7 ms·
These are all still pretty fast No's in my experience. The worst No's are the ones where they ask to do Due Diligence and then never open the dropbox folder. O
by AndrewKemendo 9y ago
These are all still pretty fast No's in my experience.
The worst No's are the ones where they ask to do Due Diligence and then never open the dropbox folder. Or if you are on your fifth meeting and they just keep trying to pump you for competitive information.
So how do you know when you get a Yes?
When you get a wire or a check. That's the only way.
Even a signed note or Equity docs don't mean anything until that money clears.
The best No's I've had were from Bessemer and a16z years ago. Almost immediate and right to the point that they wouldn't invest, with specific reasoning/metrics behind them. A++ would get told no again.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- fao_ 9y ago> The best No's I've had were from Bessemer and a16z years ago. Almost immediate and right to the point that they wouldn't invest with specific reasoning/metrics behind them. Don't you mean "without specific reasoning/metrics behind them"?
- cbhl 9y agoI think they're saying the "no" had specific reasons and metrics for the no.
- kornish 9y agoHe's saying that they made a decision, then explained the reason for their decision. That's the best possible way to receive a No as a founder.
- yebyen 9y agoI don't think so, I think it says he was really pleased with the rejection (and that could have been because it came with actionable feedback, like reasons and metrics.)
- mtgx 9y agoI think a comma is missing: > Almost immediate and right to the point that they wouldn't invest, with specific reasoning/metrics behind them.
- komali2 9y ago>Almost immediate and right to the point that they wouldn't invest with specific reasoning/metrics behind them. Was going to comment on the article itself: You shouldn't walk away from a VC without this in hand. Kind of a general sales concept - never take "no" without a good reason.
- patio11 9y agoA related sales concept is forcing people to say no, even if you don't get a reason for it. This is why some very effective sales folks will follow up essentially forever until they get a definitive answer. It looks like crazy behavior if your mental model is "I brushed him off twice, clearly that is a constructive no, why can't he take the hint", but the rep's mental model is "I close deals all the time after the 18th unanswered followup. If I haven't gotten a no yet, there is insufficient evidence to exclude the possibility that e.g. they're just busy."
- greenshackle2 9y agoThat's why when I'm not interested or trying to cancel something I always give a content-less, irrefutable reason. If you give a specific reason, they will challenge it. "No, I don't want this product, because I'm not interested." "I'd like to cancel this credit card, because I don't want to have this credit card anymore."
- enraged_camel 9y agoI've lied to pesky sales reps and telemarketers and told them that I've been diagnosed with terminal cancer and have six months to live. That ends the conversation pretty quickly and they never call back.
- bigiain 9y ago"Oh, I'm so sorry Mr Enraged_Camel... Perhaps I can interest you in a new unsecured credit card with a $25k limit?"
- 9y ago
- tptacek 9y agoCame here to write the same thing. This needs about 5-10 more "No" variants that all include the words "yes, we're excited to move forward with you, and...". I'm not sure we ever got a VC to give us one of these waffling "no"'s without apply serious pressure.
- jessmartin 9y ago> So how do you know when you get a Yes? > When you get a wire or a check. That's the only way. YES to this.
- brightball 9y ago> Or if you are on your fifth meeting and they just keep trying to pump you for competitive information. 15 years ago after the funding I'd arranged to start a company fell through after about a year of travelling to raise it...we finally went to a VC. He insisted that he could not sign an NDA because of the precarious position it put him in hearing so many of these pitches. At that point we figured, this was basically our last option anyway so we gave him the pitch. He really liked it and wanted a local company to build it that we weren't comfortable with, so we parted ways. 5 years later I found out he had the company build it about as well as he could from memory of our pitch. It had plenty of flaws but it was a company that ended up selling for several million. As far as I can tell, it was re-sold and the company had a complete shift of focus afterwards. Meanwhile, in NY 2 years after my meeting with the VC an enterprising group of people who were not affiliated with that VC at all pursued and built a business out of one of the core features of my original platform. As it turned out, that feature stood as a business on it's own. I'd included it in the overall system because as an integrated feature, it facilitated a lot of efficiency gains. My platform was a comprehensive information system for public schools designed to make it easier for teacher's to focus on their students, reduce their workload and make it easier for them to communicate directly with parents. As a part of that system, there was to be a market place for teachers to sell and exchange lesson plans. This was back in 2003 and now smaller companies have popped up doing various parts of what our original plan was for. In NYC, Teachers Pay Teachers has made a business out of that aspect and for what it's worth, I'm really happy that they have been successful. The whole experience was really eye opening and I've been extremely reluctant to pursue funding for any of my business ideas because of it. I wish that wasn't the case.
- germinalphrase 9y agoI find TPT interesting and - as a teacher - have a strong interest in platforms that could help debalkanize curriculum and support materials; however, it's always seemed to me that the marketplace model (while a successful business) must limit both the amount of teacher engagement as well as the type of teachers/materials present on the platform due to the incentives involved. Because of that, it's never seemed systemically useful. Did the platform you built attempt to create a shared curriculum libraries? If so, was the focus on the school, district or national scale? Happy to take a response via email so as not to derail the thread (see profile).
- wfunction 9y agoIs a check really fine? I presume if a VC is willing to give so many other things and renege on them then he might well give a check that bounces too?
- rcfox 9y agoI'm pretty sure it's illegal to write a cheque you know won't clear.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- wfunction 9y agoOh wow, I didn't know that. I thought a check was a permission to withdraw rather than a guarantee of available money, kind of like a paper form of an ACH withdraw (which is why I thought we had cashier's checks and such). I did some searching now and it seems that intent to deceive/defraud is required at least in some states. Common sense would say you wouldn't get any company shares or other things until your check clears, so if it bounces, is it actually fraud? Or just being a jerk?
- wolf550e 9y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cheque_fraud#Combating_cheque_fraud https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cheque_fraud#Combating_cheque_... I think all cases of writing a check you know isn't covered is fraud. The cases when you thought it would be covered but you were mistaken are difficult to judge, need to prove what you knew when.
- patio11 9y agoDue to the way the US legal systems work, it is unlikely you'll be arrested for uttering if you bounce a $50k check as an accredited investor but far more likely it will happen if you bounce a $50 check as a welfare recipient. There are a number of gates which will prevent the first incident from becoming a criminal case -- the police will laugh at it, the DA will decline to prosecute, the 'victims' will not choose to set fire to their professional reputations by demanding a prosecution, etc etc. Police won't laugh at the second one -- sorry, business owner, we know that people defraud you all the time and that sucks. The DA has an expedited program to defer some of these cases and prosecute repeat offenders. The victim has someone whose literal job it is to move the case forward and convictions per year may be a KPI for them. (That someone is probably not a lawyer, this being not worth the time of a lawyer on a private payroll, but rather "loss prevention specialist" or similar. "Yes sir, we do intend to prosecute. Yes sir, I would be happy to get you that documentation. Yes sir, I can be at that meeting. Thank you sir, we appreciate you looking out for us.")
- godzillabrennus 9y ago#truth on the don’t trust a contract detail mentioned I've known people who claimed to be from a VC fund that had $10MM raise out of $50MM and was making investments. In reality they had no money raised but signed $11.5MM in investments with startups. It's a crazy world out there. Vet your investors.
- logicallee 9y agoI don't understand your story. Why would they sign investments they can't pay for?
- chrisabrams 9y agoYou're trying to think rationally against an irrational situation :O
- logicallee 9y agoSomething was going through their head. For comparison, how many people who are poor enter terms to buy hundreds of millions of dollars of property without having any mortgage or ability to pay or any expectation other than "wheeeeee - that was fun." I'd wager approximately zero. There is more to the above story. As described, these VC's wasted tons of their own time. How did they even have offices?
- EGreg 9y agoI toured some apartments without the ability to afford them. Perhaps these VCs were expecting money to come in but in the end their fund fell apart?
- logicallee 9y agoTouring is very different from signing! OP said "had no money raised but signed $11.5MM in investments with startups". maybe they mispoke.
- novaleaf 9y agototally agree on that (yes is when the check clears) I was helping a startup getting VC and basically the check never came. Granted that they wernt' very happy with the progress and that was pretty transparent, but they never actually said it would impact anything. I think the founder could have handled it better but I can understand taht it's sometimes hard to tell what a hard-requirement is from a stretch-goal.