14 ms·
Turkish GSM networks currently play a message of the President on any phone call
Turkey reached another milestone of propaganda thanks to the total control of the communications.
Right know when you make a phone call using your mobile phone, before ringing starts citizens are forced to listen to 10 seconds voice recording of the president Recep Tayyip Erdogan.
Here is a demonstration: https://twitter.com/sendika_org/status/886343590208835584
Here is a Twitter search that will provide you with many more videos showcasing the issue: https://twitter.com/search?f=videos&vertical=default&q=erdoğan%20telefon&src=tyah
Here is a report by BBC(Turkish edition): https://twitter.com/bbcturkce/status/886351634888085505
The message is about the anniversary of the unsuccessful coup attempt believed to be orchestrated by Gulenists(previous allies of the president, currently branded as Terrorists ) that took place on 15.06.2016, claiming the lives of more than 200 civilians and led to uncontested power grab by the President.
Right now Turkey is one of the most hostile countries for the journalists. Wikipedia is banned since a while.
- rdtsc 9y agoFor a additional level of scary allow people to opt out but record who they are and compile a list. Use the list to deny them services or imprison when the next overthrow is attempted."You've been protesting and we noticed you blocked messages from our glorious leader... clearly a candidate for the labor camp"
- qq66 9y agoOuch. It's terrible when guys like this find guys like you to work for them :)
- chillydawg 9y agoBut someone else would have done it anyway.
- justinjlynn 9y agoAh, but you see, you were the one who actually did do it.
- eru 9y agoThat's what the UK does with their anti-porn policy. (At least the first part.)
- fouadmatin 9y agoThe number in the video is 112, which is Turkish-equivalent of 911 in the U.S.
- mmusc 9y agoPasted from Wikipedia 112 is a part of the GSM standard and all GSM-compatible telephone handsets are able to dial 112 even when locked or, in some countries, with no SIM card present. It is also the common emergency number in India and in nearly all member states of the European Union as well as several other countries of Europe and the world. You can dial it in the US too..
- devdoomari 9y agoeven for 112? what if some real emergency happens (fire/robber/terrorism)? The caller has to listen to the recording? That's lame.
- dghughes 9y agoThat's some IT Crowd TV show level bizareness.
- cjsturgess 9y agoThis.
- Theodores 9y agoI wonder if anyone in Turkey is dialling 112 to test if the message is played. Maybe people are calling their mums to test if the message is on, perhaps it is a good day for telco revenue.
- fsniper 9y agonah, telcos granted free usage rights for the day. It's absolutely absurd.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- appendixsuffix 9y agoYou are doing black propaganda my friend. Hacker News is not a place for your intentions!
- mrtksn 9y agoSorry you feel that way but I think it is a fascinating example of governments interference in the communication channels. I wrote the political information to give a context. The information is factually correct, it's not my interpretation except defining the message as a propaganda message.
- appendixsuffix 9y agoI called 112. The sound recording that you mentioned did not present. If this was true, we would discuss the repercussions...
- mrtksn 9y agoThere are numerous reports accompanied with video recording as evidence. I'll dismiss your report as it comes from an account created 20min ago and you don't provide any evidence. But I hope that they came to senses and stopped playing the message, at least for the emergency calls.
- appendixsuffix 9y agoYou have a wonderful logic! Modus operandi of your mind: if someone's account is new, she must lie!
- mrtksn 9y agoI added many more links to solidify the evidence, including a link from BBC. The age of your account combined with the factually wrong information that you provide indicates that you are spammer at best, govt. propaganda worker at worst. I'm really sorry that the Turkish population is so divided and I am sorry for what Gulenists did to this country, it's just sad.
- mmerlin 9y agoSo so sad when a country devolves into quasi-dictatorship
- jacobush 9y agoQuasi?
- colechristensen 9y agoAt least it could be said that it could get worse.
- nindalf 9y agoBut that's always true, even in North Korea.
- otempomores 9y agoQuasi-modu-operandi
- int_19h 9y agoThey still have elections.
- Grangar 9y ago'elections'
- int_19h 9y agoIt's a gray area. So far, at least, they still count the votes, and the votes do add up to the majority. You could argue that in the absence of truly free media, those voters are deceived, and are voting against their interest. But then we have free media in US, and yet... Turkey is not the only country like this, by the way. In Russia, the government similarly enjoys majority popular support, even though elections aren't even free at this point (numerous fraud issues). Many would say that Hungary and Poland are on their way to this same place. I would argue that such a system is still democratic, insofar the government does reflect the desires of the majority of the electorate. It is no longer a liberal democracy, however, with checks and balances to prevent abuses and to allow the electorate to (in theory) make informed decisions. Perhaps "authoritarian democracy" would be an appropriate term.
- Fnoord 9y agoWhat exactly is he saying? Can someone translate?
- the_common_man 9y agoWould like to know as well. Not a single comment on Twitter or here has the translation.
- 0xFFC 9y agoI am Persian/Azeri. I know a little bit of Turkish too. I provide you with a little bit of translation until official translation will be available: "... congratulation for our Democracy and our national day, we want compassion for our mythers from God. I want health and prosperity for our ...[I couldn't understand this part]" This basically kind of congratulation/propaganda message. p.s. My Turkish is not reliable.
- jnbiche 9y ago> p.s. My Turkish is not reliable. But worth mentioning that Azeri is a Turkic language, and probably the closest major relative to Turkish.
- anon4728 9y agotranslate.google.com
- mrtksn 9y agoHe says: "I would like to congratulate the 15th of of July, the democracy and national unity day. I pray to God for the Martyrs and I wish health and prosperity to our wounded" It may sound benign but the actors and they way the coup attempt happened are disputed and close to half of the population does not subscribe to the official accounts. The main opposition leader claims that the coup attempt happened under supervision of the president himself and was used as a tool to grab total control of the state.
- 9y ago
- AdamJacobMuller 9y agoWhat does this say in English?
- kbody 9y ago"As president, I send congratulations on the July 15 National Day of Democracy and Unity and wish the martyrs mercy and the heroes (of the defeat of the coup) health and wellbeing," Source: https://au.news.yahoo.com/world/a/36394050/mr-president-erdogan-voice-message-surprises-turkey-mobile-users/#page1 https://au.news.yahoo.com/world/a/36394050/mr-president-erdo...
- pavlov 9y agoMartyrs and heroes -- the core elements of unabashed propaganda.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- diminish 9y agoActually I m glad I don't make too many phone calls, (who's using their smartphones for making calls) but this type of "call injection" may annoy similar to Ads-gone-insane recently on the web. That happens because after the Gulen Islamists' coup d'Etat faction killed around 250 civilians and wounded 2500 civilians(mostly ) last year during the coup attempt - the voters for the main party feel too emotional during the anniversary of the event. Ironically AKP voters had sympathy for US based cleric Gulen who calls himself the Imam of the Universe and embedded thousands of his sect members in police, army etc in past 40 years especially accelerating in the past 15 years. I guess and hope in a couple of years - things will be normalized.
- yequalsx 9y agoClearly you miss the point of the outrage over this.
- alanh 9y agoAre you in fact Turkish? (HN: If he is, maybe he shouldn't be downvoted so hard… aren't you at least curious to hear from laypersons there without punishing them for not seeing things the way we do? Hear, converse, leave with greater understanding)
- OzzyB 9y agoI don't understand what the problem is. How is this any different from the Queen of England taking over the entire UK airwaves for a half-hour speech on Christmas Day? /s
- mustaflex 9y agoThe difference is you can opt to not listen to the Queen, here you have no other choice, the message is played for any call you make.
- truxus 9y agoTo play devil's advocate: you can opt to not listen to Erdogan, just wait until he is finished. I believe he's right, the Queen's message is similar.
- mickronome 9y agoDevils devils advocate here :) It's part of the nature of radio that you are in control of the channel, but not the message heard, as it's controlled by programming - the other kind of programming. This is dissimilar to telephone where a specific channel (number) is uniquely expected to reach a specific person, company, or household. Thus the analogy breaks twofold. First, while the radio works as expected under these conditions, the telephone does not. Secondly, opting out means to take some action without affecting anything else than what you are opting out from. If you consider opting out in this context, it's clear that waiting can not be considered to be an action we take, and thus can't be considered a way of opting out, our waiting in line could be considered to be "opting out of standing in line", an obvious contradiction.
- gonvaled 9y agoTurning on TV and selecting a channel is supposed to give me news or funny people doing funny things. On Christmas day some channels are hijacked by the Queen in the UK. No opt-out is possible (and would be scary). You are so convinced of your moral high ground that you do not even notice the similarities. Pot calling the kettle black and so.
- anon4728 9y agoVICE (HBO) just had an episode about Turkey's politics and the referendum to eliminate positions and consolidate Erodgan's power.
- anon4728 9y agoManufacturing consent by official decree and directly advertising Erdogan-brand Mustache Wax: the best mustache wax and the only allowed mustache wax. Say anything bad about the mustache wax and you will be disappered.
- exabrial 9y agoWhy are they a NATO country again
- CamperBob2 9y agoLucky choice of real estate.
- sremani 9y agoIts not Lucky, Location, Location and Location is very important for Geo-politics.
- pavel_lishin 9y agoBut it's not like the Turkish people, or government, got to look at the 2017 world map and place a claim marker. It's 100% luck.
- tehlike 9y agowasn't luck hundreds of years ago. that said, the country as it is today isn't in a good position to take advantage of its position.
- tnecniv 9y agoYes, but only in so much that it's luck that anything is next to anything. The Turks wanting to control the region was a natural decision at the time. The area was a major trade center due to the Hellespont and Anatolia became quite wealthy from trade between the Greeks and Persians. When Rome conquered the area, it was the richest spot in the empire.
- jballanc 9y agoIf you think that it's "luck" that Turkey's location on the map is important in 2017, you should go back and look at the history of the region. Istanbul has been one of the major focal points of world history for literally 7000 years. Ottomans, Romans, Greeks, Persians, and even Celts (yes, those Celts) have ruled over or passed through the region. Hell, the place where "history" was invented is even in modern Turkey. "Luck" has nothing to do with it.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- trumpownsyou 9y agololturkey
- powertower 9y agoThe other side of the story - US and NATO tried to overthrow the Turkish president, and turn Turkey into Syria, 2 times in a row just recently. They also attempted to start a war between Turkey and Russia just before these attempts. Now that this has all failed, and Turkey is aligning with Russia geo-politically, this does need to be taken into consideration when talking about propaganda and what really is happening.
- pas 9y agoCredible sources on that overthrow thing please.
- noncoml 9y agoI wonder how would things have been if Turket had been accepted to EU 10 years ago. Would it have helped?
- sremani 9y agoTurkey has been powerful when it had the "Islamic World" under its stewardship. Being EU member would have improved the hand of "Secularists" for few years or so. Given the unraveling of EU experiment it would have at best delayed certain things, sooner or later in a generation the Turkey will look more like the Ottoman era both in its power and projection than it was for much of 20th century. So broadly speaking, NO.
- vixen99 9y agoIs no one else getting really fed up with this discriminatory dimming feature on HN? It's basically "Many of us don't like what you're saying (OK) and will therefore make it difficult for those with poor sight to read it (not OK)". What is it but weak censorship? What about an alternative?
- acjohnson55 9y agoIt may have simply made it easier for more cosmopolitan Turks to leave the country. Or, maybe integration would have harmonized them with Western society. Who can say?
- matt4077 9y agoYes, almost certainly. They wouldn't have had to become a member back then. All that was needed was a realistic path to membership. Instead, some influential EU leaders basically said "It's never going to happen", sometimes under pressure from their countries' right wing. Not because Turkey was economically too far behind, or because of concerns with the rule of law, but simply because a sizeable portion of EU populations objected to non-christians becoming part of the EU. Nobody knows what could have been, and the current situation shows that turkish democracy was rather weak all along. But it's important to remember that Erdogan started out as a moderate, who sought nothing more than approval from the EU, and only turned to the dark side after repeatedly being humiliated. It's possibly one of largest mistakes made in recent history.
- xepbam57 9y agoHave anybody thought why you hear the sound(beeeep-beeeeep-....) when you make a call and from where it comes? Yes, telco can put anything there. Even more, I wounder why we do not hear some commercial Ad's every time we call. This would be in a spirit of current times...
- AlphaWeaver 9y agoIndeed! Verizon, a carrier in the US, actually made a product out of this by allowing people to buy what they branded "Ringback Tones" which would play some song or tune when someone called your number and you hadn't picked up yet. Not sure if it's still a thing.
- netheril96 9y agoThe ringback tones were immensely popular in China. Nowadays it has faded in popularity.
- sk0g 9y agoSame thing in India, though I was there a while ago. People seemed to love setting it to the some song from a recent movie. It was about a dollar a month, decent income for the telcos, I'd imagine.
- kalleboo 9y agoThey were pushed heavily by operators in (parts of?) Europe in the mid 2000's, back when every other TV ad was for Jamba ringtones. I was on the operator "Three" and they let you set your ringback tone to "3 Is A Magic Number" for free much to the chagrin of absolutely everyone who called me.
- bjterry 9y agoI have a friend who works at Verizon and still has a ringback tone.
- tnecniv 9y agoYou can still get them, they just hide them away in a corner of Verizon's site now.
- homero 9y agoWhen people voted, they were tricked into thinking somehow they were voting against the West instead of installing a dictator for themself
- buremba 9y agoEven if you stop watching TV, reading newspapers and following the political people on social media and avoid discussing political news with people, you can't escape from him and his followers. They will force you to believe what they believe and if you don't, they will flag you and also make you listen their leader no matter what you do to avoid their propaganda. Even though I believe that the leaders of Gulenist group did the coup attempt and are terrorist, Erdogan gave this power to them and yet acts like he's not responsible from all these shit.
- sesqu 9y ago> Gulenist group did the coup attempt Has the government provided convincing evidence of this? I know Gülen was immediately accused despite not being in the country, but I don't know of any evidence of his audience being involved beyond Erdoğan not getting along with the guy, which automatically makes any opposition sympathetic to him.
- mrtksn 9y agoAFAIK the evidence is that well known civilian Gulen affiliates were caught in military bases and armoured vehicles on the coup night but a concrete evidence of Gulen himself giving the orders do not exist. A bit like the story of the Russian military personnel in Ukraine(like everything points to Russia but Kremlin denies any involvement and claims that the caught soldiers were on a vacation in war zone). If you want to read more about the subject, here is a nice write up by pro-Erdogan, liberal, non-islamist(yep, they still exist) Turkish jurnos: https://medium.com/@15thJulyCoup/who-was-behind-the-15th-july-coup-in-turkey-19f75a5771c5 https://medium.com/@15thJulyCoup/who-was-behind-the-15th-jul...
- riffraff 9y agoAs someone outside of Turkish politics: how is it even possible to be liberal and pro-erdogan? I can see why someone might like the guy or think he's somehow good for the country, but it seems, to an outsider, that he's 100% incompatible with liberal values.
- marcxm 9y agoFuck, this sounds a lot like a communism.
- lostlogin 9y agoI'm no expert on Erdogan but I understood him and his party to be centre right/right wing. This sort of action seems fairly characteristic of authoritarian regimes rather than just leftist ones.
- throwaway76493 9y agoThere is something equally insane happening on the Turkish internets right now. At least two major mobile operators / ISPs are injecting JS into web traffic to display pop-up ads / Youtube videos on the lower right corner of every web page. The videos "commemorate" last year's events on July 15 in a language that is, to put it mildly, thorougly in line with Erdogan's ideology, and make a point of offering free data and phone credits throughout the 3-day commemorations being held.
- batuhanicoz 9y agoYeah, I've noticed the injected video my ISP, Turkcell Superonline. Only works with sites with no HTTPS/HTTP->HTTPS redirection since they can't proxy sites with SSL. Interestingly, I don't get the Erdogan's message on my cell. My friends tried calling me last night to hear the message, they don't hear it when they call me either. Could be related to me using my networks -paid- call ring tone customising app.
- tgragnato 9y agoBack in 2013 the Turkish CA (TURKTRUST) enabled phishers to spoof Google. Given the current situation, finding someone who tries to mess up the certificates should not be a surprise. > https://security.googleblog.com/2013/01/enhancing-digital-certificate-security.html https://security.googleblog.com/2013/01/enhancing-digital-ce... > https://www.wired.com/2013/01/google-fraudulent-certificate/ https://www.wired.com/2013/01/google-fraudulent-certificate/
- gruez 9y agoNobody would burn a CA just so they can inject some ads into Google. They'll be able to do it for 24hrs max before somebody notices (less if it's a google site, because chrome reports rogue certificates to google)
- mrighele 9y agoSome time ago Wikipedia has been banned in Turkey because the government didn't like a couple of pages about its involvement in the Syria civil war. (I don't have references handy but you can find easily with Google) In the past couple of weeks I noticed the a number of ISPs (for sure Turkcell for mobile and Türk Telekom for land lines) started injecting a wrong certificate, I guess to MITM the communication. The certificate is of course wrong (it is both untrusted and the domain name is wrong) so the browser will notice this and block the access, but I'm surprised that I haven't seen any discussion about this online
- NicoJuicy 9y agoIt's funny to see that Erdogan wants to battle every European country and at the same time he asks us to visit Turkey. His power comes from the wealth and investments of Western companies, so the people had it good in the past. But this is currently changing. Its 'just' a waiting game.
- diminish 9y ago> His power comes from the wealth and investments of Western companies, That's not true - though wished for.
- Talbotson 9y agoThis is 100% normal for these types of situations.
- alanh 9y agoRegardless of whether you are being sarcastic or not, you aren't really saying anything informative or provocative; this is probably why you are being downvoted
- friedgraymatter 9y agosomeone is really butthurt by turkey and the little sultan. being hitler du jour was never a meritocratic affair. what did he do ... and of course we know who is butthurt cause since our "networks" have been playing this single note song for quite a while now
- toroslar 9y agoIt's a lie like so much other stuff in the press. I'm currently in Turkey/Antalya, I've a cell-phone with a turkish Vodafone SIM card - I had several phone calls today - no president in my phone.
- diminish 9y agoI haven't heard anything neither, although I tried hard to call everyone. Maybe some portion of prepaid tariff sim cards could be having it as they had some other types of ads in the past. Maybe you're right, could equally be "fake news".
- mrtksn 9y agoDefinitely not "Fake News". TRT(Turkish equivalent of BBC) reported that the stunt was organised by the BTK(Information Technologies Committee, govt. body): http://www.trthaber.com/haber/gundem/gsm-operatorlerinin-aboneleri-erdoganin-surprizi-ile-karsilasti-324605.html http://www.trthaber.com/haber/gundem/gsm-operatorlerinin-abo...
- diminish 9y agoThe reason I was suspicious is that your post read more like a basket case for dramatization propaganda including "total control of the communications", "wikipedia", "journalists". Between 2005-201x, When Gulenists were embedded in every institution, and our fake "liberals" were cheering - people used to be afraid to make phone calls as they were recording and posting mobile conversations by everyone on their "liberal" media. Many businessmen used to apply to them, for tweaking the judicial system. But I guess, the BTK guy, went too far to put the 10sec celebration message of the president to celebrate the official national public holiday. Just FYI - on prepaid tariffs there's already some kind of ads by mobile operators.
- mrtksn 9y agoI don't want to bring the classical Turkish political debates to HN. I will briefly say that Turkey actually had really good progressive years under AKP right until they teamed with the Gulenist and begin arresting people for the Ergenekon&Balyoz. Turkey before Erdogan was also not short of imprisoned journalists and intellectuals, that's why liberals were eager to give Erdogan a chance.
- Lagged2Death 9y agoDexter Palmer's 2016 novel Version Control had imagined something rather like this in a near-future United States, where phone calls and video screens would occasionally be interrupted by a message from the president. I had thought it was inventive and evocative, but sort of unrealistic. I was wrong. Yikes.
- alanh 9y agoSo easy to imagine Trump doing this, too. He's already made much ado of needing Twitter to be heard properly instead of going through the "fake" (mainstream) news media. Imagine Twitter no longer feels like enough of a megaphone to the egomaniac. Is there any law against pressuring telcos to do this? Would he care if there were? Would he even be challenged if it came in response to a national emergency?
- madtxl 9y agoWatch Black Mirror's episode "Fifteen Million Merits"...
- zagfai 9y agoUse a VPN to stop this happened again. Such as Yoga VPN, Bestline VPN, Super VPN...