5 ms·
or express disbelief that we didn't anticipate <fairly obvious outcome> as an unexpected side effect of immune system tailoring. <fairly obvious outcome> is li
by dekhn 9y ago
or express disbelief that we didn't anticipate <fairly obvious outcome> as an unexpected side effect of immune system tailoring.
<fairly obvious outcome> is likely to be "large increase in incididence of autoimmune disorders"
- rubatuga 9y agoWell if you use antibodies, they should be able to slowly be excreted and broken down after a while. I don’t believe antibodies undergo any memory effect. If you use a specific form of T cells, they should undergo the same degradation, although I guess there is a possibility that in some unknown cases it might revert to a memory cell, although to my knowledge this doesn’t happen. Lastly, since the virus used to express the receptor should only infect the cells extracted from his blood, any autoimmune response shouldn’t last (since cytotoxic T cells don’t last forever). The virus isn’t self replicating, and isn’t used to infect any other cells.
- dekhn 9y agothats a lot of "shoulds" for a complicated system.
- rubatuga 9y agoI don’t believe you have a compelling argument, any biological organism has a degree of unpredictability, but with a series of molecular checks and controls, it becomes predictable, almost deterministic. Think of how the brain works, how you have billions of cells acting the way they “should”, and acting in a predictable way allowing you to perform daily tasks. I agree we have a lot to learn and that some mistakes might be made, but that’s what testing and clinical trials is for.
- dekhn 9y agoUnfortunately, autoimmune diseases violate the assumption that biological organisms become also predictable. That's true for brains, too.
- reasonattlm 9y agoWhich might be controlled by immune ablation; safer targeted forms of destroying all immune cells would be a very good way to stop all forms of autoimmunity, and would act as a good backstop to immunotherapies in general. Right now immune ablation is pretty rough chemotherapy, but has nonetheless been shown to put multiple sclerosis and type 1 diabetes into remission. There are new approaches to targeted cell killing under development now (such as Oisin Biotechnologies' system) that should be much better, with minimal side-effects. Couple that with a cell therapy to accelerate replacement of immune cells and it looks pretty promising.