9 ms·
Lessons from the CIA’s classified guide to good writing
- beelle 9y agohttps://www.amazon.es/dp/1521567476 https://www.amazon.es/dp/1521567476
- codyb 9y agoI think they're both proper but I feel like it'd be better titled "The CIA's guide to writing well.". Just being pedantic though maybe.
- hluska 9y agoIf I were wearing my editor hat, I'd cross out 'well' and suggest that in that case it's redundant. "The CIA's Guide to Writing" is just as strong.
- robotresearcher 9y agoIt's an internal memo, so "The CIA's" is redundant. Which leaves us with "Guide to Writing". Can we do better? Stephen King's book on writing is called: "On Writing". Nice.
- abraae 9y agoOr, complying with the CIA's guidelines regarding capitalization: "On writing".
- hueving 9y agoWell once you've distilled it down that far, might as well drop 'On' because it's not adding much. "Writing."
- jschwartzi 9y agoAgreed.
- justin66 9y agoAs I recall "On Writing" does not have a great deal to say about writing, it's much more about the life of a writer. To get a pretty good book that is actually about writing you'd want to upgrade to William Zinsser's "On Writing Well." So...
- sanityUnbounded 9y agoI read the first two sections of On Writing and that was enough for me. The first is a memoir from Stephen King in which he goes through major events in his life. The second is a writing style guide which centers around one theme: simplicity in writing allows for greater imagination in the reader. The second section goes through sentence structure, syntax, verb/adverb choice, pronoun placement, ect. I would agree that the first section does not say a great deal about writing, but the second section reminded me of sitting in my High School english class with my favorite teacher writing a couple sentences on the board as an example and passionately (oops) dissecting the structure with arrows and margin notes to explain how and why a certain picture was playing in my mind while reading them. Placing King's personal anecdotes and thoughts about the "life of a writer" before the actual lesson felt to me, when I began the second section, like I was sitting in the classroom of an artist who has far more passion for his work than I have ever felt for anything in my life before then. It made the writing lesson more impactful, if anything. But it certainly had a lot to say about writing.
- hluska 9y agoThe document itself is titled "Essays on CIA Writing". And, it's largely on trends observed within CIA writing, so I'd argue that it's well titled.
- rangibaby 9y agoWriting That Works
- pbhjpbhj 9y agoIsn't the "on" implicit if the title were just "Writing". If the book was just writing and not concerning the subject it would be "writings" so there should be no confusion?
- kfriede 9y agoThis is quickly turning into a new comic idea for Randall Munroe (XKCD)
- dfc 9y agoPedantry would also require that you drop the "the." It's not the TLA, or the IBM or the GE.
- ams6110 9y agoIt is "the" Central Intelligence Agency though. I think "the" is appropriate in this case.
- jsmthrowaway 9y agoThey prefer “CIA” without an article, oddly enough. At CIA, CIA concludes, etc. When speaking with other Washington types the A is often dropped, too. “(So and so) at CI” is something one hears a lot.
- valbaca 9y ago"...these tips will make that next report on regime change into your magnum opus" Obligatory "you won't believe #5!"
- daveslash 9y agoThere is a lot in here that reminds me of the Air Force's Tongue & Quill (public). For example, the CIA's "avoid jargon" section looks eerily similar to page 82 of T&Q. http://static.e-publishing.af.mil/production/1/saf_cio_a6/publication/afh33-337/afh33-337.pdf http://static.e-publishing.af.mil/production/1/saf_cio_a6/pu...
- QAPereo 9y agoOr better yet, if you notice that your workplace is starting to resemble the old, bloated, wildly checkered bureaucracy of the CIA run like hell. This guide seems less like a style guide in general, and more like an attempt to flush some nonsense out of the CIA in particular. > it says that CIA writing is “full of jargon, of would-be professional language, of clichés; it is even opaque” That's what I'd have expected frankly, which is what you'd expect from people trying to build towers out of sand. If your ideas are lacking, bullshit, and if bullshit isn't working, obfuscate... that's the alphabet-agency way.
- walshemj 9y agoand spelling cliche with an apostrophe isn't ;-)
- joncampbelldev 9y agoThat is an accent, not an apostrophe
- walshemj 9y agooops my bad
- oblio 9y agoApostrophe? :-?
- QAPereo 9y agoI love your username, and assume it's from 'The Point'?
- Hnrobert42 9y agoSource?
- c3534l 9y agoApart from this being very elementary instructions, I think the bigger story is that the CIA is abusing its power to classify information so extensively that simple writing advice was classified for 55 years.
- hyperion2010 9y agoWhile I agree with the idea that the CIA abuses power, techniques that enable effective communication are a HUGE advantage. Knowing how to write in a way that other people can actually understand (and take action on) is absolutely advantageous (as is any other technology that reduces miscommunication). Of course at this point in time you can take a course like Little Red Schoolhouse and come away with many, many practical actions you can take to improve the clarity of your written communication, so probably in effect is has already been declassified.
- xor1 9y agoI can't wait to see the CIA guide to shitposting once it's declassified.
- wtvanhest 9y agoIt just says: "Look at the top post, disagree with one point, bring up a distracting point"
- rfrank 9y ago> MEMETICS—A GROWTH INDUSTRY IN US MILITARY OPERATIONS - United States Marine Corps, School of Advanced Warfighting http://www.dtic.mil/dtic/tr/fulltext/u2/a507172.pdf http://www.dtic.mil/dtic/tr/fulltext/u2/a507172.pdf
- 3131s 9y agoI submitted that a few months ago! In general people don't realize the extent that information warfare is taken seriously in some circles.
- pier25 9y agoI'm guessing they also have a coding manual. Tabs or spaces?
- Pamar 9y agoOne of my backburner projects is to check out the declassified CIA documents, OCR and clean up them, and make these available on my website [1]. The idea was to look for stuff that was interesting as a resoure for role playing games, mostly, but I also included one about "how to produce estimates"[2] that is close in spirit to the one about writing. [1] http://www.pa-mar.net/Main/Games/Games/Espionage%20Files.html http://www.pa-mar.net/Main/Games/Games/Espionage%20Files.htm... [2] http://www.pa-mar.net/resources/The-evolution-of-some-techniques-in-the-national-estimating-system.pdf http://www.pa-mar.net/resources/The-evolution-of-some-techni...
- edraferi 9y agoUSG documents are automatically declassified after 25 years by default. CIA makes their declassified documents available via the CREST database[1]. Data.World has published the metadata about these documents in a nice format[2]. Might be worth getting in touch with Noah Ripper to coordinate your efforts [3] [1] https://www.cia.gov/library/readingroom/collection/crest-25-year-program-archive https://www.cia.gov/library/readingroom/collection/crest-25-... [2] https://data.world/cia-crest-files/cia-crest-archive-metadata/discuss/cia-crest-archive-metadata/7531 https://data.world/cia-crest-files/cia-crest-archive-metadat... [3] https://data.world/nrippner https://data.world/nrippner
- rawland 9y agohttps://github.com/reedes/vim-wordy https://github.com/reedes/vim-wordy by @reedes (Reed Esau) is my favorite tool to automatically help me with many of the mentioned points. Spell-corrects/warns you about: * Weak and lazy words * Redundancies * Puffy & Jargon * To be and passive voice * Colloquialisms, idioms, and similies * Lots more..
- ant6n 9y agoIs there an emacs version?
- OliverJones 9y agoMy grad school teachers would kick my butt for writing like that. Look at this lede. "The trouble with CIA writing is much the same trouble that there is with other governmental writing and with writing generally in the United States." How about "CIA writing baffles our readers. We share this problem with other parts of government and the United States at large." Check out this sentence. "CIA's problem is unique only in the relation of our profession to our writing but this relation is important, for it lends itself to bad writing and if we do not write well we risk losing valuable information and wasting dangerous effort." WTF? I think this writer means "At CIA we write about hard-won information. We lose that information and waste our agency's work when we write badly." Look, it's easier to be an editor than a writer. Everybody knows that. It's always easy to cherrypick a sentence or two and make them better. The point is this: good writing isn't a solitary job; it takes editors as well as writers. It's like software, which takes coders and testers.
- jamesrcole 9y ago> The point is this: good writing isn't a solitary job; it takes editors as well as writers. That's an empirical claim, and I'm wondering how often it is actually true. I have no doubt that for many people, and probably most people, it is true. But how many people out there can (and do) write well without an editor?
- voidhorse 9y agoThey exist. They are called writers who know how to edit. Most writers need editors because of the two d's: 1. Distance 2. Deadlines Distance is necessary to read your work as a reader and not a writer. In order to polish your writing you have to have an insane amount of empathy for your reader. It's hard for people to edit their own work because it's hard to forget what you know. You know what you've meant by a phrase, of course, but your reader, coming from who knows what background, may not. Your diction, metaphors, etc. may be more idiosyncratic, arcane, limited, or just plain confusing than you realize. We're talking a whole tabula rasa situation which is not easy to pull off. As to our second d, deadlines, they prevent writers from being able to address the first d alone. As with any art, critiquing your own work from the perspective of the audience takes 'fresh eyes', 'fresh ears'--when you're grinding on a piece you become so involved it's hard to look at it from the audiences perspective unless you have sufficient time (sometimes months) to step away and get your brain out of creative/obsessive mode. you're blessed if you actually have the time to simply take off from your writing like this. As such, an editor is your stand in--a set of fresh eyes that can vouch for the audience while you keep grinding away and ensure your hit that deadline.
- jjguy 9y agoFor many years, I have used "Words of Estimative Probability" - a similar CIA "on writing" piece: https://www.cia.gov/library/center-for-the-study-of-intelligence/csi-publications/books-and-monographs/sherman-kent-and-the-board-of-national-estimates-collected-essays/6words.html https://www.cia.gov/library/center-for-the-study-of-intellig... Also written in the 60s, it reflects upon their experience with how to convey uncertainty in prose, in a meaningful and consistent manner. Imagine an analyst writing a two pager for the President, who is going to use it to decide go/no go on a covert action. It's a big, ugly and complex situation - with a mixture of highly confident assessments, educated guesses and total speculation. Synthesizing it into something simpler is The Art of Writing; doing so while not losing the anecdotal quantification of uncertainty of the discrete issues is a more unique skill. If you are in a position where you write about uncertain situations, it's worth the read. I'm a security guy and frequently find myself in that role (think annual risk assessments and estimating the likelihood of a successful attack). It's been a go-to reference for many years to refresh my thinking.
- jaypaulynice 9y agoAnyone else noticed 2 spaces after a period and 1 space after a comma in the writings? I've always done the same, but for some reason 1 space after a period is correct.
- losteverything 9y agoThat is how we were trained in typing class.
- jaypaulynice 9y agoSo 2 spaces only on a typewriter?