8 ms·
This is very neat from a technological point of view, but: who are these people who have hundreds and thousands of tabs open, and how can we get them the help t
by pavel_lishin 9y ago
This is very neat from a technological point of view, but: who are these people who have hundreds and thousands of tabs open, and how can we get them the help they need?
- sp332 9y agoAt this point it's not that much different from bookmarks.
- krzyk 9y agoAlmost. It is more like a temporary bookmark with an instant on feature. It is so easy to use and useful (and doesn't use much ram 8n Firefox) that I frequently hit 1000 tabs open. In Chrome it was impossible.
- overcast 9y agoWhile thousands is ridiculous, a hundred isn't that unreasonable. I often keep open many as I'm researching new things, or putting sites in my to follow up, or read later queue.
- jrimbault 9y agoThat's why "bookmarks" were invented for... I never understand any of my friends who keep having tens of tabs open. Just bookmark the thing and free up some CPU/RAM. It's a keystroke away.
- wvenable 9y agoNo bookmarks are for things I want to save; tabs are temporary. If I'm reading hacker news, I'll open all the articles I want to read in new tabs (maybe with their comments in yet another tab) and then go through them one at time. Obviously this is unmanageable in Chrome from the UI but with the right extensions (tab mix plus w/ multi row tabs) in Firefox it's pretty usable.
- Karunamon 9y agoTree tabs are godly for this because it lets you retrace your steps. Say you start on HN and open five articles. You've now got HN/Site1, HN/Site2, and so on. Then you find an interesting link on 3 of those 5 sites. With normal tabbing, you now have 9 tabs open and a majority of the text hidden on one line, where with a proper tree view, you can see the entire site, and how you got there, which is probably more valuable to me than the actual content.
- soapdog 9y agoFrom what I have seen, it is like RAM vs HD usage. You bookmark things that are going to be useful in the future, long term, while you keep tabs open while they are in current use such as when researching a topic. For example, when someting here breaks or I want to learn more about a given topic, it is not uncommon for me to use hundreds of tabs open while I triage what is useful and what is not. Some of those will be added to the bookmarks (or pocket, or pinboard, depending on how I like them). My personal workflow usually involves opening huge number of tabs researching something, then closing most of them later. So we can say that there are peaks of tab usage followed by a phase of organizing stuff. The advances in the recent Firefox releases really help me. But this is my own personal way of working, others may have different views.
- roryisok 9y agoI'm the same. In Vivaldi you can hibernate background tabs to free up memory. Then they get reloaded when focused
- jrimbault 9y agoI research many things (being a student and as part of my job). But I usually close useless tabs after reading them. I keep the main research tabs open, the trunk you could say, that trunk can always lead me back to the leafs.
- vernie 9y agoI don't want to bookmark any of my tabs.
- truebosko 9y agoMental thing. By having the tabs open (pinned), it's a reminder that I need to get this shit done. Eventually the ones that didn't get done are sent to the graveyard.
- overcast 9y agoIn my experience, bookmarks just get forgotten about. You end up with years of bookmarks, never revisited. Tabs are a visible reminder.
- Tomis02 9y agoBookmarks are mostly useless for read-later tabs because out of sight, out of mind, and there's always new stuff to read. Open tabs force you to make a decision - read me or close me. And, as usual, Opera 12 was the best browser of its time, and even today is orders of magnitude better than the current offerings, at least in some respects.
- Programmatic 9y agoTree-style tab and middle clicking means that you can have a hierarchical record of your browsing when researching. Middle click three to five tabs from a search, middle click from each tab when reading through on the first article for any interesting subarticles, then when you get to the bottom you have a visual record of your path to that point. To make things even better, when you're done with that research point you just kill the parent level tab and the children all go away too. Tens of tabs is pretty typical in my workday and improves my productivity vs. fewer tabs and forgetting how I got to a tangent.
- imtringued 9y agoMost people that have tens of tabs open google something then open every result in a new tab and basically use the tabs as a very short term todo queue. When you close the current tab you get moved to the next item in the queue. Managing bookmarks for something you're only reading for maybe two minutes isn't worth the effort. This also has the advantage of loading the pages in the background so you don't have to waste your time on bloated webpages.
- StavrosK 9y ago> While thousands is ridiculous, a hundred isn't that unreasonable That reads like "while <more than I use> is ridiculous, <as many as I use> isn't that unreasonable". I never have more than about ten tabs open, and a hundred strikes me as ridiculous too. To each his own, though, I guess.
- overcast 9y agoWell, a hundred is actually manageable. A thousand just takes up so much space, in any form, that you can't possible sort through them in any reasonable time.
- roryisok 9y agoSome extension that vertically groups tabs from the same domain would be great. I know in Vivaldi you can do this
- overcast 9y agoI still don't want to read A THOUSAND lines.
- naasking 9y agoI think you misunderstood. A tab per site, some kind of drop down-type interface per tab for each page on that site. So if you had 50 tabs, you'd have an average of 20 pages under each per tab. That would indeed be a much better use of space.
- craptocurrency 9y agoHaha. That's insane. For me 4-5 tabs are enough. Going beyond the limits and claiming the victory is nonsensical.
- andrethegiant 9y ago"I say, let your affairs be as two or three, and not a hundred or a thousand; instead of a million count half a dozen, and keep your accounts on your thumb nail." I bet Henry David Thoreau would say the same about browser tabs.
- aquadrop 9y agoWell, for example when I go into Wikipedia frenzy, I can easily open 10-20 tabs, terminology, graphs, tables, nested articles etc. It's much faster to switch between tabs than close and open them constantly. Why should I limit myself to 5? And yes, after an hour or two I usually get them off the stack one by one, collapsing back to first one, knowing much more about the history of Parliament in Canada.
- basch 9y agotabs combine bookmarks with back and forward buttons. if i open a new tab and want to go "back" I switch tabs. now i have both states saved, which is good for speed and keeping my location on a page. tabs dont do a good job of showing me "how" i got somewhere", especially once I convert them to bookmarks. to "solve" the tab problem, you need to combine tabs, history, bookmarks, back/forward buttons, pinboard/tags/pagecache into groups that are instantly rearrangable by their proximity to each other: spatially, by topic, or temporally. i should be able to, in one command, show only tabs that are hacker news or originated from hacker news, but maybe something i googled while on one of those pages deserves to be related. now the machine should be making inferences on what goes where, and i give it feedback when it is wrong. tabs should be more like a wiki document, where as i accumulate more about, say, stagecoaches, or good reads from redef, those metadata relationships to topics and origins are preserved. i should be able to go back and show only bookmarks from only hackernews/redef/longreads combined, and only the ones about stagecoaches. i know mozilla has shown a demo of something like this, but its a long way from being more useful than tabs, because it neglects the content of the page itself.
- vannevar 9y agoTabs seem like a poor visualization of your browsing history. A history tree of your last N sites seems like it would be a lot more useful and informative (not to mention compact). Tabs don't show the tree relationship.
- infogulch 9y agoTrue, but right now it's the only way to access it. History itself is useless for this purpose.
- seanp2k2 9y agoYou really need a graph with a timeline / histogram or similar. See my previous comment which has more ideas. I hope someone builds this, but I know that the way to see it happen is to go do it.
- 9y ago
- msla 9y agoI know you're joking, but the "You're holding it wrong" mentality is one reason I'll probably never go back to proprietary software: The style of software which attempts to prescribe certain workflows and proscribe others inevitably reaches a point where it pisses me off.
- Macha 9y agoYeah, getting a bit of: "Chrome is so much better for my usecase. Look how much Firefox usage has declined, Firefox should just die" "Here's my use case which Firefox is better at" "Your use case is invalid!" from HN comments this week.
- denzil_correa 9y agoI personally know many people with approx. 50 tabs open. The reason was that they opened the tabs, want to read but haven't got around to reading it yet. They wouldn't want to invest time in maintaining it into a Reading List software.
- tangent128 9y agoKnowing myself, if I kept a separate reading list, I would never revisit it. Leaving a tab open means I'll actually stumble across the page again.
- aquadrop 9y agoI tried reading lists, didn't work. I treat tabs as pieces of information fighting for my attention. Some win, some don't and get closed after several weeks or months... :)
- maxerickson 9y agoThe link describes the Firefox devs helping by improving performance for their use case.
- Arcsech 9y agoThe use of what most HN users would consider an absurd number of tabs is shockingly (to me anyway) common among the non-tech-worker crowd. I'd say about half of my family members that don't work in tech have at least dozens and probably hundreds of tabs open at any given time. I think it's the sort of thing where this works well enough for the same purpose that other people use a read-later or bookmarking system for, and it's reliable enough that people don't care to switch (or don't know there's an alternative). It's good that Firefox is trying to adapt to the way people use technology, rather than trying to force people to adapt to how the technology works - I think that's a much faster road to widespread adoption, and it creates more goodwill on the part of their users.
- xbmcuser 9y agoI can understand opening 20-30 tabs but with 100 or so it would take me longer to find the tab then just searching it for in Google or history. I went from Netscape/internet explorer to Firefox then because of the frequent crashes and how slow it was to Chrome. I am to entrenched in the Google eco system to change now so just can hope this will make Chrome cut down on the bloat.
- eitland 9y ago> but with 100 or so it would take me longer to find the tab then just searching it for in Google or history. With FF when you start to type it intelligently suggests tabs you already have open. Perfect for keyboard lovers like me :)
- weaksauce 9y agoI think this is a pretty common practice. I know I have hundreds of tabs open as a temporary bookmark system over many windows(48 windows, 354 tabs right now) ... to the point that I made a simple extension to find what I am looking for visually and have links on the page that focus that window and tab. I find it pretty useful in practice. firefox: https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/tabist/ https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/tabist/ chrome: https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/tabist/hdjegjggiogfkaldbfphfdkpggjemaha https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/tabist/hdjegjggiog... source: https://github.com/fiveNinePlusR/tabist https://github.com/fiveNinePlusR/tabist
- Yoric 9y agoWell, I am. I often use tabs as my todo/toread list. I generally have ~100 of them open, on Firefox.
- reifnir 9y agoHi, I'm Jim and I'm a tabaholic. It's been 3 months since I cleaned-up my tabs
- azinman2 9y agoI worked on a prototype new browser that understood this exact need -- visualizing browsing sessions -- so that you can quickly go to where you need. We used additional information, such as how long you spent on a page, to avoid cluttering it with less important information. Ultimately we were convinced by a former Mozilla C-type that getting people to switch their browsers was a herculean task (especially on the iPad where you can't change default browsers) and we moved on. http://www.azinman.com/stateless http://www.azinman.com/stateless
- the8472 9y agoEasy recipe to accumulate tabs: - make a habit of Ctrl+T before googling something - open all outgoing links in new background tabs so you can continue reading the current page - leave several pages of reference material open (e.g. docs, issue trackers, random blog posts relevant to whatever you're doing) - open links that someone sends you to work on them later And once the inevitable distraction hits you you might forget closing some.
- nice_byte 9y agoI have all of these habits, yet my number of open tabs never goes over ~20. I just garbage-collect often :)
- huntie 9y agoI have >450 tabs open right now, so I guess this is me. I said this the other day, but I use the Tab Groups plugin, and I have a different group for each project I work on. For example, I have a keyboard group with pages related to DIY keyboards. I don't have the resources to make my own keyboard right now, but I don't want to lose the research I've done. My keyboard group lets me keep my research available in the state I left it, allowing me to quickly get up to speed when I have time to work on it. It's not as though I have hundreds of tabs in one group, it would be inconvenient to access all but 20-30 of them. I think most users with similar amounts of tabs use plugins like tab groups or tree-based tabs to manage their tabs.
- mikeash 9y agoI don't usually get to hundreds, but it does happen sometimes, and for me it's just a matter of forgetfulness or laziness. It's easy to open new tabs, and easy to forget to close old ones, so they tend to accumulate. Eventually I'll try to find something I already had open, realize I have way too many tabs open, and go through and close all the ones I no longer need, and then the cycle repeats.
- Macha 9y agoYo. Reasons I have a lot of tabs open: 1. Google searching problem. The first result is rarely a complete solution to a problem if I've resorted to Google. Maybe it's a partial solution, maybe it's no good at all. Usually I'll open anything looking relevant from the first page, skim through them, if they don't have a quick answer I'll check the next. Then I'll eliminate any that are totally not relevant. If any have partial answers, I'll keep them around while searching related search terms. See also searching our jira instance for related issues when I know this is very similar to something that's came up before. 2. Programming docs have this annoying habit of sticking one class per page, meaning I usually have to have multiple pages open to understand some area of a library if I'm unfamiliar with it. 3. Reddit/HN threads often send me on tangents down links while I keep the parent threads open. 4. Sometimes I'll go on an aside and do something else while keeping my previous context open for when I return. Yes, I could bookmark them, but bookmarks are a lot more awkward to load back and also mentally feel like they're for something a lot more permanent than "I might need in 3-4 hours but won't need it tomorrow". Plus when it's not costing me much to not have to put up with the reload time... 5. Sometimes I open new windows to view multiple pieces of content at once. Sometimes I end up following links in these new windows. 6. Sometimes I open new windows to create a seperate context for a new piece of research when the previous one might be still relevant. I have tried pinboard, pocket when it was readitlater, browser bookmarks, etc. None of them have really solved this use case and I tend to forget about using them after a while. I tend to idle in the 5-20 range, go up to the 50s when researching. Hitting 100+ happens many days, and my record is closing out a browser with 354 open tabs.
- riquito 9y agoWhy do you think they need help? If their memory works differently and they have everything organized, what's there to fix? Just enjoy that Firefox is faster and less memory hungry for everybody.
- dbalbright 9y ago::waves:: It's generally from researching a topic while working on a project. It's a bit like a cache of bookmarks, you don't really know what you're going to need until you've made some headway and found what was truly helpful that you may need later versus what you can safely close.
- navinsylvester 9y agoThe subtitle even mentions the term 'power user' but still. Cheesy comments on top - way to go fanboys. But seriously why do HN folks love chrome?. We talk about privacy as fundamental right but are ok with chrome. We all know it's a memory hog but still are ok with it.
- ssivark 9y agoTab-o-phile reporting! I currently have ~500 tabs open, unevenly distributed among 20 "tab groups". It's very much like expecting your editor/IDE to open a bunch of files and git status when you switch to a "project". - I'm pursuing a multi-pronged agenda which requires context switches to get different things done (multiple projects/activities, each with their own group eg: communication, project1 at work, project2 at work, paying my bills, topic FOO that I've been reading about in the evenings, HN content, etc. ). I prefer for my browser to display the state at which I left things, including the possible resources I was consulting -- so that I can continue from exactly where I left off. Also, one might actually want to save the state of the javascript objects on the page or something, rather than just the URL! - A lot of my browser activity has the flavor of research. A lot of searching, consulting references, trying out things in Jupyter notebooks, etc. - A large part of it is keeping track of interesting things to look into. Whether you call those "bookmarks" or "open tabs" is just jargon, since Firefox only loads tabs on demand. So, for all practical purposes, it has an amazingly convenient way to save context, without having to click once for each page. And closing a tab feels easier than deleting a bookmark. I sometimes think that this might be the electronic analogue of some (creative?) people who have messy offices and are able to get along just fine. As an example, refer to the recent discussions about Claude Shannon's style: 1. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14819377 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14819377 2. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14774163 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14774163 3. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14776520 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14776520
- setr 9y agoI have the opposing opinion Who are these people with a shockingly low number of tabs, and how do we get them the help they need? Those I usually see with few tabs are either those who only browse the web for extremely simple things (ie facebook, netflix and google for very simple questions), or those who only just maintain like a single docs page at any given moment. The hell kind of absurd usage pattern is that? Do you keep one book on your shelf too? Do you just not have any interests? Nothing but one thing at a time? I keep around ~300 tabs and a heavily organized bookmarks storage with some 400 links; tabs are ram and bookmarks are disk. How else would you naturally organize your web-information? I can only imagine you have very little information to organize...
- pavel_lishin 9y ago> Do you keep one book on your shelf too? I would argue that 300 tabs is like having 300 open books piled on your desk. > Do you just not have any interests? Yes, and my bookshelves - and bookmarks - are crammed full of them. But I don't need to have every project I'm working on on my desk. I guess it's pretty arbitrary, but I find it easier to organize things in bookmarks - for certain things, hierarchically in folders; for others, with tags - but if I'm done working on Thing X, and want to start working on Thing Y, I don't want to have to search through my 300 open tabs to figure out where things are. An advantage of many open tabs, I will freely admit, is that they're typically scrolled to where you last left off, sometimes with information pre-filled if it's something interactive.
- saurik 9y agoThere is absolutely no technical reason why bookmarks and tabs are separate concepts: if there is a way to search and organize bookmarks more easily that should be applied to tabs, and the idea that a tab has to be some kind of constantly-open running program burning RAM and CPU is essentially a mistake made only by Google (and we can probably guess why they like that), as the only permanent state of a tab is the history of URLs it represented (which can be easily verified by rebooting: if the browser doesn't save it to disk it isn't part of the semantic state).
- Mithaldu 9y agoWho are you, why are you so cruel, and how can i get you help to be not cruel?
- eitland 9y ago> who are these people who have hundreds and thousands of tabs open, I'm one! I'm a happy software/systems/knowledge engineer. > and how can we get them the help they need? Thanks for asking! Here is my idea: Make an even better solution! What I need: An effortless[0] way to research big topics. This includes - multi-path discovery (currently solved by ctrl-clicking to open links that looks useful or interesting in a sub-tab-tree while continuing to read the piece I'm already reading.) - possibility to bookmark stuff I work on effortlessy and with cross-device sync. I currently use pinboard which is great. I'm not even fully utilizing it (.tags for instance is a part I'm sure I'm not utilizing as much as I should.) My current setup has a few weaknesses, e.g.: - I want a way to stash away everything down to the position of the windows (no, I actually don't think I need that, but I really would like: the current windows, the current tabs, nested the way they are etc etc). Why? In case I want to switch to another task (e.g. urgent request). - I want an even better "OneNote" that integrates effortlessly with FF (or whatever you create to replace it). - A tool to automatically transcribe booooring videos or at least extract the juicy few seconds that I need :-P Feel free to suggest more great ideas here. [0]: Yep, if you want a chance to replace my exiting system effortless is your goal.
- badloginagain 9y agoTab trees would be pretty cool, especially if you list tabs in column view like I do. Opening a link in a new tab would list as a child tab, and the list of child tabs could be collapsed/hidden. Drag child tabs out of the tree to become parents themselves. This would be great for dynamic research tasks. You could collapse trees and get a top level view, useful if you're in the weeds; you could close trees by parent, great for killing avenues of research you no long need. It would also be good for when you need to quickly check the syntax of something or fix a minor bug without disrupting the larger project you're focusing on. From a Dev/LiveOps perspective, it would be huge- grouping all my AWS pages, CMS pages, custom dashboards, would be a huge help. I can easily sprawl tens of separate tabs to get different services to talk to eachother.
- eitland 9y agoThis is exactly what we are used to in FF! Currently we are in a position where we'll push for devs to provide the necessary APIs going forward and I'll be happy to have more people along to push for that. (Also, AFAIK Mozilla will provide a LTS version of the last version that will work with real extensions.)
- BeetleB 9y ago>and how can we get them the help they need By telling them about OneTab.
- DennisP 9y agoHere's the help I need: make a button I can push to save the urls of all open tabs to a separate history, and close the tabs. There's too much noise in the regular history. Bonus points if the saved urls are grouped by the window they were in. I tried making a chrome plugin for this, but with a lot of tabs it didn't work reliably, and I didn't have time to put more work into it.
- pkkm 9y agoYou can create a "to read later" folder in your bookmarks, then right click the tab bar in each window and select "Bookmark All Tabs". That's fairly close to what you're describing, and also works with Firefox Sync (though in my experience it's best to keep the number of bookmarks below 5000 for Sync to work well).