3 ms·
At the time the DOJ began seriously looking into Microsoft about anti-trust abuses derived from their monopoly, there were still a vast number of medium to larg
by adventured 9y ago
At the time the DOJ began seriously looking into Microsoft about anti-trust abuses derived from their monopoly, there were still a vast number of medium to large software & tech companies that competed head on with Microsoft. That of course meant there were a large number of parties that could sign on to the aggrieved list against Microsoft.
As Facebook formally kills off Snapchat in the next few years, it's a curious problem of which companies will supply the ammunition to go after Facebook for anti-trust abuse. Said companies will be the biggest motivating factor for the US Government to act, their prompting will drive the case.
Given the scale we're talking about now (Facebook is already more profitable non-inflation adjusted than what Microsoft was at the height of its power; and they might double their profit in a few years up to $20 billion before any government action would come through). I would expect companies to begin lining up with their hands out. Twitter as one example, stands to easily land maybe $5 billion or more as compensation for being one of the few survivors of Facebook's social monopoly. Something that has changed a lot in the last 20 years, corporate fines & costs of negative legal outcomes have skyrocketed in practically every industry. Google's worsening EU disaster is just the latest example of that. Facebook will need tens of billions of dollars set aside for settling with governmental entities and competitors (even semi-dead competitors like MySpace - its owners will show up with their hands out for a settlement, and they'll definitely get some crumbs as Facebook will settle just to move on as the lawsuits stack high after the blood hits the water).
As the world witnesses Facebook intentionally kill off Snapchat by leveraging its monopoly in nearly every way it can, there are going to be few people remaining in the Facebook defender camp as the number of major social players in the US & EU markets drifts toward just a few small competitors left standing. Snapchat better have been worth it, as I can assure you that crushing Netscape wasn't worth what it cost Microsoft.
- boulos 9y ago> Facebook is already more profitable non-inflation adjusted than what Microsoft was at the height of its power As a nit, what's the point of using a non-inflation adjusted comparison? You wouldn't say have compared Facebook to Standard Oil :). It turns out that 1998 to today is only a 50% change according to CPI [1] and MSFT had $4.5B in net income for FY 1998 [2]. So your point still stands given Facebook's massive ~$10B FY2016 net income [3]. [1] https://www.bls.gov/data/inflation_calculator.htm https://www.bls.gov/data/inflation_calculator.htm [2] https://www.microsoft.com/investor/reports/ar98/fins.htm https://www.microsoft.com/investor/reports/ar98/fins.htm [3] https://investor.fb.com/investor-news/press-release-details/2017/facebook-Reports-Fourth-Quarter-and-Full-Year-2016-Results/default.aspx https://investor.fb.com/investor-news/press-release-details/...
- adventured 9y agoOk, serious answer. I used the non-inflation adjustment specifically because while I recognized enough time had passed to cause a not-entirely-trivial adjustment, I didn't regard it as enough time to matter enough to warrant a distraction to the more core points. Inflation adjustment precision is a notoriously disagreed upon thing, the more near term you get the less valuable the matter becomes. I knew that someone might lodge that point, so I wanted to potentially preempt it (hoping that it would make the responding comment not worth bothering with, that the person writing it would be too lazy to bother writing a comment just to argue inflation adjustment numbers for ~1997-2017). Why bother making the point at all then? Because it highlights Facebook's growing financial power. If their net income isn't beyond Microsoft's on an inflation adjusted basis today, it will be very soon (perhaps by the end of fiscal 2017 or mid 2018 on a run rate). Further, I suspected most people realize that while there has been some inflation since the late 1990s, it's not N hundred percent.
- boulos 9y agoNo problem! I'm notoriously incapable of guessing how much inflation has happened in the last {20, 30, 50} years. I was surprised it was only 1.5x (I had predicted ~2). I agree that CPI is a particularly clumsy measure (not mentioned is the fudge factor in how accounting for stock/option-based compensation has changed). Your comment had the desired (ultimate) effect though: I really haven't been watching how much cash Facebook has been generating, and it's amazing to compare it to Microsoft at peak monopoly.
- majani 9y agoI voted you up for making good points, but I think Facebook's 3b buyout offer(which many thought was on the high side at the time) negates any accusations of abuse of power.
- adventured 9y agoMicrosoft tried to buy Netscape. It doesn't negate it on the part of Facebook, just as that did absolutely nothing for Microsoft back then and for exactly the same reason. In fact it enhances the negative view of the monopoly company in question as a predator looking to dominate. That's how it'll be played in the press, it's how it'll be spun by competitors and by the government entities. If you go back and read about Microsoft's interactions with Netscape (Marc Andreessen provided a key piece of evidence of Microsoft's predatory behavior by taking notes in said meeting/s), you'll find that their efforts to 'buy or bury' Netscape was entirely relevant as the case went on as evidence of a sort of character portrayal the government was spinning of Microsoft as a company hell-bent on dominance (ie seeking to limit consumer choice to enhance their market power; which is perhaps how it'll be spun against Facebook - by wiping out Snapchat, Facebook can plausibly raise its ad prices, as consumers will supposedly have fewer social destinations, and advertisers will have fewer platforms competing for their marketing dollars, etc etc and so on; it doesn't matter if one agrees with this premise, it's exactly the sort of slightly subjective argument (that happens to be kinda hard to prove and kinda hard to disprove) that will be used by the government). The fact that the offer was perhaps high at the time, will also be spun as proof that very clearly Facebook has too much power, that they are deriving such immense profit from their social monopoly that they can afford to overpay to sustain that monopoly. You see, anti-trust is an intentionally subjective field of law. It was designed to be vague, it enables them to go after you for nearly any perceived abuse of market power (with a more recent high-tilt toward consumer well-being, but back in reality the Microsoft case was overwhelmingly about powerful, rich competitors crying foul).
- AndrewKemendo 9y agoSnapchat better have been worth it, as I can assure you that crushing Netscape wasn't worth what it cost Microsoft. What exactly did it cost them? Last I checked they never broke up and won their appeal in Federal court [1]: The case found its way to the D.C. Circuit Court of Appeals, which rejected Jackson's remedy and accused him of unethical conduct after it was revealed he had private conversations with reporters about the trial while it was still ongoing. Microsoft would settle the case with the Department of Justice in November of 2001 by agreeing to make it easier for Microsoft's competitors to get their software more closely integrated with the Windows operating system Their settlement has basically nothing to do with why they aren't dominant today - only top 5 - they missed out on mobile to Apple/Google.
- sillysaurus3 9y agoIf the web hadn't become free, Microsoft may not have lost their foothold.
- AndrewKemendo 9y agoBecome free? Netscape wasn't free. It didn't even try to be free before the Mozilla project really. In fact I remember switching to Opera before IE because Netscape was shitty.
- sillysaurus3 9y ago> Snapchat better have been worth it, as I can assure you that crushing Netscape wasn't worth what it cost Microsoft. What exactly did it cost them? Microsoft became irrelevant when the web took off, and the web took off partly because Microsoft made it free to crush Netscape. They dropped the price of browsers to zero.