9 ms·
> Another panelist shut them down immediately: doctors and scientists aren’t even close to solving the phantom pain and limited mobility that most amputees face
by Terr_ 9y ago
> Another panelist shut them down immediately: doctors and scientists aren’t even close to solving the phantom pain and limited mobility that most amputees face, let alone building something uniformly better than a human limb.
To repost a slightly tounge-incheek description of features your "standard model" has:
1. Supports a very large number of individual movements and articulations
2. Meets certain weight-restrictions (overall system must be near-buoyant in water)
3 Supports a wide variety of automatic self-repair techniques, many of which can occur without ceasing operation
4. Is entirely produced and usually maintained by unskilled (unconscious?) labor from common raw materials
5. Contains a comprehensive suite of sensors
6. Not too brittle, flexes to store and release mechanical energy from certain impacts
7. Selectively reinforces itself when strain is detected
8. Has areas for the storage of long-term energy reserves, which double as an impact cushion
9. Houses small fabricators to replenish some of its own operating fluids
10. Subsystems for thermal management (evaporative cooling, automatic micro-activation)
- Qantourisc 9y agoNice list. BTW the current models often fail practically at #3 getting a repair would often be easier, instead of a long road to recovery ;)
- nielsole 9y ago11. Worldwide standardization, lots of repair shops available with the right tools available. 12. Comes in many different shades of skin color, individualized just right for your body. 13. Full compatibility with other body parts, e.g.immune system lung heart
- PhasmaFelis 9y agoSuper nitpick: I would say "density restrictions" in #3. Weight, unfortunately, remains a largely unsolved problem.
- __m 9y agoI'll take one. No, make it two.
- Houshalter 9y agoMany of the things the human body was optimized for aren't really that important in the modern world. E.g. I'd take a body (or brain...) that was 10 times stronger but required ten times more energy. Energy is abundant now. Another serious downside is fragility. Sure it can self repair. But it's very slow and only works for minor damage. Id prefer to just swap out the broken part and fix it quickly. And the whole fluid system is connected, so if a single part breaks it can drain the whole system. Not to mention the whole pain thing. It can't even extreme temperatures or environments at all.
- WalterBright 9y ago> fluid system Reminds me of the P-51 radiator. One tiny leak, the slightest battle damage, and the engine was toast. I have to admire the badass mofo's that flew them over long stretches of the Pacific. The P-48 (air cooled) would keep running with a lot of engine damage. My truck sprung a leak in the heater hose last week (the fan belt ground a hole in it), and I was able to limp it the mile home before all the coolant was gone and the engine melted, but it wouldn't have gone any further.
- ethbro 9y agoNoted and begs the question of why "human augmentation" tends to popularly mean "partial replacement." (I'll assume because artificial limbs read better in visual media) In reality, there are plenty of opportunities for true augmentation. F.ex. a friend was discussing the pacemaker his mother recently had implanted after an episode of tachycardia. Fairly small, continuously monitors vitals & syncs to communicate with base station (which can contact physician if needed), internal battery. And works in conjunction with the existing biological heart! Why not focus on actually augmenting our already-amazing bodies?
- WalterBright 9y agoAnyone remember the "6 Million Dollar Man"? Steve Austin had an arm and both legs replaced with bionic ones with super powers. He'd do thinks like break handcuffs by spreading his arms. But only one of his arms was bionic. It would have just ripped the other hand off. Similarly, his running at superspeed would have just shattered his spine. I.e. you can't increase the power of the engine without increasing the strength of the drive train.
- mirimir 9y agoIndeed. Flesh is some pretty impressive nanotech.
- Terr_ 9y agoTo recycle another comment: > [C]onsider that you are an enormous colony of vicious nanomachines, shaped by millions of years of fighting and cooperating with other varieties for survival. > Your mobile swarm contains thousands of tools for finding, neutralizing, disassembling and anything useful it comes in contact with... including techniques for identifying and destroying possible intruders. Now, those tools aren't perfect -- and everybody else has their own tricks -- but the fact that you're around means you're competitively equipped and you're at least somebody's else's nightmare. All the really bad players were eaten long ago. https://www.reddit.com/r/explainlikeimfive/comments/6i881n/eli5_went_on_vacation_fridge_died_while_i_was/dj4fxzh/ https://www.reddit.com/r/explainlikeimfive/comments/6i881n/e...
- Gatsky 9y agoIt will probably be cheaper and easier to grow a new arm in a dish and surgically attach it rather than cybernetic alternatives - this has already been done with donor arms. I can't see the economics of fully synthetic prosthetic limbs ever being viable in the current era.
- FullMtlAlcoholc 9y agoYes, but a synthetic arm could offer a wider range of utility and pack an assortment of attachments from lockpicking to weaponry to a sensor array. Although
- grogenaut 9y agoYou know what else also carries that? A backpack. All those things are bulky and you usually need a lot available. Also, no one picks locks unless they don't want it known they were there or don't want to pay for another lock. So ... just use your weapon.
- CM30 9y agoThat's the use case I was imagining too. Something like in Mega Man, Metroid or Bionic Commando where the arm acts like a super fancy swiss army knife. Seems like something there could be military applications for, or something espionage agencies may want to have available.
- mcappleton 9y agoFunny, I was watching a video of a guy with a prosthetic hand. He loved it. He said he went from almost committing suicide to being ok with life again. When he talked about his bionic hand, he said "I'm not left handed, I'm other-handed", as he turned his hand a full 360... It was pretty funny.
- 52-6F-62 9y agoSort of a meta analysis, but: While I don't disagree with your level of skepticism necessarily, I'd like to take this moment to make a point -- this kind of negative sentiment seems so characteristic of HN lately toward anything new and difficult, in spite of the fact that this is a community generally aimed toward entrepreneurial, forward-looking, highly-technical types. Instead of such a short stop "it would be expensive, so why bother, it won't happen for a long, long time" sort of sentiment, why does't the community make more pointed suggestions about flaws. Simply and vaguely saying "the economics look bad to me" generates only sentiment, and no real knowledge to be shared. I can be guilty of it, too, but usually because of emotional response and not a technical criticism. This sounds like a technical criticism with no reasoning. On top of that, "era" is a really vague term. I mean, it might not be perfect, but try $300 on: https://www.engadget.com/2015/03/23/this-300-cybernetic-arm-gets-its-smarts-from-your-cellphone/ https://www.engadget.com/2015/03/23/this-300-cybernetic-arm-... I don't think it's as far and distant as you think.