3 ms·
I have "management" in my degree title, from a world famous uni. Basically a good taste of an MBA, since an MBA there is a year. Very little of a management co
by lordnacho 9y ago
I have "management" in my degree title, from a world famous uni. Basically a good taste of an MBA, since an MBA there is a year.
Very little of a management course is about how you treat people. If anything, you are left with Taylorism and the lingering question of how it relates to knowledge workers. Because Taylor was basically measuring factory workers' performance, whose contribution is to do some repeated action over and over. If that sounds like treating someone like a robot, it's because it is.
This is not to say nobody has thought about this. HBR will run an article now and again about HR issues. But there's nothing especially compelling where you'd be able to find a root cause, find a specific solution, and implement it. If it was, management wouldn't be magic, it would be engineering. And the practitioners would not be paid enormous sums for doing the impossible, they'd be paid moderately well for being ordinarily competent.
Most of the things on the course are really not that different from reading the FT regularly. So-and-so company found their product wasn't appealing to young people, so they tried X and it was a massive success. Doesn't tell you what to do if you were to run this firm, but after you've read a few you'll think you know. Case studies are a case study in post-hoc fallacy.
Then there's a bunch of supposedly advanced financial stuff, which if you're an engineer you'll laugh at. Ratios, really? Interest rates? If you do a proper finance course there will be real things to learn (stoch calc doesn't show up much in engineering), but not in the business school.
And there's a few useful things, too, like the history of capitalism, but nothing that develops a proper intuition or method for a field of problems like engineering does.
- dasmoth 9y agoThanks. Ultimately, I think I was referring to the Taylorist aspect. There's also a philosophy that I've seen labelled as "teamism" and which seems to form the basis of methodologies like Scrum. I'm not sure teamism is quite the same thing as Taylorism -- but it shares the same distrust for individuals working on problems without near-constant oversight.
- crdoconnor 9y agoScrum has elements of Taylorism: team members are treated as interchangeable cogs to be assigned units of work and it has a crappy "productivity" measure built in (velocity).
- epalmer 9y agoI don't measure velocity in the scrum team I coach. And people's skills are not interchangeable but we do want most of the team member to be able to perform the easy stuff. A front end developer is not interchangeable with a backend developer. Having a task card about thinking through a design is always welcome. We use standup to have face to face conversations.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- eru 9y ago> And the practitioners would not be paid enormous sums for doing the impossible, they'd be paid moderately well for being ordinarily competent. That's an awesome description of where we should move management to, hopefully. (Same for programming, marketing etc.)
- heymijo 9y agoThis just, kind of blows my mind. What is management if not people? I mean Drucker's very definition of management is the idea of organizing a group of people to drive towards a common aim where you learn how to make each individuals' strengths effective and their weaknesses irrelevant. Deming was adamant that psychology had to be a pillar of management. Why? Because people! I'm curious then, who were the authorities/what were the theories (if any I guess) that were used for your management degree? - Also, why am I talking about Drucker and Deming? Because if I drew a family tree, I could trace at least some aspect of nearly any management idea today back to them (lots of amalgams out there these days). There is one big caveat though, lots of management practices today have neo-Taylorism embedded into them that most people are unaware of.
- lordnacho 9y ago> I'm curious then, who were the authorities/what were the theories (if any I guess) that were used for your management degree? It felt like a very sporadic hodge podge of names. Porter's five forces, tech cycle, a load of case studies. That's looking back a decade later, so maybe I'm missing something. But it all seemed very vague. I remember thinking how on earth did Porter get his name on a "theory" when really that's just common sense? A company is going to tend to have customers, suppliers, entrants, and substitutes, and internal rivalry. I mean why would you think otherwise? Also, creating those categories is no guarantee that you're not going to miss out something. If anything I've learned more about management from reading agile type stuff like Scrum, because those kinds of things are usually grounded in experience from a specific industry, with specific pain points and specific solutions.
- thaumasiotes 9y ago> I remember thinking how on earth did Porter get his name on a "theory" when really that's just common sense? This is how I've always felt about "De Morgan's Laws". There are two, and they state: 1. If it is not the case that two things are both true, then at least one of those things is false. 2. If it is not the case that either of two things is true, then both of those things are false. (Actually, they are logical equivalences, so they also apply in the other order -- "1b. If at least one of two things is false, then it is not the case that both things are true.") I'm pretty sure both of those "laws" were known well before the nineteenth century.