12 ms·
How economics became a religion
- vbuwivbiu 9y agoEconomics is worse than religion: it's astrology. It has the trappings of mathematics (ODEs and whatnot) as astrology uses numbers, like astrology and auguring (in their day) economics is a fantasy serving to flatter the powerful.
- igravious 9y agoNot true. Too cynical. That the economy is amenable to quantification is unquestionably true. That it has so far completely resisted our advances is false. Edit: Having said that I see where you're coming from.
- tnone 9y agoIf economics is the study of macro-psychology, then it would have the same problems as regular psychology: the inability to do truly controlled experiments, only with an even smaller set of entities to build your N out of. I think the closest we can get is to compare the predictions from their theories to reality X years later. It anyone has done that, I'd be very curious to see it.
- igravious 9y agoWhat's macro-psychology? Do you mean group-psychology? Economics is the study of a particular value system within society, that value system being the monetary/capital one. Human psychology comes into play (both at the individual and group level) because human evaluation and action is involved.
- tnone 9y agoGroup psychology vs egregore psychology. The difference is whether you are paying attention to individual desires in aggregate, or whether you are attributing desires to the collective entity that no single individual has.
- Retric 9y agoEconomics has many successes, but the problem is it's trying to approach psychology with math. They know that people are not actually rational, but there is some value in treating them as such.
- nabla9 9y agoRational choice theory is usually the right model. There are others.
- culturalzero 9y agoThe biggest problem I run into with this is that I believe the bounds of rationality for different individuals had far more variability than is accounted for. I suppose it's still useful to look at for a perspective on some things though
- NhanH 9y agoI know nothing of modern economics, but couldn't you just model the rationality of individual as a random variable like everything else?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- nabla9 9y agoEconomic models usually look at average behaviour for large groups. There are cases where the model breaks, but jumping into "oh, it was all bs then" is just populism.
- mannykannot 9y agoI hope that 'right', in this context, means that it leads to observationally verifiable predictions of significant real-world events, and not, say, 'makes the math tractable', or 'produces results that conform to the existing tenets of economic theory'. I would be less skeptical if there were not apparently at least two schools of economists, producing diametrically opposed analyses and recommendations for any situation.
- blibble 9y agoI think Futurama got it right with their "voodoo economists"
- Tomminn 9y agoWhich was originally a quip Bush Sr used to describe Reaganomics.
- raverbashing 9y agoA lot of economics is just concepts built on pure math (interest rates, etc). There's nothing astrological about this Statistical models also are interesting but there are limitations, both at micro and macro levels But I think people take its prediction power too seriously and ignore linked events that seem independent at first (like low graded loans failing affecting payment of other loans)
- mcguire 9y agoSee Milton Friedman's "The Methodology of Positive Economics" (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Essays_in_Positive_Economics https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Essays_in_Positive_Economics): "Truly important and significant hypotheses will be found to have "assumptions" that are wildly inaccurate descriptive representations of reality, and, in general, the more significant the theory, the more unrealistic the assumptions (in this sense) (p. 14)."
- thinkfurther 9y ago> A lot of economics is just concepts built on pure math A lot of numerology is also pure math, addition for example.
- raverbashing 9y agoIf you can't see the difference between an interest rate and "finding your lucky number" this discussion can't be furthered
- thinkfurther 9y agoInterest rate is "pure math", and used within a framework, parts of it rather arbitrary. "finding your lucky number" is framework and adding up numbers in a name or stuff like that is "pure addition", so that framework uses pure math. That's my point, you're just not getting it.
- tempodox 9y ago> ... it's astrology. And it has alchemists, too. Like the alchemists of old were searching for a formula to make gold (assuming they legitimately tried and were not just scamming their employers), their modern-day peers try to find a formula for producing unicorns.
- nabla9 9y agohttps://www.bloomberg.com/view/articles/2017-07-14/so-many-critics-of-economics-miss-what-it-gets-right https://www.bloomberg.com/view/articles/2017-07-14/so-many-c... Noah Smith has good rebuttal for standard blanket critiques and he uses this article as an example.
- culturalzero 9y agoIdk... He admits upfront that the standard critiques have merit, but that recent shifts to hard data are a positive upheaval(thank you, you hackers you).
- Analemma_ 9y agoToo bad the Austrian Schoolers didn’t get that memo and continue carrying on as though lack of empiricism is some kind of virtue.
- saosebastiao 9y agoThe "Austrian school" isn't what you think it is. The Austrian school refers to a theoretical school of thought of a very narrow subsection of macroeconomics (which itself is a very narrow subsection of economics) called business cycle theory. That subsection doesn't even represent 1% of what professional economists worry about, yet it somehow has 100% of the attention of armchair economists and political parties. The funny thing about the statement isn't that it is true (the Austrian school doesn't rely on empiricism) but rather that you singled out a single school of business cycle theory for that criticism. Because BCT can't rely on empiricism. It is an area of economics where controlled experiments are impossible and standard impact measurement methods used in econometrics are not applicable due to dynamic cycles. That's the reason why "see, look at this trend line...your idea didn't work" is always defended by "well it would have been worse if we didn't do it!". The implication is that by design, none of the "schools" of BCT use empiricism and all of them rely primarily on theory. Any appearance of empiricism coming from one of those schools is highly suspect on its face and far more likely to come from a politically backed think tank than from a peer review process. And that includes the incredibly terrible claims of empiricism from Keynesian and Monetarist schools in addition to your target of scorn.
- igravious 9y agoThey use the word `ideology' in the article, it would be more correct to use it in the title as well. Both sectarian religious thinkers and partisan economists let their ideology lead their reasoning. So are oblivious to this, others are aware of it.
- nautilus12 9y agoSouthpark already explored this concept pretty well I think. Season 13 episode 3. Im gonna go watch that instead of read this :P
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- Torai 9y agoEconomists don't want to address the elephant in the room: whenever money is created, by private interests, is given to governments and society as debt. So, the way economy is structured now, it's by design a transfer of wealth => resources => power from the public to the powerful.
- JumpCrisscross 9y ago> whenever money is created, by private interests, [it] is given to governments and society as debt The U.S. government, in 2016, issued $1.4 trillion of debt [1] and took in almost $3 trillion in taxes [2]. I'm not sure I see your point. [1] https://www.treasurydirect.gov/govt/reports/pd/feddebt/feddebt_ann2016.pdf https://www.treasurydirect.gov/govt/reports/pd/feddebt/fedde... [2] http://federal-budget.insidegov.com/l/119/2016 http://federal-budget.insidegov.com/l/119/2016
- muninn_ 9y agoBut that $3 trillion is all spent. Is it not?
- JumpCrisscross 9y ago> But that $3 trillion is all spent. Is it not? And the $1.9 trillion isn't? At the micro level, economies are just transactions. People (e.g. natural persons, companies and governments) buy goods and services with money or credit. Credit creates debt. "Money" would still exist if we zeroed out debt, e.g. gold-based economies of yore, but that destroys the double-entry ledger system [1] that serves as a a distributed error-correcting mechanism. It also decouples the currency from economic growth, which produces all kinds of nasty side effects. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Double-entry_bookkeeping_system https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Double-entry_bookkeeping_syste...
- paulpauper 9y agoIt want to capital infusions for major banks and QE-related asset swaps. It's not like money was printed and given to people.
- adekok 9y agoA personal anecdote about Economics... A friend was doing a Masters in Nuclear Physics at the same time as myself. She decided she didn't like it, and went to do a Masters in Economics. 4 months later, she was back in Physics. Over a beer, she told me that the comment which did it for her was a professor who claimed "The math you're learning now is more complex than nuclear physics." Uh.... right. She showed me her notes (math, no explanation), and I correctly identified it as Bayesian probability calculations. It's hard to have respect for a field when they're don't know what they're doing, and still think they're better than everyone else. I'm sure there's lots of things in economics which are real and useful, but there's a lot of woo in it, too.
- agumonkey 9y agoIt's also present in other fields. Maybe in most fields. We're kinda looking at the gem of knowledge from our own perspective thinking we found the best one.
- Olivia4654 9y agoI've made $64,000 so far this year working online and I'm a full time student. Im using an online business opportunity I heard about and I've made such great money. It's really user friendly and I'm just so happy that I found out about it. Heres what I do, ====http://www.joinmate2.com http://www.joinmate2.com
- adekok 9y agoSadly, no. Or, not anywhere near that level of BS. There are fields where the practitioners actively try to dis-prove themselves. Where they are aware of the limits of human psychology, and design experiments / analsyses to work around their own limitations. These fields are called "science". There are other disciplines which don't do that, but who do fake it. See Noam Chomsky for a great explanation: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1M-2_OD3oMc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1M-2_OD3oMc
- mistermann 9y ago
- Suncho 9y agoTo be fair, they're mostly talking about macroeconomics.
- agumonkey 9y agoAnything too large and too diffuse is religion IMO. Technology, growth based capitalism etc .. It's what people holds as an entity to respect by "all" means.
- Vektorweg 9y agoSuggested recently by Richard Wolff and many others before him: a possible solution out of this economy is worker coops aka democracy at work. https://youtu.be/ynbgMKclWWc https://youtu.be/ynbgMKclWWc
- JumpCrisscross 9y agoI tend to believe a diversity of systems is the healthiest state. Coöperative housing, for example, has a mixed history in New York. By removing price as a selection factor, they whitewashed "other* selection criteria, e.g. race [1]. [1] http://www.nytimes.com/2013/05/10/nyregion/new-bill-seeks-to-curb-discrimination-by-co-op-boards.html http://www.nytimes.com/2013/05/10/nyregion/new-bill-seeks-to...
- Vektorweg 9y agoDemocracy itself is certainly not the best decision making process, but it tends to avoid some radical pitfalls of oligarchic and tyrannic processes.
- JumpCrisscross 9y agoElections behave differently depending on scale [1]. This may be a function of the law of large numbers [2], or that the difficulty of coördinating scales exponentially with the number of people one must coördinate [3]. A small group of people with absolute authority to decide who does and doesn't get to live in a building can be more tyrannical than a large group of people forced to compete on just price. (And vice versa.) [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Selectorate_theory https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Selectorate_theory [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Law_of_large_numbers https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Law_of_large_numbers [3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Theory_of_the_firm https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Theory_of_the_firm
- jostmey 9y agoFrom what little exposure I had as a student in Biological sciences to the economics department at the University of Chicago, I saw the economics department as an excuse to do lots of sophisticated mathematics and proofs. I never heard people in the economics department talk about collecting data or measuring the flow of money. It was always prove this or solve that. It was the opposite of science and very much like theology -- theory divorced from testable observation Edit, I need to emphasize the use of the word little
- dbecker 9y agoEconomic research can be roughly divided into three subfields: Macroeconomics, Micro theory, and Empirical Micro. The first 2/3 of an undergrad curriculum at most universities is all macro and micro theory. So, most of what an undergrad sees is prove this or solve that. But far more econ faculty focus on empirical work for their personal research. It's possible that we focus on theory because it spreads economic orthodoxy faster than empirical work. But economists spend much less time doing theory when they are outside undergraduate classrooms.
- JumpCrisscross 9y ago> It's possible that we focus on theory because it spreads economic orthodoxy faster than empirical work Or for the same reasons we start physics in a frictionless, idealized environment.
- arethuza 9y agoPretty sure when I started physics in high school we started with measuring trolleys accelerating (or not) done an inclined run timed with ticker tape and covered the maths alongside the experiments. Edit: I seem to remember friction being addressed pretty quickly as it was required to explain why your trolley would stop accelerating.... [NB It's been 30+ years]
- tpeo 9y agoWhy would they talk about data? Data collection in economics is often very much outside the scope of economics departments. Not only because it's beyond the budgets of individual departments to maintain the necessary personnel, but because it's hard to get people to disclose that sort of information. That task falls mostly on the lap of government and international organizations, who have the sort of legitimacy to pull that off. Besides that, there's experimental data, surveys sent out to private organizations and private (closed) databases. But the majority of the data used in econ deparments was produced elsewhere. If what you wanted to hear someone talk about "measuring the flow of money", you'd probably be better off in some Federal Reserve bank.
- known 9y agoJust 3% is cash in the economy; Everything else is debt, debt and damn statistics; http://www.positivemoney.org/our-proposals/debt-based-money-vs-sovereign-money-infographic/ http://www.positivemoney.org/our-proposals/debt-based-money-...
- JumpCrisscross 9y ago> for every pound in your bank account someone else must have a pound of debt This is called double-entry bookkeeping [1]. Every pound in your bank account is a debt on the bank's balance sheet. If it weren't, you wouldn't have any claim to exercise when you walked into the bank to demand your deposits. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Double-entry_bookkeeping_system https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Double-entry_bookkeeping_syste...
- andy_ppp 9y agoThat’s true except fractional reserve banking means the lending of those “debts” out by the bank multiple times. Doesn’t seem really like a liability in the normal sense.
- JumpCrisscross 9y ago> Doesn’t seem really like a liability in the normal sense Banks borrow from depositors and lend to borrowers. Deposits are a liability in that if the bank can't pay them back, the bank's assets are seized the firm put under conservatorship (or even liquidated, e.g. Lehman Brothers). Note that eliminating fractional-reserve banking, i.e. switching to a full-money system [1] per the Chicago Plan [2] is not a free lunch. It shifts a lot of power from de-centralised actors to the state. That, in turn, makes central-bank independence even more important [3]. (Note that implementing the Chicago Plan would maintain double-entry bookkeeping, and so the persistent Internet meme about us being in a debt-denominated economy.) [1] https://blogs.cfainstitute.org/investor/2016/01/27/is-this-the-end-of-fractional-reserve-banking/ https://blogs.cfainstitute.org/investor/2016/01/27/is-this-t... [2] http://www.imf.org/external/pubs/ft/wp/2012/wp12202.pdf http://www.imf.org/external/pubs/ft/wp/2012/wp12202.pdf [3] https://people.ucsc.edu/~walshc/MyPapers/cbi_newpalgrave.pdf https://people.ucsc.edu/~walshc/MyPapers/cbi_newpalgrave.pdf
- known 9y ago$1.54 trillion is CASH. $19.96 trillion is DEBT. http://www.federalreserve.gov/faqs/currency_12773.htm http://www.federalreserve.gov/faqs/currency_12773.htm
- spfan 9y agoSouth Park did an episode about this https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=7OevEml84BI https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=7OevEml84BI
- paulpauper 9y agoYet if history teaches anything, it’s that whenever economists feel certain that they have found the holy grail of endless peace and prosperity, the end of the present regime is nigh. On the eve of the 1929 Wall Street crash, the American economist Irving Fisher advised people to go out and buy shares; in the 1960s, Keynesian economists said there would never be another recession because they had perfected the tools of demand management. 2008 crash was no different. Five years earlier, on 4 January 2003, the Nobel laureate Robert Lucas had delivered a triumphal presidential address to the American Economics Association. Reminding his colleagues that macroeconomics had been born in the depression precisely to try to prevent another such disaster ever recurring, he declared that he and his colleagues had reached their own end of history: “Macroeconomics in this original sense has succeeded,” he instructed the conclave. “Its central problem of depression prevention has been solved.” Sigh...it seems like every month there is new article that degenerates economics by comparing to a religion or astrology. Economists don't need to be able to predict http://greyenlightenment.com/why-economists-dont-need-to-be-able-to-predict/ http://greyenlightenment.com/why-economists-dont-need-to-be-... A doctor cannot predict with 100% certainty when or if someone will get sick. A car mechanic cannot predict with 100% certainty when someone's car will fail. Economics models such as the Black Scholes equation do an adequate at describing reality. Are they perfect/ no, but in most instances good enough. When such models fail, they can be modified, but that does mean having to do away with models altogether. In the past few decades, very sophistical financial models have been developed that can account for nearly everything. I agree that over-reliance on models can be problematic, but models are descriptive, not just prescriptive. Just saying "We don't know" and ending it there means scientific progress stalls. The 2008 bank bailout, in retrospect , although maligned, was a success by infusing liquidity to the weakest parts of the economy (financial institutions, housing, etc.) so that the healthier parts (retail, tech, payment processing) would bot be hurt too much by contagion. The post-2008 bull market and ecoomic expansion is the longest ever, and programs such as TARP helped in that regard, but also the strength of the private sector, exports, technology, and consumer spending. No sooner do we persuade ourselves that the economic priesthood has finally broken the old curse than it comes back to haunt us all: pride always goes before a fall. Since the crash of 2008, most of us have watched our living standards decline. Meanwhile, the priesthood seemed to withdraw to the cloisters, bickering over who got it wrong. Not surprisingly, our faith in the “experts” has dissipated. The S&P 500 is 60% higher than it was in 2008. After factoring in dividends, it's 80% higher. Profits & earnings have also grown considerably. Dwelling on the mistakes and crisis of the past means one overlooks how things have improved. For decades, neoliberal evangelists replied to such objections by saying it was incumbent on us all to adapt to the model, which was held to be immutable – one recalls Bill Clinton’s depiction of neoliberal globalisation, for instance, as a “force of nature”. And yet, in the wake of the 2008 financial crisis and the consequent recession, there has been a turn against globalisation across much of the west. More broadly, there has been a wide repudiation of the “experts”, most notably in the 2016 US election and Brexit referendum. I agree that many experts who predicted a bear market and recession as a consequences of Brexit and Trump were dead wrong, but that goes to show how hard predicting is (but I'm sure personal political biases also played a role). But economics is also descriptive: the US economy did not enter recession, simply because Brexit and Trump failed to have any negative impact on earnings.
- unit91 9y ago> Over time, successive economists slid into the role we had removed from the churchmen: giving us guidance on how to reach a promised land of material abundance and endless contentment. I don't think the author understands Christianity at all.
- throwaway7645 9y agoYea, sounds like a baseless jab.
- mathgeek 9y agoSounds like the televangelist form of Christianity, or the various offshoots dealing with prosperity.
- Spooky23 9y agoDepending on where you live, stuff like prosperity gospel is both mainstream and dominant, especially if you aren't associated with a less extroverted church that doesn't use modern marketing. This modern religious thing that you see is weird to me. I spent most of my childhood going to an urban Franciscan catholic parish. Those guys took charity seriously and would have sold off the pews except that they didn't actually own the church building they were in.
- lordnacho 9y agoThere's a good section in Harari's recent book Sapiens where he lumps ideologies with religion. Basically the common thing is a shared strong belief in some idea, the only difference being whether it involves supernatural creatures. My own take on economics is I'm glad I studied it while also studying engineering. Taken with a proper science, you learn an awful lot about how how to think critically. If you only do science, you don't think too much about whether the conclusions are warranted. You gasp, but it's true. And it's because you can pursue the evidence in a very detailed way in sciences, and that has been done for you by the time you come to study it. So when you're learning, most of the time isn't spent on considering whether you believe in quantum tunnelling. Your time is mostly spent understanding the intricacies of the explanation, and calculating predictions based on the theory. With economics, all my engineering friends would make a face when you talked about it. Law of one price? Really? Oh yeah, it's an idealised world. And in contrast to the frictionless, airless world in intro physics, we don't have much of a clue of how loosening the assumptions affects the model. For instance there are agent based models where you get multiple prices. Other unlikely things are where some consumer is meant to be optimizing some utility function. Most graduates will find this hard to do with a computer, so I'm not sure I believe the hand-wavy "they use a heuristic" explanation. Also, my parents ran a restaurant and despite having an economics degree I never saw my dad draw a nice supply and demand X to set prices. That being said I still think there's a lot of value in economics, especially on the micro end. It's worthwhile having a simple market model in your head, where "market model" actually means a catalog of how markets can deviate from Econ 101. Mainly it' a collection of failures of information. Lemon problem, star-systems in employment, network externalities. Also game theoretic ideas are useful to have heard of, even though the actual models are incredibly complex. With macro, I wondered whether anything was learned. A lot of it seems like mathfuscation. Econometric models can get very complicated. More complicated normally means it needs a lot of data to validate. But how is economic data gathered? Well it depends on what the economic theory of the time finds important. And it's not cheap or easy to gather, so you don't get terribly much data. A GDP print comes out maybe four times a year. And the economic regime has shifted over the years with various governments, so how do we draw any conclusions? A lot of the political "lessons" in economics are badly reasoned. Especially when you chat with political types, you get a single example in support of some idea. (Print money? Weimar Republic!) It decays into storytelling, which is not science. Post uni, I've had an interesting journey. At one stage I saw a lot of value in libertarian ideas. I was always wary of certain people I knew who just swallowed it whole. They're very loud, and somewhat articulate, but the more confident someone was, the less likely it was they knew the evidence. For instance you'll sometimes run into someone who denies that monopolies have ever existed. They can explain away everything with their model: the invisible hand was trying, but mankind got in the way. Usually a red mankind. And that brings me back to religion. A lot of people who don't know what they're talking about will confidently tell you their version of economics is the right one. Even when you have counterexamples, which you will because you're a graduate, they will wave it off generically (X is actually misunderstood / X is not that important). Some of these people are actually intelligent fools, and they'll create elaborate and technically sophisticated explanations for their world view. It's often impossible to get them to see any light, because your objections will not cause them to overturn their world view. How do you know it is fruitless? With ideology as with religion, nothing is ever explained simply. Find the right professor and he'll explain in a way you will understand why a plane flies. Find a religious person or ideologue, and the explanation is elusive. It's part of god's plan, or it's the hand again. If you get the feeling the emperor has no clothes, you're right. I actually like Adam Smith, his explanations were simple and not trying to take things to extremes. For instance he talked about how what the market wanted might not be good for the people in it, because if you specialise in some aspect of pinmaking you might find it boring. It's a bit unfortunate how he's been characterised over the years.
- tomrod 9y agoI'm an economist by training (PhD) and by trade. The claims in the article are astute. Economics is a "social science" that often tries to answer the "why" people do things by postulating on the "what" they do (Weak/Strong Axioms of Revealed Preference). There is certainly a generation of economists who focused on theory, formalization, microeconomics foundations to macroeconomics, and general equilibrium theory that required heavy mathematics to succeed--resulting in survival bias towards formalization on systems involving choices. The questions of formulations of preferences (preferences drive the underlying utility theory) or moving outside the consumer context are taboo. Since taboo, they support a religious overtone. Of course, people relying on economists have often quipped they wished they could find a one handed economist ("on the other hand...") Thanks for the great article.
- Jabanga 9y agoThe Guardian is a notorious proponent of central economic planning, which is the most hubristic economic ideology there is. It presumes a small group of economists, using macroeconomic data, can plan the activities of millions of people better than they can themselves using vast stores of localized private knowledge that's diffused across society. Moreover, it advocates that the government should give these economists the right to override an individual's own decisions on what to do with their life and property, in order to force them to comply with said plan. Every other article from them promotes basic income, prohibitions on 'dangerous' free market interaction (e.g. Uber), conspiracy theories about the wealthy promoting the free market ideology, or some other bullshit economic fad based almost entirely on conjecture from anecdotal evidence that satisfies its ideological biases.
- mapleoin 9y ago> The Guardian is a notorious proponent of central economic planning Do you have a citation for that, please?
- ThomPete 9y agoWell I am not a proponent for that and I agree with them. Furthermore Basic income is NOT a central economic idea it's an idea that goes across political ideologies and rightfully so.
- Jabanga 9y agoBasic income is a form of central economic planning. A central authority deems that X% of every individual's income will be forcibly redistributed through a program that disperses it equally amongst the population. Like all central economic planning schemes, it overrides the individual's right to privacy and property in order to force the individual to conform to some simplistic plan. Central economic planning contrasts with the market mechanism, where individuals decide for themselves what to do with their person and property [1]. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Economic_planning https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Economic_planning
- 9y ago
- dmichulke 9y agoI studied economics through the backdoor, starting with game theory, then (around 2008, because "no one saw it coming") generalizing to economics, political economics and politics. If you go that way, you will inevitably end up subscribing Austrian economics (and also libertarian justice/politics) which is basically a non-existent area in mainstream economics but is the only consistent theory and kind of automagically leads to many of Taleb's criticisms (e.g., second order effects). For the interested I recommend as an introduction: - Atlas shrugged (A. Rand, for those who have time) - Economics in one lesson (H. Hazlitt, for those who don't have time)
- int_19h 9y ago> you will inevitably end up subscribing Austrian economics (and also libertarian justice/politics) How do you account for all the people who did subscribe to it at some point in the past, but no longer do? Case in point: I used to be an ancap. I've read "Atlas Shrugged" many times, and I worshiped Rothbard. That was many years ago. In this past election, I supported Sanders.
- dmichulke 9y agoHmm, it's a minefield for me to speculate about your reasons :) Maybe you can elaborate a little more what changed your mind? One good reason for your vote would be however that DT and HC were close to 0 on most scales you could think of (economic understanding, morality, diplomacy, consistency) so you were in a hard position to begin with. Hell, I would've probably voted the same. Btw I also feel that I softened my stance due to - a much better financial position (e.g., if you earn 20k p.a. then 30% tax is a lot; but the same tax rate affects you much less if you earn 80k) - kids and other things to care for and worry about
- int_19h 9y agoFor the most part, based on my observations, I have realized that libertarian economics is not going to create an ethical society - the one that I would want to live in myself, for example. I still apply the same basic principles in my politics - i.e. that personal freedom and lack of regulation is a good thing in and of itself, but regulations can be a necessary lesser evil to mitigate some greater evil. Thus, society should have "just enough government", and no more than that. I just draw the line on what is "enough" much further to the left than I used to - enough so to firmly identify as left-wing by now on the basis of policies that I end up supporting with this justification (e.g. socialized healthcare, UBI, some anti-discrimination laws). As far as tax rates, I'm not sure I get it... who pays a 30% tax off $20k annual income? Unless you include all taxes, such as sales. But then the logical response would be to replace sales taxes with income or property taxes (i.e. make the tax system less regressive), not necessarily to campaign for lower taxes overall.
- javiramos 9y agoNot only are the theoretical foundations of some areas of economics dubious but the profession is (particularly at the high levels) very money-driven and, in some cases, very morally dubious. Some professors and academics are paid hefty sums to write papers that support and influence important policies.[0] Please watch the Inside Job for an example of how money goes around the high strata of the economics profession. [0] https://www.propublica.org/article/these-professors-make-more-than-thousand-bucks-hour-peddling-mega-mergers https://www.propublica.org/article/these-professors-make-mor...
- ThomPete 9y agoEconomics is fundamentally based on the fallacy of statistics to say anything meaningful about society. However as someone once noticed, statistically humans have one testicle. It's statistically true but pragmatically useless. Economics is in reality a study of history sometimes a social science rather than a study of the future. And all economic models are based on historical knowledge. Economy in itself is pretty harmless but when it's combined with politicians who use it to steer public discourse it's catastrophic. And so we have economist with no model for factoring in technologys' effect on society advising and informing politicians about public policy. It is my guess that Economics in the future in many ways will be seen the same way many of us sees astrology. As something which is really good at finding correlation but very bad at exposing any causation.
- tomrod 9y ago> statistically humans have one testicle. It's statistically true but pragmatically useless. A funny quip that highlights more misapplication of statistics than a deep truth of the quantitative realm. Yes, the mean is a statistic. But bi-modality is also something good statisticians (and economists!) pay attention to.
- ThomPete 9y agoOh of course completely agree. The problem though is that it then comes down to the individual rather than the field as a whole.
- soVeryTired 9y agoThe widely-used representative agent paradigm more or less does assume that everyone has one testicle.
- tomrod 9y agoMeh, thus the push for expressing heterogeneity over the past few decades in the literature. Sample papers: [0] [1] [0] http://siteresources.worldbank.org/DEC/Resources/JDSAntmanMcKenzieRevised.pdf http://siteresources.worldbank.org/DEC/Resources/JDSAntmanMc... [1] http://sedici.unlp.edu.ar/bitstream/handle/10915/3512/Documento_completo.pdf?sequence=1 http://sedici.unlp.edu.ar/bitstream/handle/10915/3512/Docume...
- digi_owl 9y agoGonna leave this here: https://www.patreon.com/ProfSteveKeen https://www.patreon.com/ProfSteveKeen Yeah, it seems dodgy. But he moved to focus on his Patreon page as his older blog got spam flooded.
- narrator 9y agoMainstream economics is a bit of a cult due to the identifiability problem. This is the problem that empirical evidence is ignored in most econometric papers and there is usually no way to identify economic events discretely that correspond to the ones mentioned in papers. Paul Romer, a professor at the Stern school of business, has published a great paper calling this out (pdf: https://paulromer.net/wp-content/uploads/2016/09/WP-Trouble.pdf https://paulromer.net/wp-content/uploads/2016/09/WP-Trouble.... ) . Central planning has and always will be an epic failure. The economic calculation problem always leads to its downfall. The Chinese banking and finance model, which is akin to largely privatized central planning, is the only real alternative and it is ignored, though it seems to have solved the business cycle, given that western observers have been predicting a Japanese style prolonged financial crash for 30 years and instead there's been continuous growth.
- mcguire 9y agoFor more in a similar vein, see * Debunking Economics by Steve Keen. It's rhetoric aside, it provides strong arguments that the basics of economics are simply...wrong. * Misbehaving by Richard Thaler. A history of and introduction to behavioral economics, it has many amusing stories about interactions with economists behaving badly.
- baron816 9y agoMacroeconomics isn't so much a religion as it is a pantheon of religions. Religion and spirituality are really separate things. Jainism, Buddhism, Daoism, and Confucianism are religions, but they worship no deities. Religions just try to explain how the world works and how to make the existence of its members better. Communism, Keynesianism, and Nazism do the same thing. Few Western economists think they know all the answers. Saying economists are wrong to try to estimate what the economy will do if some policy is enacted is like saying that biologists shouldn't try to estimate what will happen to a human body if a certain drug is administered. Of course, no one will know for sure how someone will react to the drug as there are a million different factors that influence such things. But, it's best to do your best to try to figure out if something is going to be poisonous based on all the things you know about the human body and chemistry before you give it to the patient, right? Economics is hard because you can't do repeated trials. Most economists acknowledge this, and they understand the pitfalls of their craft. There are plenty of instances of individual economists making outrageous predictions about the future that proved comically false. But these are the exception, not the rule. The problem we have now is that politicians think they do have all the answers. The Republican party has decided all that is needed for economic growth is lower taxes (not low taxes, mind you--lowER taxes). The Democrats, likewise, think all you need to do is throw money at a problem, or regulate it, and it will be fixed. They KNOW the solution and they won't consider any other solution because they already have the answer. I wish just one politician would say "I don't know" and would ask economists what is likely to work under the circumstances.
- soVeryTired 9y agoFew Western economists think they know all the answers... But they do think they know the methodology that will get them the right answers eventually. It boils down to 1/ Write down a model, which is unknown up to a vector of parameters 2/ Use economic theory (e.g. assumptions about rationality) to restrict the parameter space 3/ Use data to estimate the model 4/ Draw conclusions from the estimates In principle, that's OK. But the analysis can go very wrong at any one of those steps. There are also many, many ways to understand complex phenomena that don't go via steps 1-4. Attempting to use that methodology in fields such as biology, psychology, or anthropology would often yield lousy results (though not always). It's not at all clear that it's the definitive method through which to understand the economy.
- lottin 9y agoIf economic theory was so bad as it is often implied any idiot could come up with a better theory and replace the one that we have now. The fact that this doesn't happen would suggest that it isn't that bad.
- lliamander 9y agoAll you've established is that economics is better than some random idiot. Hardly sufficient reason to accept the opinions of economists as hard science. The fact of the matter is, as many economists themselves will admit, economic theories suffer from both poor predictive power and poor falsifiability. This is by no means a knock against economists. They can still provide valuable insight. But they don't have automatic authority over a reasonably informed layman.
- Aron 9y agoThis article goes well with the recent submission of an old Asimov article on the cult of ignorance. Science is a religion. Economics is a religion. Experts don't know anything. You can believe whatever you want! edit: Just noticed that the page has it's own internal link to another guardian article 'the cult of the expert - and how it collapsed' so they know what they are doing.
- FlashGit 9y agoIf anything has become a religion it is politics.
- jondubois 9y agoIn the same way that a religion uses church to reinforce its doctrine at regular intervals, the school of economics leverages the media to reinforce its own doctrine at regular intervals. But unlike economic ideas, many religious ideas are so much at odds with observable reality that they need constant (weekly) reinforcement in order for people to keep believing them. Like with religion though, the ideas spread by economic theory also have a certain uplifting (hopeful) quality which give people an incentive to believe in them. The doctrine of economics promises that if you adhere to its rules, you will be rewarded with financial independence; this is not so different from the doctrine of religion which promises that if you adhere to its rules, you will be rewarded with eternal life - While the promised land of economic theory may not quite measure up; it makes up for this deficiency by being easier to reconcile with observable reality; especially for those who happen to be among the chosen few who actually get to see the promised land.
- jeffdavis 9y agoPeople are prone to religion. If they don't have an organized faith, they will look for it elsewhere. That's why progressives (who are generally atheists or agnostics) seem to treat non-religious things like the environment as a religion.
- awkwarddaturtle 9y agoEconomics has always been more of a religion than anything else. It has no predictive aspects. It is purely reflective. And the entire system has a group of "ideologies/leaders/etc" that adherents cling to and worship. Economics is what Feynman calls a "pseudoscience" ( aka social sciences ). https://youtu.be/tWr39Q9vBgo https://youtu.be/tWr39Q9vBgo One sect of economists will argue with another sect of economists and neither side can ever win. Just like muslims and jews will argue with each other and never get anywhere.
- PakG1 9y agoIt has no predictive aspects. While economics has issues, this is an unfair assessment. Entire nations base economic policy based on much economic theory. That is as predictive as you can get, betting with real stakes. Some nations succeed. Some don't. There is fairly solid agreement as to why certain countries perennially have extremely poor economic performance while others are not bad. There is fairly certain agreement as to why Germany experienced hyperinflation. Choosing good or poor economic policy results in predictions either way.
- awkwarddaturtle 9y ago> While economics has issues, this is an unfair assessment. It's the truth. > Entire nations base economic policy based on much economic theory. Sure. Just like in the past entire nations based their economy/society on religion. > That is as predictive as you can get, betting with real stakes. No. That's called "gambling". It isn't predictive. It isn't science. > Choosing good or poor economic policy results in predictions either way. You are mistaking what I mean by "predictive". I meaning in the sense of science where assertions are made and if it fails, the theories/laws are gotten rid of. It is empirically and predictive based where you can test it. Imagine a religious society. A priest says, if everyone prays to god, then we will have a great harvest. Everyone prays but we get terrible harvest. What's the priest's response? People didn't pray hard enough. Economics is the same. If an economic model fails, they blame politics/the people/weather/whatever. A socialist/communist economists will cling to their beliefs and say no "true" form of socialist economics system has been created yet. There isn't a "test" to definitively show on or the other. That's what I mean.
- jimheckmen 9y agoSo it looks that pretty much everybody here actually graduated in theology instead of science (as claimed). If not, are you sure to know enough of theology to call upon it ?
- jimheckmen 9y agoSo it looks that pretty much everybody here actually graduated in theology instead of science (as claimed). If not, are you sure to know enough of theology to call upon it ?
- melnonic 9y agoThis thread has become laughing stock for economists https://www.econjobrumors.com/topic/the-coders-over-at-hackernews-are-attacking-my-friends-on-ejmr?replies=17#post-3631832 https://www.econjobrumors.com/topic/the-coders-over-at-hacke...
- melnonic 9y agoThis thread has very low quality discussion. MOst of you have no clue of what you're talking about.