6 ms·
There they go again, again [pdf]
- mamon 9y agoBitcoin is first and foremost a money-laundering method, especially from ransomware hackers. EDIT: some recent news on that ($4B money laundered): https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2017/07/officials-arrest-suspect-in-4-billion-bitcoin-money-laundering-scheme/ https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2017/07/officials-arrest...
- sddfd 9y agoWhy is this getting downvoted?
- pmlnr 9y agoGood question. I'd say because people want to believe it's not.
- csomar 9y agoUnproven statement. I could have written it also and replaced bitcoin with cash. Bitcoin probably handles much less than 1% of the world-wide money laundering business at its current market cap.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- mamon 9y agoYou got it backwards: it is not about what percent of money laundering is done with Bitcoin, it is about what percent of Bitcoin is used for money laundering. I've just posted link (few comments above) about $4B laundering scheme discovered, that's 9% of global Bitcoin market cap (currently $46B). And you can assume that this Russian arrested wasn't the only one doing it, so actual proportion is probably bigger.
- csomar 9y agoYou'll probably need to research backed-up numbers to confirm that. Yes, I do believe the same too (most bitcoin activity is used for illicit activity) but we don't really have the numbers yet and I am not sure if it is possible to do it.
- bognition 9y agoBecause it's a blanket statement that demonstrates the commenters failure to understand what Bitcoin actually is. Sure its used for those things but that isn't it's first and foremost use.
- bhaak 9y agoEven if Bitcoin's first and foremost use were money laundering, it is not very well suited for that with its public ledger. Anybody who needed proof for that just got it with the btc-e founder case.
- fsniper 9y agoWith a global ledger where every transaction is recorded, blockchain is the worst choice for money laundering. If you have seen the BTC-e founder case, you would understand what I mean.
- loceng 9y agoIt's because the individual didn't have a network to launder the money through, that's why he started the BTC-e exchange - however I suppose he was sloppy, especially since they were able to connect his real name to an account because he posted about it online, connected to some crypto-asset. It's similar to the mafia, however the mafia evolved to launder money through networks of families and starting 'cash' businesses that they could disguise funds coming in - at least until the businesses became 'legitimate.' This trusted network basically would have started to develop through strong arming. Late edit: For crypto-assets, the network of 'trusted' people is formed simply by the early adopters - most of which those are people who are purchasing or spending resources mining for speculation purposes. Then you have these people who are all aligned to increase adoption. Strong arming can come later, when people in positions of power (or who have control) are manipulated (whether through bribery/lobbying, etc) or other tactics to have them tie the crypto-assets value into a nation's real currency's value, essentially legitimizing it by force and potentially forcing everyone to buy at the then going rate. Imagine if a company on the stock market told you you're buying their stock for $y price, even though you don't believe or know it doesn't have any value, and they forced everyone to do that; this is war, a battle anyhow, with capitalism and finance involved instead of capitalism and physical military force/mass bloodshed - massively different in their subtleties, and where the first can quickly gain global adoption and tap into global speculative greed and money when tied to a crypto-asset.
- apk-d 9y ago>"Serious investing consists of buying things because the price is attractive relative to intrinsic value," he wrote. "Speculation, on the other hand, occurs when people buy something without any consideration of its underlying value or the appropriateness of its price." So basically, every currency is a pyramid scheme.
- eterm 9y agoNo, not really. Most currencies have a value which can be tied to real-world value at the most reductionist via which governments accept it for tax and the stability of those governments. Bitcoin is different, not just because of the lack of government backing but also because the way it is structured meant the earlier people got into it the more bitcoins they got. (Fundamentally because mining rewards reduce over time). But that's irrelevant to fact you've missed the point of his quote, that most people buying other currencies are doing it with purpose (such as hedging) and considering their value, whereas people buying bitcoins are doing it for speculative reasons and aren't making a judgement on where they think the price of bitcoin ought to be.
- StavrosK 9y agoI think the price of bitcoin is hugely, immensely overvalued (because you can buy things with it at even fewer stores now than a few years ago). That doesn't mean I don't think it will be twice as overvalued in the future.
- eterm 9y agoI'm not sure it is overvalued, at least in the medium term. Ransomware forces people to buy bitcoin while at the same time making the bitcoins spent unspendable (because spending them will get you caught). If you controlled all bitcoin, the way to make money with ransomware is selling your legitimate coins to people who need to buy them to fulfil their ransoms. Each ransom paid decreases the bitcoin in circulation which further puts pressure on the price. Eventually the pool of legitimate bitcoin will be tiny, but ransoms will still get paid, so the ransom demands will be smaller and smaller in bitcoin denomination. If we assume the ransoms that people are willing to pay is steady in dollar value then that will push the price of bitcoin up. There is tremendous inflationary pressure on a fragile bitcoin eco-system. It can withstand high inflation because no-one has their salaries or bills in bitcoin. Where does deflationary pressure come from? It will have bubble cycles that will bubble and pop but overall even as it gets less popular by users, the actual price can rise and rise if the currency circulates slower and slower. The last few bag-holders might have huge paper wealth before they realise there's no one left to actually buy their coins. I don't think it's a legitimate investment though, it's still a pyramid scheme by it's nature (Satoshi still owns a large proportion of all coins) and even without that investing in bitcoin is investing in cyber-terrorism and funding criminals. (Unlike the "if you download MP3s you're funding terror" bullshit this one is actually closer to the truth).
- bognition 9y agoWhy do articles like this keep showing up on HN? So the guy called the burst of a previous bubble, guess what lots of people did but that is bound to happen when thousands of people are crying bubble every day for years. Inevitably when the market crashes there will be a lucky few who think they predicted it. Next, even if he is some savant that can see bubbles coming how does that qualify him to make blanket statements about Bitcoin?
- watty 9y agoWell if he's an expert on investments then it qualifies him to make a statement on bitcoin as an investment. You don't have to agree, or believe him, but it's pretty easy to see that many people are throwing money at it in hopes that more people continue to throw money at it.
- amingilani 9y agoSure but that can be said of any speculative trader going long on an asset. It doesn't make it a bubble.
- frgtpsswrdlame 9y agoOf course, a bubble is something that popped so can only be defined post hoc. There's some good reasoning in this letter though.
- cm2187 9y agoYeah but an equity investment has intrinsic value. Either through future earning to which as a shareholder you are entitled or to the residual value of the company if you shut it down now. You can trade it in a speculative way, and if it starts to trade at a level that cannot be justified by its intrinsic value, then we are in bubble territory too.
- mtgx 9y agoAgreed. I also believe we'll enter an economic crisis (smaller than the 2008 one) in 2018, in part because an economic crisis seems to happen every 10 years or so, and in part because the stock bubble is looking to burst sometime soon and it will bring other things down with it (because of the overall panic in the market, as it tends to happen). There's a high chance I'm going to be wrong about the year, but if I do get it right, I'm going to refer to myself as "the man who called the 2018 economic crisis" around here afterward.
- empath75 9y agoI think crypto is in a massive speculative bubble right now, especially ethereum, but as long as criminals can use bitcoin to make transactions, it's going to have some value.
- reallydattrue 9y ago> but as long as criminals can use CASH to make transactions, it's going to have some value. There fixed it for you. Why do people chose to remain ignorant and make ignorant claims? Do you even know how much the US Dollar is used to profit criminals? Illegal sales of Oil by ISIS. Opium sales in Afghanistan. Drug trade coming from Latin America. Seriously. Before you start throwing rocks at Bitcoin and talking about things you have no idea about. Have a few minute to ponder about what you are saying. There are plenty of uses for bitcoin and crypto currencies. The remittance market, transactions between banks in different countries, p2p micro-transactions and replacing gold as a digital store of value. All of these are legitimate uses.
- 43224gg252 9y agoI think it's a pump-and-dump that's gotten out of hand.
- Eleopteryx 9y agoOK, we get it. People have been calling Bitcoin a pyramid scheme for years now. Not exactly breaking new ground with that assertion, and he's not making any new arguments to back up that assertion.
- bhouston 9y agoPyramid schemes can be long running and successful, like Herbalife. Seriously, that is a pyramid scheme but it has gone on for quite some time and is successful. Others are Amway and other multi-level marketing products.
- oelmekki 9y agoSo, do you imply that people buying bitcoins then try to sell them to their friends and family? People keep buying, then selling, then buying again, then selling again bitcoins. This hardly qualifies as a pyramid scheme, this is speculation.
- bhouston 9y agoIt is a speculative bubble: http://www.investopedia.com/terms/s/speculativebubble.asp http://www.investopedia.com/terms/s/speculativebubble.asp Pyramid scheme is implied because people try to get others to adopt bitcoin, may not friends and family but it is promoted to others as a way to get rich. Have you seen the various cryptocurrency sub-reddits? They often read like mass delusions or pump-and-dump schemes. The only real value of Bitcoin that I have seen is the highly illegal darknet marketplaces, but outside of that I haven't seen much.
- oelmekki 9y agoI see your point, but then most financial investments could be considered pyramid schemes as people always are vocals about how their investment is great, partly for the feeling of being convinced to be a good investor, partly because value raises if other people are buying. The definition of "pyramid scheme" has to be stricter than that if it has to have any meaning :) Regarding intrinsic value, there's one thing I hope from bitcoin (or any other crypto that could achieve that) : replacing my bank account. Banking services have got so bad with years, it's really time to disrupt them. Granted, we're far from there yet, and it may never happen. That's why it's a risky investment, with possible high reward (or high loses) and why ... it can't be used as a bank account (because of the volatility). Still going in the right direction, IMO.
- mrleiter 9y agoMeta-comment: I really dislike judging a person's argument based on correct predictions said person made before. It's turning the "argumentum ad hominem" inside out, giving credibility to an argument because someone specific said it.
- oelmekki 9y agoIn philosophy, it's called an "aristoteles dixit" (Aristotle said), based on the fact that it was often considered proof enough in middle age if an argument was defended by Aristotle. As a meta-meta-comment, this is one of the things I like the most about HN : we don't see any avatar and nicknames are not obvious, so we consider arguments before considering who made them.
- shanusmagnus 9y agoMeta-reply: '[C]orrect predictions [someone] made before' = data. Instead of discounting it, I would rather count it more heavily, esp. in a complex domain where a full principled evaluation of the evidence is beyond most people. There's a reason you can't read a review paper and then get a PhD in whatever topic. Having to establish everything in a logical chain from first principles every time you want to opine is inefficient, to say the least. Previous performance matters. It's not all that matters, but nobody is claiming that.
- prostoalex 9y agoYep, the Meredith Whitney effect. She made a correct call on large financial institutions facing trouble in 2007-2008, and then predicted a large number of municipal bond defaults. That second prediction is still waiting for the reality to catch up.
- csomar 9y agoInstead of reading this value-empty article, here is the report: https://www.oaktreecapital.com/docs/default-source/memos/there-they-go-again-again.pdf https://www.oaktreecapital.com/docs/default-source/memos/the... In my opinion, the report shows a lack of understanding of the fundamentals and inner-working of both bitcoin and other digital currencies. It is hard for me to take a report so seriously when the author shows incompetency in the underlined topic. The report main argument against crypto-currencies is: "But they are not real!" repeated multiple times through the report. Well, define "real". What does it mean to be real? Is the dollar real because you can hold a 1 dollar bill in your hand? If so, is the value of the dollar equal to value of paper; or the amount written on it? The author main argument is very weak; and in my opinion shows a lack of understanding of how markets work. In the very long run, everyone will die, the Sun will run out of fuel, and the universe might crunch. We could also be in a simulation. What matters is the normal distribution of volatility of such assets; for day to day usage. And their trend, for longer term investment. People assume the US dollar is a stable currency because we have yet to experience a black swan event that disrupt that.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- andosa 9y agoOne thing that makes the dollar more "real" is that you are required to pay taxes in it. This creates an automatic demand for dollars. Even if you make your money in bitcoin in US, you need some dollars to pay your taxes or risk being thrown in jail. There is no such "intrinsic" value for bitcoin.
- mtgx 9y agoSomeone is looking to buy low. Joking aside, I think what's happening in the cryptocurrency world is what has happened in the financial world before, just on a much more accelerated and aggressive pace. Cryptocurrencies have value as commodities or even a securities through ICOs just like many things in the real world, too. I don't think they are that fundamentally different. People just tend to think of them as being different because they are digital assets and not something you can touch, even though people "buy gold" all the time that they also never get to touch. And don't get me started on fractional reserve banking's "virtual money"... Pretty much everything in this world doesn't have inherit value. It's the value we assign to it in a marketplace that makes things valuable. I remember an older discussion on HN about this, with Bitcoin being more like tulips and gold not being like that because it has "inherit value." No it doesn't. Gold is like tulips, too, except it lasts longer, so it's a better (key word) "store of value" because of it. Think about how things were in let's say the 1600's. Why did kings store their wealth in gold? Because they thought other kings regarded gold (and not some random rock or mineral) as valuable. Bitcoin is the same. It's valuable because people who hold it believe others think it's valuable, too. Same for the USD, or the Venezuelan bolivar. People still believe the USD has value right now, but in 50 years it could be another bolivar if everyone starts believing that the US will never repay its $100 trillion debt (or whatever it will be then). Then nobody will think the USD has any value. FIAT has no more inherit value than anything else. It only has value as long as everyone agrees it has value (and even that changes on a micro-time frame, as people compare it to other currencies or gold on any given day).
- nonsince 9y agoDesktop link here https://www.cnbc.com/2017/07/26/billionaire-investor-marks-who-called-the-dotcom-bubble-says-bitcoin-is-a-pyramid-scheme.html https://www.cnbc.com/2017/07/26/billionaire-investor-marks-w...
- synaesthesisx 9y agoIt's not BTC but rather the absurd ICO bubble - the majority of these companies are selling worthless tokens in exchange for Ethereum. It's like penny stocks but even less regulated!
- thinkcontext 9y agoI made this point to someone a while back on Reddit, and added that it couldn't work as a currency because it is inherently deflationary. This was back when the aggregate value of Bitcoin was $100M. Meanwhile I have a relative that was an underemployed anarchist who now has his own plane purchased w/ Bitcoin proceeds.
- cma 9y agoThe block chain could eventually fork to become inflationary.
- notzorbo3 9y ago> Meanwhile I have a relative that was an underemployed anarchist who now has his own plane purchased w/ Bitcoin proceeds. That's basically just survivorship bias. I know someone¹ that won the lottery and is now a milionair. That doesn't make lotteries a sound investment. This is why I also believe Bitcoin is an unintentional pyramid scheme. Its real value is way too low. It's too difficult and dangerous to actually use it for payments. So its only use now is speculation, and that only works as long as other people are willing to buy bitcoin for more money than it was worth in the past. Typical pyramid scheme. ¹) not really, but it illustrates the point.
- jayvdb1 9y agoI would also be twisted and bitter if I didn't get in early
- joelthelion 9y agoIt's not a binary thing. I would say perhaps 90% of bitcoin's current market value is speculation. But bitcoin does have some use cases, and as such it does have intrinsic value. The question is, how much?
- dumbfounder 9y agoMost people understand that crypto is in a bubble, but that doesn't mean that extreme value won't be attained. There was a dotcom bubble because of speculation, but it was merely a timing issue. It took another 5-6 years before companies started extracting the value to match the speculation and the bubble just couldn't stay in tact long enough. If you could invest in "The Internet" as a concept back in 1999 you would be rich today because the value has skyrocketed way past that bubble. If you think Bitcoin is going to last 20 years then it doesn't matter if we are in a bubble, you should buy some. Maybe it goes down for a while, but if it's around in 20 years it is almost certainly going to be worth way more than it is today.
- badloginagain 9y agoThere may have been a dotcom bubble, but internet companies didn't go away after it popped. The bubble was fueled by an understanding that the internet was a fundamental shift in the future of the global economy, without it being around long enough to actually do so. I can see parallels in crypto-currencies, and I think even if there is a bubble, it won't spell the death of crypto.
- pdog 9y agoIf you actually read the latest memo from Howard Marks, he tried to understand Bitcoin but couldn't make sense of it: https://www.oaktreecapital.com/insights/howard-marks-memos https://www.oaktreecapital.com/insights/howard-marks-memos Then he makes the perplexing argument, "But they're not real." And he calls it a fad and possibly a pyramid scheme. But obviously if you don't understand something, you shouldn't invest in it.
- sideshowb 9y agoI bet the other Howard Marks would be more supportive of bitcoin if he were still with us...
- free_everybody 9y agoIMHO his thoughts on bitcoin apply more fully to all the other alt-coins, including (especially?) ethereum. Bitcoin has value because of its popularity and has been used successfully for years on dark web markets and legitimate markets like the Microsoft store. Its value may fluctuate, but it is surely valuable to many people in the world. On the other hand, most alt-coins (Monero is an exception) are the products of people who want to get rich via scamming.
- frgtpsswrdlame 9y agoWhy the exceptions? Ethereum is a scam but Monero isn't? They're all the same.
- free_everybody 9y agoThe most important metric when comparing cryptocurrency is "real world" usefulness. Bitcoin is obviously useful because it's popular and widely accepted. Monero is useful because it the most traded highly secretive coin. The development team only wants to provide untraceable currency, no more and no less. They even have actively tried(https://bitsonline.com/fluffypony-speaks-troll-monero-market/ https://bitsonline.com/fluffypony-speaks-troll-monero-market...) to keep Monero's price low while other alt-coins were spiking because they hate the direction that the Ethereum ecosystem is taking and spreading to all of cryptocurrency. (i.e. the get-rich-quick mentality) I don't think Ethereum is a complete scam. Vitalek is very smart and wants to change the world. The problem is, he created a nest for scammers with his smart contracts. Theoretically, smart contracts create trustless transactions. In reality, this becomes a wild west for anyone with an ounce of swindling talent to con people out of money, or just lose it because of poor coding practices. I would link some articles but there are SO MANY that its common knowledge by now. Check out Monero community member Riccardo Spagni's comments(https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zJbxaFHGk2M https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zJbxaFHGk2M) about Consensus 2017, a crypto conference during which he was bombarded by talks of ethereum ICO's that had no actual products to show for.
- deweller 9y agoHere's an entertaining list of bitcoin "deaths": https://99bitcoins.com/obituary-stats/ https://99bitcoins.com/obituary-stats/
- auggierose 9y agoTotally agree, digital currencies are not real. Of course that doesn't mean they cannot have an effect on reality, just as a psychopath can run around and shoot people because of his unreal delusions.
- vasilipupkin 9y agothe report is kinda bulshitty. Look, why don't you just make a prediction such as "investors should do xyz". Otherwise, what's the point? Move forward but with caution? what does that even mean? What do I do with cash I have ?
- daxaxelrod 9y agoCrazy how this comment section fixates on bitcoin which was the subject of maybe 2 pages out of a 23 page report. His points on flagrant debt purchases (Argentina's), levered tech funds (Softbank's) and passive etf investing were quite good. ETFs, while a macro good, has underlying securities being purchased regardless of price.