7 ms·
Someone is massively registering multiple *.eth domains
- hartator 9y agoIt's not unfair if he is paying for them.
- 45h34jh53k4j 9y agothis is the 'cocacola' problem. No strong name system can work in the real world if cocacola has no legal right to their name. Sue a smart contract, lol! Considering cryptocurrencies supposedly 'square' zooko's triangle, a fraud namespace like this eth registration can not survive the real world.
- knocte 9y agoI guess we won't see massive migration from DNS usage to ENS usage in a matter of days. I foresee we'll have mixed usage decentralized and centralized naming systems for a long time until people start seeing the advantages of the former. By that time, CocaCola will just have to buy the domain from the squatter instead of registering themselves (too big to fail, on this matter).
- 45h34jh53k4j 9y agoI agree, there will be both central and decentralized namespaces; I do love the idea of decentralized, but I am realistic about the limitations. CocaCola can ether buy the keys (or have a court requisition them from something.. ) Now, this relies on the keys that registered this domain still existing! No court in the world can force a deleted key to be transferred to CocaCola. Likewise any cryptocurrency cannot be forceably stolen by the threat of state violence -- the math does not permit it. So either, cocacola has to have cocacola1.eth (lol), or they have to institute a court ordered hard fork to recover the keys. Both seem undesirable!
- wslh 9y agoNo, I think it can work in another way: at the end the descentralized system is connecting to a protocol outside the blockchain, this is the weakest link. You can contact the legal entity using ETH and sue them in the country they operate. Switzerland? https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/ETH_Domain https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/ETH_Domain
- 45h34jh53k4j 9y agoSo the scenario becomes: a) use DNS b) use "central"-ENS, but if the domain is already registered now I have to sue some .ch organisation to unregister it. c) use regular ENS and live with whatever namespace entries are free a) offers everything b offers, but its likely cheaper and has a real-world dispute resolution process. Take a look at the grandfather of decentralized DNS namespace; .bit from namecoin. After 6 years it has not found its place in the internet name ecosystem.
- gst 9y ago> Likewise any cryptocurrency cannot be forceably stolen by the threat of state violence -- the math does not permit it. You're underestimating violence. They just need the key: https://imgs.xkcd.com/comics/security.png https://imgs.xkcd.com/comics/security.png Of course that's going to be harder if you don't know who holds the key, but judging from all the raided darknet markets it's definitely not impossible to figure that out.
- DonbunEf7 9y agoIt's 2017. Stop letting users pick their own identifiers.
- grayhatter 9y agolol wut... As opposed to? Wait, let me guess, UUIDs right?
- SkyMarshal 9y agoActually, yes, UUID's would be ideal. Then we'd just a public registrar of some sort to index them with a more human-readable name.
- BenjiWiebe 9y agoI hope this is sarcasm. The human readable IDs would than be squatted upon.
- 0xJRS 9y agoDon't feed the troll
- SkyMarshal 9y agoYes it was sarcasm :D. I wouldn't insult anyone's intelligence here by adding a /s
- a_t48 9y agoDid you pick your HN id?
- DonbunEf7 9y agoNo. I do not know how this name was chosen.
- al_chemist 9y ago25 days ago someone brought 600 domains that does not exist. That is not a news.
- xur17 9y agoYeah, I was expecting hundreds of thousands based on the title. This doesn't seem like news.
- pdelbarba 9y agoI don't understand why domain squatting in general isn't considered more of a problem. I tried a couple different times to get a .link domain for my blog and just about anything short/meaningful on the obscure tlds are taken, but none of them are actually used for anything. They wanted $5k for sym.link...WTF?!? I actually sort of appreciate the logic behind the .sucks tld managers if not the intent. You can't squat everything if the registration actually costs something semi significant.
- pan69 9y agoI agree with you. But what do you expect from a system that allows you to create real-estate out of thin air?
- FussyZeus 9y agoI recently had a communique with a domain squatter who held myname.com, wanted $100k for it. I actually asked if he was on drugs. According to the wayback machine that domain has been parked since 2002. 15 years of annual renewals, never been sold apparently, never actually held a website (or seemingly any services) yet somehow that equals $100k. Domain parkers should be booted from the Internet. It's the most useless, scummy form of business.
- ChuckMcM 9y ago
- Phlow 9y agoCan someone tell me why I'm seeing so much about ethereum on Hacker News lately? It's starting to feel like a concerted marketing push, the same way that the latest Kardashian outrage is a non-event most people don't care about, but they sure make it look like news...
- nshung 9y agoI guess it is because many people on HN own ether.