16 ms·
Birkenstock CEO accuses Amazon of ‘modern-day piracy’
- marksomnian 9y agoThe whole "let's not sell our products on Amazon because of counterfeits" seems exceedingly silly to me. The only people who will know about it are your "hardcore" buyers, those who keep up with everything to do with your company. To the average buyer, if the official products aren't up, all that'll do is give more exposure to the counterfeits than before, because the legitimate goods aren't there to soak up that exposure. If anything, if they're scared of counterfeits, they should have listed the genuines even more aggressively, to get more of the views that would have gone to the counterfeits.
- marak830 9y agoI half agree with your point but the again, what about buyers who receive badly made counterfits and assume thats is the brands quality control level? Sort of screwed if you do and buggered if you don't sort of situation.
- cleansy 9y ago> If anything, if they're scared of counterfeits, they should have listed the genuines even more aggressively, to get more of the views that would have gone to the counterfeits. It's ultimately the responsibility of the market place to ensure that illegal, possibly trademark breaching products are not on sale. That is their job. Amazon failed, and continues to fail to do that. From this perspective I can understand why makers don't want Amazon to sell their stuff. Which may raise enough attention to finally do more against counterfeits. In the end, it benefits us all.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- sgift 9y agoIf the products are actual counterfeits (which are illegal) it's the job of the law to block them from being sold. If it's just "we don't like comparable products near ours ..." then I don't see why that's Amazons responsibility either.
- ss64 9y agoUnfortunately Amazon make it really hard for customers to tell the difference, 'fullfillment by Amazon' means that third party seller products are on the same warehouse shelf as Amazons own stock. So you buy direct from Amazon but actually get a third party counterfeit product.
- sametmax 9y agoTheir making overpriced sandals and are now surprised everyone can do the same, for cheaper, and get a piece of their pie. Well, doh.
- RandomBookmarks 9y agoBirkenstock does not mind anyone selling cheaper sandals, but they do mind that "after deeming that Amazon wasn’t doing enough to guard against fakes."... which is actually reason I buy less on Amazon these days. I can never be sure if I am simply getting a "good price" or a cheap look-alike product.
- dalbasal 9y agoIf you can do the same for cheaper, great. You can't pretend that you are Birkenstock. You can make up your own name, call them Birkenstock-like sandals, home brand sandals, whatever you want. Birkenstock is apparently complaining about "counterfeit products and unauthorized sellers." Those are two very different things. Unauthorized reselling is legal, counterfeiting is not. These are good laws. One helps consumers, the other harms them. -This message was written by sametmax
- Kluny 9y ago> -This message was written by sametmax ...que?
- gpderetta 9y agodalbasal was making a point.
- randyrand 9y agoWell, even if you could make birkenstock-like sandals usually you still have design patents to deal with too. Only birkenstock is allowed to sell sandals that look like birkenstock sandals.
- Kluny 9y agoThey're not really overpriced. They're noticeably higher quality than the knockoffs. The whole point is that you can't check the quality of a sandal online, but you can look at your friend's birkenstock, like it, and buy one with the same brand online confident in the knowledge that you're getting the same thing your friend showed you. Except you can't if Amazon allows fakes. It's reason enough to stop buying brand name stuff on Amazon until they work this out, honestly .
- dalbasal 9y agoThere are a whole bunch of issues discussed here in paralel. Most, like all the back-channel stuff, are contractual issues and aren't really relevant to the consumer. Consumers can benefit from Amazon seeking product back channels. Trademark violation (counterfeiting) is a different story. Unlike copyright or patents, trademarks are not there to protect the "owner" of the trademark in principle. It's there to protect consumers. You shouldn't be tricked into buying at a fake amazon. You shouldn't be tricked into buying a fake Toyota. Amazon's tolerance of counterfeits is (very possibly) harmful to consumers, who can't reliably purchase the products they want. Birkenstock have their own interests. One is competition from counterfeits. The problem here is that this is a grey policy. If Amazon believes these counterfeit products are valuable and customer friendly, then label them as Birkenstock-imitaion or somesuch.
- _fizz_buzz_ 9y ago> Unlike copyright or patents, trademarks are not there to protect the "owner" of the trademark in principle. It's there to protect consumers. That's not how trademarks work. A trademark is registered by the owner and the trademark has to be defended by the owner. If someone sells something under the brand name Birkenstock, it's not some consumer protection organization that will sue, but it is up to the owner of the trademark to defend it. If trademarks only existed to protect consumers, there would be different mechanisms in place.
- snowwrestler 9y agoHuge swaths of consumer protection are enforced through private lawsuits. Don't confuse the mechanism with the policy goal. Yes, it is up to trademark owners to defend their trademarks. But the reason they are empowered to do so under the law is because the public has an interest in feeling confident that they know who they are buying from.
- _fizz_buzz_ 9y agoDon't get hung up on my point about the mechanism. The general point is that trademark law is a lot more like a property (protecting the owner) than a consumer protection law. When I own a trademark, I can do anything I can do with any property. I can use it myself, I can sell it to someone else, I can license it someone else, I may even license it to someone that makes a different product (with some restrictions). When you buy sunglasses with the Versace trademark, you won't get anything produced by Versace or invented by them or quality controlled by them, or with warranty from them.
- doe88 9y agoCounterfeiting is a real issue on Amazon, I understand the appeal of what Birkenstock is trying to achieve : if you see a product labelled Birkenstock on Amazon it's likely counterfeit, don't buy. Sometimes it is worth playing the long game and in this case I think he is right to protect its brand above all else.
- andreasklinger 9y agoSimilar issue: Buying apple headphones on amazon >All< of them are fake
- cjsuk 9y agoMy daughter got bitten by this. Contacted Amazon and they refunded. Still selling them though!
- kbart 9y ago"Contacted Amazon and they refunded. Still selling them though!" That's the most annoying thing about Amazon. Even if you report obviously counterfeit item, they still continue to sell it. I don't get it, how this can be legal and why nobody sued them yet? Compare that to draconian DCMA actions, where the slightest suspicion can get your site blocked for good..
- CWuestefeld 9y agoI think folks misunderstand the Amazon data model. It appears that Product represents a thing that can be sold. But beneath that there's something like a SellerItem, which represents a given Product as sourced from a particular Seller. If Amazon is notified of a counterfeit Product, the correct action is NOT to remove the Product. There's no reason to think that there's anything wrong with that SKU (it's got the right description, part#, media assets, reviews, and everything). The problem is the SellerItem - they ought to do something about the naughty seller who's trying to pass off the counterfeit item as if it's the actual Product. Thus, even if Amazon nukes the offending Seller, the Product will still appear on the site. But one would hope that the offending seller is not listed as one of the choices for fulfilling the order. Now, Amazon's apparent willingness to treat on-hand inventory from all Sellers as fungible is another problem...
- bko 9y agoNike faced a similar situation where they felt that they could not effectively control their brand image so they pulled their products from Amazon. However, the product was still around as many individual re-sellers listed Nike products. So Nike ended up having even less control without having a relationship with Amazon [0]. Counterfeits are one issue, but brands have to accept that they cannot control distribution channels as they have in the past. Companies don't like to have their products showcased against similar products, but that's inevitable. Margins will shrink, and they'll just have to compete more on quality, value and reliability. In the end, the consumer benefits. The only solution would be to severely restrict what it means to own a product in a legal sense, which would be very harmful to consumers who value ability to re-sell and donate clothing. [0] https://www.wsj.com/articles/how-nike-resisted-amazons-dominance-for-years-and-finally-capitulated-1498662435 https://www.wsj.com/articles/how-nike-resisted-amazons-domin... (paywall)
- FussyZeus 9y ago> Nike faced a similar situation where they felt that they could not effectively control their brand image so they pulled their products from Amazon. However, the product was still around as many individual re-sellers listed Nike products. So Nike ended up having even less control without having a relationship with Amazon [0]. This brings an interesting point though; is it fair in the market for a retailer/distributor to have such sway that not selling with them becomes a riskier proposition then selling with them? Isn't that the sort of thing that we have anti-trust laws for?
- bryanrasmussen 9y agoI suppose Nike could have a contract with their resellers requiring they not sell Nike products on Amazon.
- philipodonnell 9y agoIt sounds like that's exactly what Birkenstock has and it doesn't make a difference to Amazon.
- tmnvix 9y ago> Kahan added that he is considering legal action against Amazon.com for “knowingly encouraging a breach of our policy.” This seems like a very weak argument. For context, Kahan was referring to Amazon's offer to purchase retailers' Birkenstock products. Birkenstock do not sell to Amazon and forbid any of their stockists from supplying resellers.
- will_brown 9y agoWhy is that a weak argument and not a valid cause of action for tortious interference with a business relationship/contract?
- tmnvix 9y agoTo me (not a lawyer) it seems like a weak argument. The policies in question are Birkenstock's. Amazon doesn't necessarily know anything about the restrictions placed on the retailers.
- will_brown 9y agoIf this were to go to court during the discovery process Amazin would have to disclose all communications their employees had regarding the Birkenstock brand. Of course there would be other evidence that Amazon was on notice of violating Birkenstock's policy which Birkenstock would be able to produce, and it's hard to imagine employees didn't have internal communications in response.
- CWuestefeld 9y agoI can't recall the specifics now, but there have been recent cases showing that after the first sale, the manufacturer no longer retains any right to determine what happens to their products. So if a Birkenstock shop sells product to Amazon (not through Amazon, but to them), it's none of Birkenstock's business what Amazon does with it no matter what Birkenstock's policies are.
- losteverything 9y agoI find it amusing thay the first time i could not read a wapo article free from HN was now: about a negative Amazon article. So... Wsj.. Wapo and nyt (paywall me)
- tmnvix 9y agoFor the Washington Post and New York Times a new incognito session solves that problem.
- moocowtruck 9y agoanother option, open up dev console. go to settings and click disable javascript. all the content shows and none of the ad/bs crying crap does not
- Consultant32452 9y agoWaPo is owned by Amazon's CEO. [insert conspiracy theory here]
- morsch 9y agoReadily available on Amazon.de, from Amazon itself and from third party shoe sellers. Just saying. Quite a bit cheaper than in the US, too (sample size = 1).
- breakingcups 9y agoYou mean the counterfeits?
- morsch 9y agoI have no reason to believe they are counterfeits. Their shoes are 20% cheaper in Germany even when you buy from the official store. I think Birkenstock just has a different relationship with the German Amazon subsidiary. It's also conceivable that limiting the resale in the way they do in the US is simply not legal in Germany.
- blunte 9y agoConsidering the trouble other companies/sites have gotten into just by allowing _links_ to pirated goods and services (particularly audio video content), I cannot fathom why Amazon hasn't been slammed for hosting and selling so much obvious counterfeit goods.
- revelation 9y agoHosting, selling and shipping. How Amazon has not been bankrupted by suits is beyond me. They receive my money, they ship the item from their warehouse. They can tell tales all day but there simply is no third party anywhere close to this transaction.
- nerdponx 9y agoToo big to fail.
- bluejekyll 9y agoThis term was used for the banks. It implied that were they to fail, the economic fallout would be a disaster. I think it was also used for the American big three auto companies (two of which got a bailout). I don't think Amazon is in that category, do you? AWS definitely for the computing industry, but for sales like these it seems like it would be a boon for local retailers.
- nerdponx 9y agoYou are right, of course. But I'm cynical. The banks themselves were too big to fail. But their executives and directors were/are not "too big to jail", yet most of them walk free today. Amazon is increasingly woven into the fabric of our economy. How long before it truly is too "big" (read: has installed enough shills in government) to fail, or too big to punish? They would be following in the great traditions laid by oil companies, auto makers, telcos, and of course banks. Case in point: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14865112 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14865112
- heisenbit 9y agoeCommerce is all about cutting out the middle men. The only way goods can be sold in shops is if the shop is making enough money. The margin needs to be there to support space and people. Which means the distributors can't be allowed to have a big margin - if the had big ones they are tempted to do big sales to the like of Amazon undercutting individual shops. Which makes the role of traditional middle men tough. Also the fewer steps in the distribution the more commercial and contractual power the producer (provided a unique product) has. It is a war - product brands vs. platform brands. For the former controlling distribution is key.
- point78 9y agoAmazon.com as of writing my comment has tens of models listed. If birkenstock pulled their product how is Amazon allowed to list this?
- thiagocsf 9y agoIf Amazon can get their hands on stock, nothing stops them selling them. At least I believe there's no law against it.
- bluejekyll 9y agoWhat about counterfeit stock? Isn't Amazon liable for that?
- LeifCarrotson 9y agoYes, if someone buys the product and it turns out to be counterfeit, they can sue Amazon. But Birkenstock can't sue Amazon for selling legitimate Birkenstock products, and no one (so far) has been able to force an audit of Amazon warehouses to prove that their stock is legitimate. The problem is that Amazon can fall back on the possibility of unofficial resellers of hypothetically genuine Birkenstock goods - you or me walking into the mall, buying a pair of Birkenstocks, and reselling them on Amazon. This, obviously, isn't an efficient business model: You or I paying list price, adding our markup for our expenses and profit, and Amazon's profit demand that we find a way to get them at less than the price on the sticker at the mall to have a competitive price (or we just list them on Amazon at higher than list for people who want to NOT go to a Birkenstock shop and would instead prefer to have them appear on their doorstep...just saying...). Hypothetically, we could find them on sale, or go to the shop owner and get them at near wholesale prices under the table, or the shop owner could list them himself. Of course, the other hypothetical way we could make this business work is to make our own fake Birkenstocks and send those to Amazon. Amazon is just throwing their hands up and claiming they aren't responsible for determining which of these is the case. And I honestly don't understand why Birkenstock isn't able to bring them to court, get a warrant to check their warehouses, and prove that the goods they have are counterfeit. After this, they could either go for monetary damages and try to incentivize Amazon to self-police for fear of a repeat suit, or they could see if the judge is willing to force Amazon to stop listing products under the Birkenstock name.
- sevensor 9y agoMy running tally of reportedly counterfeit goods received from Amazon: * Consumer electronics * Hobby electronics * Footwear for aging hippies * Fashion footwear * Books (!) * Perfume * Clothing * Pet accessories * Bicycle accessories It doesn't seem to be hurting their business one bit.
- claudiulodro 9y agoI've heard a lot about people getting counterfeit books on Amazon. How does that work? Are the contents of the book the same as the legit version but it's been printed by a 3rd party?
- rev_null 9y agoIt could be copied from an advance copy, which lacks the final editing.
- sevensor 9y agoI've heard about people receiving books with the correct contents, but cheaply printed and bound.
- JosephLark 9y ago> Are the contents of the book the same as the legit version but it's been printed by a 3rd party? In the case I dealt with, yes. You can see some example here: https://artofelectronics.net/the-book/counterfeit-editions/ https://artofelectronics.net/the-book/counterfeit-editions/
- JohnTHaller 9y agoCounterfeit goods are routinely sold as legitimate on Amazon. It's the same listing as the legit product, too, just a different seller. Or it used to be. Since Amazon started intermingling their own inventory with Chinese counterfeit sellers, you have no idea whether you will get the real thing you ordered or a fake until you receive it regardless of which seller you order from.
- jschwartzi 9y agoThis is why I've stopped buying batteries on Amazon. Everything I get for my phone is counterfeit.
- brudgers 9y agoThis shows why I have come to use Amazon less and less over the years...no it's not the "piracy" bullshit. It's that Amazon is buying up goods at full retail and then marking them up and counting on my ignorance and impulse to turn a profit. In short, Amazon shopping has become adversarial. Its website is premised on dark patterns. That's why its search sucks and prices and terms change on the fly. Look how noisy Amazon's web page is, how long the delays are, and how far down the page important discriminating information...like the product description...is buried. In particular, Prime is designed to confuse the value proposition. It mixes in differential pricing, video on demand, and shipping. A person can't look at it and determine how Amazon makes money off of Prime. Having had Prime, the obvious way it profits is algorithmically. It just shows me more products that are cheaper elsewhere.
- paulcole 9y ago>It's that Amazon is buying up goods at full retail and then marking them up and counting on my ignorance and impulse to turn a profit. The fact that Amazon fooled you for so long is telling. Amazon's goals NEVER been to be the lowest price on everything. They want to provide the best value (convenience, trust, etc.) to the customer. And they do! I don't even comparison shop because I know Amazon will get my order here in 2 days and it won't be a hassle if I have to return it. Who cares if I'm paying an extra couple of bucks here and there?
- jorvi 9y agoPretty much this, yeah. I buy all my tech stuff at Amazon because I know if breaks down within 2 years, they will refund or replace it within a simple 5 minute livechat. Another experience: my (second-hand) Kindle Paperwhite suddenly started to displaying ads. It had never done this and I had specifically bought an ad-less version. Go to Amazon, open livechat - fixed within a few minutes. Another company would have probably told me tough luck and to buy the ad-removal.
- onli 9y agoConsidering the hassle I had when getting a laptop repaired that was not bought on Amazon (Lenovo refused to repair a display that no longer turned on because the plastic guide of one USB-slot fell out as well, and the vendor tried to to fuck us over by not taking it back/exchanging it; until I made a stink on social media), my next laptop will almost certainly be bought from Amazon exactly because of the service I saw them provide in similar cases (and it will certainly not be a Lenovo laptop. Never again). Only not if it is a special model bought from the producer, like System76 or something like that. But that is also because counterfeit goods are less of a problem with Laptops. For many other things Amazon has a real problem there. It's okay to be a bit more expensive if the service is good, it is not okay when I have to be one the lookout for fakes when buying there. And for the site I have that links to Amazon offers, all the scam offers that are or at the very least were active there ("send a mail to cheater@scamcompany.com before buying") were a real problem as well.
- samirillian 9y agoThat reminds me, I need some Birks. To the store locator!
- undersuit 9y agoHow do you know if the brick and mortar store has real Birkenstocks? You essentially have to buy Birkenstocks from the producing company, or the store could open up their finances so you could see the receipt of the store buying directly from Birkenstock.
- amyjess 9y agoThat "modern-day piracy" crack is terribly offensive, and it's going to backfire in his face. "Piracy on the high seas" is still a thing. People have been murdered, tortured, starved to near-death, and used as human shields by Somali pirates. To equate Amazon exercising the right of first sale by buying and reselling shoes to the violence perpetrated by Somali pirates is an insult to the survivors of actual piracy and to the families of anyone who was murdered by Somali pirates.
- Mefis 9y agoNo thread would be complete without someone taking offense at something...
- kstrauser 9y agoI used to believe that, too, until I learned that "piracy" as slang for "copyright infringement" dates to 1603: http://www.luminarium.org/renascence-editions/yeare.html http://www.luminarium.org/renascence-editions/yeare.html You are (and I was) 400 years out of date. That ship has sailed.
- eridius 9y agoSaying that nothing is piracy unless it involves murder, torture, and starvation is ridiculous.
- agentgt 9y agoI think (but I'm hardly certain) if the cost of fast shipping is reduced and provided for all companies we might start to see some downfall of Amazon. More and more I'm buying directly from companies websites. Its often cheaper, the service is often better, and the overall shopping experience can often be easier than Amazon (comparing products and colors on Amazon is a nightmare). The only real issue is not having 2 day shipping. This is why I think Amazon is investing so much in there own label/brand. If shipping is fast and cheap and most companies have a good ecommerce system and It was all aggregated (aka google) nicely why would I buy from Amazon? For so long people have said lower price is what drives sales. That people go where the lowest price is. I'm starting to think immediacy is now the higher priority. When I need baby wipes ... I needed them yesterday.... and I need them to work and be the correct ones.
- quadrangle 9y agoThis is fascinating. It's a (possibly too late) push back against a growing monopoly/monopsony but the approach is a heavy-handed rejection of First Sale doctrine and the positive aspects of open markets. Trademark should suffice, if enforced well, for customers getting the right products. On the other hand, a world in which absolutely everything is available at Amazon and most shoppers use it exclusively will be a terrifying one where Amazon will have true tyrannical power over the market.
- distances 9y agoThis is not a rejection of the first sale doctrine. This is about Birkenstock being free to choose their distributors. End users are of course free to sell their own shoes, and Birkenstock is free to choose for which retailers it will provide its stock.
- quadrangle 9y agoAll Amazon needs to do is get someone to go to a Birkenstock store and buy sandals and then sell them through Amazon. That's not the store selling to Amazon, it's selling to some customer who happens to then resell them on Amazon. The first-sale doctrine applies when Birkenstock is asking stores to figure out how to control what customers do with the sandals after they are sold.
- eridius 9y agoBirkenstock isn't asking stores to figure out how to control what customers are doing. The problem is Amazon is approaching the stores themselves and attempting to buy out their inventory. This has nothing to do with customers deciding to sell their purchased shoes to Amazon.
- Veratyr 9y ago> This is not a rejection of the first sale doctrine. This is about Birkenstock being free to choose their distributors. Not so, the article says "He emphasized that the German shoemaker prohibits shop owners from selling, distributing or shipping its products to resellers". It doesn't distinguish resellers from distributors. What if I buy a pair, never open or wear them, then a year later want to get rid of them by selling them as "New"? Under this policy the store I purchased them from would be closed.
- hari_sem3 9y agoWe operate a powerful brand tracking system to monitor branded products sold on Amazon. If you're a brand looking to protect your products, check out www.semantics3.com
- phreeza 9y agoIn this day and age, for items which do not operate on razor thin margins (like I imagine Birkenstocks are) I don't understand why there isn't a technical solution to this. Slap a unique qr code on every item leaving your plant, and have vendors check that code against your database every time they get new stock. Seems to me everybody wins? Which player is incentivised against this?
- tomhschmidt 9y agoYou're assuming that vendors are selling these counterfeit products unintentionally. There are fat margins to be had for counterfeit merchants on Amazon / eBay / Aliexpress.
- phreeza 9y agoYes for the merchants, but not for Amazon (I assume). They could do this for FBA items. Maybe even add a logo for items that are verified to be authentic this way.
- erikpukinskis 9y agoThe lower the price, the higher Amazon's sales volume, which is their top level metric.
- phreeza 9y agoThat is true in the first order, but in the long term, don't they run a huge risk of customer dissatisfaction shipping lots of counterfeit goods?
- kbart 9y agoLook at Amazon warehouse photos[0] and try to imagine how long it would take to scan every single item out there. Also, what happens when 1000 items have the same QR code? Do you inspect every of them individually to determine which one is genuine? Or do you discard everything, genuine products included? 0. http://thefrick.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/11/enhanced-buzz-wide-10564-1417008855-13.jpg http://thefrick.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/11/enhanced-buzz...
- thrillgore 9y agoIf there really is a piracy issue, why isn't ICE doing its job and investigating Amazon's suppliers? They can't just be handling immigration matters all day.