5 ms·
There are a lot of people who use tabs as bookmarks. Seems like a good way to keep the RAM industry going strong. Someone once told me (seriously) "I need at
by ilaksh 9y ago
There are a lot of people who use tabs as bookmarks. Seems like a good way to keep the RAM industry going strong. Someone once told me (seriously) "I need at least 128 GB of RAM otherwise I can't keep my tabs open." But does everything you were interested in over the last X weeks or months really need to be loaded up? No, and if you use it like that then it can't preload stuff.
I think the main lesson is that bookmarks don't work too well or people just don't use them. If nothing else, make the bookmark display show newer bookmarks rather than the same old ones from four years ago. And maybe start preloading if they are opened regularly. Merge two features together, maybe add optional other organizational features for example similar to new tab screen.
The tricky thing is that there are a lot of things that are potentially supposed to happen while a tab is open. The browser is now it's own OS, and it may be very difficult for developers to use important features if tabs (processes) only _look_ like they are running.
- motoboi 9y agoI had the same feeling. Seems like they are using tabs as a history. A better history may solve their problem.
- Arelius 9y agoSure a better history along with bookmarks and a pile of things could indeed fix my problem. But using tabs also fixes my problem perfectly well.
- jackiejj22 9y agoThat is delusional. So “perfectly well” that it was slow, broken, and had to be specifically optimized for? So instead of advancing browsing for everyone, Mozilla made it so a few idiots wouldn’t complain that “Firefox is slow when I do stupid things” There are many ways to do something, many of them are dumb
- tr1ck5t3r 9y agoOr a better tab interface, I cant see how its productive scooting left or right to find the correct tab, even with a mouse scroll wheel. Still its a low hanging fruit diversion from making Firefox more secure.
- Macha 9y agoIt's not just tabs as bookmarks. I can build up a stack of 100 tabs in a day easily.
- vocatus_gate 9y agoHow??? I've never understood how people can have that many tabs open and it be useful at all. At that point the information overload is too much. I have at most 10 open, and close them as I'm done with them. Helps reduce cognitive load.
- pavanky 9y agoAlso looking up what you want when you have dozens / hundreds of tabs open is no better than going through your history browsing history. In fact going through your browsing history may be faster because you can actually use key words to search for what you want. I have 2-3 tabs open most of the time. If I am looking something up, I go to 10-12. When I am done, it goes back down to 2-3. I can't even fathom under what situation people are using hundreds of tabs.
- jamesrcole 9y ago> looking up what you want when you have dozens / hundreds of tabs open is no better than going through your history browsing history I have heaps of tabs open, but there are orders of magnitude more pages in my browser history. The latter usually contains so much that is too much to look through to find anything but quite recent entries. The tabs still open are pages still with some relevance to me, while the history is filled with lots of incidental stuff that is no longer of use. [Edit: also, with open tabs the page content is already there so it's more quickly accessible. This can be useful if you need to look at it to help find the page you're looking for, and to get the content from the page]
- BenjiWiebe 9y agoI usually max out at around 50. Today I got to 40, by reading several articles in the morning, and then starting a programming project in the afternoon. And the project included several unfamiliar topics, and I opened multiple tabs for some Google searches because not every website has the same take on the matter.
- robbrown451 9y agoCouldn't agree more. Bookmarks are so poorly implemented, people use tabs instead. Which is dumb
- 123e1daAdfafsdf 9y agoDoesn't a lazy-loaded tab solve this problem? To me, the problem is that bookmarks are "while browsing, go to a different component that loads the browser tab with what I want". Tabs, OTOH, are a placeholder for things that I want to keep just 1 step closer. Saying it that way, I don't think it makes rational sense. But 1 cognitive step to a page instead of two is huge for me.
- robbrown451 9y agoWell, which is it for? To make your page come in quicker when you click it, or to be a more accessible UI for choosing among options of sites you've visited and want to return to? To me they are different things, and shouldn't be lumped together the way they are.
- jamesrcole 9y agoWhy is it dumb?
- montibbalt 9y agoEdge's reading list shows newer entries at the top. The problem is you don't have to do anything extra to use tabs. You just... leave them open, and then there's no reason to use bookmarks or reading list or history
- throwaway91111 9y agoYea, but that reduces the value of tabs overall. You can't just glance at the top of the browser to remember where you just were. If i don't look at a tab for a few hours, it's not worth keeping around as it just adds to the noise without providing value. If i need to read something, i either read it immediately or bookmark it to read later. The result: i can confidently resume work without distractions at any time.
- always_good 9y ago> You can't just glance at the top of the > browser to remember where you just were. You just look at the last X tabs you opened. Just because it's not your workflow doesn't invalidate it. With tree-style tabs, each root represents a train of thought. I just collapse them until I decide what to do with them. Sometimes I bookmark and banish them. Sometimes I come back to that thought next weekend. Chrome's default tabs at the top, to me, are the distraction where each tab has equal weight. But I'm not going to say that anyone is doing it wrong if that's what they prefer.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- bigbugbag 9y agoThere's a good reason not to use edge: it's not available outside windows.
- acdha 9y agoHow is that relevant to a UI discussion?
- flyinghamster 9y agoIt doesn't help that the bookmarks toolbar is not shown by default. I prefer to keep my tabs down to a reasonable number, and put folders on the bookmarks toolbar instead. If I want to bookmark something, I can just drag that link to the appropriate folder.
- rallycarre 9y agoI use holmes google chrome extension and it's awesome. Once a website is bookmarked, it can be easily searched with by simply *[tab] and it searches for it. Highly recommended. https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/holmes/gokficnebmomagijbakglkcmhdbchbhn https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/holmes/gokficnebmo...
- vit05 9y agoThat's because the bookmarkers sucks. They do not adapt to what you are doing, you need to do a lot of setup and organize a lot to be able to use it well. It should be more organic, grow with the use you make. I still believe that anyone who makes a better bookmark will dominate more than just the browser war.
- gyrgtyn 9y agoI'd try a thing for tabs that works like cmd-tab / alt-tab works for apps.
- _wmd 9y agoBookmarking always struck me as a 90s solution to just having fulltext search and analytics over your browser history, there have been a few attempts at browsers that addressed this head-on, but they've all died off over time IMO just one good new tab UI over a user's history/local cache could make a sizeable dent in Google's ad revenue
- bigbugbag 9y agoOpera with its unique cache offered the option to have full text search in history and it was great. Then quarterly profit became a priority for the board and they dropped their browser to become a google chrome advanced skin.
- JetSpiegel 9y agoIt's not like you have to reinvent the wheel even, just use Xapian like notmuch to do the grunt work of full-text indexing.
- raesene2 9y agoHave you tried pocket? I used to keep a load of bookmarks but the problem was that after a while many of the source urls would die off. So something like pocket is very handy as it takes a copy of the page you're interested in.
- 9y ago
- peterwwillis 9y agoI think the main lesson is web browsers are bloated as hell now.
- bigbugbag 9y agoBookmarks have been broken in browsers for more than a decade. Using bookmarks requires so much work and time that it makes no sense to use them.
- k__ 9y agoHow come? First you have to create some categories, but that doesn't take long and then you simply throw bookmarks in these categories. the end.