13 ms·
A Bay Area developer wants to build 4,400 homes where they may be sorely needed
- dalfonso 9y ago>> “We’re a small town,” City Councilman W. Clarke Conway said at a meeting on the project last fall, “and we’re a small town by choice.” >> Last year, Brisbane hired a consultant who found that the city would net $1 million a year in tax revenue by approving the Baylands. But if the city instead approved a project with lots more commercial space, a larger hotel and no housing, Brisbane would gain $9 million annually — an amount equivalent to more than half the city’s current day-to-day operating budget. >> “I’d like to think if just the fiscal incentives were reversed, if a city could make as much money off housing as they could retail, we’d be having a very different conversation in California,” Stivers said. >> “I see a lot of stuff,” Dettmer said. “I see beds in garages. You have to increase the [housing] supply. If you really want to help out people, let them live in dignity. It just seems like a no-brainer.” >> “I do feel sorry that the younger generation is not going to get to live the life that we did,” she said. “But it’s a different time.” These were the quotes that stood out to me. It seems like, for various reasons, the only benefit to existing residents and policy makers is "we may be able to help other people". That's not enough of an incentive.
- getemback 9y agoThose numbers don't make a lot of sense. Wouldn't 4400 homes generate something in the vicinity of 50 million dollars in annual property taxes?
- mars4rp 9y agowho gets that property taxes??
- cardiffspaceman 9y agoIf you assume that the property tax on those homes was .011, which is the 1% baseline plus possible voter-approved add-ons, you get $48.4 million per $1 million of value of the average home among the 4400. I paged through the report that is linked to the article [1] and it says that about $9.5 million is the city's share of the property tax revenue (table on page 14 of the consultant's report). So there's a gap to be understood. [1] http://brisbaneca.org/sites/default/files/ccBaylandsHearing_04062017.pdf http://brisbaneca.org/sites/default/files/ccBaylandsHearing_...
- derekdahmer 9y agoI'd imagine the missing $8.5 million of profit goes towards the cost of services for ~10,000 new residents. That's only $850/year/person. This study [1] should give you an idea: the median residential property operates at a net loss to the city at a revenue to expenditures ratio of 1:1.15 whereas commercial operates at a huge net gain at 1:0.27. [1] http://landuse.uga.edu/Documents/cocsrep.pdf http://landuse.uga.edu/Documents/cocsrep.pdf
- rajeshp1986 9y agoI don't know who is the genius who crunches such kind of numbers. Even though 4400 homes will only get $1 million in direct property taxes. There will be huge indirect economic boost that will happen because of the so many people that will stay. There will be new opportunities for the locals for employments & businesses. There will be lot of restaurants, shopping center etc that will cater to these residents. That will be more than building commercial properties and getting $9 million in property revenues.
- dragonwriter 9y agoLet's assume that the 4400 homes are $1 million each; that will be $4.4 billion in property value; property tax (aside from that dedicated to approved bonds) is fixed at 1%, so with million dollar homes it would gross $44 million in property taxes. So, it'd take much more expensive homes to net around $50 million for the city, and while I don't see a clear estimate of the price of the homes, the fact that the article points to affordability as an issue addressed suggest the plan isn't to build million-dollar homes.
- tj-teej 9y agoI think to the planners who make these decisions, helping people is simply a positive externality.
- m0llusk 9y agoYou have things backwards. Planners try to smooth things out or at least prevent disasters. Most of the existing towns in the SF Bay Area are full of great opportunities for expansion but NIMBYs want their villages to stay the same. That is driven not by planners but reactionaries. This particular plot of land is a chronically flooded lagoon and swamp which is awkwardly distant from local transit. It is interesting that instead of being realistic about this land's obviously undesirable nature this article chose instead to print a picture of a nearby plot. The picture shows the former Schlage factory grounds which have undergone extensive remediation and are getting a new high density community built in no small part because of the ongoing efforts of planners to get the highest and best use for that site. As long as people can't stop lying about what the situation is and what options might be available the chances of a favorable outcome are low.
- cylinder 9y agoA "small town" ... 7 miles from the center of a major global city and metro area ... even closer to a major international airport. These people are assholes.
- getemback 9y agoThere's nothing wrong with small villages 7 miles from a major city or even a capital city, if the principal city is built properly. If you walk 7 miles from the center of Zurich, Switzerland you'll probably find yourself in the middle of a vineyard or pasture.
- aphextron 9y agoZurich is not located on a 7 mile wide peninsula.
- glibgil 9y agoThis is some strange SF manifest destiny argument
- greglindahl 9y agoYour statement appears to have nothing to do with the area that Brisbane, CA is located in.
- getemback 9y agoI was just objecting to the idea that a small town was inappropriate in this context. With a suitable urban form there's no reason why you couldn't take the entire population of Brisbane and put them all on 640 acres, with 80% open space. But Brisbane, California is not a "small town" it's a disgusting example of exurban sprawl. https://www.google.com/maps/place/Brisbane,+CA/@37.679201,-122.330704,3a,78.3y,90t/data=!3m8!1e2!3m6!1shttps:%2F%2Fthumbs.trulia-cdn.com%2Fpictures%2Fthumbs_6%2Fps.102%2Fe%2F7%2F5%2Fd%2Fpicture-uh%3D9c9ef53f4781e89553177368d022-ps%3De75d7f71be33c23a4e3456941b73ffa7-142-Elderberry-Ln-Brisbane-CA-94005.jpg!2e7!3e27!6s%2F%2Flh5.googleusercontent.com%2Fproxy%2FjFOwihIPa-3H8QgXCGQ-ml2v3OklBa9hKVt3vmtj1YKCdX7sXcJmtp5tXnET_ujA_xFhQZl_IYdtZkrQZ2sh6wI0WGNMQjDnXoM-5_fMEFuHsctScZjCUljHrMmoniDsXhgA0YrAwUgBSS7q-Pif_R1prKxUtAs%3Dw159-h106-k-no!7i1440!8i960!4m5!3m4!1s0x808f78d8f2a30531:0xff55e02fce53ae30!8m2!3d37.6807661!4d-122.3999715 https://www.google.com/maps/place/Brisbane,+CA/@37.679201,-1...
- mylons 9y agothe quote from Michele Solomon of Brisbane is disgusting.
- jimbobob 9y agoShe's not even trying to hide her selfishness. What a lack of empathy.
- mylons 9y agoit reminds me of the mentality of the extreme right and left wing. if they just repeat their rhetoric over and over, and in groups, it gives them a sense of solace that they aren't being inhumane, greedy pigs.
- true_religion 9y agoAs an outsider, the discussion of San Fransisco housing seems incredibly polarized. Are advocates of new housing talking about disenfranchising their parents, grandparents, and older aunts and uncles? Are they actually talking about tearing down their old family homes that they grew up in and putting up apartment complexes instead? If so then... wow that's a level of forward-thinking that's truly rare. If not ... then these people are trying to have their cake and eat it too. They want whatever district they move to temporarily for jobs to utterly change its character to suit them, at the expense of those already resident there. And yet anything they find sentimental, and all of their families' land assets, will remain safe in their hometowns far-far from San Fransisco.
- closeparen 9y agoYou don't get to criticize us for being temporary when it is the policies you write that force us out. And yes, if for some reason millions of people wanted to move to Wisconsin, I'd rather they built on the site of my family home than lived in RVs and mega-commuted. People's well being matters more than the sentimental value of manufactured goods. I didn't win the genetic lottery to be born in a place with economic opportunity. But I am an American, and since we live in America and not 14th century feudal Europe, I am not obligated to stay put.
- jorams 9y ago> if a city could make as much money off housing as they could retail The article points out concerns about the size of the expansion relative to the current city, which makes sense, but why is tax income a concern for a city? Surely it doesn't exist to make as much money as possible?
- patmcguire 9y agoResidents have kids who go to school, they need hospitals, they take up services. That million dollars a year net is only going to go down over time as things get more expensive and the real estate taxes stay the same. Eventually they'll lose money. Cities don't have to make money they just have to not lose it.
- sdenton4 9y ago“I do feel sorry that the younger generation is not going to get to live the life that we did,” she said. “But it’s a different time.” An excellent encapsulation of what I call the "fuck you, got mine" mode of American politics.
- oneshot908 9y agoIf Silicon Valley were serious about solving its housing crisis (which it's not), there are solutions. Because while you're concern trolling that Brisbane doesn't feel any sort of civic duty to create some sort of Gibsonian tech ghetto with their valuable (but really smelly) land, the valley could solve this problem on its own by relaxing zoning laws (which they won't). https://www.citylab.com/equity/2014/02/heres-what-it-would-look-if-all-silicon-valleys-employees-actually-lived-there/8429/ https://www.citylab.com/equity/2014/02/heres-what-it-would-l... Now imagine an alternate reality where the BART had circled the bay and then extended northward, southward, and eastward instead of getting @#$%blocked in 1961 by San Mateo county. But since we can't have nice things like that, Brisbane IMO owes SF and the bay area nothing and they should squeeze out the last drop of profit from this situation. http://www.mercurynews.com/2007/02/05/history-of-bart-to-the-south-bay/ http://www.mercurynews.com/2007/02/05/history-of-bart-to-the...
- erentz 9y agoGibsonian tech ghetto? That's a bit exaggerated. We are talking about building medium density housing and mixed use around a railway station versus commercial property and office parks. Sounds more like what Brisbane wants with the commercial property is closer to a Gibsonian tech ghetto to me.
- oneshot908 9y agoSounds to me like they want to max out tax revenue and that's their right. Were you jumping up and down and holding your breath when San Jose built office space and very little housing for exactly the same reason during the first dotcom boom? All this developer has to do is make building that housing a no-brainer for Brisbane, but I suspect in doing so the profitability plummets or somebody would have already done this, no?
- anth1988 9y ago> >> “I do feel sorry that the younger generation is not going to get to live the life that we did,” she said. “But it’s a different time.” 63 year old said that. How about in honour of the different time we stop bothering to keep the elderly alive. I feel sorry for them for not getting the health care that they need, but it's a different time.
- rbanffy 9y ago> That's not enough of an incentive. One relatively simple solution is to pass laws that mandate building homes along stores and hotels. Want to build a large hotel and some stores? Need to also build 4,400 affordable houses. And, since we are fixing the world, add to that mandatory investment in clean energy for seawater desalination, because water and energy for those homes will have to come from somewhere. And I didn't even suggest higher density habitations.
- getemback 9y agoThis has been going around, but even this plan to build 4400 dwellings is still total nonsense, because the plan also includes office space for 15000 people. 15000 jobs requires much more than 4400 dwellings, so this plan will just make things worse. I recommend comparing and contrasting with this plan for Coyote Valley, to see what real urbanism looks like. http://www.greenbelt.org/wp-content/uploads/2012/01/Coyote-Valley-Vision-Document.pdf http://www.greenbelt.org/wp-content/uploads/2012/01/Coyote-V...
- djb_hackernews 9y agoThat plan is from 2003. Not familiar with the area, how did it turn out?
- getemback 9y agoIt's on ice. Nobody is building anything in Coyote Valley. But it's a wonderful plan.
- bdamm 9y agoThat is an outstanding plan.
- beamatronic 9y agoIf you want to see a well planned community check out Reston, VA
- getemback 9y ago"Reston is a Car-Dependent city" -- https://www.walkscore.com/VA/Reston https://www.walkscore.com/VA/Reston
- smalley 9y agoMy current favorite local example of this taken to its ridiculous ends is this one: http://www.mercurynews.com/2017/06/09/internal-affairs-san-jose-v-santa-clara-round-one-goes-to-santa-clara/ http://www.mercurynews.com/2017/06/09/internal-affairs-san-j... . Where San Jose and Santa Clara are going back and forth suing each other about who gets to have the businesses and who has to bear the "burden" of having housing.
- billhathaway 9y agoHow could the net increase in tax revenue only be $1M? At 4400 units, that would be only be $227 per unit per year. While prop 13 limits increases, for new units, they would be assessed at current value.
- maxerickson 9y agoIn the report, the $1 million is a fiscal surplus. So it factors in the cost of providing services.
- thephyber 9y agoTo expand, city services are more expensive for a resident of a city than an employee, hence the asymmetry of the fiscal surplus numbers.
- Animats 9y agoRedwood City is encouraging apartment construction in a big way. Block after block of buildings in the 8-story range are going up near the railroad station. Meanwhile, Stanford University is building an additional campus about a mile from downtown. The strip-mall area in between is starting to be replaced with larger buildings. It's happening fast; there are construction cranes all over town. Meanwhile, real estate in SF is dropping in price. The bubble seems to be popping there.
- Animats 9y agoI just found out that Stanford's "Redwood City campus" is entirely administrative. 35 acres of bureaucrats. 2700 people. "School of Medicine administration. Stanford Libraries and University Archives administration. Business Affairs. Land, Buildings and Real Estate. Human Resources. Residential & Dining Enterprises. Office of Development (i.e. fund-raising). And those are just the off-site administrators. There are more back on the main campus. Stanford has only 2,180 faculty members.
- HoppedUpMenace 9y agoMay not be a popular opinion but I'd have to say that I value the idea of having space between me and my neighbors, so I'm definitely not in favor of maxing out the land for homes to the point where the houses might as well be attached and labeled condos or apartments. I can understand where the people are coming from in wanting to maintain what they've invested into. I'd hate to see a sudden boom in population and sudden traffic spikes due to the knee jerk reaction of building 100's of more houses in an area that wasn't even planned to support more than what is existing. People do need housing but people also need to be realistic about where they live and how they plan to keep on living there.
- getemback 9y agoWith respect to your and our values, the people of the state have mandated that greenhouse gas emissions be reduced below 1990 levels by year 2020, and state law requires every city to adopt a climate action plan to that effect. Brisbane's adopted plan recognizes that transportation is the majority of the city's greenhouse gas emissions, and acknowledges that "Lack of affordability in urban core housing causes people to live far away from where they work", but does not propose fixing this problem. The only solution their climate action plan proposes is to install public electric car chargers!
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- pix64 9y ago> May not be a popular opinion but I'd have to say that I value the idea of having space between me and my neighbors They aren't building new houses between old houses...
- TRUMPISYOURPREZ 9y agoBoomers will NEVER allow housing to be built in the Bay Area.
- Mz 9y agoIt might be easier for residents and elected officials to welcome growth if the city received more tax dollars for doing so. But the opposite is true. Because of tax limits established in 1978 by Proposition 13, local governments generally receive more revenue from sales and hotel room taxes than property taxes. Proposition 13 limited property tax rates to 1% of a home’s taxable value and restricted how quickly that taxable value could increase after a purchase. Last year, Brisbane hired a consultant who found that the city would net $1 million a year in tax revenue by approving the Baylands. But if the city instead approved a project with lots more commercial space, a larger hotel and no housing, Brisbane would gain $9 million annually — an amount equivalent to more than half the city’s current day-to-day operating budget. I have suggested before that tax incentives are part of why we have this issue. This isn't exactly the way I figured it was screwing things up, but it is evidence that tax structures are part of the problem.
- dragonwriter 9y agoLow fixed property taxes means cities rely on sales and use tax, which means retail is favored and housing disfavored. Prop 13 ruins everything.
- kqr2 9y agoProp 13 is the big elephant in the room. Repealing Prop 13 and rent control would probably align everybody's incentives to keep housing "affordable". Owners would probably welcome higher density housing to help keep property taxes down. Renters would likewise welcome more housing to increase the rental supply. However, there doesn't really seem to be a way to actually repeal any of these laws.
- s73ver 9y agoProblem being, a lot of people would get absolutely screwed by that, and end up losing their home. There needs to be a way to fix that, without going back to the original problem Prop 13 was intended to fix, which was people being unable to afford the property tax on homes that they had been living in forever.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- notadoc 9y agoBuild up, not out. Easy solution.
- jpao79 9y agoI think the issue as it stands is that the current residents have only 2 options: A.) Approve high density housing and then see the value of their current house drop (and rental income drop if they are landlords) and their schools, grocery stores, parks, open space, parking, favorite restaurants, fitness centers and traffic become all be super crowded B.) Approve high density office and then see the value of their current house skyrocket, see additional community benefits from developer concessions and no impact to their current community amenities. What happens if the developer proposed a third option of profit sharing so the current residents each benefit as individuals: C.) Build high density housing and high density office and give a significant share of the profits to the existing residents. For 4400 units, the profits could easily be in the $500M to $1B range. With only ~2350 (4700/2) households, profit sharing of $50 to $100K per household would be $120M to $235M. That could be a nice down payment for a house in the Central Valley if they want to have that small town feel. Profit sharing on the annual office rent could also provide some UBI income for the residents and keep apartment rents stable.
- santaclaus 9y ago> B.) Approve high density office and then see the value of their current house skyrocket, see additional community benefits from developer concessions and no impact to their current community amenities. The state of California needs some sort of Beds for Butts in Office Chairs legislation. Want to build office space and expand your tax base? Pony up the space to house those employees.
- jpao79 9y agoAgreed! Even then though you still need to get it past the existing NIMBY population. I think buying them out via cash payments is really the only way to get existing NIMBYs on board with high density residential units which were not zoned when the bought into the community. Basically the issue is that the developers are changing the rules of the game AFTER the existing NIMBYs bought into the community.
- wbl 9y ago
- zaroth 9y agoHow can 4,400 homes net only $1 million in property taxes? Tell me where I can sign up to pay $227 in annual property taxes!
- thephyber 9y agoAs mentioned elsewhere, gross is not net. Once you factor in city services costs for those new residents, the net change is far lower than the gross property taxes per new resident.
- zaroth 9y agoAh, well in that case, property taxes in theory should be neting exactly $0! The government isn't supposed to be for-profit after all...