14 ms·
Monopoly was invented to demonstrate the evils of capitalism
- mrleiter 9y agoFrom just reading the headline, one could assume this is bogus. For anyone wondering: they are talking about the game 'Monopoly'.
- owebmaster 9y agoYou avoided a lot of comments replying only to the title. Thanks, I guess.
- amelius 9y ago> So next time someone invites you to join a game of Monopoly, here’s a thought. As you set out piles for the Chance and Community Chest cards, establish a third pile for Land-Value Tax, to which every property owner must contribute each time they charge rent to a fellow player. How high should that land tax be? And how should the resulting tax receipts be distributed? Such questions will no doubt lead to fiery debate around the Monopoly board – but then that is exactly what Magie had always hoped for. Could a computer program (e.g. genetic programming) come up with a fair set of rules?
- empath75 9y agoThe free parking rule that some people use and makes the game last for hours and hours is basically inflationary monetary policy by the central bank.
- amelius 9y agoBut does this rule make the game fair?
- DugFin 9y agono, it just prolongs the inevitable. The first player to gain an edge on the others still eventually wins, it's just that it takes hours instead of minutes.
- Broken_Hippo 9y agoI'm not sure if it makes it fairer, but it makes the game different. Theoretically, the game starts as fair. All start with the same money, on the same place on the board. But since you move by rolling dice, some folks get luckier than others, with more chances to buy things or gain income.... or simply avoiding landing on a built up property. The free parking money basically puts lottery money into action. Sometimes, free parking is funded by fees (jail fees, cards, etc) and some folks just take moeny from the bank and put it in the middle. At times, it means the rich get richer. Sometimes, the poor pull themselves up. Many times, it just makes everyone richer at different times and it takes a lot longer to make folks go bankrupt. It does give a little chance of winning something with each go around the board, and I think this is why the rule is popular.
- CuriousSkeptic 9y agoOne way to approach it, retaining the free market dynamics, is to have players bid on land with rent. Instead of paying the bank a big pile up front, agree on a rent to pay every turn to keep the land, highest bidder wins.
- js8 9y agoReminds me of Czech game "Soudruhu, nezlob se!" (literally "Don't get angry, comrade", see http://www.deskove-hry.eu/soudruhu-nezlob-se http://www.deskove-hry.eu/soudruhu-nezlob-se), which is a version of more popular children game https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mensch_%C3%A4rgere_dich_nicht https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mensch_%C3%A4rgere_dich_nicht It was designed partly as a joke, but partly to demonstrate ridiculousness of communism. The goal of the game was to become a secretary general of the communist party and emigrate abroad.
- ourmandave 9y agoI would add rules so the other players had a small chance to make it so the winner emigrated to the wrong country.
- tray5 9y ago>It was designed partly as a joke, but partly to demonstrate ridiculousness of communism. The goal of the game was to become a secretary general of the communist party and emigrate abroad. I can't read the Czech link (do you know if there's a translated link or something in English?) but that seems more like from your one sentence description (and my reading of the wikipedia link) a game satirizing the ridiculousness of playing politics rather than communism?
- SyneRyder 9y agoTry this link: https://translate.google.com/translate?sl=auto&tl=en&u=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.deskove-hry.eu%2Fsoudruhu-nezlob-se https://translate.google.com/translate?sl=auto&tl=en&u=http%... If you go to Google Translate, type in a URL and click translate, you can translate any webpage. (Chrome has the feature built-in.)
- js8 9y agoI didn't bother with translate link, because I thought it's actually quite hard to understand the jokes anyway, but someone else did, and I have to say, it turned out better than I expected. Just to explain the most unclear things, "mina" means mine (explosive device), and "veksl" means illegal money exchange (with western currency). Yes, it was more about ridiculousness of the real socialism, not the idea of communism.
- geekamongus 9y agoPlayed this game a couple of weeks ago with my family (my wife, an 11 year-old, and a 14 year-old.) We quickly remembered why we hadn't played it in a year: you must be greedy to win, hopes & dreams get dashed, and someone always ends up angry and/or in tears.
- thinkMOAR 9y agoAre you sure the 'we' and 'someone' shouldn't be read as 'I' and you just aren't so good at playing monopoly? :) (just kidding; almost weekend) Though to be on topic again, are there many board games where the goal isn't to beat the other player by whatever means the rules of the board game allow? From tic-tac-toe to monopoly to card games, there will always be a loser, and if he or she can't handle that, they will cry/tirade.
- brians 9y agoYes, there are! Hanabi, Pandemic, Sentinels of the Multiverse are three of the biggest games of the last decade. All are cooperative. You all win or lose together.
- thinkMOAR 9y agobit late, with reading replies, sorry. hmm i never heard of these games, i'll be checking those, thanks
- ourmandave 9y agoRage quitting / table flipping was always a late game strategy when I was growing up. Especially playing Risk.
- meri_dian 9y agoIf a simple board game played with family leaves someone angry or in tears then that's a problem. Games like monopoly are actually great opportunities for children to learn self control and perspective.
- problems 9y agoThank you, eugh, it's incredibly annoying, like people miss a hundred year history lesson and want to repeat the mistakes of the past here. Even the bottom 20% that everyone is so concerned about in the western world are better off than any time in history - heck, I have no qualms saying I'd rather be bottom 20% today than top 1% just 200 years ago. That is the level of productivity we've had, and primarily thanks to our economic system. Could it use some tweaks? Sure, if you want to advocate free healthcare or college, go for it, but the main concepts are still quite good.
- ivanbakel 9y agoBetter is not necessarily good enough. Why would people not want a system which furthers their quality of life even more? It's not at all convincing to suggest that you shouldn't complain since things have improved somewhat under capitalism.
- problems 9y agoThings have improved immensely, more than any other time in history under capitalism. And we've watched other systems crash and burn. We don't need to experience it for ourselves, thanks.
- ivanbakel 9y agoWe've also witnessed capitalist systems fail drastically, and other systems succeed impressively. There is little historical comparison for what you quote as capitalism's success - nobody performed a double-blind trial to see if the industrial revolution and colonialism improved quality of life in non-capitalist systems.
- problems 9y ago> We've also witnessed capitalist systems fail drastically, and other systems succeed impressively. Please, show me one country not rooted in capitalism which has "succeeded impressively" in recent decades.
- yosito 9y agoAre the original "prosperity rules" published anywhere? How much modification of a modern Monopoly board would it take to play?
- Nursie 9y agoWell it certainly is evil, taking several hours, provoking family arguments, the slow grinding down of anyone that didn't get ahead quickly at the start. There are reasons I don't play it very often!
- emodendroket 9y agoIt's mostly counting cash that takes forever; the one they sell with the fake debit cards goes way faster.
- nandemo 9y agoThat's too kind an assessment. Monopoly sucks. It sucks as an educational tool and it sucks as a board game. First, if it was meant to teach the evils of capitalism it has failed in many levels, as the article illustrates. Even if you were to play with the amended rules, it'd be moot; nobody cares about Georgist socialism anymore. As a board game: there are literally hundreds of games better than Monopoly. Even we restrict ourselves to so-called "family" games. If there's something you like about Monopoly, I can assure you can find a better game that has that something but it's better designed: https://boardgamegeek.com/familygames/browse/boardgame?sort=rank&sortdir=asc https://boardgamegeek.com/familygames/browse/boardgame?sort=... Many will be simpler and shorter too. Of course, you might like or dislike a particular game in that set, but consider that Monopoly is ranked at 1583 in the family category. There's no excuse to play Monopoly unless one somehow has managed to stay unaware of the existence of all these other games.
- tray5 9y agoLast time I played Monopoly it ended up two people who were too big to fail constantly running around the board passing money back and forth. A subtle jab by the universe at two party politics within capitalist societies?
- justaman 9y agoI don't understand why everyone hates capitalism now. Its like "what the cool kids do". You know whats really cool? Inventing stuff. Using the power of your mind to form matter into a new thing that the universe has never seen before. Whats really cool is starting a business that adds enough value to the world to hire people. Feeding them with the power of your mind and a little bit of shared elbow grease. The "cool kids" seem to be bashing capitalism today. Thats not cool.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- emodendroket 9y agoHm, yeah, can't think of any events in the past few decades that would make people angry and distrustful of our economic system.
- chippy 9y agoYou could say that of any bunch of decades in any part of history for the last three hundred years. I think it's a natural side effect of being human and living and perceiving in the present day. Every people in their own time think that they are living in the most crucial and important time ever, if one remembers that, and the perspective that history gives, we can temper our reactions.
- emodendroket 9y agoI never said this was "the most crucial and important time ever" (how do you even quantify that?). What I wanted to imply is that since the 70s wages have stagnated and now many people are going backwards and experiencing worse standards of living, with occasional crises like the 2008 housing crisis along the way. It's not really surprising that people are looking for something different.
- noahth 9y agoOne thing I don't think enough people appreciate about history is how nothing got invented before capitalism.
- dmichulke 9y agoThe problem with monopoly is that it's zero-sum. Capitalism is not zero-sum.
- DanCarvajal 9y agoThis is why my kids will only have PowerGrid, Ticket to Ride, and Settlers.
- throw2016 9y agoCapitalism benefits a few at the cost of many and it's designed too. Can any supporter articulate a scenario where capitalism enables prosperity for the majority without immediately resorting to bottom barrel comparisons to feudalism? The reality is we need to imagine a more evolved society without pandering to the greed and self interest of a few. This of course appears to be our eternal struggle. The bigger problem with capitalism is it is designed to perpetuate entrenched interests and status quo. It origins from a time when few had capital or property, only the nobility did, convenient, and was obviously designed to perpetuate feudalism by proxy as they could direct economies and systems with their resources, and continue to. A few examples of those who sacrifice their entire life to gain more capital offers eternal hope to the masses to hop on to the gravy train some already are on by birth, and those who sacrifice their life to accomplish this are obviously going to be overzealous supporters of 'the system', their entire identity and self worth riding on this achievement. We need to find a way to detach progress from capitalism. Human progress cannot depend on greed which is basically what capitalism boils down to, rewarding and perpetuating the base traits of humanity and leaving a soulless society unable to rise above basic greed in its wake.
- Overtonwindow 9y ago"Well first of all, tell me: Is there some society you know that doesn’t run on greed? You think Russia doesn’t run on greed? You think China doesn’t run on greed? What is greed? Of course, none of us are greedy, it’s only the other fellow who’s greedy. The world runs on individuals pursuing their separate interests. The great achievements of civilization have not come from government bureaus. Einstein didn’t construct his theory under order from a bureaucrat. Henry Ford didn’t revolutionize the automobile industry that way." -Milton Friedman
- Sommersonn 9y agoBiggest problem with communism is that ALL communist countries decided to eradicate millions of 'enemies of the state'. See USSR, China, Cambodia.
- brightsize 9y ago> We need to find a way to detach progress from capitalism What, you mean this[0] isn't progress? /s The surge in irregular jobs doesn’t just create problems for the people working those jobs. It’s also led companies to feel that they can treat their regular workers poorly, because those workers feel so lucky to have a job, Konno told me. Knowing that people in their 20s and 30s are desperate to get regular jobs, companies hire lots of young people and force them to work long hours for little to no overtime pay, assuming that most won’t be able to survive the harsh conditions, Konno said. Japan has long had a culture of overwork—there’s even a Japanese word, karoshi, for death by overwork—but Konno says that it has worsened since the Great Recession, as companies have realized that good jobs are hard to find in Japan, and so push their employees harder. ... Though company employees left work at 7 p.m. on paper, Matsubara said he was required to work until late at night almost every day. Employees were required to sign off at 7 p.m., even if they were still working, and were given iPads so that they could do so even if they were out of the office at meetings. If they didn’t sign off, they’d get a call on their cellphones brusquely asking them to sign off immediately but keep working, he said. “The amount of time you're actually working and the amount of time that is recorded you're working have absolutely no relation to each other,” [0] The Mystery of Why Japanese People Are Having So Few Babies https://goo.gl/zoHH6L https://goo.gl/zoHH6L (theatlantic.com)
- fiatjaf 9y agoThere was a thread about boardgames here on HN two days ago and someone commented that Monopoly wasn't just a bad game, but a game created with that purpose (so that being "bad" was an intended feature). The comment sparked a lot of discussion and most people didn't know about that original goal of Monopoly. Now this article appear on a major magazine. It's very suspicious. Unless this is a huge coincidence, these writers must think again about their intellectual honesty.
- brudgers 9y agoMonopoly as the basis for how Louis CK tells a joke, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ufdvYrTeTuU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ufdvYrTeTuU
- matthewmarkus 9y agoMonopoly is a board game in which you shuffle around finite resources. Capitalism is the reason why there isn't a single copy of the board game Monopoly.
- ionised 9y agoPeople being better off now than earlier times in history is a straw man argument. That would be true regardless of the system we were under. That's a natural result of human intellectual progress and knowledge being passed down through generations. So people now get to live a little longer, travel farther and faster, and absorb more banal entertainment than ever before. Who gives a fuck? None of that matters in this context. The point you should focus on is how much of a share in the overall wealth and prosperity of their nation does a person have today? How much power and personal freedom? Is it growing or shrinking? It's shrinking and has been for decades. It's the increasing consolidation of wealth and the power and influence that naturally comes with that is why people are raging against a system that they can see has become totally unrestrained and rigged against them from birth. GDP is held up as the gold standard metric of measuring how well a nation is doing, but all it really tells you is how prosperous it ther 'country' is as on the macro level. It doesn't tell you that most of that wealth is concentrated in the hands of fewer and fewer people that are becoming obscenely wealthy while the lowest classes in society are becoming objectively poorer and less empowered to act. You rephrase the argument and a working class stiff what he wants more, a shinier, faster car and a higher-resolution TV , or a greater stake in the economy and the resulting benefits that naturally occur as part of that and he will tell you the latter every damn time. The problem is thinking like yours, where the proles should be happy that they get to be more consumerist and materialistic than ever before while the ones filling the world with shit nobody needs steal away the actual benefits of our system and entrench themselves for generations.
- problems 9y ago> That's a natural result of human intellectual progress and knowledge being passed down through generations. We have direct evidence that that is incorrect and any high school student knows it. Many, many times have we failed to progress due to being in systems that don't allow for it. > Is it growing or shrinking? Why would that matter to me as an individual? So long as my overall wealth is increasing, I don't care. I don't need to be making more than my neighbor to be happy with my life. As long as I still get the goods, I'm quite happy with this deal. This is just plain wrong in terms of a way to think about the economy or my life.
- Overtonwindow 9y ago"[T]he record of history is absolutely crystal clear, that there is no alternative way so far discovered of improving the lot of the ordinary people that can hold a candle to the productive activities that are unleashed by the free-enterprise system." -Milton Friedman
- dragonwriter 9y agoA pretty quote, but—unless one defines “the free enterprise system” so that it encompasses democratic socialism, social democracy, other versions of the modern mixed economy rather than just classical capitalism as targeted by Monopoly (which, unlike Friedman's statement, predates the widespread emergence of the various forms of the modern mixed economy and the Communist-originated-but-eagerly-adopted-in-the-West conflation of it with “capitalism”), it is rather obviously false, and that was clear even at the time he said it, since the whole reason various forms of the modern mixed economy displaced classical capitalism everywhere in the developed world is that they are generally superior on the point in question.
- Overtonwindow 9y agoCapitalism is the most productive system that humanity has produced because it leads to individual entrepreneurship. Exhibit one: Grumpy Cat is a millionaire.
- mzw_mzw 9y ago"So next time someone invites you to join a game of Monopoly, here’s a thought. As you set out piles for the Chance and Community Chest cards, establish a third pile for Land-Value Tax, to which every property owner must contribute each time they charge rent to a fellow player. How high should that land tax be? And how should the resulting tax receipts be distributed? Such questions will no doubt lead to fiery debate around the Monopoly board..." Wow. This lady must be a lot of fun at parties.