7 ms·
AMD Threadripper prices undercut Intel's Core i9 by as much as $1,000
- UnoriginalGuy 9y agoI'm just glad AMD are still competitive. Seemed like for a few years there they might almost gone out of business. I think consoles have helped keep them afloat in the bad years too. Obviously Intel will respond to this (either via hardware or pricing) but the fact they even need to respond to something is a good thing. The only thing that has been eating Intel's lunch in recent years was mobile.
- leeoniya 9y ago> I think consoles have helped keep them afloat in the bad years too. That and their desktop GPUs. Their ATI acquisition turned out to be pretty vital.
- digitalzombie 9y agoI swear I thought ATI had diverted their attention away from CPU so they lost the edge. I feel like they were doing well until they bought ATI. Then they ran out of cash, less R&D money, and then they had to spin their fab to global foundry. Now it seems like CPU is slowing down while GPU is growing especially in scientific stuff. Super glad they're decent now, hopefully good. I don't want to deal with Intel monopoly.
- kartD 9y agoAMD screwed up when they decided to make something similar to the P4 arch (high clock speed, long pipeline) after they spent the previous 5-7 years beating it using high IPC, lower clock speed cores. I still don't get why they did this...
- unethical_ban 9y agoAMD cannot go out of business, in my opinion. They are the only other company licensed to produce x86, and the license is non-transferable. If they die, Intel faces instant monopoly issues. AMD will stay around. Next time their stock dips big one day, get some.
- Already__Taken 9y agoThis was my opinion 5 - 7 years ago. I wish I wasn't afraid to buy stocks.
- szatkus 9y agoInteresting that their console microarch (Jaguar) was really great. So good that even after Intel one-upped them with non-crappy Atoms (Silvermont) they released competetive offering which was basically just an evolution (Puma).
- btown 9y agoAny reason not to prefer AMD CPUs for VR applications, given the price difference?
- frozenport 9y agoSome applications need 70+ cores. AMD doesn't have that.
- pzduniak 9y ago64 cores on 2P EPYC 7601/7551/7501. Intel has its 4P platform, which in theory almost doubles the ceiling (4 * 28 cores in the top tier Xeon Platinum aka new E7). If you really need that many cores, you should either use specialized hardware (GPUs, FPGAs etc.) or clustering anyways.
- minxomat 9y agoThere's a thing in between. Think Thunder ARM chips or Power8
- sliken 9y agoThe Intel top x-series (that competes with Threadripper) only has 36 cores (not 70+), is limited to a single socket, and it's not shipping yet. Even with dual sockets 70+ cores is not easy (or cheap) and other things like memory performance become more important than core count. AMD has a bandwidth advantage with single and dual sockets having 8 channels per socket instead of Intel's 6. Intel doesn't have competition with 4 or more socket systems, but that topic drifting pretty far from a thread discussing Threadripper.
- redtuesday 9y agoWhich Intel part has 36 cores? Do you mean threads, or is there a Knights Landing card with so few cores I'm not aware of?
- frozenport 9y ago
- efgrbgfrf 9y agoSergio Benitez
- madengr 9y agoAre there Intel specific instructions that may not be implemented on the AMD processors? I do allot of EM simulation, and my software installs the Intel MPI Library: https://software.intel.com/en-us/intel-mpi-library https://software.intel.com/en-us/intel-mpi-library Will I take a performance hit; maybe that question can only be answered by the software developers? I know the VOLK library used by GNU Radio is used to abstract away vector operation, so your code can take advantage of specific instructions on Intel, ARM, etc.
- revelation 9y agoThey support pretty much everything up to AVX2, though that is more of a compatibility implementation. Though its dubious Intel MPI and other software will use the correct accelerated path even if an AMD processor supports it.
- madengr 9y agoFrom that MPI link: "Optimization Notice: Intel’s compilers may or may not optimize to the same degree for non-Intel microprocessors for optimizations that are not unique to Intel microprocessors. These optimizations include SSE2, SSE3, and SSSE3 instruction sets and other optimizations. Intel does not guarantee the availability, functionality, or effectiveness of any optimization on microprocessors not manufactured by Intel. Microprocessor-dependent optimizations in this product are intended for use with Intel microprocessors. Certain optimizations not specific to Intel microarchitecture are reserved for Intel microprocessors. Please refer to the applicable product User and Reference Guides for more information regarding the specific instruction sets covered by this notice. Notice revision #20110804"
- kartD 9y agohttp://www.agner.org/optimize/blog/read.php?i=49#49 http://www.agner.org/optimize/blog/read.php?i=49#49 TLDR; Intel purposely chooses slower code gen paths for AMD processors in ICC.
- 9y ago
- sliken 9y agoSad that the cheapest skylake-x with 4 memory channels (double the bandwidth) is $390 (i7-7800X) and the cheapest threadripper is $800. So AMD is competitive with a $2k chip that sells in extremely low volumes, but not at $400.
- E6300 9y agoAre there any applications that are RAM bandwidth-bound, though? The main bottleneck is supposed to be RAM latency. Going from single channel to dual channel offers like an 8% performance increase, IIRC. Is there any reason to expect any different with quad channel RAM?
- dijit 9y agoI can chime in and say that memory bandwidth is our primary bottleneck on servers at my current company.
- E6300 9y agoThe only situation where I imagine that could happen is if you need to apply a small number of instructions to a massive data set that's fully loaded in memory. What sort of application are you running? If you can say, obviously.
- dijit 9y agoThat's exactly the case. I run dedicated gameservers. We preload "phases" which you can affect and transition to/from as a player.
- merb 9y ago> The only situation There are many more: - Caches/Databases that should keep as much stuff in memory as possible (i.e. if you have a 32gb es instance you actually gain a lot from "fast memory") - In-Memory Databases - In-Memory RPC/message broker which of course has as a limitation factor the memory bandwidth. In all cases the memory bandwidth might be a important factor.
- tgtweak 9y agoThe 12 core threadripper (1920) is comparable with the 10 core 7900X in temrs of milticore performance, while still $200 cheaper. You can't compare only on the basis of core count as this review did. More detailed review here: http://wccftech.com/amd-ryzen-threadripper-1950x-cpu-performance-benchmarks-leak/ http://wccftech.com/amd-ryzen-threadripper-1950x-cpu-perform...
- redtuesday 9y agoLike I have written in the other thread already: add to that the ECC support of Threadripper [0], 20 more PCIe lanes and no raid key shenanigans (on Intels x299 you have to pay 100$ extra for RAID 1 and 300$ for RAID 5 support with their VROC feature [1]). Unless you really need AVX 512 and better single thread performance (and 2 more cores in case of the not available 18 core part), why would you buy Intels new offering? Because you can reuse the cooler since it's compatible with x99? [0] https://www.reddit.com/r/Amd/comments/6icdyo/amd_threadripper_supports_up_to_256gb_of_ram_942/dj5lhs7/ https://www.reddit.com/r/Amd/comments/6icdyo/amd_threadrippe... [1] https://youtu.be/TWFzWRoVNnE?t=11m38s https://youtu.be/TWFzWRoVNnE?t=11m38s
- aphextron 9y ago>on Intels x299 you have to pay 100$ extra for RAID 1 and 300$ for RAID 5 support with their VROC feature [1] This really bothers me about Intel. It's not like they have a separate die for these chips. They are literally charging you to flip a switch on something you already paid for.
- pacificmint 9y agoThey didn't used to do that. I feel that it became more and more common the less competitive AMD became, in some kind of direct correlation. (Not that this is some kind of big surprise) So hopefully the fresh wind and competition that AMD is bringing forward will put the pressure back on.
- kajecounterhack 9y agoIf it makes you feel any worse both AMD and Intel provide cheaper chips by disabling cores on more expensive chips. To me it's fine -- it's just a method of manufacture. No different than buying different versions of software. "They are literally charging you to flip a switch on something you already paid for." << To be clear, physically you have the thing in your possession, and you could physically figure out how to flip the bit or re-enable disabled cores (people do try this). I'm 100% for that being legal since it's a physical device -- no DRM for me. But I'm also 100% OK with them doing this to begin with if it makes it cheaper for them to give me their base product.
- Boothroid 9y agoI have an FX 8350 which is serving me ok at the moment but would love to upgrade to ThreadRipper soon. I was tempted to build a dual E5-2670 system but glad I held off now. I have some fairly weighty OpenStreetMap crunching that could definitely benefit from loads of cores, and nested VMs might be an interesting usage.