11 ms·
Dice-O-Matic hopper and elevator (2009)
- tlb 9y agoWhen I play RISK with my kids, the time invested in each roll of the dice is proportional to what's at stake. During a critical close battle, they might shake, blow, and otherwise cajole the the dice for a minute before rolling. Playing on an iPad with its RNG loses all this, so it's very pleasing to think of playing online with real dice.
- lanewinfield 9y agoThey should definitely add a fan or compressed air to simulate blowing on the dice. For accuracy, of course.
- JamesNK 9y agoPremium feature: reserve a set of lucky dice for your roles. $5/month
- theandrewbailey 9y agoA few years ago, I found a WebGL physics-based dice roller. http://a.teall.info/dice/ http://a.teall.info/dice/
- King-Aaron 9y agoI just made it throw a few hundred dice in one roll, and chrome promptly packed it's bags on me
- Majestic121 9y agoIt works pretty well on my side, but I get stuck dices that never land
- yummybear 9y agoCan you add a table edge and some piece of furniture they can roll under?
- BatFastard 9y agoI assume for critical rolls (edit:roles) you also sacrifice small animals? Just as effective as talking to the dice!
- Claire88 9y agoas Phyllis replied I am in shock that any body able to make $4140 in a few weeks on the internet . try this website.. http://www.joinmate2.com http://www.joinmate2.com chek it site.
- philippnagel 9y agoThe Internet of Things is amazing.
- tofflos 9y agoIt's magnificent!
- PhasmaFelis 9y ago> I have used Math.random, Random.org and other sources, but have always received numerous complaints that the dice are not random enough. Some players have put more effort into statistical analysis of the rolls than they put into their doctoral dissertation. I seriously doubt that high-quality electronic randomness is non-random enough to have a noticeable effect on the outcome of board games. It's nice that the guy is accommodating enough to go to all this effort, but it seems unnecessary. Cool project, though.
- zackbloom 9y agoI think you can assume he's in on that joke. The goal of this was to build a fun machine, not to actually increase entropy.
- thiagocsf 9y agoThe fact that he offers to melt and mail a die to any player who complains of non-randomness is a giveaway he's having fun.
- Forge36 9y agoA similar story I recall was that shuffling a deck (by hand) vs randomly sorting cards. It's more likely that the values were TOO random and resulted in a less enjoyable experience (or the player wanted to blame someone other than themselves). I went looking for a video I recalled about a craps player able to choose what he'd roll. I didn't fint it but I did find: https://www.insidescience.org/news/dice-rolls-are-not-completely-random https://www.insidescience.org/news/dice-rolls-are-not-comple...
- dmurray 9y agoBridge is particularly prone to being affected by poor shuffling, for two reasons. Firstly, cards of the same suit are clumped together as part of each trick, and if they are not separated during the shuffle, get evenly distributed back to the players. Secondly, suit distribution is important in bridge - it's normal to describe a hand by the amount of each suit it has. Players noticed that voids and singletons were more common when playing online or with computer-generated hands. Unlike the board gamers of the article and everyone else who complains about bad RNGs, they had noticed a real effect, but the effect was backwards - the computer hands were better shuffled and more random.
- falcolas 9y agoInsufficient randomness from random.org? Odd. Seems like the only way it wouldn't be random is if the code transforming the output into die rolls was wrong, or if the inherent unfairness of dice with pips carved out of them is truly desired (which, it seems, could still be modeled from a truly random source). A cool machine though. I was expecting the captures to take place somewhere other than the lifting chain though, but it makes sense for the setup.
- dcookie 9y agoI think the insufficient "randomness" is explained here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14805265 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14805265
- falcolas 9y agoYou're probably right, it's probably more of a psychological issue than an issue of randomness. Perhaps his users simply trust dice more than they do "atmospheric noise with a certification of randomness across sliding windows", even though minor imperfections in dice (and dug-out pips are more than minor imperfections) will cause them to be much less fair. That said, it would be really interesting to see the referenced thesis-like papers. Or use high quality Vegas dice for awhile and compare the outcome of those to the purely random data.
- tgb 9y agoThat's discussing a different dice project - what's the connection to this one?
- misnome 9y agoThe psychological effect of people not "believing" true randomness is the same.
- amelius 9y agoI think there might even be a chance that there is bias in the die-recognition system, so random.org would be in fact more random.
- Animats 9y agoCute mechanism, but only running it part time and storing random numbers for later use is asking for a security breach. If you can find out what random numbers are coming up, you win. Vibratory bowl feeders pretty solve the problem of getting simple objects lined up.[1] Any object that isn't lined up properly gets dropped off the ramps back into the bowl for another try. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Mejn0n4IslY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Mejn0n4IslY
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- ckwalsh 9y agoAgreed, but it sounds like this project was for fun and to make users happy, not to actually guarantee true randomness. I would wager the amount of wear on the dice, and small flaws in each individual die, produce a non negligible bias to the rolls that could be avoided by using cryptographicly secure random sources. If they start using these dice to generate cryptographic keys, I'll run for the hills, but so long as they are only used for playing board games over the internet, this is really cool.
- cbanek 9y ago> If they start using these dice to generate cryptographic keys, I'll run for the hills, but so long as they are only used for playing board games over the internet, this is really cool. This just gave me a flashback to making cryptographic keys long ago, and adding in entropy by typing randomly on the keyboard. What a time to be alive.
- dpark 9y ago> If you can find out what random numbers are coming up, you win. So an adversary can breach the system and read the upcoming results but they can't mutate the results? That seems like an unlikely scenario. Also the security implications of this are that some jerk cheats at a board game. Hardly something to lose sleep over.
- 9y ago
- samfriedman 9y agoThis is great. Reminds me of the Lego brick identifier/sorter that was posted a while ago. Sure, there's no real reason that true-random bits from Random.org couldn't be used, but I think a project like this is neat precisely because it takes such great strides to bring back a classic physical component of playing board games that the service is otherwise designed to eliminate.
- BatFastard 9y agoA wonderful machine, I can imagine the sound of it two rooms away. So now as an engineer and semi-pro backgammon player, the ultimate dice were ones that had the divots drill out and replaced with a different colored plastic. This way the uneven weight of the dice was not a factor. Just wondering...
- b_emery 9y agoHas it ever been shown that dice not made as you describe are non-random?
- BatFastard 9y agoThe manufacturers represented them as less biases. I do not have any statistics to back it up. But it does make sense that the removal of any material would effect the rolling unless very sophisticated things were done to offset the remove of material.
- cbanek 9y agoReally? I've never heard of this, and I live in Vegas where fair dice are considered pretty important. The pips on opposing sides always add up to 7, and each of the faces are balanced (1 is in the center, 2 is on opposing corners, 3 is a line, 4 is all the corners, and 5 is the corners and the center, 6 is two rows). At least in craps, what the casinos worry about are fake dice, and not hitting the back wall with the dice. The back bumpy wall introduces a lot of randomness. Some people try to put the dice in various initial positions and roll them so that they only roll over one axis, to try to influence the rolls. The casino will throw you out if you don't hit the back wall repeatedly. Also, over time the sharp corners of the dice get ground down just by friction. Uneven wear is also a problem, which is why they frequently switch out the dice.
- BatFastard 9y agoThe I want to say (counter sunk) dice always have rounded corners too. I think the cost might outweigh the randomness benefit for Vegas.
- theophrastus 9y agoWhat an impressive device! Does it retain statistics keyed to a particular die? So that you could possible identify a 'loaded' cube which sneaked in?
- w8rbt 9y agoThis is awesome. Seems you could make it a business and sell some random bits. Maybe compete with hotbits and random.org.
- dang 9y agoDiscussed in 2009: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=626092 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=626092.
- rhizome 9y agoThe 10fps potatocam footage made me wonder.
- gsdfg4gsdg 9y agoIt would be cool if the online game showed you the actual photo of your dice roll.
- JoeDaDude 9y agoIf you need a really random number, NIST can provide one free of charge: https://beacon.nist.gov/home https://beacon.nist.gov/home
- kevin_thibedeau 9y agoIt would be interesting to silently switch back to a PRNG for a few months and see if anyone notices.
- saluki 9y agoI've been playing on gamesbyemail.com for over 12 years. It's amazing what Scott implemented early on in the AJAX era. I mainly play WW2 the Axis & Allies game. Amazing job. Great fun. He had a lego dice roller before this. Amazing site. Thanks for all the hard work on this.
- gburt 9y agoHow could rolling dice be "more random" by any meaningful definition of randomness than random.org? Rolling dice is a pretty trivial physics problem with really hard to observe parameters... parameters that the machine reduces the dimensionality of considerably.