9y agoThat is why I have embraced it. I never liked the features lacking from bitcoin. And when the anonymous coins like monero and zero coin came out even then it took me a while to research and embrace one. Monero was what I settled on. I like cash because it's untraceable. I like Monero because I can carry out transactions in private and anonymously. It's no ones business what I do with my money including governments. I have always felt that way. Time will tell wether Monero's ring signatures and other privacy features hold up. But for now that is where I park some of my assets.
- 0x4f3759df 9y agoMonero and Dash are both making a play at the anonymous space, do you have an opinion about Monero vs Dash?
- brndnmtthws 9y agoAs I understand it, Dash doesn't aim to provide privacy in the way that Monero does. The goal of the Dash project seems to be to improve the usability of cryptocurrencies. Both projects, IMO, are doing good work and have their place in the cryptocurrency space. Here's a fairly detailed StackExchange thread on it: https://monero.stackexchange.com/questions/112/how-is-monero-compared-to-dash https://monero.stackexchange.com/questions/112/how-is-monero...
- lawn 9y ago1. Monero's transactions are private by default. In Dash it's optional (and slower). 2. Dash is basically a coin join, working like a Bitcoin mixer. This means you can still gather some information from the mix given enough analysis. It's different compared to Monero where you cannot tell which of the possible inputs is the right one. The security is based on probability and cryptography instead of obfuscation. 3. Monero hides both the addresses of the transaction and the amount. In Dash the transaction amount is open and analysis could correlate the obfuscated sending and receiving addresses. 4. The mixing in Dash is performed by "masternodes", a subset of all nodes, and if compromised they can break the privacy. Particularly scary after the recent Bitcoin mixer shutdown. Monero contains no such third party weakness. All in all the anonymity of Dash is a joke compared to what Monero gives you.
- poopoopoopoo 9y agoWhen all the exchanges have KYC then it will be hard to hide from the law with Bitcoin. For example you buy $1000 of bitcoin on localbitcoins. But that guy is just a trader who buys them from an exchange. You do something nefarious with the BTC and they trace it back to an exchange transaction, to the seller who gives you up.
- blubb-fish 9y agocheck out bitcoin mixing.
- justifier 9y agoblockchain has what i call 'effective anonymity' if you buy 'into' BTC in an anonymous manner and make purchases 'within' BTC the transactions are wholly traceable but the source is anonymous anonymity is lost when moving 'out' of BTC 'into' other currencies that require, or have subsequent effect, of identifying the user