3 ms·
I don't think people like Musk or the others that he gets some of these ideas from, such as Kurzweil, are actually saying we shouldn't pursue advanced AI. Are
by ilaksh 9y ago
I don't think people like Musk or the others that he gets some of these ideas from, such as Kurzweil, are actually saying we shouldn't pursue advanced AI. Are they? I mean Musk helped fund OpenAI right?
He is just saying that it is actually an existential threat or will be soon enough that we need to consider the problem seriously.
I think the point of him mentioning that besides just worrying about it, is to motivate efforts like Neuralink that will allow for high-bandwidth communication between the brain and AIs.
There is some misunderstanding on the part of Zuckerberg and others that saying that AI is an existential risk is the same thing as saying 'we should suppress AI research'. You would not think that was the implication if you understood from the perspective of Kurzweil/Musk/other people who have read Kurzweil's/Bostrom's book(s) or think the same. The idea is that we cannot possibly stop advanced human-like and then human-surpassing AI from developing. No matter how hard we try to slow down AI development.
So when they say that AI can be dangerous, they do not mean that we should try to stop developing AI, since that is impossible. What they mean is that we should try to mitigate the risks to some degree. One way, which Musk and others are pursuing, is to try to create strong but friendly AI before some less friendly but equally potent variant becomes dominant. But if we do not develop some kind of high bandwidth interface with computers and AI that we control, eventually we should expect computer-based intelligence to significantly surpass our capabilities, to the point where we become irrelevant.
If you disagree that there is any possibility of strong AI or any existential threat, what harm is there in pursuing strong but friendly AI, or in developing the BCIs (brain-computer interfaces)? The only 'harm' I can see is if this gets oversimplified as it has been to the idea of "AIs could be bad, we must stop AI" -- which they are not trying to say.
- bredren 9y agoWasn't Elon's original point that he has current access to working AI demonstrations that personally frightened him, and served as the basis of his call for regulation?
- tim333 9y agoKinda though his arguments seem largely from first principles that robots will get smarter than us so we'd better be careful what they get up to. Here's him chatting a bit at "National Governors Association Streamed live on Jul 15, 2017" https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2C-A797y8dA&feature=youtu.be&t=48m9s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2C-A797y8dA&feature=youtu.be...