8 ms·
I don't understand why he finishes with this paragraph: I’m as excited by the idea of colonising Mars as much as the next nerd. But not at the opportunity cost
by Tepix 9y ago
I don't understand why he finishes with this paragraph:
I’m as excited by the idea of colonising Mars as much as the next nerd. But not at the opportunity cost of not solving the problems facing us on Earth. That’s a bet too big.
Making an effort to colonize Mars does not carry such a cost. People who are interested in solving this issue will not magically do whatever you'd like them to do instead. We will never solve all problems we have here on Earth, that shouldn't stop us from venturing out into space.
- agmcleod 9y agoI agree with you. But typically when people make such an argument, it's about where we spend money.
- loceng 9y agoMoney is a human-made construct, productivity is all about people wanting to work on things they are passionate about - whether that's having a healthy family or Elon's escapist plans of colonizing Mars. Once we have UBI and automation in place - which will lead to properly managed capitalism - then everything can become very efficient. The foundation to this working is people being healthy and community being healthy, real community where we have time to have deep discussion not only online but in person - which is currently greatly lacking. What currently keeps most of us engaged is economics, the requirement of a job. Once UBI is in place worldwide then things will really start moving.
- richmarr 9y agoWhy will UBI and automation lead to properly managed capitalism? And what do you mean by "properly managed capitalism"?
- loceng 9y agoGood questions. The brief of it is that it's known if you increase money available for education, educational institutes will increase their fees- the same goes for landlords and rent - and pretty much everything which leads to inflation; the more of a necessity something is will generally dictate who benefits the most from these cost increases and pressure on systems. There will have to be a floor created for housing, food, transportation, etc. Most of what we need can be automated, heavily automated. We'll have to decide as a society what people should have a baseline for everything. Fitting that new system in the existing system is the tricky part.
- sharemywin 9y agoStep 1: UBI you can chase your dreams Step2: well you can't afford real dreams you're on UBI so chase your dreams in VR. plus the clicks will help pay for UBI. Step 3: eat Soylent it's less expensive and you don't need much nutrition your always in VR anyways. besides the system can get more clicks the more time your in VR. Step 4: you can get a more enriched experience if we attach cables to you. besides the system can get more clicks the more time your in VR. Step 5: The system decided to make VR more like real life and add constraints and problems to your life. besides the system can get more clicks the more time your in VR. Shit we ended up in the Matrix....except it turned out to be a giant click farm.
- CalRobert 9y agoDevil's advocate - if the experience of VR is completely indistinguishable from reality, is it not just reality for the consciousness experiencing the VR? We experience sadness, happiness, joy, and despair, based on sensory input, which is supposedly a manifestation of the world around us, but maybe it's the abstractions we build on top of that matter which are important. Maybe the experience of VR fishing with my dad is imperceptibly different from actually going fishing (better, even, since the simulated fish isn't full of microplastics and our two stroke boat didn't poison the water) - If my VR avatar and your VR avatar build full, rich (as far as we can tell) experiences together, and generate real sensations of joy, then I'm not sure it's so different from doing the same thing in reality. In either case we're manipulating atoms in ways we find pleasant; in one case those atoms simply happen to be in a computer. As a thought experiment, say you could build an entire copy of our civilization, but at half the physical size - its experiences would be no less rich, I think. Lower carbon emissions too. Now make it a hundredth the size. Or a billionth. Maybe modeling this inside a computer isn't so different from that scenario. Having everyone hooked up to VR all the time sounds like a hellish nightmare, for the record, but I'm not sure why it bothers me as much as it does.
- mistermann 9y agoVery interesting way of thinking about it, I'd enjoy to read a much longer fleshed out version of this. Also, is there a name for the "persuasion technique" you've used here? The idea of taking an understandable scenario and then reducing it? I have a similar technique that starts with an exaggerated and unavoidably rhetorical question, and then work back towards the topic at hand, when someone has a mental block and simply won't budge. I've always wondered if there's a name for it so I could become more effective at it.
- jp555 9y ago> money is a human-made construct Like the alphabet, and just a useful.
- nhaehnle 9y agoUsually, people who point out that money is a human-made construct are not trying to say that money is useless. Rather, they're trying to encourage you to question how money is constructed, likely because they think that making some tweaks would lead to it being more useful. Kind of like people who tweak fonts to make them more useful, to stick somewhat close to your alphabet example.
- loceng 9y agoI didn't say it wasn't useful, UBI is using money still? It's all about distribution of resources.
- dropit_sphere 9y agoBut even so, the law of diminishing returns kicks in here. The more a field is neglected, the higher the likelihood that there's some low-hanging fruit left unharvested. Article author should go play a few hundred games of Civilization.
- lottin 9y agoMy take is he means that trying to move to another planet isn't a good survival strategy as a species, because of the high probability that such an endeavour would end in failure.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- kiba 9y agoHowever, it is a good idea to move our heavy industries off Earth if possible. Once we have access to space, we can get things from space cheaper than we can get from Earth, with asteroid and moon mining and all.
- QuantumGravy 9y agoWe stay on this rock, we die on this rock. Confining ourselves to Earth isn't a survival strategy, it's giving up. Rebuttals would be appreciated, though!
- Asdfbla 9y agoWell, there's the simple fact (or what seems to be a fact at least, might not be true) that the reality of physics confines us to this rock, more or less. We don't travel faster than light, so at best we can achieve a Mars colony dependent on Earth supplies. So yeah, I'd rather just focus on developing survival strategies for our rock. But the whole discussion is maybe a bit off topic here too.
- halomru 9y agoA self-sufficient Mars colony isn't easy, but it doesn't seem impossible. And the lack of FTL doesn't really limit us to this solar system either: generational starships with nuclear pulse propulsion [1] could get us to the next star with around 100 years travel time. Not exactly something we want to start tomorrow, but fairly feasable. 1: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_pulse_propulsion https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_pulse_propulsion
- 9y ago
- xxxdarrenxxx 9y agoStaying on earth is running a server without a backup. We all know how that ends.. Work oppurtunities for data retrieval companies. Other planets would be our species redundancy at the very least. Playing it out, our sun will run out off fuel eventually. Mother nature is immune to patience. It will come. Saying no to space travel for survival reasons is the definition off "ignorance is bliss". The sun is here for a few million years, "what do I care" right, I'm long gone anyway.
- wu-ikkyu 9y ago>Staying on earth is running a server without a backup. We all know how that ends.. Work oppurtunities for data retrieval companies. Unless there is an exoplanet comparable to Earth that we can reach, your analogy is akin to calling a floppy disk (Mars) an adequate backup for a server (Earth) with petabytes of data. Colonizing Mars for an extinction event would be a data retrieval endeavor
- xxxdarrenxxx 9y agoThis is true. That said, many inventions in history were not the endgoal, but a side-effect off a research with a different goal in mind. Do you think if we stopped development on pc's around the 80's, and pick it up fresh in 2017, we would "invent" the Iphone or the SSD within a week? The internet was mainly motivated for porn distribution, then data, now it literally runs the entire world, and speeds up science and business on a scale that warrants an applause. We need to walk before we can run, at least that's what I personally like to believe. Mars is not feasible, but we still can learn many things off (consumer & daily) space travel, and living in a radical different environment by starting with it. Waiting with any practical/experimental advancement until we are "absolutely sure" more often than not tends to end up in little to no advancement at all, or very slowly. There are also non-technical reasons to "test drive" inter-planetary migration on a planet that can be "thrown away". Imagine we find the perfect planet, go there, but then this newly found goverment or terrorists decide to nuke it for reasons. Rather have Mars destroyed, than a super rare planet. Humans like to theorize, but it's accidents and mistakes that drives practical advancement.
- perseusprime11 9y agoA real-life example of this is the current commute mess in NY/NJ area. There is free wifi on the streets but subways and train stations are falling apart with no visioning for commuter growth over the last 5 years and the next 5 years. http://www.nytimes.com/2012/04/10/nyregion/report-disputes-christies-reason-for-halting-tunnel-project-in-2010.html http://www.nytimes.com/2012/04/10/nyregion/report-disputes-c... goes into some of the mess and lack of accountability.
- eru 9y agoWe already know how to solve these problems: just do whatever Singapore does.
- perseusprime11 9y agoand what is that?
- eru 9y agoIt's a bit of a complex topic. There's lots to learn from how their civil service is run, and how infrastructure is build, how the legal system is set up, etc. My comment comes from having lived there and seeing what results they achieve in practice---without relying on eg oil money. The main barrier to adopting Singaporean methods for eg "current commute mess in NY/NJ area" would be institutional, not technical. Some very quick Googling turned up eg http://www.alphr.com/life-culture/1005939/building-a-smart-city-how-singapore-is-forging-a-path-ahead-of-the-rest http://www.alphr.com/life-culture/1005939/building-a-smart-c... and http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-32028693 http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-32028693 and https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Economy_of_Singapore https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Economy_of_Singapore
- perseusprime11 9y agoThanks for coming back to reply. Too bad hacker news does not notify you about such things. Do you think the Singapore model can scale to larger countries? I've heard a lot of arguments around healthcare, education and transportation models from Europe don't scale beyond those small countries. Any thoughts?
- coldtea 9y ago>Making an effort to colonize Mars does not carry such a cost. People who are interested in solving this issue will not magically do whatever you'd like them to do instead. The same holds true for every calculation of opportunity cost. It's not about whether you WILL do Y instead of X, but about the relative cost of doing X vs Y. E.g. a business that does X will not "magically do Y instead" just because X incurs a big opportunity cost. But that's beside the point -- it will bear the opportunity cost whether it's willing to switch to Y or not. If the CEO is stubborn and doesn't even want to hear about Y and wants only to do X, doesn't mean the company wont suffer the opportunity cost of not doing Y. The same holds true for humanity. If the people spending resources to go to Mars wont ever direct them elsewhere, we (as humanity) will still have an opportunity cost of going to Mars vs spending the same effort on something else. (And it's not like that's our premise a given -- that those Mars resources can't "magically go to something else instead". Pressure on the government for example could cut NASA's budget and Space-X subsidies towards some other cause).