6 ms·
Except the article cites several examples of where demand isn't being met. -Farmers in Alabama are fretting that crops may rot in the ground for a lack of work
by sharemywin 9y ago
Except the article cites several examples of where demand isn't being met.
-Farmers in Alabama are fretting that crops may rot in the ground for a lack of workers to bring in the harvest.
-Despite high demand, home builders in Colorado are throttling back activity because they can’t find the workers to erect frames.
-An airline canceled flights because it couldn’t find enough pilots to steer them.
Those aren't demand problem but supply problems.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- jdavis703 9y agoI was on an airline that could not find enough pilots at a low enough rate to fly the planes. That was Spirit Airlines, an ultra-low cost carrier. I don't mind small, hard seats and no snacks for a quick flight, so I thought I'd save the money. Well, it turns out that Spirit has one of the highest profit margins [0] of any domestic U.S. airline, yet they decided they'd rather cancel flights than pay pilots enough to show up [1] -- they'd even rather hand out $100 vouchers to all the affected passengers than pay the pilots more. On a flight of 50 people, that's at least $5000 they lost, not to mention the staffers they had to pay (baggage handlers, gate agents, etc) that didn't actually wind up being able to complete their jobs. [0] https://www.dallasnews.com/business/airlines/2014/09/22/sevem-u-s-carriers-among-the-worlds-most-profitable-airlines https://www.dallasnews.com/business/airlines/2014/09/22/seve... [1] http://money.cnn.com/2017/05/09/news/companies/spirit-airlines-pilots/index.html http://money.cnn.com/2017/05/09/news/companies/spirit-airlin....
- lotsofpulp 9y agoIt's a combination, where the demand curve never meets the supply curve at an acceptable price for the consumer. It could be due to being able to obtain a product cheaper from somewhere else due to lower labor costs (happens due to converging standards of living across the world), and it could also happen that there are alternatives, such as other jobs and/or social security disability or welfare that make doing undesirable jobs need an even higher price point to make it worthwhile.
- nsxwolf 9y agoYour last point is why I've never understood the claim that Wal Mart subsidizes its low wages with public welfare.
- sharemywin 9y agoa lot of people on public welfare work for a living. child tax credits, obamacare subsidies, subsidized student loans and grants.
- nsxwolf 9y agoBut the minimum price they're willing to work for has to be higher than if the welfare benefits didn't exist.
- specialist 9y agoMany welfare programs requires recipients to work as able.
- s73ver 9y agoWal Mart specifically tells it's employees to get on welfare. They even pass out food stamp forums in the office. Why should my tax dollars be going to subsidize a for profit company, which is making billions of dollars of profit?
- s73ver 9y agoWell, kinda. Those are supply problems, but the supply is low because the wages are poor.
- randomdata 9y agoThe definition of demand in economics is a consumer's desire and willingness to pay a price for a specific good or service. A job with a wage low enough to not have anyone willing to fill the position cannot be counted as demand. As such, these jobs have no impact on price, which is driven by the supply and the demand, not the hope of hiring employees.
- s73ver 9y agoI believe they were talking about the supply of labor, not the supply of products for people to buy.
- randomdata 9y agoLabour is no different than any other product or service. The price is established through the same properties of supply and demand like every other product and service. The parent is suggesting that the price of labour should be rising because the jobs he listed have increased the demand for labour. However, the jobs he listed haven't actually impacted demand at all. The employers are not willing (or, perhaps, able) to pay the price necessary to get the desired workers, thus are, by definition, not demand. Since they are not part of the demand for labour, they cannot be considered in this discussion of labour price at all.
- s73ver 9y agoI completely disagree. They absolutely can and should be considered. You're assuming that the employers are acting perfectly rationally, which is a fallacy. And the fact that they offer these positions, and that they would hire someone who does agree with what they're offering, DOES mean that they are part of the demand for labor. Reasoning the way you are, you can hand wave away anything, making it appear as if there not only is not a lack of labor, but a surplus, implying that wages are too high. This is clearly not true. It is far, far more plausible that employers have become accustom to lower labor prices, and thus are hesitant to raise wages.
- mason240 9y ago>- Farmers in Alabama are fretting that crops may rot in the ground for a lack of workers to bring in the harvest. The oil field boom in ND didn't have a problem getting skilled workers from across the country to live in tents because they paid them well. They AL farmers are not worried about finding workers, they want to lowball American laborers so they can throw their hands the air and claim that they need a supply of immigrants laborers, which they can exploit.
- randomdata 9y agoThere is also the fact that we have more than enough food to go around (at least among the nations producing the food). I expect the AL farmers don't have the resources to pay more for workers, but they cannot afford to pay more because the crop isn't really needed in the first place. Nobody in the US, that I am aware of, went hungry because of that failure. If that loss was going to be devastating to the consumer, they would have opened their wallets to ensure it got harvested.
- logfromblammo 9y agoNot entirely accurate. The migrant farm laborers are actively avoiding Alabama as a result of anti-immigrant legislation that passed a few years ago. Even though it was subsequently voided by court order, the workers remember it, and are not stupid, so they will demand a premium for dealing with Alabama's racist, protectionist bullshit. And even paying that is cheaper than offering the sort of labor standard that a citizen--even a high-school dropout or ex-con--would expect in America. That's pretty much what they deserve for voting the same party in every election, without regard to their own economic self-interest. Edit: The state raised the perceived cost of working for migrant laborers, to the point that the prevailing wage offered by the farmers is no longer sufficient to entice those workers to come to work. They aren't lowballing to preferentially employ migrants, they are just lowballing all labor, period, because as commodity producers, the labor expenses cut directly into their profit margin.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- 9y ago
- MrFantastic 9y agoAre temporary field hands the future of the US economy? Many construction workers can't move to high demand areas because they are financially locked into the areas they currently live. Most planes could function with 1 pilot due to automation but regulations won't allow it.
- chiph 9y agoThe US has the H-2A visa for temporary agricultural workers. https://www.uscis.gov/working-united-states/temporary-workers/h-2a-temporary-agricultural-workers https://www.uscis.gov/working-united-states/temporary-worker... No idea how many people use it.
- caseysoftware 9y agoI'd love to see how those demand areas line up with the high unemployment areas. I'd wager they're geographically far apart because other than the pilots, the rest don't take much training (days to weeks) to get up to speed. In Austin, the unemployment rate is <3% and Texas as a whole is incredibly low. Since we're one of the largest population states with an unemployment rate well below average, I assume there are numerous smaller places with well above average unemployment.
- marcosdumay 9y agoI'd expect those jobs to also have the feature that they are in underpopulated areas and have a high seasonality or high instability so that people can't move to take them.
- randomdata 9y agoThe BLS suggests that Texas has one of the higher unemployment rates, at 4.8%, and is above the national rate of 4.4%. https://www.bls.gov/web/laus/laumstrk.htm https://www.bls.gov/web/laus/laumstrk.htm But it is true that unemployment can vary widely even within state lines. Even from one town to the next. It is possible that localized unemployment is still quite low where the jobs are unable to be filled.
- reefoctopus 9y agoIf you can't find workers, you aren't offering high enough wages. This is econ 101.
- cylinder 9y agoI generally agree but there's a limit. If the cost of renovating my house becomes too high (e.g. labor too expensive) I simply won't do it and will put it off. In fact this just happened with a relative. There's certainly an equilibrium point.
- reefoctopus 9y agoYes. At this point the price you are willing to pay would be below the equilibrium price.
- randomdata 9y agoThis seems to be the mistake that the article makes. You saying that you want to renovate your home, or that a farmer wants to harvest his crop, or that an airline would like to fly somewhere, is not a real indication that work needs to be done. There is always a point where the cost makes it not worth doing anymore, and at that point, the jobs aren't really jobs. Trying to include them in the demand for labour violates what demand means.
- s73ver 9y agoAnd then wages will back down a bit. But I don't think anyone could argue that we are anywhere near that point.
- mywittyname 9y agoPractically speaking, you're right, but only to a degree. Pay is not always a motivator for people past some point. Some jobs require a baseline intelligence to do effectively, and often times those people have other great employment opportunities. People capable of becoming skilled tradesman are also capable of getting high-paid jobs working in offices. So companies looking for electricians or machinists are competing with companies looking for IT managers and the like. Not only is the pay much less than these people could otherwise get, the jobs are more physically demanding and often times, less flexible. It's going to be hard to entice workers who already make 60+k a year doing a job with a lot of flexibility and downtime to take up a more demanding position. People love to talk about how much tradesman make, but the generosity of their salaries is often over-stated and ignores the seasonality and volatility of these jobs.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- JPKab 9y agoColoradan here who is having a home built currently, and oh yeah, I used to be a construction worker when I was in my early 20s: The issue with the entire building industry is that they don't pay carpenters, electricians, etc enough. Period. They have been able to avoid paying enough by using what I refer to as "illegally imported labor" at below-market wages. (I like the term because the verbage puts responsibility on the hiring companies who are clearly exploiting un-documented workers) Having worked in construction, I've seen what happened to the wages paid. Essentially the large home-building companies who build the bulk of homes in this country in single, large-scale subdivision builds have increasingly been able to lower the skill threshold for construction. This by itself would have lowered the barrier to entry for documented workers, and probably has a minor downward pressure on wages. However, the lowering of the skill threshold also made hiring undocumented workers much more viable. I didn't have to speak Spanish to train guys to use a nail gun and a saw to do framing. I usually worked on high-end, custom homes for the wealthy. These jobs paid well, required a lot of skill, and were pretty much exclusively staffed by legal workers. However, at times, I'd have to find work with the big builders doing the giant subdivisions. They paid shit, and were largely staffed with undocumented workers. In North Carolina where I worked, the bulk of these folks came from central America. McDonald's wages were literally higher than what these folks were paid. McDonalds doesn't hire illegals, but construction companies do. So this creates a very weird situation: Why would an American work a dangerous, hot, back-breaking job for a lower wage than McDonalds? The local construction companies in Colorado were decimated in 2009, and many never came back. Now, the bulk of building here is being executed by national builders who are used to paying low wages, and there aren't enough undocumented workers to fill the jobs at these artificially low rates. The worst part is that the low wages have caused documented workers to not even BEGIN to pursue construction, and therefore they aren't learning the skills (in certain markets), which creates a long-term labor supply issue. There is a very easy solution to this: Make all construction companies and their sub-contractors use E-verify. But that will never happen because congress has two parties who both have interests in not doing this: The GOP loves cheap labor while simultaneously saying they want to crack down (using completely unrealistic plans by design) on illegal immigration to appeal to the bigots in their base as well as the "law and order" crowd. The Democratic Party views illegals as a source of votes once their kids are old enough. They ignore the fact that illegal immigration helped to break the back of unions in the meatpacking and construction industries because they have long-since replaced alignment with labor with racial identity politics. Because of this, I'm going to pay waaaay too much for my house, the workers will be paid too little, the house will take too long, will be built somewhat poorly, and the suits running the building company will make a ton.
- wmil 9y ago> Farmers in Alabama are fretting that crops may rot in the ground for a lack of workers to bring in the harvest. This is a constant claim, but it's not really true. Some of the crop will always rot in the field since all plants don't ripen at exactly the same time and it's only economical to do a certain number of harvests. Farmers could always use cheaper labour, so they'll always complain about the price. But there's no real disaster. The pilot problem is real, but it's entirely a result of airlines paying low salaries for the past 15 years or so.
- randomdata 9y agoThe underpinning to this issue is that these jobs aren't actually necessary. If the population was going to starve if that crop wasn't harvested, or if the population was going to die without that flight, the money to find farmhands/pilots would appear pretty quickly. But luxuries are only desirable up to a certain price point. We don't normally do work for the sake of working. We work to provide what people want, at a price that is agreeable to all parties. If an agreeable price isn't found, it means not that we need to find people, it means the work to be provided isn't really wanted by anyone in the first place.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- BearGoesChirp 9y ago>Farmers in Alabama are fretting that crops may rot in the ground for a lack of workers to bring in the harvest. Aren't they just investing? Not exactly like normal investments, but if they let some crops rot, they can use it as a corner stone for an attempt to keep their normal cheap labor flowing, which ends up earning them more money than just paying Americans enough to harvest the crops.
- mdpopescu 9y agoIn economics, "demand" isn't just a word for "something I'd like". It's a technical term, meaning "what actually gets bought". Farmers in Alabama fretting does not mean demand. Farmers in Alabama paying workers means demand. To put it another way, me looking at a Ferrari in a store doesn't create demand for Ferraris. Me going to the store and buying one does.