9 ms·
Eating Clean is Useless
- x40r15x 9y agoI am sorry but GMO is actually bad for you.... Monsanto tried to spread gmo corn in France, they tested it on rats for a year and the rats developed multiple tumors the size of an egg.
- fusiongyro 9y agoI hate to be "that guy" but I'd like to see a source on that.
- WatchDog 9y agoI assume you are referring to this article[1]? Looks like there were numerous issues with it and it was retracted by the journal it was published in. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/S%C3%A9ralini_affair https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/S%C3%A9ralini_affair
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- koverda 9y agoRats and humans are very different.
- justin--sane 9y agoYou mean the retracted, unethical propaganda piece by Seralini? https://sciencebasedmedicine.org/the-seralini-gmo-study-retraction-and-response-to-critics/ https://sciencebasedmedicine.org/the-seralini-gmo-study-retr...
- coconut_crab 9y agoI thought the article was talking about eating food contaminated with dirt reading its title. Which I happen to agree with, small doses of bacteria do wonder for my immune system. It turned out to be an article of counterargument against antiGMO and organic food though.
- struppi 9y ago"100-percent organic, locally sourced, non-GMO, and free of antibiotics" Even if it does not have an effect on your health, three of those four (100-percent organic, locally sourced, and free of antibiotics) are at least good for the environment. The fourth (free of antibiotics) is maybe even good for your health, in the long run: Over-use of antibiotics by farmers (not using them to cure sick animals, but to make animals grow faster) seems to be a big problem (creating resistent bugs)... Edit (after reading a comment): I left out non-GMO here because I have ready about some evidence that - at least some GMOs - can be better for the environment and for your health.
- fusiongyro 9y agoYour wording makes it sound like you've accounted for all four of those adjectives, but you haven't done anything with "non-GMO."
- struppi 9y agoBecause some GMO might be better for your health AND for the environment. Like that GM rice that provides vitamins ppl in some parts of asia lack...
- Underqualified 9y agoOrganic is not automatically better for the environment, and often isn't. Sorry, one of my pet peeves.
- bpodgursky 9y ago100-percent organic is often bad for the environment because it takes more land to grow the same food. It often takes more energy to grow food locally (greenhouses and fertilizer) than transported food. Antibiotic-raised foods grow faster and thus have better caloric ratios, and less farmland per pound of beef.
- azinman2 9y agoSource? There are many ways in which organic and non-organic affect the environment other than land use (which is likely a marginal difference). Big agro, most associated with non-organic farming, does lots of bad things for the environment. Pesticides that are linked to decline of bee populations, pesticides that yield local imbalances in what animals/bugs are around to eat each other, synthetic fertilizers that thrash the land from being able to grow diverse crops into the future, chemical run offs into local water sources, exposure of workers to high concentrations of pesticides and their subsequent-related illnesses, GMO seeds spreading farther than the intended land mass mating with other species producing unknown effects (and lawsuits), etc.
- mc32 9y agoI eat organic fruit and vegetables mostly to avoid synthetic chemicals, and because you have more heirloom varieties which can offer better taste, but I'm not a vegetarian, so I'm okay with the blood meal and bone meal that goes into the product.
- qyv 9y agoWhat is the basis of the idea that organic pesticides and herbicides are safer/better than synthetic ones?
- loeg 9y agoThis article seems to be making the implicit claim that "clean eating" refers to eating organic products. On the other hand, I've always understood the expression to just mean eating healthy, especially including plenty of vegetables. Has the meaning changed or have I just always misunderstood it?
- eBombzor 9y agoI was confused the same way. I think the article should replace "clean" with "organic\non-GMO."
- ithought 9y agoThe best evidence for eating healthy are girls who do yoga.
- jjawssd 9y agoTo me "eating clean" means eating mostly vegetables by volume and mostly fat and protein by weight. For instance typical ketogenic/paleo diet. Eating "dirty" is theoretically doable. If one prototypical example of eating "dirty" is having a standard supermarket cake slice or mound of cereal and milk to fulfill daily caloric needs, then it is actually harder to maintain a "dirty" diet. Satiety becomes an unattainable goal. We simply cannot handle the insulin spikes well. We get hungry and cravings are more intense with such a diet. It is essentially impractical. It may also explain why there are so many obese in the world. "Eating clean" can be used as a marketing term to get people to fork over huge bucks for an oversold concept. But fundamentally, "eating clean" the way I define it is very cheap, tasty, and pragmatic. Especially for losing weight and maintaining a low weight.
- edejong 9y ago"Eating dirty is theoretically possible". I think you mean "hypothetically", unless you have some references to scientific research?
- jjawssd 9y agoSorry; my English is poor.
- TheSpiceIsLife 9y agoThis is how I eat, with the addition of nuts, seeds, and legumes. I focus on are cruciferous vegetables, of which there are many, and buy only what is on special. When maintain this eating plan I have boundless energy and am emotionally stable. When I don't I am tired and letharg all the time and prone to angry outbursts.
- 0xbear 9y agoNon-GMO and organic is mostly BS of course, but it's a fact that refined carbs are cheap and plentiful, so the poor consume proportionally more of them. They simply can't afford fruit and meat. This is in part because of the infinite shelf life of processed carbs, and in part because they're heavily subsidized by the government. Also, government dietary guidelines still push people towards relatively high carb diets, and snacking is encouraged from kindergarten and up, causing insulin resistance and type 2 diabetes. The point being, the nutritional situation in the US is a clusterfuck, and GMO and organic stuff are kind of orthogonal to rectifying it.
- usaphp 9y ago> snacking is encouraged from kindergarten and up, causing insulin resistance and type 2 diabetes. It's not snacking that is causing insulin resistance and type 2 diabetes. Snacking is good if you eat healthy snacks.
- fratlas 9y agosnacking is bad? I thought it was good for your metabolism.
- sgift 9y agoNot really: https://intensivedietarymanagement.com/perils-snacking-hormonal-obesity-xiii/ https://intensivedietarymanagement.com/perils-snacking-hormo...
- majkinetor 9y agoContext really matters. With acid reflux, snacking is good.
- sgift 9y agoContext always matters, but the question was about metabolism. Acid reflux is a completely different matter.
- 9y ago
- kneel 9y ago'Clean eating' is suppose to be about eating minimally processed foods. You can eat plenty of GMO produce and mass produced meat and still eat 'clean'
- smegel 9y agoLink doesn't work in Australia. Just get redirected to https://www.vice.com/en_au https://www.vice.com/en_au. Yet this works: https://www.vice.com/en_au/article/d385ak/eating-clean-is-useless https://www.vice.com/en_au/article/d385ak/eating-clean-is-us...
- Jeaye 9y agoThe most appealing benefits of organic foods, in my household, are not to do with our own health. Instead, we adopt the practice under the information that organic farming is more sustainable and better for the environment. Top three search results for "organic food better for environment." http://www.fao.org/organicag/oa-faq/oa-faq6/en/ http://www.fao.org/organicag/oa-faq/oa-faq6/en/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/lifestyle/food/is-organic-agriculture-really-better-for-the-environment/2016/05/14/e9996dce-17be-11e6-924d-838753295f9a_story.html https://www.washingtonpost.com/lifestyle/food/is-organic-agr... http://www.thechicecologist.com/green-living/food-drink/is-organic-food-really-better-for-the-environment/ http://www.thechicecologist.com/green-living/food-drink/is-o... Regarding it being a "rich [white] people thing," either way, that may very well be, in practice. Is caring about sustainable farming and the environmental impact of our savage resouce consumption also a rich white people thing?
- kirrent 9y agoOn the other hand, if you search "organic food worse for environment" you get results which explain why organic farming is less sustainable. Your search results are dependent on your query so if you search "vaccination schedule bad for children" don't be surprised when you get some highly placed anti-vax stuff. In any case, assuming you eat a diet typical of an organic shopper with far less meat and more vegetables compared to the general population then organic farming is merely as carbon intensive and uses only 40% more land. If you buy organic but have a pretty normal diet then it's even worse. Is it a rich person thing? Switching to organic for everyone would require massive deforestation worldwide and probably still wouldn't get us enough arable land so not only would the price of food go up, we'd likely be hit with large food shortages that would probably disproportionately hit the developing world. Yeah, it's a rich person thing. They're the people who can afford organic and they're fine when food shortages come along. https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Maria_Nordborg/publication/316871522_Carbon_footprints_and_land_use_of_conventional_and_organic_diets_in_Germany/links/59340791aca272fc553cb695/Carbon-footprints-and-land-use-of-conventional-and-organic-diets-in-Germany.pdf https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Maria_Nordborg/publicat...
- justin--sane 9y agoWhat about the heavily increased land use in organic farming? http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0959652617309666 http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0959652617... What about the pesticides used in organic farming? I'd jug some Roundup (LD50: 5,600 mg/kg in rats) before eating Copper sulfate (LD50: 30 mg/kg in rats) used in organic farming. My main problem is, that the whole thing is just a big appeal to nature. More natural does not mean safer for consumption or better for the environment.
- sapote 9y agoThis article smacks of narrow-minded contrarianism for its own sake. The cheapest thing one can do -- and healthier than the option of eating Lucky Charms daily -- is to grow one's own food. The space requirements are actually tiny -- it's possible to grow all of one's own veggies in something like 300 sq ft of space (in a mid-latitude region) and all one's own calories in something like 800 sq ft of space. It's cheaper to do it without sprays too, so you end up organic by default. I'd recommend interested folks check out ... Grow More Vegetables ... by John Jeavons and One Circle by David Duhon for how to do space-efficient veggie gardening. Edited to add: I should have mentioned: I'm opposed to the fad diets that the article is attacking as much as I am to the contrarian posture the article takes. Growing food and eating it, and eating a variety of such homegrown foods with a mix of other things, seems sensible to me, and it's also cheaper than either highly-processed industrial food products or fad-oriented yuppie foods.
- Banthum 9y agoThis is only a cheap option if you consider your own labor to be free. Plus don't forget about the seasonality of the crops, the effort of preservation, etc.
- sapote 9y agoIt is free. The time you spend in the garden is time you would have otherwise spent exercising in some other form and (to a lesser extent) shopping.
- saosebastiao 9y agoIm glad you've found something that works for you, but you must understand that you have quite the unique circumstance there. There is no gardening out there that would ever be able to replace the exercise that I do...gardening is extremely mild cardio at best. And 300-800 sqft of sun-exposed space per person in the city where I live would undoubtedly cost an order of magnitude more than I currently spend on food. If it were really that easy to grow one's own food, industrialization would have never happened.
- gpsx 9y agoI think the author researched this article after selecting his position rather than vice versa. He keeps claiming health benefits have not been shown to be true. He goes so far as to say: "...organic produce tends to have more antioxidants—but those differences haven't been shown to improve health outcomes." Maybe, but I'm pretty sure they do. In my experience being around a good number of athletic people, the ones who look really good, as in others do double takes or give gratuitous compliments, are not the ones work out the most but instead the ones who eat the best.
- fuwafuwa 9y agoAll of our fitness and nutrition advice is troubled by the cargo-culting, marketing-driven, personal-religion factors: if I go to a yoga class I spend a lot more time and money to get effects roughly similar to doing a high school gym class stretching regime each morning and evening. I paid $14 yesterday for the experience of a burger with a fancy name and an overly sweetened bun that was ultimately less satisfying than Burger King. If I buy and use supplements marketed by a bodybuilder, or try to follow their training program as printed in a magazine, I'm not going to look like the bodybuilder, and I will probably overtrain, because they weren't using the supplements at all, they were using a PED stack to train harder, eat more, and recover faster without overloading their system. Worrying about my body weight, BMI, or aesthetics is similarly Quixotic in that my body will prefer to stay in a certain range regardless of how I eat or train, and the numbers I can consistently improve tend to be "weight and reps" or "time and distance", while aesthetics and vanity numbers are much harder to aim towards. To wit, it's more important to develop your own feedback loops for each of these things. There are serious concerns with fitness and nutrition in the U.S. but they aren't necessarily because it's impossible to get at the good stuff: it's just that eating beans and rice and oatmeal, making a habit of stretching and bodyweight exercise, and studiously logging one's training are all unfashionable, implicitly discouraged by most workplaces, and not well served by market forces.
- brucephillips 9y ago> implicitly discouraged by most workplaces What do you mean?
- fuwafuwa 9y agoLong "crunch" work hours with little or no enforced break, laissez-faire approaches to lunch and break room snacks, occasional encouragement to drink alcohol, lengthy car commutes to office parks, heavy preference towards in-person over remote. These are just some of the things workplaces do to lifestyle that are too small to be a topic for regulation but big enough to impact lives.
- ice109 9y agothis kind of thinking is just another iteration of self-serving anti-intellectualism (akin to climate change denial and anti-vaxxing). there is absolutely hard exercise science you can read in order to exercise more effectively than "stretching" (an activity whose value has never been empirically proven) and "body-weight" exercises (slightly more effective than nothing but pales in comparison to real weight training and cardio). protein supplementing does work[1], creatine does work[2], caffeine+ephedrine does work[3] (though you can't buy that anymore). the hard science is in exactly the same place it always is: research journals. for starters I always recommended exrx.net. [1] http://m.ajcn.nutrition.org/content/96/6/1454.short http://m.ajcn.nutrition.org/content/96/6/1454.short [2] https://jissn.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/1550-2783-4-6 https://jissn.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/1550-2783-4... [3] http://europepmc.org/abstract/med/1318281 http://europepmc.org/abstract/med/1318281
- Qantourisc 9y agoPossible problems with GMO: - Harder to digest proteins - Possible new allergies for some people (because if slightly different proteins, or mixes from other plants) - Plants with build in pesticide - Patents - Plant monoculture - Plants that grow faster and are cheaper, but not optimized for taste. Is the above list inherit to GMO's: no. Do I know if the GMO I am eating is suffering from this: no. As such until I get detailed information about your GMO, I prefer to avoid it.
- TeMPOraL 9y agoWait, you listed some hypotheticals, said they don't necessarily apply, and still concluded they do? But what do I know. I'm a food contrarian - if I see two items, one labeled "no GMO" and one without such label, I pick the latter...
- brucephillips 9y ago> and still concluded they do? When did they do this?
- TeMPOraL 9y agoThe way I read that comment was: - [list of possible problems with GMOs] - Are they inherent to GMOs? No. - Do I know if a given GMO has them? No. - Conclusion: I will avoid GMOs.
- dragonwriter 9y agoYou don't know if modern non-GMO crops have these problems, either; transgenic (“GMO”) crops actually have greater controls than modern non-transgenic (“non-GMO”, though their genetics are, in fact, artificially modified) crops in many ways. It's completely irrational to focus on “GMOs”.
- quickthrower 9y agoLink takes me to a page of round the web adverts and no article? Anyone else getting that?
- Underqualified 9y agoTo me eating clean means avoiding preprocessed food, the author is taking a much more extreme view which to me feels like a straw man. If someone is used to junk food and switches to more fruit, veggies, lean meat and fish, I'm pretty sure they'll start noticing a difference after a little while. I know it worked for me (n=1).
- Toine 9y agoClickbait title leading to poorly written article by a mid 30s man-child wanting to justify eating Lucky Charms everyday because he left mom's house too soon. "Eating clean is useless" is such a terrible statement to make, especially today. You want to eat crap, good for you, but don't try to avoid feeling bad about it.
- yellowapple 9y agoI never understood the hate toward GMOs themselves, considering that genetic modification is practically the definition of agriculture as it's existed for thousands of years. Granted, we relied on artificial selection instead of, say, CRISPR, but still. I do understand the hate toward companies like Monsanto, however. Hating all GMOs because of some unethical company peddling them seems heavy-handed and broad-stroked to me, though.
- kirrent 9y agoI'm always interested in people's perceptions of Monsanto considering that to me they seem like an entirely pedestrian and boring GM crops company with a couple of cool products. Perhaps you could explain why you dislike them and think they're unethical?
- yellowapple 9y agoI don't like their intellectual property policies. Suing small farmers because their crops were inadvertently exposed to patent-encumbered Monsanto pollen is, suffice it to say, a dick move. Monsanto is basically to agriculture as Oracle is to IT.
- kirrent 9y agoPerhaps you could link me to an example where that happened? Probably the most famous cases of Monsanto suing farmers were Bowman v. Monsanto and Monsanto v. Schmeiser. In both cases the infringement was entirely purposeful. Schmesier's case is one where the seeds were initially blown onto his property so that may be what you're referring to. From Wikipedia: As established in the original Federal Court trial decision, Percy Schmeiser, a canola breeder and grower in Bruno, Saskatchewan, first discovered Roundup-resistant canola in his crops in 1997. He had used Roundup herbicide to clear weeds around power poles and in ditches adjacent to a public road running beside one of his fields, and noticed that some of the canola which had been sprayed had survived. Schmeiser then performed a test by applying Roundup to an additional 3 acres (12,000 m2) to 4 acres (16,000 m2) of the same field. He found that 60% of the canola plants survived. At harvest time, Schmeiser instructed a farmhand to harvest the test field. That seed was stored separately from the rest of the harvest, and used the next year to seed approximately 1,000 acres (4 km²) of canola. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monsanto_Canada_Inc_v_Schmeiser https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monsanto_Canada_Inc_v_Schmeise... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monsanto_legal_cases#As_plaintiff https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monsanto_legal_cases#As_plaint...
- trabant00 9y agoA little straw man here, a little twisting of the meaning of clean there and voila: trying to eat healthy is classist and racist. Junk food is being marketed at poor uneducated people. Yes! That is even more reason to fight it, not find escuses to indulge in it. And if you are really into social justice and the like, that yoga guy and the whole white middle class is not the enemy of the poor black guys. They are not the owners of junk food mega corporations, nor do they pass laws to subsidize corn syrup. If you want to "stick it to the man" stop buying his horrible products. "Fuck you white middle class yoga guy, I'm eating all the Nestle shit I can find, take that!" - how dumb is this?
- sapote 9y agoAgreed. I'm surprised at the support for this article... I somehow got downvoted for saying that growing one's own food is a great alternative to the narrow perspective the article is pushing.
- Toine 9y agoMost people prefer to find justifications for their generally poor diet choices (ie eating Lucky Charms every day) rather than being objective. Food is really an emotional thing for most of us.
- sprayk 9y agoExcept the author didn't call actual healthy eating classist/racist, nor did he promote the consumption of junk food. It was argued that the use of the label "clean" was classist/racist, and that pursuing it alone is pointless because science.
- vorotato 9y agoI think the maxim "There is no ethical consumption under capitalism" whether true or not is useful here
- sprayk 9y agoIs there a single definition of "clean"? The author has one definition which seems based on items commonly found on labels, like "non-gmo" or "certified organic", that gives consumers an easy way to feel good about what they are about to eat. The commenters here, however, seem to each have their own different idea. Is it keto? Is it organic/"chemical-free"? Can someone point me to one single definition of "clean" eating that isn't just what you feel is "clean"? If there is, how does it line up with the author's definition? How does the actual definition fit with the content of the article? If there isn't one definition, I'm sort of with the author on this one. "Clean" is whatever labels the consumers use to feel superior through what they are eating.
- siliconc0w 9y agoI have a pet theory that food ideology is/has replaced conventional religion for a lot of folks. There is a need to feel 'virtuous' in our daily lives and since we gotta eat it's a convenient place to go. So we get all these strange ideologies and dogmas which don't seem to make us much healthier physically but maybe helps fills in some accumulated spiritual decay.
- usharf 9y agoIn respect to value, at least, bio/organic (real, not just misleading labeling) is suppose to be free of pesticides, and that's actually a good thing... I'm sure. Regardless, I don't think even the WHO suggests there's a preference to organic food, but clearly indicates the danger of food contaminated with pesticides. Even if most pesticides are now forbidden in most developed countries, we can see that in the USA legislation and regulation is being again "relaxed", which is not a good thing.
- Mikeb85 9y agoWhile the article is somewhat correct in that 'clean eating' is useless, what the hell is up with every single US News outlet literally stirring up racial tensions? Back to the clean eating part - all my ancestors that I know of (grandparents, great-grandparents) at relatively unhealthy food. Tons of butter, lard, and carbs. True, it was natural-ish, they all grew up on a homestead, but far from the 'clean eating' ideal. As for the racial tensions, WTF? Does every single article in every single outlet have to bring it up? All this does is make it worse in my experience.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- Banthum 9y agoThey don't want to solve the problem, they want to exploit the problem. A lot of media/activist/political activity makes a lot more sense through this lens.
- svaha1728 9y ago"And for 30 years I've somehow not only survived but thrived. " At 30 years of age, your habits haven't caught up to you yet. A 30-year-old smoker could make the same claim.
- nunez 9y agoFinally. So true. "Eating clean" is probably one of the best marketing campaigns in history; billions of dollars spent on products that make you feel healthier, but in reality, don't amount to shit. It's all about calories in, calories out and macronutrient composition (carbs, fats, proteins). That's literally it.* * Unless you seriously train for a sport, in which case the little stuff (eating time, micronutrients, # of meals, etc) matter.