6 ms·
So much money is floating to the top x% that even just renting to them on weekends is more lucrative than renting to locals 365 days per year. Where are people
by mistermann 9y ago
So much money is floating to the top x% that even just renting to them on weekends is more lucrative than renting to locals 365 days per year. Where are people supposed to go when even the middle class is homeless?
I guess we still have some buffer room as most people still have some disposable income that doesn't go to rent, but when that cap is hit, then what?
- bpodgursky 9y agoEr, in this case the x% is like, 30+%. Lots of people take ski weekends in the winter.
- ChuckMcM 9y agoProbably true but it doesn't really take away from the point of resources being tied up by a percentage that is significantly less than 50% of the population. Rents businesses essentially "short circuit" the flow of capital through the economy. So a "one percenter"[1] buys a cabin which he rents through AirBnB to other "one percenters". Because he isn't a hospitality business he doesn't hire desk staff, a concierge, or pay taxes that are funding local government efforts. Instead the 'rents' just recirculate right back into the "one percenter" pool. The absurd extreme of this notion is something like the vision in Elysium of a rich people enclave with no need of any human "non rich" staff. I don't see that actually coming to pass but as Gates and others have noted, it is important to understand how technology can distort an economy and work on ways to repair that distortion. [1] In quotes because it is a stand end for 'top n% where n << 50'
- wbl 9y agoIncreased affordable housing supply in these areas would help. Unfortunately residents often don't want it.
- blackguardx 9y agoThey generally used to be very affordable until highly paid remote workers and vacation rentals became more popular.
- mistermann 9y agoQ: What's the difference between a developer and an environmentalist? A: A developer is someone who wants to build a cabin in the woods; an environmentalist is someone who already has one.
- Consultant32452 9y agoIf you're talking about a true 1%er they're hiring handy-man types and maids. They're paying property tax on those homes, funding roads and schools they will never use. It's highly likely they are paying other state and local taxes too, including but not limited to income taxes. All of the other 1%ers who come into that area are spending money at local restaurants or other venues which is pulling money out of the 1% and into the hands of locals. If you're talking more like a 20%er, then they are either doing the same thing, or they live locally so even though they're not hiring a maid/handy-man, money is going from the 1%er to a person living in the local economy (themselves).
- mistermann 9y agoWhew, I feel better now that it's clearly going to all work out with just a temporary minor hiccup as the economy readjusts.
- Consultant32452 9y agoIf the citizens of these towns want more affordable housing, they are free to vote such zoning into existence. If they continue to shoot themselves in the foot, then I'm not sure how many crocodile tears I'm supposed to shed for them.
- mistermann 9y agoOh right, in a democracy "the people" make the decisions, I forgot about that. /s
- Consultant32452 9y agoThe smaller the government the easier it is for the people to have control. I mean, we're talking about towns of a few thousand people here. It has to be pretty easy to sway an election over a single issue like this if the people are in your favor.
- ChuckMcM 9y ago
- aphextron 9y ago>Er, in this case the x% is like, 30+%. Lots of people take ski weekends in the winter. But the reality is that the resorts make their profits off a tiny percentage of the clientele. The middle class family who stays in a budget hotel, buys season passes, and brings their own food, ends up being a net loss for the company. Practically all the money is made on the full price daily ticket sales, expensive marked up restaurants, and high end real estate sales/rentals. Without the rich people who blow $20k on a week of skiing once a year, the industry as we know it simply would not exist.
- _delirium 9y agoYou are significantly overestimating. According to the ski industry itself, which tends to use a fairly generous definition that includes things such as cross-country skiing, only around 7% of Americans ski: http://www.planetski.eu/news/4090 http://www.planetski.eu/news/4090 And many of these are people who live in day-trip distance of ski areas rather than renting or owning second homes, so the proportion in that market is even lower.
- Jabanga 9y agoI know it sounds like free market dogma, but I swear this is true: supply grows to meet demand. Airbnb will just encourage more housing to be built, by creating a new short term housing market that until now had not existed.
- chongli 9y agoThat doesn't work for mountain towns. When skyscraper condos start going up it ceases to be a mountain town.
- Jabanga 9y agoThe parent comment asked: "Where are people supposed to go when even the middle class is homeless?" They can go to places that aren't mountain towns. EDIT: or they can build new mountain towns. There is no shortage of mountains.
- matheweis 9y agoThere is a shortage of water, though, unless you solve desalination and pumping it up the several miles of elevation...
- Jabanga 9y agoRight but there's no shortage of mountains where new towns can be built. If people really want to live in mountain towns, the market can meet that demand for pretty much any number of people.
- ghaff 9y agoAnd, in fact, there are tons of "mountain towns" where real estate is cheap. They just aren't chi-chi mountain towns with cute coffee shops and gourmet restaurants often associated with world class ski areas.
- klipt 9y ago
- jseliger 9y agoWhere are people supposed to go when even the middle class is homeless? You know, there are pretty simple and century-old technologies that let us build more units of housing on a given piece of land. The problem is that we choose not to use them: https://object.cato.org/sites/cato.org/files/serials/files/regulation/2002/10/v25n3-7.pdf https://object.cato.org/sites/cato.org/files/serials/files/r.... Or see http://www.slate.com/articles/news_and_politics/politics/2015/01/the_upper_middle_class_is_ruining_all_that_is_great_about_america.html http://www.slate.com/articles/news_and_politics/politics/201... for a broader view. Housing doesn't intrinsically need to get more expensive. But if we make it impossible or difficult to increase the supply, we're going to see prices rise. This isn't really about money "floating to the top;" it's about legal and regulatory problems.
- threatofrain 9y agoZoning can only be one side of the equation, as it only affects supply. There's no zoning or technology for too much demand, too much people. Better infrastructure is a temporary band-aid before people either do or don't come up with a consensus on what society and growth should look like.
- erentz 9y agoIn a free nation, demand can only be controlled through restriction on immigration and birth rates. For the USA that means demand is a national policy issue. It cannot be managed by cities or states. All cities and states can do is manage supply to meet demand. But for addressing your concern this is good news: "before people either do or don't come up with a consensus on what society and growth should look like." Unless there is a dramatic shift in policies to allow MASS immigration or everyone starts breeding like rabbits in the USA, we do not really have a problem here where our urban spaces will develop into unpleasent places. In fact it's actually the underinvestment in our urban spaces that precisely creates many of the issues people connect to cities. Cities and states need to address the supply and infrastructure problem to allow people to live affordably, with a good standard of living, in the places that they want to live.
- aphextron 9y ago>So much money is floating to the top x% that even just renting to them on weekends is more lucrative than renting to locals 365 days per year. Where are people supposed to go when even the middle class is homeless? This has always been the case in mountain towns. The article is more doom and gloom than anything. I spent my early teen and twenties ski bumming around the exact towns mentioned (Crested Butte, among others) years before AirBnB existed. It has always been a lifestyle of poverty couch surfing and floor camping. The dichotomy of extreme rich and poor has existed in these towns like nowhere else in the US for as long as skiing has been an upper class pursuit. Those who wish to make their lives in these towns know this and value the lifestyle above all, so they adapt. The ones who don't move to Denver.