2 ms·
The rising wages is notably mentioned in the article, and it is the implied reason for automation - the industry is not going to replace cheap workers with expe
by PeterisP 9y ago
The rising wages is notably mentioned in the article, and it is the implied reason for automation - the industry is not going to replace cheap workers with expensive workers, it's going to restructure everything (including the crop species it grows) to ensure that cheap workers are replaced with machines.
If some industry is employing $10 million of labor and market wages go up 20%, the expected outcome is not spending $12m on labor, you should rather expect something like spending $9m on labor and $2m on machines that weren't worth it back when labor was cheap but are worth it now.
Many industries, including this one, employ humans only because (and only while) they can do it cheaper than the machines. Yet. As the technology matures and becomes cheaper, and people want to earn more, the result is going to be simply less jobs.
- ihsw2 9y agoTell that to the plethora of hotels that are constantly hiring contractors to clean their hotels because their staff either quit due to lack of pay or being overworked due to lack of staff. The same for trucking companies that are haemorrhaging drivers. The same for the construction industry. Market efficiency implies the market is managed well. It's not half the time.
- shostack 9y agoFrom a hotel accounting standpoint I honestly wonder which is more profitable for what I'd assume can be classified as a low-skill job: 1. Hire more employees and/or pay higher wages or other benefits to retain experienced (and thus presumably more efficient and effective staff) 2. Churn and burn with abandon because there will always be people desperate enough for any job to keep themselves off the street, even if it's just until they can find something marginally better I'm not making any judgements on the morality of this...just raising the question since I have a guess that #2 is more profitable.
- SomeStupidPoint 9y agoI suspect that number 2 is less profitable: the quality of work drops, your reputation drops, and the effective market rate you can charge drops. But I think you can get trapped in a number 2 situation regardless -- eg, there's an economic downturn, so people spend less, the business "cost optimizes", which causes people to spend less, etc. I think the second case is a sort of "survival" mode witnessed in fundamentally unhealthy economies where businesses are being squeezed because people in general are being squeezed.
- HillaryBriss 9y agoFrances Gabe, an Oregon woman who took the first steps toward a self cleaning dwelling: http://kuow.org/post/remembering-frances-gabe-oregon-inventor-self-cleaning-house http://kuow.org/post/remembering-frances-gabe-oregon-invento... i think the idea still needs some refinement before it can be rolled out at a Holiday Inn though
- e12e 9y agoI'd say the math is off, but your ideas are sound. If you can reduce a 10M labor market to capital investment with zero yearly wages, it would probably make sense to spend 80M on robots that will cost 20M over ~10 years (or something similar). Point being, if you plan on being in business for a few decades, getting rid of labor costs (especially there might be a race to get rid of labor costs) is likely going to be essential.