3 ms·
Please bolt the panel down, if wind picks it up and blows it off the roof it could easily kill someone.
by sitkack 9y ago
Please bolt the panel down, if wind picks it up and blows it off the roof it could easily kill someone.
- Retric 9y agoI really doubt the wind is going to pick up a 2'x4' ~20lb panel like that when it's flat on a roof. Now if he had lifted an edge to try and get a better angle with the sun that would IMO be a much larger issue.
- mbreese 9y agoNo, that could easily happen. The parent was right, that panel should be secured in some way. Wind gusts can do some crazy things.
- Retric 9y agoFirst, there are no hurricanes or tornadoes in that area. So, you can work out max wind via historical data, but 85MPH is not going to be enough to move it over that lip. The skin effect around a building drastically reduces the forces involved.
- quickben 9y agoYou aren't accounting for a million other things that can happen.
- Retric 9y agoI have no problem saying bolting something to the roof is a good idea, I just don't think the wind in that area is going to lift that specific object. Move sure, lift no. So, saying any if the actual significant reasons to bolt it does haze zero influence on my objection.
- serf 9y ago"Really doubt" is probably a poor level of confidence with regards to a decision that may or may not kill someone.
- Retric 9y agoTell that to the average car driver. But sure, bolt it down. Minimal effort vs minimal risk is something people do all the time. My point is the actual risk is very close to zero.
- accountyaccount 9y ago20lbs is nothing for a strong gust of wind on a roof.
- Retric 9y agoFlat roof, low profile, is very different from even an 1/8th inch gap on a slanted roof.
- 1_2__4 9y agoYou really need to stop replying to every reasonable comment pointing out a very real risk with all this ignorant nonsense. You know not a thing about air flow on that roof (or anyone else's), and you seem to be utterly clueless as to how powerful even mild gusts of wind can be. Trying to convince people they DONT need to take reasonable safety steps, even when presented with knowledgeable arguments that are clearly better informed than yours, is incredibly irresponsible. Please reconsider.
- Retric 9y agoRun some actual math > fear. Yes, in a slightly different situation this would be an issue. But, wind is not magic fairy dust that can lift arbitrary loads.
- quickben 9y agoLook, there is a reason why people secure stuff on rooftops. What are you arguing here: That it's okay to leave shit around because the chances are low that it will kill somebody? Just stop with the flawed logic.
- Retric 9y agoNo, I have no problem saying securing stuff is generally a good idea. If nothing else it makes it harder for someone to steal it. My point is the specific bad thing described is unlikely to happen. And sure I got a lot of knee jerk reactions but nobody actually did any kind of meaningful calculation demonstrating an issue.
- ChoGGi 9y agoCoastal city, flat panel on a roof. That's a when not if scenario waiting to happen.
- enraged_camel 9y agoMother Nature is stronger than you think: http://i.imgur.com/3fqbBgY.gifv http://i.imgur.com/3fqbBgY.gifv
- Retric 9y agoCars are much easer to move than a heavy panel flat to the ground. And I am being serious here, if you notice to car rotated and got slightly lifted but not flipped into the air or moved very far. But most importantly, the wind is much stronger a few feet in the air vs 1 inch from the ground.
- trhway 9y ago>I really doubt the wind is going to pick up a 2'x4' ~20lb panel like that when it's flat on a roof. thus the difference between the air speeds over the panel and under the panel in this case equals to the wind speed. To compare - Cessna wing loading is 15lb per square foot and it is generated at the minimum no-stall speed required by the FAA for general aviation of something around 70 miles/hour, and in that situation the speed difference between over the wing and under the wing is obviously significantly less than the 70 miles/per hour that wing moves through the air with. Thus it is pretty possible (to be sure one can just plug the numbers into any aerodynamics calculator on the web) that this panel at 8 square feet would generate multiple tens or even like 100lb+ lifting force at storm/hurricane winds of like 70 miles/hour and may pretty easy lift itself at the 30-40 miles per hour wind (which do happen on occasion in SF/BayArea). This is basically the same basic aerodynamics (Bernoulli speed difference) that tears buildings' roofs off in hurricanes.
- Retric 9y agoThat's not how wings work. https://www.grc.nasa.gov/www/k-12/airplane/wrong1.html https://www.grc.nasa.gov/www/k-12/airplane/wrong1.html Most obvious problem aircraft can fly upside down.
- trhway 9y agoyou're trying to argue with the Bernoulli law. I wouldn't recommend it :) Even your link clearly states: "{The upper flow is faster and from Bernoulli's equation the pressure is lower. The difference in pressure across the airfoil produces the lift.} As we have seen in Experiment #1, this part of the theory is correct." Re-read my original comment - it is pretty much stating the same as the cited text above. The link you posted refutes the "Equal Transit" Theory which is deriving the speed difference from the wing asymmetrical shape using very simple approach. Which has nothing to do with my original comment as i was applying the [correct according to Bernoulli law and your link] theory of pressure difference generated by airflow speed difference to airfoils without regard to whether they assymetrical (Cessna wing) or symmetrical (solar panel).
- 9y ago
- agumonkey 9y agoYou've never seen a panel dismount itself through wind force only.
- nikodunk 9y agoOkay I'm gonna have to look up a mate who works in statics – not sure what to believe from the discussion below (good sources on both sides) :). My gut says it wouldn't move either, but I'm not about to gamble with others' lives. In the meantime, I'll weigh down the four corners with massive cinder blocks (so as not to block sunlight).
- sitkack 9y agoAwesome