24 ms·
Buying time promotes happiness
- atomashpolskiy 9y agoWhat these scholars are pushing for eerily resembles good old aristocratic society. Instead of promoting to consume less (having smaller houses and less clothes, producing less garbage, eating less) they advocate for buying a couple sturdy negroes to do the hard work, while their master can learn to play the piano (and not feel bored/unhappy to cleanup his own shit). Has the western society already arrived at the point, when there is such an abundance of low-income, unskilled, badly educated people, that the capitalists from Harvard Business School see big potential profits in building a brand new time-saving services industry with all this underutilized labour?
- christophilus 9y agoYeah. This is pretty much the same problem I had with the book "The 4 Hour Work Week". The ultimate solution in my opinion is to automate crappy jobs out of existence and to set up social safety-nets for the displaced workers so that their quality of life increases.
- atomashpolskiy 9y agoCrappy jobs still bring some income that can then be spent on consuming, often with the leverage of bank loans, keeping the wheels of the economy spinning. Who could be more striving for buying and consuming than a person who can hardly afford anything?
- christophilus 9y agoRight. I'm looking at it not from an economics perspective, but from a humanitarian perspective. As much as possible, we should be trying to eliminate drudgery and misery from the human condition. I remember watching a documentary about a sulfur mine in southeast Asia. The average life expectancy for miners there was something like 2-5 years. It's crazy to me that anyone would even take that job, but: A. The miners probably didn't know the life expectancy B. The miners didn't have much of an alternative C. The society viewed (views?) them as expendable I think this is an excellent illustration of an area where automation needs to be done, but market forces won't encourage it. The labor is just too cheap. But just because the economics doesn't work, it doesn't mean we shouldn't do it. Economics shouldn't be the only consideration.
- atomashpolskiy 9y agoI absolutely agree with you. In the above comment I was just speculating on the possible economical/political reasoning behind the lack of automation. In addition to simply being cheaper than automated solutions (in the short run), cheap labour might also be seen by capitalists/governments as an economical agent, that is more preferable for the economy with regards to increasing GDP, than those on welfare, because the former still has some spare money to spend, and welfare covers only the very basic needs. I agree that it's truly awful that in some extreme cases people have to pay with their health/life to be a part of a consumerist society.
- ivcha 9y agoNon sequitur. Your whole conclusion is based on an non-existing premise, or one that has little sense. It's not clear why you think this article suggests precluding a healthy system in which people have the ability to afford time-saving services (in exchange of their service to others, which is arguably a foundation of any sane such system). Moreover, it's not clear what does consumption have anything to do with the point of the article; it seems rather orthogonal.
- haddr 9y agoWhat are most common/important time saving services? (couldn't find any example in the original paper)
- joaomacp 9y agoI can't find it also... You would assume the paper would mention what the time saving services are... It's the main subject!
- e59d134d 9y agoHome cleaning. I was reluctant to let a stranger clean my home but it is totally worth it. My maid cleans home better than I ever did, and she is faster. I used to use laundry service, that was amazing.
- sethbannon 9y agoCan someone explain why they're sure this is causation and not correlation? Intuitively it seems to me a happier person would be more inclined to spend money on buying extra time than someone who's unhappy, who would be more inclined to spend on things or experiences.
- jonchang 9y agoWell, the text is free so you can just read the article... Though most of the paper's studies are based on observational and survey data, which is typically where the 'correlation is not causation' criticism is most effective, the authors actually perform a experiment. They give $40 to two groups of participants and task them to make a time-saving purchase and a material purchase, and survey their happiness after each purchase. Their results from this experiment are inconsistent with your proposed hypothesis as they've controlled for baseline happiness by randomizing the groups. See materials and methods, study 8 from the linked article. Edit: it's also in the abstract! "A field experiment provides causal evidence that working adults report greater happiness after spending money on a time-saving purchase than on a material purchase."
- kiith_naabal 9y agoIt's a good point, though they did also measure how time-stressed people felt. People who felt time-poor but didn't buy time-saving services had poorer life satisfaction. If you were time stressed and bought the services, you were protected from some of the negative effects. "In contrast, for respondents who spent money on time-saving purchases (n = 804), the negative effect of time pressure on life satisfaction was relatively weak, B = −0.03, Z = 1.46, P = 0.144, 95% CI (−0.08, 0.01). These results suggest that using money to buy time indeed buffers people from the negative effects of time stress on well-being."
- j7ake 9y agoExperiments never show causation. The caution comes from interpretation of the data, which varies between scientist to scientist. You could say the additional experiments they did were not sufficient evidence but the proper response should be a suggestion of a new experiment that would convince you rather than saying "correlation is not causation ".
- slindz 9y agoFor those who read comments here first, I read the abstract, here's my tl;dr: The people in developed countries who buy themselves things to save time are happier than those who don't. Yup. Sounds about right.
- neilwilson 9y agoCall me old fashioned, but rather than working yourself silly to then spend your money buying time back, why don't we set society up so that you have to work less in the first place to earn a living? Are we not back to the parable of the fisherman and the banker? http://www.garywu.net/fisherman-and-banker/ http://www.garywu.net/fisherman-and-banker/
- atomashpolskiy 9y agoMore work produces more goods/services to sell, why would capitalists cut back on their profits?
- beaconstudios 9y agobecause not all capitalists work for publicly traded companies where they are legally bound to maximise profits. There are plenty of businesspeople out there who aren't constantly seeking out new ways to increase profits. Usually small business owners.
- atomashpolskiy 9y agoWhat kind of impact do these lifestyle businesspeople have on an average person's life? Or do you mean that they are a good example of giving up on pursuing wealth in exchange for spare time and unquantifiable humanly joys?
- beaconstudios 9y agoI mean they're a good model of what healthy capitalism can look like. Provide valuable services, don't work your employees to death to maximise profits for the mob-rule of shareholders, stay small and focus on well-roundedness. I'm very pro-capitalism and I can't stand the enterprise model of business, it's very dehumanising.
- shusson 9y ago> why don't we set society up so that you have to work less in the first place to earn a living I think in practice this is very hard and would require modification of economic fundamentals e.g at a very broad level capitalism vs socialism.
- contingencies 9y ago"Dutch millionaires don't spend money to save time." I had to laugh :)
- z3t4 9y agoA full article with click-able links! Now entrepreneurs need to read this and invent robots that does all the house chores!
- tonyedgecombe 9y agoWe have been working on that for decades, vacuum cleaners, washing machines, dish washers, ready meals, etc. It seems we aren't great at allocating the time these devices free up.
- ZeroGravitas 9y ago"What was the greatest invention of the industrial revolution? Hans Rosling makes the case for the washing machine. With newly designed graphics from Gapminder, Rosling shows us the magic that pops up when economic growth and electricity turn a boring wash day into an intellectual day of reading." http://www.gapminder.org/videos/hans-rosling-and-the-magic-washing-machine/ http://www.gapminder.org/videos/hans-rosling-and-the-magic-w...
- z3t4 9y agoWhen it takes two hours for a robot/machine to do something that would take you five minutes, most people will think that's one hour and 55 minutes wasted, while it's actually five minutes saved
- TeMPOraL 9y agoIf someone else is looking for what the study actually means by "buying time", this is the closest thing to an answer that I found in the text: > In all samples, respondents completed two questions about whether—and how much—money they spent each month to increase their free time by paying someone else to complete unenjoyable daily tasks.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- watwut 9y agoSo basically, you are more happy if someone else does tasks you don't like? Makes sense I guess ...
- cJ0th 9y agoI wonder what types of jobs cleaners would outsource
- slfnflctd 9y agoI once found myself in the odd position of working as a janitor while hiring a maid to clean my floors and surfaces at home (only before having guests over) because I couldn't find the time and energy after I was done with my regular job. The biggest one I can think of is car repair, or driving itself. Mostly it would probably be indirect stuff like food prep, though-- dollar menus and cheap frozen dinners. For the 'working poor', being able to spend less time cooking is an accessible luxury that's hard to resist.
- samat 9y agoDid someone find in the article the actual services people used? I am struggling with what would they be. House cleaning? Food delivery?
- koliber 9y agoA friend once presented me with a model of thinking about work and time. Categorize all tasks on two scales: how much you like doing something, and how good you are at it. Now, draw a square and break it into four quadrants. One will be "good at it, but don't like doing it". Another will be "Good at it, and like doing it". The remaining ones are "Bad at it, but like doing it" and "Bad at it, and don't like doing it". Assuming you have resources to hire help and outsource, consider doing the following: For things you like doing that you are good at, make that your main job. You will be effective and happy. For things you don't like doing and are bad at, outsource. If you try doing these yourself, you will be miserable, and the outcome will be sub-par (you're bad at it!). For things you like doing and are bad at, make that your hobby. For the things that you don't like doing but are good at, either do them yourself or outsource, depending on your time availability and resources to hire help. I've been doing this for a few years as much as possible. Even at home, my wife and I naturally divide chores along these lines.
- austinjp 9y agoTwo-by-two grids are almost ubiquitous in management circles. They go by many names: BC grids after Boston Consultancy Group, decision matrices, and so on. They crop up in Covey's 7 Habits. They're extremely useful for concisely articulating a tightly-defined situation and mapping items in order to make decisions. Their weakness is that they may oversimplify and lack nuance. I used to use important/urgent decision grids quite frequently at work. http://www.informit.com/articles/article.aspx?p=709139&seqNum=7 http://www.informit.com/articles/article.aspx?p=709139&seqNu...
- kangman 9y agoWhat about things that you don't like that would have a material benefit to you in the long run? A simple example being exercise. Decision matrices seem bound for immediate needs.
- mseebach 9y agoThese models aren't meant to be algorithms you can mechanically life your life by, they are helpful in thinking (differently) about a number of things. Exercise is clearly an example of something that's important but non-urgent in Covey's model. The good-at/enjoys model is mostly applicable to things you've decided (or had decided for you) you have to do, somehow. Once you've decided that exercise is something you should do, thinking about it in terms of good-at/enjoys can be helpful in deciding how to go about it.
- koonsolo 9y agoIn Belgium we have this great thing called servicecheques (="dienstencheques"). It is a government sponsored project where you can buy a servicecheque for 9 euro's, and you will get 3 euro's back from taxes. Each cheque represents 1 hour of work such as house cleaning, ironing, meal preparing, etc. This system is to promote low-wage work, but also has the nice benefit so people can cheaply buy home services. Wages are pretty high in Belgium, so this is an ideal solution for both people doing that kind of work, and working people in high need for such services.
- bb611 9y agoIs there a lot of demand for these jobs? In the US I would have to pay 1.5-2x that for housework, which puts it squarely into a category of value that I just do myself
- 1337biz 9y agoMain reason for the scheme is in my opinion to force people into paying taxes. It is probably a market where tax evasion is the most invisible because already some sort of trust relationship is in place.
- somberi 9y agoSomewhat related: Henry David Thoreau wrote in Walden, "The cost of a thing is the amount of what I will call life which is required to be exchanged for it, immediately or in the long run." And also: "I too had woven a kind of basket of a delicate texture, but I had not made it worth any one's while to buy them. Yet not the less, in my case, did I think it worth my while to weave them, and instead of studying how to make it worth men's while to buy my baskets, I studied rather how to avoid the necessity of selling them."
- eptcyka 9y agoI think that if I was able to afford to buy time, I would be happier, but not necessarily because I was buying time.
- tlanc 9y agoI'm not seeing anything described in the article as "buying time" that couldn't also be described as "buying the right to order someone else around" aka "delegating". Surely the most direct way of buying time is by taking a pay cut in exchange for more time off, or even taking unpaid time off. It occurs to me there may be a good proxy for this in comparing similar tech jobs in the US vs the EU / UK. The latter pay less, but receive substantially more time off.
- smcdow 9y ago> Surely the most direct way of buying time is by taking a pay cut in exchange for more time off, or even taking unpaid time off. We don't get those choices. I tried for YEARS to engineer a long-term part-time career in the software industry, and I couldn't get it to happen. I'm perfectly happy to trade more free time for less money, but there are just no takers out there. The industry isn't interested. As far as taking unpaid time off -- usually, that happens after you've quit your previous job and before you've started the next one.
- tlanc 9y agoI can think of two ways you can trade money for time as a SWE: 1) Amazon has started to offer part-time jobs for SWE's (https://www.flexjobs.com/jobs/telecommuting-jobs-at-amazon https://www.flexjobs.com/jobs/telecommuting-jobs-at-amazon) 2) relocating from the US to UK / EU gives you 25-100% more PTO and shorter hours in exchange for lower salaries
- smcdow 9y ago1. Interesting, except the part where Flexjobs wants you to pay to look at job listings. Primary indication of a scam. 2. Yes, it is super-easy to get a visa to work in the UK or EU.
- starbuxman 9y agoSkipTheDrive lists remote software jobs, and doesn't charge a fee for job seekers.
- jonbarker 9y agoComplication: anything you are good at you will want to practice to improve. And deliberate practice is by definition frequently uncomfortable (not enjoyable).
- majewsky 9y agoI can confirm this anecdotally. I bought some thyme just last week and seeing the spice shelf restocked made me very happy.
- wu-ikkyu 9y ago"he sacrifices his health in order to make money. Then he sacrifices money to recuperate his health. And then he is so anxious about the future that he does not enjoy the present; the result being that he does not live in the present or the future; he lives as if he is never going to die, and then dies having never really lived."
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- praisecanada 9y agoThe journal is called "PNAS" ?! Is that a joke?
- BeetleB 9y agoPNAS is one of the more prestigious journals out there. Not sure what you find funny.
- SAI_Peregrinus 9y agoNo. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences is one of the better journals out there.
- greggman 9y agoI'm actually surprised more people don't buy time. I used to pay to have my laundry done. first it was part of a 3hrs for $60 of house cleaning I used to pay for in the mid 90s once every two weeks. Then later when I moved into a apartment with no washer. I loved it. Also loved the house cleaning when it was good. Would love to pay for some kind of shared personal assistant that would deal with whatever. I'm not sure how much I'd be willing to pay. I rent a cube at an office with shared assistants that charge for individual services. each phone call $3 for example. I'd love to be able to pay for someone to deal with all my bills, taxes, mail, basic shopping ...
- davidjnelson 9y agoThis is really interesting. I've thought about this. If you live in an area where a living wage is low enough to make this work, it could be really great for everyone. Say for example, you hire a college student for $15/hour in an area where minimum wage is $10/hour and their rent is $400/mo to work part time for you buying food, cooking food, doing laundry, and cleaning your house. They make $1,200/month, plenty to live comfortably as a college student while still having time to study. They need medical coverage from their college, but this seems to be offered. Then you don't have to worry about those tasks anymore and life becomes much better. If you make good money, that $1,200/mo is no biggie. Win/win.