3 ms·
> Trucking is badly broken, especially in the US. I'd like to see this supported, particularly the "especially" part, given the extraordinary scale of hauling
by adventured 9y ago
> Trucking is badly broken, especially in the US.
I'd like to see this supported, particularly the "especially" part, given the extraordinary scale of hauling going on in the US via trucking. The economic facts on the ground in the US overwhelmingly disagree with you.
If it's so broken, and the US economy relies so much on it, how is the US GDP per capita so high? Both can't be true. It's either functioning well, leading to the high reliability and predictable delivery times we see today, assisting the US in having the most powerful economy on earth, or it's badly broken (where is the supporting economic evidence?).
- semi-extrinsic 9y agoThere are several ways trucking could be badly broken but still consistent with your statements: a) Say today, company X sells a thing for $100, of which $15 covers shipping cost, $15 is profit and $70 is what they paid their middleman for the thing. Suppose further that shipping cost could be reduced to $11 just by properly managing trucking, increasing the profit margin by 27%. These are of course made-up numbers, but just because a business is successful doesn't mean there are no inefficiencies left. b) It is well known that certain jobs take a huge toll on the people doing these jobs, causing early burnout, physical and/or mental health problems up to and including suicide, etc. E.g. drone pilots, people working with social media illegal content filtering have been covered in the media recently. If trucking causes lots of health issues, it's not just "badly broken" in the human compasdion sense, it also leads directly to reduced national economic output (with a 2x multiplier, you're taking away a taxpayer and adding an additional user of Medicaid/whatever).
- jessaustin 9y agoIf trucking causes lots of health issues... Visit a truck stop; take a look around. Truck drivers are in poorer health than late-morning Wal-Mart shoppers.
- someguydave 9y agoI would give another example: the US government subsidizes trucking (especially long distance trucking) to a much greater degree than freight railroads through building and maintaining highways. All things being equal the marginal cost of shipping via freight rail should be lower given its higher fuel efficiency.
- ams6110 9y agoTrucks operators pay a lot of road taxes.
- someguydave 9y agohttp://www.gao.gov/new.items/d11134.pdf http://www.gao.gov/new.items/d11134.pdf See the table on page 22. When you add together extra road maintenance, accidents, particulate & NO emissions, congestion and subtract the taxes and fees you end up with a cost to society of $55 per million ton-mile for trucking and $9 for rail.
- patrickg_zill 9y agoOnly low value, commodity items are shipped via rail however.
- jessaustin 9y agoI live pretty close to some train tracks, so I observe trains on a regular basis. There are a fair number of coal cars, which I guess is a "low value commodity", but that portion is dwarfed by the overwhelming majority of rail cars that transport intermodal shipping containers. Is everything in a shipping container a low value commodity? Would it really be faster to transport containers by truck, so they would actually only travel 10 out of every 24 hours? You seem to really misunderstand freight shipping.
- patrickg_zill 9y agoIntermodal = ultimately delivered by truck.
- jessaustin 9y agoThat is typically true but in no way supports your initial [incorrect] statement that only low-value commodities are shipped by train.
- Symbiote 9y agoYou may be surprised, but: "There are also more trucks operating in Europe than there are in the United States, with 63 trucks per 1,000 people in the EU — compared to only 21 trucks per 1,000 people in the United States." [1] The USA uses long distance rail freight far more than Europe, where the railways are full (i.e. at capacity) with passenger rail. That's in spite of much stricter controls on driving time. (I think there's also a fair amount of water transport in Europe. When I moved house from England to Denmark, my belongings were transported on a ship across the North Sea.) [1] https://www.theglobalist.com/america-and-europe-keep-on-trucking/ https://www.theglobalist.com/america-and-europe-keep-on-truc...